Point-set models for homotopy coherent coalgebras
Victor Roca i Lucio, Dan Petersen, Sinan Yalin · 2026
Read Point-set models for homotopy coherent coalgebras by Victor Roca i Lucio, Dan Petersen, Sinan Yalin (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-03101.txt.
Introduction
Dan Petersen, Victor Roca i Lucio, and Sinan Yalin prove a result in homotopical algebra. They give concrete point-set models for homotopy coherent coalgebras. On one side stands the infinity-category built by localizing differential graded coalgebras over an operad. On the other side stands a general definition of coalgebras over an enriched infinity-operad. The two views often describe the same theory, but proving that takes work.
The authors work over a field. They assume the operad is cofibrant. Step by step, attaching one cell at a time, they show the two infinity-categories are in fact the same. The result yields explicit point-set models for two key families of coalgebras in chain complexes. It also models the cellular chains functor with its coalgebra structure. That leads to an algebraic model for certain p-adic homotopy types.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Victor Roca i Lucio, Dan Petersen, Sinan Yalin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 162 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-03101
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Point-set models for homotopy coherent coalgebras Victor Roca i Lucio, Dan Petersen, Sinan Yalin Abstract . We show a first rectification result for homotopy chain coalgebras over a field. On the one hand, we consider the ∞ \infty -category obtained by localizing differential graded coalgebras over an operad with respect to quasi-isomorphisms; on the other, we give a general definition of an ∞ \infty -category of coalgebras over an enriched ∞ \infty -operad. We show by induction over cell attachments that these two ∞ \infty -categories are in fact equivalent when the operad is cofibrant. This yields explicit point-set models for E n \mathbb{E}_{n} -coalgebras and E ∞ \mathbb{E}_{\infty} -coalgebras in the derived ∞ \infty -category of chain complexes over a field, and an explicit point-set model for the cellular chains functor with its E ∞ \mathbb{E}_{\infty} -coalgebra structure. After Bachmann–Burklund, this gives a point-set algebraic model for nilpotent p p -adic homotopy types. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification 18N70, 18M60, 18N40, 18N60, 55U15, 55U35, 16T15 1. Introduction 1.1. Rectification of algebras Let \mathbf{C} be an \infty -category. By a point-set model of \mathbf{C} , we mean a 1-category \mathsf{C} and a class of weak equivalences \mathsf{W}\subset\mathrm{mor}(\mathsf{C}) , such that the localization of \mathsf{C} at \mathsf{W} presents \mathbf{C} — that is, such that there is an equivalence of \infty -categories \mathbf{C}\simeq\mathsf{C}[\mathsf{W}^{-1}] . Most \infty -categories encountered in day-to-day life are naturally presented to us in terms of point-set models. Having a point-set model can be both conceptually clarifying, and also serve as a useful computational tool: in particular, if (\mathsf{C},\mathsf{W}) comes as part of a model category structure, then one obtains a powerful calculus for e.g. computing limits and colimits in \mathbf{C} , mapping spaces, or derived functors. Many constructions in higher category theory allow one to build new \infty -categories out of existing ones: localization, stabilization, sheaf categories, the Lurie tensor product, etc. When the existing \infty -categories are presented by point-set models, it is natural to ask for a point-set model for the result of the construction. Here is an important example. Suppose that (\mathbf{C},\otimes) is a monoidal \infty -category. Let \mathrm{Alg}(\mathbf{C}) denote the \infty -category of \mathbb E_{1} -algebras in \mathbf{C} . If \mathbf{C}\simeq\mathsf{C}[\mathsf{W}^{-1}] , can we write down a point-set model of \mathrm{Alg}(\mathbf{C}) in terms of \mathsf{C} and \mathsf{W} ? Under certain hypotheses on \mathsf{C} and \mathsf{W} , the answer is yes: Theorem 1.1 (Lurie) . Suppose that (\mathsf{C},\mathsf{W}) underlies a combinatorial monoidal model category, which satisfies either: (a) all objects are cofibrant, (b) it is left proper, symmetric monoidal, satisfies the monoid axiom, and is cofibrantly generated by cofibrations between cofibrant objects. Then (1) \mathrm{Alg}\big(\mathsf{C}[\mathsf{W}^{-1}]\,\big)\simeq\mathrm{Alg}(\mathsf{C})\penalty\ [\mathsf{W}^{-1}]\penalty\ , where on the left we mean the \infty -category of \mathbb E_{1} -algebras in \mathsf{C}[\mathsf{W}^{-1}]\penalty\ ; on the right, we mean the 1-category of monoid objects in \mathsf{C} , localized at the class of arrows whose underlying morphism is in the class \mathsf{W} . This is a rectification theorem: it says that every \mathbb E_{1} -algebra can be rectified to a strictly associative object on the point-set level, and that this rectification is essentially unique. We refer to [ 30 , Section 4.1.8] for more details. Theorem 1.1 is not the only rectification theorem in the literature: see e.g. [ 18 , 22 , 34 ] for extensions to algebras over more general operads and to enriched settings. Remark 1.2 . The proofs of all these rectification results are somewhat similar in flavor. One uses the Barr–Beck–Lurie theorem to show that both sides of ( 1 ) are monadic over \mathbf{C} . Then one proves an isomorphism between the two monads: in both cases, the monad is given by the usual formula (2) X\mapsto\coprod_{n\geq 0}X^{\otimes n}. (On the point-set level this formula is only valid if one restricts X to the full subcategory of cofibrant objects.) 1.2. Rectification of coalgebras. This paper is not about algebras , but about coalgebras . Let us consider again a monoidal \infty -category (\mathbf{C},\otimes) . Definition 1.3 . The \infty -category of \mathbb E_{1} -coalgebras in \mathbf{C} is defined as \mathrm{Coalg}(\mathbf{C})\coloneqq\mathrm{Alg}(\mathbf{C}^{\mathrm{op}})^{\mathrm{op}} . Following the above discussion, it is natural to ask: if \mathbf{C}\simeq\mathsf{C}[\mathsf{W}^{-1}] , can one write a point-set model of \mathrm{Coalg}(\mathbf{C}) in terms of \mathsf{C} and \mathsf{W} , under “reasonable hypotheses” on (\mathsf{C},\mathsf{W}) ? Theorem 1.1 says that we get a point-set model of \mathrm{Coalg}(\mathbf{C}) whenever \mathbf{C}^{\mathrm{op}} satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 1.1 . But these are not “reasonable hypotheses” to impose. This is because monoidal model categories always give rise to closed monoidal \infty -categories ; most monoidal \infty -categories encountered in nature are closed, but the opposite of a closed monoidal category is itself closed only in highly degenerate situations. Similarly, combinatorial model categories always model presentable \infty -categories ; nearly all \infty -categories encountered in nature are presentable, but the opposite of a presentable category is presentable only in highly degenerate situations. Remark 1.4 . Let us indicate one reason why the monoidal structure being closed is useful for the strategy described in Remark 1.2 . Let (\mathsf{C},\otimes) be a monoidal category. The formula ( 2 ) for the free algebra in \mathsf{C} is valid whenever \mathsf{C} admits countable coproducts, and -\otimes- preserves countable coproducts in both variables. If \mathsf{C} is closed, then the latter condition is automatic, since X\otimes- is a left adjoint and preserves colimits. By contrast, if \mathsf{C}^{\mathrm{op}} is closed then X\otimes- is a right adjoint. For example, if \mathsf{C}=\mathsf{Ab}^{\mathrm{op}} , then free algebras in \mathsf{C} are what’s classically called cofree coalgebras . Cofree coalgebras exist, but their construction is extremely intricate (cf. [ 12 , 19 ] ), in particular in comparison to the simple formula ( 2 ). Here are some examples indicating the subtleties involved in proving rectification results for coalgebras. Example 1.5 . Every based suspension is an \mathbb E_{1} -coalgebra in the \infty -category of based spaces, with respect to the monoidal structure given by wedge sum. But a coalgebra in the 1-category of topological spaces with respect to wedge sum must be a point. Hence there can be no rectification of coalgebras in this situation. Example 1.6 . In a cartesian monoidal category, there exists exactly one coalgebra structure on any object: the counit is the unique map to the terminal object, and the comultiplication is necessarily the diagonal. In particular, any coalgebra in spaces is cocommutative. On the point-set level, the latter fact propagates to the stable setting: in any one of the 1-categories of symmetric spectra, orthogonal spectra, \Gamma -spaces, W -spaces, and Elmendorf–Kriz–Mandell–May’s category of \mathbb S -modules, all coassociative coalgebras are automatically cocommutative [ 35 ] . This is certainly not the case for coalgebras in the \infty -category of spectra, which therefore rarely admit a strict point-set rigidification. Example 1.7 . Let \Bbbk be a commutative ring. Let (\mathsf{Ch}_{\geq 0}(k),\otimes) be the monoidal category of nonnegatively graded chain complexes over \Bbbk , and (\mathsf{sMod}(\Bbbk),\times) the monoidal category of simplicial \Bbbk -modules. We let \mathsf{W} and \mathsf{W}^{\prime} denote the classes of quasi-isomorphisms in the respective categories. The Dold–Kan functor \mathrm{DK}:\mathsf{Ch}_{\geq 0}(\Bbbk)\longrightarrow\mathsf{sMod}(k) is an equivalence of relative categories. Both \mathrm{DK} and its inverse are simultaneously lax and oplax monoidal, and induce an equivalence of monoidal \infty -categories