Statistical Study of Appearance Timing of H α \alpha Postflare Loops: Simple Scaling Law Based on Radiative Cooling sunpy ( SunPy Community et al. 2020 ) , ChiantiPy ( K. Dere 2013 )
Takato Otsu, Ayumi Asai, Kai Ikuta, Kazunari Shibata · 2026
Read Statistical Study of Appearance Timing of H α \alpha Postflare Loops: Simple Scaling Law Based on Radiative Cooling sunpy ( SunPy Community et al. 2020 ) , ChiantiPy ( K. Dere 2013 ) by Takato Otsu, Ayumi Asai, Kai Ikuta, Kazunari Shibata (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-01866.txt.
Introduction
After a solar flare, cooling loops of plasma appear above the flare site and glow in hydrogen-alpha light, sometimes as a second peak in the light curve. Takato Otsu and three co-authors ask what sets the timing of that appearance. They test one idea across many events, not just a few case studies. The idea is that radiative cooling is in charge.
The statistics tell a clear story. The delay between the soft X-ray peak and the loops' appearance shrinks as the flare's X-ray brightness grows. That matches the scaling expected if radiative cooling controls the clock. From that relation the authors derive a way to estimate the spatial size of flares on other stars, where the loops themselves can never be resolved, from light curves alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Takato Otsu, Ayumi Asai, Kai Ikuta, Kazunari Shibata |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 62 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-01866
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Statistical Study of Appearance Timing of H α \alpha Postflare Loops: Simple Scaling Law Based on Radiative Cooling sunpy ( SunPy Community et al. 2020 ) , ChiantiPy ( K. Dere 2013 ) Takato Otsu, Ayumi Asai, Kai Ikuta, Kazunari Shibata Abstract Recent Sun-as-a-star studies have shown that postflare loops can manifest as a secondary peak in the H α \alpha light curve, suggesting that stellar postflare loops are detectable. To understand what determines the timing of such a secondary peak in the H α \alpha light curve associated with postflare loops, we must quantitatively identify the key physical processes controlling the appearance of H α \alpha postflare loops. Previous case studies have indicated that the appearance timing of H α \alpha postflare loops is likely governed by radiative cooling. However, the statistical characteristics of the timing of H α \alpha postflare loops appearance remain insufficiently investigated. In this study, we statistically investigated the appearance timing of H α \alpha postflare loops to quantify their cooling processes. As a result, we found a negative correlation between the time difference between the soft X-ray peak and the appearance of the H α \alpha postflare loops ( Δ t \Delta t ) and the soft X-ray peak flux ( F X F_{\mathrm{X}} ). This relationship is consistent with the theoretical scaling between radiative cooling timescale ( τ rad \tau_{\mathrm{rad}} ) and F X F_{\mathrm{X}} , where τ rad ∝ F X − 1 / 2 \tau_{\mathrm{rad}}\propto~F_{\mathrm{X}}^{-1/2} . This statistical result indicates that the appearance timing of H α \alpha postflare loops relative to the soft X-ray peak is primarily controlled by radiative cooling. Furthermore, we examined the dependence of the scaling law on flare spatial scales ( L L ). Consequently, we demonstrated that spatial scale of unresolved stellar flares can be estimated using the following scaling law: L ∝ F X 1 / 3 Δ t 2 / 3 L\propto F_{\mathrm{X}}^{1/3}\Delta t^{2/3} . Our results are useful for interpreting secondary peaks in the H α \alpha data of stellar flares and provide new method to estimate spatial scale of unresolved stellar flares. show][email protected] I Introduction Postflare loops are loop-shaped plasma structures observed during solar flares, and they are key components of the standard flare model ( K. Shibata & T. Magara 2011 , e.g.,) . In solar flares, energy released via magnetic reconnection is transported along the magnetic loops toward the solar surface, causing chromospheric evaporation. This process fills the loops with dense and hot plasma that emits soft X-rays (typically 10^{7} K). Hot loops are thought to cool mainly through radiative cooling, which is enhanced by the high plasma density ( M. J. Aschwanden & D. Alexander 2001 , e.g.,) . Thereafter, the cooler loops are observed in extreme ultraviolet (EUV; typically 10^{5}-10^{6} K) and chromospheric lines such as H \alpha (typically 10^{4} K). The cooler loops are particularly called postflare loops, although the term ”postflare loops” is sometimes avoided because magnetic reconnection and energy release continue even while cool loops are observed ( Z. Švestka 2007 ) . During the decay phase of flares, downflows of condensed plasma along the postflare loops are sometimes observed ( P. Heinzel et al. 1992 , e.g.,) . Their dynamics are observationally investigated using chromospheric and transition region lines ( S. Şahin & P. Antolin 2024 ; D. Song et al. 2025 , e.g.,) . Although the detailed properties of downflows along postflare loops are still unclear, these downflows are believed to be formed via thermal instability –which can also explain formation of coronal rains and prominences – triggered by efficient radiative cooling ( P. Antolin & C. Froment 2022 , e.g.,) . Explosive phenomena like solar flares are also observed on various cool stars, and they are called stellar flares. Stellar flares appear as sudden brightenings on distant stars ( A. F. Kowalski 2024 , e.g.,) . In particular, stellar flares that emit energies exceeding 10^{33} erg are referred to as superflares ( H. Maehara et al. 2012 , e.g.,) . Since such energetic events are thought to significantly affect environments of exoplanets orbiting the host star, superflares are actively investigated through collaborations between the stellar and exoplanet research communities ( V. S. Airapetian et al. 2020 ; E. W. Cliver et al. 2022 , e.g.,) . Moreover, focusing on distant stars allows for collecting more samples of energetic flares. Therefore, studies of superflares provide key insights into how large flares can potentially occur on the Sun ( K. Shibata et al. 2013 , e.g.,) . Recently, a lot of studies have performed spectroscopic observations of stellar flares at optical wavelengths and have reported blue/red shifted emission/absorption in the chromospheric lines such as H \alpha spectra ( K. Vida et al. 2019 ; H. Maehara et al. 2021 ; K. Namekata et al. 2022 ; S. Inoue et al. 2023 ; K. Namekata et al. 2024a ; Y. Kajikiya et al. 2025 ; P. Muheki et al. 2020 ; Y. Notsu et al. 2024 ; M. Leitzinger et al. 2024 ) . The Doppler-shifted signatures in chromospheric lines imply the existence of cool materials moving on stars. However, the interpretations of Doppler signatures of stellar flares are basically difficult, since the stellar surfaces cannot be spatially resolved unlike the solar case. To support the interpretation of stellar spectroscopic data, solar data are utilized via Sun-as-a-star analyses in which solar data are spatially integrated to be directly compared with stellar observations ( K. Namekata et al. 2022 ; T. Otsu et al. 2022 ; Y. L. Ma et al. 2024 ; A. G. M. Pietrow et al. 2024 ; M. De Wilde et al. 2025 ) . For example, K. Namekata et al. 2022 and K. Namekata et al. 2024a reported blueshifted absorption and emission signatures, respectively, in the H \alpha spectra of a young solar-type star, EK Draconis. The temporal evolution of these features closely resembles Sun-as-a-star observations of solar filament/prominence eruptions. Therefore, the blueshifted signatures in K. Namekata et al. 2022 ; K. Namekata et al. 2024a are interpreted as stellar filament/prominence eruptions. These probable stellar filament/prominence eruptions are reproduced by simple pseudo-two-dimensional (magneto-) hydrodynamic simulations of filament/prominence eruptions, which can also explain solar eruptions ( K. Ikuta & K. Shibata 2024 ; K. Namekata et al. 2024b ) , thereby making the above interpretations, especially the existence of associated coronal mass ejections (CMEs), more reliable. Along with filament/prominence eruptions, postflare loops are important components of the standard flare model. Therefore, postflare loops are also expected to be observed in stellar cases. Contributions of postflare loops to radiation of stellar flares have been discussed in recent studies ( P. Heinzel & K. Shibata 2018 ; K. E. Yang et al. 2023 ; K. Bicz et al. 2024 ; P. Odert et al. 2025 ; S. Ichihara et al. 2025 , e.g.,) , and downflows along postflare loops have been proposed as possible interpretations of Doppler-shifted signatures in H \alpha stellar spectra ( Y. Wu et al. 2022 ; J. Wollmann et al. 2023 ; K. Namizaki et al. 2023 ; Y. Notsu et al. 2024 ; Y. Kajikiya et al. 2025 ) . However, compared to plasma eruptions,