Predictive Assessment and Comparison of Bayesian Survival Models for Cancer Recurrence

Saku Suorsa, Aki Vehtari · 2026

Read Predictive Assessment and Comparison of Bayesian Survival Models for Cancer Recurrence by Saku Suorsa, Aki Vehtari (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-01662.txt.

Introduction

Predicting whether a cancer will return is the job of survival models, and Bayesian versions of these models are widely used in medical research. Saku Suorsa and Aki Vehtari examine how researchers should check and compare such models. The data are messy: some event times stay hidden, and some risk factors change their effect over time.

Their paper sets out targeted recommendations for predictive assessment across a range of scenarios and model types. Existing checking methods often mishandle censored times or time-varying effects, so the authors show how to judge forecasts more honestly. Open-source code accompanies the guidance, letting other medical statisticians apply the same checks to their own recurrence studies.

Catalog record

CREATORSaku Suorsa, Aki Vehtari
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE58 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-01662

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Predictive Assessment and Comparison of Bayesian Survival Models for Cancer Recurrence Saku Suorsa, Aki Vehtari Abstract Complex data features, such as unmodelled censored event times and variables with time-dependent effects, are common in cancer recurrence studies and pose challenges for Bayesian survival modelling. Current methodologies for predictive model checking and comparison often fail to adequately address these features. This paper bridges that gap by introducing new, targeted recommendations for predictive assessment and comparison of Bayesian survival models. Our recommendations cover a variety of different scenarios and models. Accompanying code together with our implementations to open source software help in replicating the results and applying our recommendations in practice. keywords Bayesian inference; survival analysis; predictive model checking; predictive model comparison; cross-validation 1 Introduction The motivation for this work is to improve the predictive model checking and the predictive model comparison of Bayesian survival models with the aim of analysing the gastrointestinal stromal tumour (GIST) data set that was collected over multiple decades in a collaborative effort of multiple research centres around the world. The data set has interesting aspects related to predictive model checking and predictive model comparison that are common in survival analysis but have not received much attention in the Bayesian literature and software implementations. A large portion of the event times in the GIST data set are censored, but the independent censoring process is not known nor modelled. This means that the full generative model is not available, which complicates predictive model checking and predictive model comparison. The GIST data set also has variables with clear time-dependent effects, which encourages the building of more complex models that further complicate predictive model comparison. All GIST-related analysis presented in this paper is performed on simulated data, since we are prohibited from publishing results from the real data set. In our other examples, we use simulated data or the Rotterdam breast cancer data set ( 27 ) . All the code and data used in this paper are freely available. 1 1 1 Code and data required to replicate the results in this paper are freely available at https://github.com/Sakuski/Bayesian-Cancer-Recurrence-Prediction . 1.1 Our contributions We present new recommendations for predictive model checking and predictive model comparison in Bayesian survival modelling. We give recommendations on how to perform predictive checking for different survival models in case there are no censored event times in the data, and in case there are censored event times in the data and the censoring process is not modelled. We also give recommendations for performing predictive model comparison when some of the models cause problems in the regular Pareto smoothed importance sampling leave-one-out cross-validation (PSIS-LOO CV) based comparison. The recommendations are summarised in Section 6 and justified in Section 3 and Section 4 . Some of our recommendations were included as software implementations in the release v.1.13.0 of bayesplot R package ( 11 ) . 1.2 Relation to previous work Although the roots of survival analysis go back to the 17th century ( 18 ) , it is the ground-breaking work by 23 , 9 , 24 , and 1 in the later part of the 20th century that leads to the modern framework. In the early years, survival analysis mainly followed the frequentist approach, but as computational capabilities grew larger, the Bayesian approach became a common alternative. Notable early contributions in this area include the work by 22 and 19 . In recent years, the concept of Bayesian workflow ( 15 , e.g., ) as a structural process has been established to help with practical aspects of Bayesian analysis. Different parts of the Bayesian workflow, including inference, predictive model checking, and predictive model comparison, have been automated in software packages, such as brms ( 6 ; 7 ; 8 ) , bayesplot ( 11 ; 12 ) , and loo ( 31 ) , respectively. Bayesian methodology has been applied in previous work related to gastrointestinal stromal tumours. For example, 21 utilised a modified Cox proportional hazards model fitted with Bayesian inference to non-linearly model recurrence free survival. In addition, 20 modelled the hazard of recurrence of GIST with Bayesian methods to optimise the timing of CT scans. The relationship of our work and previous research can be summarised in the following words. We take a close look at two important steps in the established Bayesian workflow: predictive model checking and predictive model comparison. We improve these steps in the context of survival modelling through our contributions. We also improve and give improvement suggestions to the relevant software tools in this area. In addition, we continue to apply Bayesian survival modelling in the analysis of simulated data on recurrence of gastrointestinal stromal tumours. 1.3 Paper outline The remainder of this paper is organised as follows. We briefly cover the models of our focus in Section 2 . In Sections 3 and 4 , we present our contributions to the Bayesian workflow for survival modelling: improvements to predictive model checks and new suggestions for predictive model comparison. In Section 5 , we demonstrate the methodology covered in earlier sections of the paper in a case study on a data set related to gastrointestinal stromal tumours. Finally, we summarise our contributions in the form of recommendations in Section 6 and discuss limitations and potential directions for future research in Section 7 . 2 Survival models In this paper, we focus only on models that are supported by the brms R package ( 6 ; 7 ; 8 ) . The brms framework allows for the inclusion of censoring and left-truncation in survival modelling. The possible model types include the common proportional hazards (PH) and accelerated failure time (AFT) models, but also a Bernoulli model that requires a bit more manual crafting. The Bernoulli model, which we introduce here, uses discrete time. Thus, in order to apply the model in a practical cancer recurrence setting, one must first discretise the continuous follow-up time. This involves choosing a suitable interval length (e.g., one month or one year) and dividing each subject’s observation period into these discrete time intervals. For each individual and for each discrete time interval in which they are observed and at risk, we model the probability of cancer recurrence using a Bernoulli model. This means that within any given interval, the outcome for a subject is binary: either a recurrence occurs, or it does not. A key point is that time intervals after a subject has experienced the event (recurrence) or has been censored (e.g., died from other causes, lost to follow-up) are excluded from the analysis. The Bernoulli model assumes that the probability of recurrence occurring at some point in time for some individual is \theta , which depends on the possibly time-dependent covariates. For example, if we are applying a logit link, the relationship between \theta and the covariates is \mathrm{logit}(\theta)=\log\left(\frac{\theta}{1-\theta}\right)=\beta_{0}+\beta_{1}X_{1}+\dots+\beta_{p}X_{p}, (1) where X_{j} is the covariate j and \beta_{j} is its regression coefficient. This modelling approach requires the data set to be transferred to a long format. Instead of having one row per subject, we create a data point for each discrete time interval for each individual. In this format, a single subject is represented by multiple rows, one for each time interval in which they

Read the complete text