Excess energy of strongly coupled one-component plasma from variational approach

S. A. Khrapak and A. G. Khrapak · 2026

Read Excess energy of strongly coupled one-component plasma from variational approach by S. A. Khrapak and A. G. Khrapak (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-01659.txt.

Introduction

Sergey Khrapak and Alexey Khrapak tackle a basic quantity in plasma physics: the extra energy stored in a one-component plasma, a fluid of charged particles that repel each other strongly. Their calculation uses a variational method, meaning it searches for the best estimate within a chosen family, with a hard-sphere fluid as the reference system.

Several versions of the reference fluid's entropy are tried, and the results are checked against recent large computer simulations. The Percus-Yevick virial entropy proves the most accurate choice, and an older scaling rule for the thermal part of the energy matches the simulation data closely. The findings give plasma researchers a tested recipe for a quantity that is otherwise costly to compute.

Catalog record

CREATORS. A. Khrapak and A. G. Khrapak
YEAR2026
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE21 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-01659

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Excess energy of strongly coupled one-component plasma from variational approach S. A. Khrapak and A. G. Khrapak Abstract The excess energy of the one-component plasma fluid is calculated using the variational approach combined with different variants of the excess entropy of the hard-sphere fluid, which is used as a reference system. Our comparison with recent Monte Carlo results for the excess energy of the one-component plasma identifies the Percus-Yevick virial entropy as the most accurate entropy to be used in the variational calculation of this kind. The reason for this and potential developments of the present analysis are briefly discussed. We demonstrate that the original Rosenfeld-Tarazons scaling of the thermal component of the excess energy of the one-component plasma fluid is in excellent agreement with recent Monte Carlo results. I Introduction To estimate the properties of a many-body system, a relation can be made to another reference system whose properties are known with better accuracy. In particular, the Bogoliubov variational inequality is widely used for this purpose Hansen and McDonald 2006 . It represents a fundamental result in statistical physics imposing an upper bound on the Helmholtz free energy of a many-body system: F\leq F_{0}+\langle H-H_{0}\rangle_{0}, (1) where F and F_{0} are Helmholtz free energies of the actual and reference systems, while H and H_{0} are their respective Hamiltonians, evaluated at a given state of the reference system. For classical systems of particles interacting with pairwise potentials, the Hamiltonians differ only by the potential (excess) energies evaluated for a given state of the reference system. This can be expressed through the radial distribution function (RDF) g_{0}(r) of the reference system by means of the integral energy equation Hansen and McDonald 2006 . It is particularly tempting to use an assembly of hard spheres (HS) as a reference system because the potential energy is identically zero, the properties of the system, such as g_{0}(r) , are quite well known and depend on a single parameter – the packing fraction \eta=\pi n\sigma^{3}/6 , where n is the density of spheres and \sigma is their diameter. Adopting this choice, we can rewrite the Bogoliubov inequality as F\leq-TS_{0}(\eta)+\frac{N}{2}n\int g_{0}(r;\eta)\phi(r)d{\bf r}, (2) where T is the temperature, S_{0} is the entropy of the hard-sphere system (related to an appropriate equation of state), N is the number of particles, and \phi(r) is the interaction potential of the system considered. The right-hand side (RHS) of equation ( 2 ) depends on the packing fraction \eta , which acts as a variational parameter. Minimizing the RHS with respect to \eta would produce the best estimate of the free energy of the system considered. This is how the variational calculation with the HS reference system works in practice. Naturally, it should be expected that the HS reference is more appropriate for systems with steep interactions such as the Lennard-Jones system Mansoori and Canfield 1969a ; Mansoori and Canfield 1969b or inverse power potentials with sufficiently large exponents Ross 1973 ; Young and Rogers 1984 . Surprisingly, it remains a useful phenomenological model even in the case of extremely soft and long-range Coulomb-like interactions, although not all of its realizations deliver satisfactory accuracy Ross et al. 1981 . Actually, it turns out that the procedure is rather sensitive to the exact form of the HS entropy. Not the accuracy of the S_{0}(\eta) term per se , but rather its consistency with the RDF g_{0}(r;\eta) used to calculate excess energy determines the accuracy of the variational calculation. In this paper, we consider a strongly coupled one-component plasma (OCP), which is a classical fluid of charged particles that interact through a Coulomb interaction potential and are immersed in a uniform compensating background of opposite charge to ensure quasineutrality Baus and Hansen 1980 ; Ichimaru 1982 . We calculate the excess internal energy employing a variational approach with the HS fluid as a reference system using five different equations of state (EoS) of the HS fluid. In this way, we quantify the accuracy of different approximations for S_{0}(\eta) in this important special case. Importantly, we base our comparison on results from recently reported molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the thermodynamical properties of HS fluids Pieprzyk et al. 2019 and Monte Carlo (MC) simulations of OCP fluids using the angular-averaged Ewald potential (AAEP) Demyanov and Levashov 2022 ; Demyanov and Levashov arXiv, 2025 . Since these results seem to reach the level of accuracy needed for most practical applications, a systematic evaluation of the impact of different assumptions for HS entropy appears to be both relevant and timely. In addition, we use this opportunity to update the applicability of the Rosenfeld-Tarazona scaling in the case of the OCP fluid. II Calculation The OCP is characterized by a single dimensionless Coulomb coupling parameter \Gamma=q^{2}/aT , where q is the electric charge and a=(4\pi n/3)^{-1/3} is the Wigner-Seitz radius. At \Gamma\ll 1 the weakly coupled regime is realized and the OCP exhibits a gas-like behavior. At \Gamma\gtrsim 1 strong coupling takes place and the OCP exhibits fluid-like behavior. In fact, the center of the crossover from gas-like to liquid-like dynamics has been recently identified at \Gamma\sim 10 Huang et al. 2023 ; Khrapak and Khrapak 2022 ; Khrapak et al. 2025 . At \Gamma\gtrsim 50 vibrational dominance governs the dynamical behavior and transport properties of the OCP Khrapak 2021 ; Khrapak 2024a . The fluid-solid phase transition occurs at \Gamma\simeq 174 , where the Helmholtz free energy of the fluid and solid phases intersect and the OCP crystallizes into a body-centered cubic lattice Ichimaru 1982 ; Dubin and O’Neil 1999 ; Khrapak and Khrapak 2016 . The existence of a glass transition at even high \Gamma has also been discussed in the literature from different perspectives Tanaka and Ichimaru 1987 ; Ichimaru and Tanaka 1986 ; Cardenas and Tosi 2004 ; Yazdi et al. 2014 ; Khrapak 2024b . Here, our main interest is the strongly coupled fluid regime. Omitting the ideal gas terms, we rewrite Eq. ( 2 ) in conventional reduced excess units Baus and Hansen 1980 f_{\rm ex}\leq-s_{\rm ex}(\eta)+u_{\rm ex}(\Gamma,\eta). (3) The calculation of excess energy should be adapted to reflect the particular properties of the OCP. Taking into account the presence of neutralizing background, the Coulomb interactions potential \phi(r)=q^{2}/r , and introducing the reduced distance x=r/\sigma , the excess energy term becomes u_{\rm ex}(\Gamma,\eta)=6\Gamma\eta^{2/3}\int_{0}^{\infty}\left[g_{0}(x;\eta)-1\right]xdx. (4) The integral can be calculated by noting that \int_{0}^{\infty}\left[g_{0}(x;\eta)-1\right]xdx=\\ =\lim_{t\rightarrow 0}\int_{0}^{\infty}e^{-tx}\left[g_{0}(x;\eta)-1\right]xdx=\lim_{t\rightarrow 0}\left[G(t,\eta)-\frac{1}{t^{2}}\right]. (5) In Percus-Yevick (PY) theory, the function G(t,\eta) is known analytically Wertheim 1963 . Evaluating the limit is a nice exercise yielding u_{\rm ex}(\Gamma,\eta)=-3\Gamma\eta^{2/3}\frac{1-\tfrac{1}{5}\eta+\tfrac{1}{10}\eta^{2}}{1+2\eta}. (6) This result was derived by Jones Jones 1971 , although with a misprint in the original version Stroud and Ashcroft 1976 . The excess entropy is related to the compressibility factor Z=P/nT (we measure the temperature in energy units so that Z is a dimensionless quantity) through an integral equation s_{\rm ex}(\eta)=-\int_{0}^{\eta}\frac{Z(\eta^{\prime})-1}{\eta^{\prime}}d\eta^{\prime}. (7) In the following, we test five different EoS for the HS fluid. The first two are the conventional PY results Wertheim 1963 ; Thiele 1963 obtained either through the virial (pressure) route Z_{\rm v}(\eta)=\frac{1+2\eta+3\eta^{2}}{(1-\eta)^{2}}, (8) or through the compressibility route Z_{\rm c}(\eta)=\frac{1+\eta+\eta^{2}}{(1-\eta)^{3}}. (9) The difference is due to thermodynamic inconsistency related to the approximate character of the

Read the complete text