On electric fields in hot QCD: infrared regularization dependence
G. Endrődi, G. Markó, and L. Sandbote · 2026
Read On electric fields in hot QCD: infrared regularization dependence by G. Endrődi, G. Markó, and L. Sandbote (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-01478.txt.
Introduction
Three authors led by Gergely Endrődi settle a dispute about how a hot plasma of charged particles responds to a weak electric field. The response, the electric susceptibility, matters for the first instants of heavy-ion collisions and for laser-plasma experiments. Two formalisms in the literature gave two different answers at nonzero temperature, and the field had no clean account of why.
The authors attack from two sides. An exact propagator for fermions in a uniform electric field, at finite temperature and volume, gives one anchor; an improved perturbative calculation gives the other. Comparing them exposes the origin of the disagreement, which turns on how equilibrium is defined and which thermodynamic ensemble describes the system. They also build the susceptibility in a simpler hadron resonance gas model for the cooler regime. The paper is careful bookkeeping for hot quantum chromodynamics, where such errors can mislead simulation programs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | G. Endrődi, G. Markó, and L. Sandbote |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 192 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-01478
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On electric fields in hot QCD: infrared regularization dependence G. Endrődi, G. Markó, and L. Sandbote Abstract We study the impact of background electric fields on a hot plasma of charged particles – a setting relevant for the early stages of heavy-ion collisions as well as laser pulse experiments. Historically, the electric susceptibility – encoding the behavior of the hot medium for weak fields – has been defined within two different formalisms, leading to two distinct results at nonzero temperature. With the help of an exact fermion propagator in a homogeneous electric background field at nonzero temperature and finite volume on the one hand, and an improved perturbative result on the other, we identify the origin of this disagreement. The equilibrium conditions for the system are discussed and the role of the thermodynamic ensemble used to describe the system is highlighted. Finally, we construct the electric susceptibility in a simplified hadron resonance gas model, relevant for the strongly interacting medium in the low-temperature regime. 1 Introduction A key feature of a quantum field theoretical system is its response to classical background fields. With regard to the electromagnetic response, the background field couples to the electrically charged particles originating from virtual or thermal fluctuations, forming a medium with non-trivial magnetization and polarization. Two prime examples for such a behavior are the thermal media described by Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) and Quantum Electrodynamics (QED). Here we focus on the electric polarization of the thermal medium, induced by background electric fields. For QCD matter, this response is relevant for the behavior of the strongly interacting medium formed in the early stages of heavy-ion collision experiments 9 ; 35 ; 24 . In turn, the reaction of the QED plasma to strong electric fields is put to the test routinely in laser pulse experiments 21 ; 10 ; 17 . Both setups give rise to a broad range of fascinating physical phenomena 23 . While QED interactions are essentially perturbative, the QCD medium is strongly coupled at low to intermediate energies and may only be studied via non-perturbative first principles methods like lattice QCD simulations. Nevertheless, leading-order perturbation theory was observed to describe the response of the QCD medium to weak background fields surprisingly well. In particular, a quantitative agreement between one-loop perturbative predictions and lattice QCD simulations was observed down to temperatures of the order of T\approx 300\textmd{ MeV} , both for weak magnetic 3 ; 4 and weak electric fields 15 , see also the recent review 16 . Perturbative QCD calculations are in general expected to become valid at high energies, where the QCD coupling decreases due to asymptotic freedom. Altogether, perturbation theory turns out to be a reasonable tool for both QCD and QED plasmas in this context and in this paper we consider a perturbative treatment of these setups to one loop order. In addition, the generalization of the QED result to constituent particles (i.e. hadrons) also allows to predict the electromagnetic response of QCD matter at low temperatures, where it is well approximated by hadron gas models 22 ; 26 . In fact, such a hadron resonance gas model has been constructed for the case of magnetic fields 13 ; 4 and has been revisited recently 36 ; 30 ; 25 . Here we work out an analogous model for electric background fields. The response of the medium is encoded by the behavior of the thermodynamic potential \Omega . The leading-order coefficient, in a weak field expansion, is the electric susceptibility \xi=-\left.\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}\Omega}{\mathrm{d}(eE)^{2}}\right|_{E=0}\,, (1) which will be in the focus of our discussion. It is normalized by the elementary electric charge e>0 for convenience. 1 1 1 In this manner, multiplicative renormalization constants do not appear in \xi , see e.g. Ref. 16 . As we will discuss in detail below, the response of the thermal system to the electric field is twofold. First, it involves a macroscopic rearrangement of electric charge carriers, generating an inhomogeneous charge distribution. Second, it includes the quantum response of the medium, encoded in the propagation of particles. In the present paper, we are interested in the latter contribution and will therefore carefully isolate the two responses in order to compute the susceptibility. Interestingly, the susceptibility ( 1 ) can be calculated via two fundamentally different approaches. One possibility is to calculate the thermodynamic potential \Omega(E) using Schwinger’s exact fermion propagator 33 at nonzero electric field, followed by a weak field expansion to obtain ( 1 ). This strategy was followed both using real-time propagators 28 ; 11 ; 12 as well as within the imaginary time formalism 20 ; 19 ; 8 at arbitrary temperatures and fermion masses. The so defined susceptibility will be denoted by \xi_{\rm S} . Alternatively, one may expand \Omega in a general background photon field to express the susceptibility directly in terms of the photon vacuum polarization diagram at E=0 . This approach was employed in the seminal paper by Weldon 37 for massless fermions and generalized to the massive case in 14 , see also 7 ; 18 . This determination of ( 1 ) will be denoted by \xi_{\rm W} . As first pointed out in 14 , the two approaches surprisingly disagree, \begin{split}\xi_{\rm S}&=\,-\frac{1}{6\pi^{2}}\int_{m}^{\infty}\frac{\textmd{d}\omega}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}-m^{2}}}\,\Bigl[2n_{F}(\omega)+\omega\,n_{F}^{\prime}(\omega)\Bigl]\\ \xi_{\rm W}&=\,-\frac{1}{6\pi^{2}}\int_{m}^{\infty}\frac{\textmd{d}\omega}{\sqrt{\omega^{2}-m^{2}}}\,\Bigl[2n_{F}(\omega)-\omega\,n_{F}^{\prime}(\omega)\Bigl],\end{split} (2) where n_{F}(\omega)=1/(e^{\beta\omega}+1) is the Fermi-Dirac distribution and m the mass of the fermion. In particular, the difference of the two susceptibilities in a high-temperature expansion reads \xi_{\rm S}-\xi_{\rm W}=1/(6\pi^{2})+\mathcal{O}(m^{2}/T^{2}) . This disagreement poses a substantial discrepancy between the above two seminal methods. Schwinger’s approach forms the basis for Euler-Heisenberg effective actions employed for QED thermodynamics and in QCD effective models 31 but is also highly important for laser physics 23 . In turn, Weldon’s approach, generalized to color interactions, has been influential for hard thermal loop perturbation theory 6 ; 5 and for quark-gluon plasma physics, see e.g. Ref. 2 . It is therefore essential to identify the reason for \xi_{\rm S}\neq\xi_{\rm W} and to resolve this discrepancy. Previously, the disagreement was argued to be rooted in the infrared (IR) divergence that appears due to the singular equilibrium charge profile in homogeneous electric fields in an infinite volume 14 . 2 2 2 We mention that infrared divergences also show up in calculations of the electric permittivity in the vacuum 34 . Moreover, the ambiguity was conjectured to be related to the ordering of infrared limits like the thermodynamic limit and the weak electric field limit 14 . In this paper, we address this conjecture and explicitly demonstrate that the reason for \xi_{\rm S}\neq\xi_{\rm W} is indeed rooted in infrared physics, but emerges rather because the global spatial averaging involved in \xi and the limit of homogeneous electric fields do not commute. Thus, the settings in e.g. Ref. 37 and Ref. 11 indeed correspond to different physics, i.e. to observables with different measurement instructions. Furthermore, we point out the importance of using different thermodynamic ensembles – the local grand canonical ensemble, where density fluctuations around the equilibrium density profile are allowed, and the local canonical ensemble, where the density profile is fixed. This paper is structured as follows: In Sec. 2 , we discuss the equilibrium at finite temperature modified by the presence of an electric background field and