Critical Volatility Threshold for Log-Normal to Power-Law Transition
Valerii Kremnev · 2026
Read Critical Volatility Threshold for Log-Normal to Power-Law Transition by Valerii Kremnev (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-01269.txt.
Introduction
Valerii Kremnev asks why markets that look calm and log-normal up close sometimes produce extreme, power-law outcomes. His answer points to structure, not shocks. When payouts are cut off below zero, expected values are fed forward through layers, and each layer is random, mild processes can tip into fat-tailed ones past a sharp volatility threshold.
Using a chain of options on options as the model case, he derives that threshold. Without selection, it sits near two hundred fifty-one percent volatility. When participants must clear a minimum return to stay in, it drops sharply to about one hundred twenty-five percent. The resulting distribution has a closed-form exponent set by survival pressure and growth. The claim, presented as a model result, recasts fat tails as something layered markets generate on their own rather than something imposed from outside.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Valerii Kremnev |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-01269
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Critical Volatility Threshold for Log-Normal to Power-Law Transition Valerii Kremnev Abstract Critical Volatility Threshold for Log-Normal to Power-Law Transition: Iterated Options Model Abstract Random walk models with log-normal outcomes fit local market observations remarkably well. Yet interconnected or recursive structures - layered derivatives, leveraged positions, iterative funding rounds - periodically produce power-law distributed events. We show that the transition from log-normal to power-law dynamics requires only three conditions: randomness in the underlying process, rectification of payouts, and iterative feed-forward of expected values. Using an infinite option-on-option chain as an illustrative model, we derive a critical volatility threshold at \sigma^{*}=\sqrt{2\pi}\approx 250.66\% for the unconditional case. With selective survival - where participants require minimum returns to continue - the critical threshold drops discontinuously to \sigma_{\text{th}}^{*}=\sqrt{\pi/2}\approx 125.3\% , and can decrease further with higher survival thresholds. The resulting outcomes follow what we term the Critical Volatility (V*) Distribution - a power-law whose exponent admits closed-form expression in terms of survival pressure and conditional expected growth. The result suggests that fat tails may be an emergent property of iterative log-normal processes with selection rather than an exogenous feature. Preface Financial systems are built on rectified payoffs. An investment in a high-risk project returns either something or nothing - you cannot lose more than you put in. An option pays \max(S-K,0) . Even limited liability is a form of rectification. These rectified structures often feed into one another. A successful project enables others built on top of it. A successful trade becomes the capital for the next trade. Derivative products reference other derivative products. It would be useful to know how such iterations behave - whether they remain stable or exhibit qualitatively different dynamics. To answer this, we analyze the limiting case: an infinite chain of options, each written on the expected payout of the one before. The result depends on three conditions - randomness in the underlying process, rectification of payouts, and feed-forward of expected values. These are sufficient to produce a critical threshold at \sigma^{*}=\sqrt{2\pi}\approx 250.66\% . Below this, cumulative optionality remains bounded. Above it, the system diverges. With selective survival - participants requiring minimum returns to continue - the threshold drops to \sigma_{\text{th}}^{*}=\sqrt{\pi/2}\approx 125.3\% . The divergent outcomes follow what we term the V* Distribution - a power-law whose exponent depends on the specific volatility and participants’ willingness to make the next bet. We also identify a self-similar regime at exactly the critical threshold, where each iteration reproduces the statistical structure of the previous one. The conditions are minimal: randomness, bounded downside, and iteration. These are not exotic assumptions, suggesting the mechanism may apply broadly to dynamic systems with compounding behavior. As for the infinite derivative tower itself: to our knowledge, no one has built one. This is probably wise. But should financial engineering continue its march toward increasingly layered products, at least the location of the cliff is now known. 1. Introduction and Motivation The Black-Scholes framework provides a foundational model for pricing European options. Under risk-neutral valuation, the price of a call option reflects the expected value of its payoff \max(S_{T}-K,0) , discounted appropriately. This “rectification” - the maximum of a potentially negative quantity and zero - is the essential nonlinearity that gives options their asymmetric payoff structure. A natural question arises: what happens when we write an option on an option? And then an option on that? In principle, one could construct an arbitrarily deep tower of such instruments, each layer deriving its value from the expected payout of the layer below. This paper analyzes the mathematical structure of such iterated rectified expectations. We find that: 1. The system exhibits a phase transition at a critical volatility of \sigma^{*}=\sqrt{2\pi}\approx 250.66\% annualized for the unconditional ATM case. This assumes the perfect case, where pricing has no errors and volatility doesn’t amplify between derivative layers but stays perfectly correlated to asset price at a constant ratio. Real systems, if built, will diverge much faster. 2. Below criticality ( \sigma<\sigma^{*} ), the total value of an infinite option chain converges to a finite sum, meaning optionality is “bounded” no matter how many layers are added. 3. Above criticality ( \sigma>\sigma^{*} ), the chain diverges - the cumulative value of optionality exceeds the underlying asset itself. This is not merely a mathematical curiosity; it implies that in extreme volatility regimes, the optionality can dominate the fundamental value of the product. This leads to amplification of expected payout at each consecutive step, making the expected payouts follow power-law dynamics. 4. At criticality ( \sigma=\sigma^{*} ), the system becomes self-similar, with each iteration reproducing the statistical structure of the previous one. 5. With selective survival - where participants require minimum returns to continue - the critical threshold drops to \sigma_{\text{th}}^{*}=\sqrt{\pi/2}\approx 125.3\% . Power-law dynamics (the V* Distribution) emerge when \beta_{\text{eff}}>1 , where \beta_{\text{eff}} is the conditional expected growth given survival. These findings have implications for understanding volatility regimes during market stress, the pricing of compound options, and the theoretical limits of derivative layering. 2. The Black-Scholes Setup 2.1 Standard Framework Under the Black-Scholes model, the underlying asset follows geometric Brownian motion: dS_{t}=\mu S_{t}\,dt+\sigma S_{t}\,dW_{t} The Black-Scholes formula for a European call option is: C(S_{t},t)=N(d_{+})S_{t}-N(d_{-})Ke^{-r(T-t)} where: d_{+}=\frac{1}{\sigma\sqrt{T-t}}\left[\ln\left(\frac{S_{t}}{K}\right)+\left(r+\frac{\sigma^{2}}{2}\right)(T-t)\right] d_{-}=d_{+}-\sigma\sqrt{T-t} and N(\cdot) is the standard normal CDF. 2.2 ATM Special Case For an at-the-money option where S_{t}=K , we have \ln(S_{t}/K)=0 , so: d_{+}=\frac{r+\sigma^{2}/2}{\sigma}\sqrt{T-t} d_{-}=\frac{r-\sigma^{2}/2}{\sigma}\sqrt{T-t} In the r\ll\sigma limit (which holds for high-volatility regimes where \sigma>100\% and r\approx 5\% ): d_{+}\approx\frac{\sigma^{2}/2}{\sigma}\sqrt{T-t}=\frac{\sigma}{2}\sqrt{T-t} d_{-}\approx\frac{-\sigma^{2}/2}{\sigma}\sqrt{T-t}=-\frac{\sigma}{2}\sqrt{T-t} Since d_{-}\approx-d_{+} , we have N(d_{-})=N(-d_{+})=1-N(d_{+}) , and the option price simplifies to: C=K\left[N(d_{+})-N(d_{-})\right]=K\left[2N\left(\frac{\sigma\sqrt{T-t}}{2}\right)-1\right] The ATM option price reduces to a single Gaussian CDF minus a constant. Let us analyze its behavior. 2.3 The Gaussian Structure The Gaussian distribution appears explicitly in Black-Scholes through N(d_{+}) and N(d_{-}) , and simplifies to a single Gaussian CDF under the high-volatility ATM assumption. We observe that the option payoff \max(S_{T}-K,0) cannot be negative by definition - the option structure rectifies the underlying returns at zero. The expected value of a rectified Gaussian is the mathematical core of option pricing. We now analyze the general case of \mathbb{E}[\max(X,0)] for X\sim\mathcal{N}(\mu,\sigma^{2}) . In the following mathematical derivation, \sigma denotes the standard deviation of the distribution X\sim\mathcal{N}(\mu,\sigma^{2}) , following standard statistical convention, not the scale-less volatility. 2.4 Rectified Gaussian Expectations Let Y=\max(X,0) where X\sim\mathcal{N}(\mu,\sigma^{2}) . We seek \mathbb{E}[Y] . The expectation splits into two regions: \mathbb{E}[Y]=\mathbb{E}[X\cdot\mathbf{1}_{X>0}]=\int_{0}^{\infty}x\cdot\frac{1}{\sigma\sqrt{2\pi}}e^{-(x-\mu)^{2}/2\sigma^{2}}dx Substituting u=(x-\mu)/\sigma : \mathbb{E}[Y]=\int_{-\mu/\sigma}^{\infty}(\mu+\sigma u)\cdot\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}e^{-u^{2}/2}du This separates into: \mathbb{E}[Y]=\mu\int_{-\mu/\sigma}^{\infty}\phi(u)\,du+\sigma\int_{-\mu/\sigma}^{\infty}u\cdot\phi(u)\,du The first integral is \mu\cdot\Phi(\mu/\sigma) . For the second, note that u\cdot\phi(u)=-\phi^{\prime}(u) , so: \int_{-\mu/\sigma}^{\infty}u\cdot\phi(u)\,du=\left[-\phi(u)\right]_{-\mu/\sigma}^{\infty}=\phi(\mu/\sigma) Therefore: \mathbb{E}[Y]=\mu\Phi\left(\frac{\mu}{\sigma}\right)+\sigma\phi\left(\frac{\mu}{\sigma}\right) where \Phi(\cdot) is the standard normal CDF and \phi(\cdot) is the standard normal PDF. 2.5 The Function g(z) Normalizing by \sigma and letting z=\mu/\sigma : \frac{\mathbb{E}[Y]}{\sigma}=z\Phi(z)+\phi(z) Expanding using the integral forms of \Phi and \phi : \frac{\mathbb{E}[Y]}{\sigma}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{2\pi}}\left(z\int_{-\infty}^{z}e^{-t^{2}/2}dt+e^{-z^{2}/2}\right) We define: g(z)=z\int_{-\infty}^{z}e^{-t^{2}/2}dt+e^{-z^{2}/2} so that the expected value of the rectified Gaussian becomes: \mathbb{E}[Y]=\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{2\pi}}g(z) This form will be essential for analyzing iterations. 3. Iterated Options: The Mathematical Structure 3.1 The Iteration Scheme Consider a chain of options where each option is written on the expected payout of the previous one. In a simplified model of such chain, we would be putting a new derivative instrument with the price of expected payout of the previous one, and calculate new parameters. Since the strike price