One loop renormalization of 5D gauge-Yukawa theories
Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Wanda Isnard, Roman Pasechnik, Anca Preda · 2026
Read One loop renormalization of 5D gauge-Yukawa theories by Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Wanda Isnard, Roman Pasechnik, Anca Preda (2026) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2601-00453.txt.
Introduction
Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Wanda Isnard, Roman Pasechnik, and Anca Preda question a common belief about theories with a fifth dimension. Such theories are usually said to lose predictive power just above the scale where the extra dimension is curled up, because couplings grow too fast. The authors show five-dimensional gauge-Yukawa theories can stay valid to very high energies under two conditions.
Only a finite number of terms may be needed to absorb the fast-growing divergences, and all couplings must flow toward stable ultraviolet fixed points. By computing the relevant divergences directly, they prove the one-loop behavior for interactions that would be well behaved in four dimensions. The result gives a test that separates consistent five-dimensional models from ones describing only a few extra modes.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Wanda Isnard, Roman Pasechnik, Anca Preda |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2026 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2601-00453
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
One loop renormalization of 5D gauge-Yukawa theories Giacomo Cacciapaglia, Wanda Isnard, Roman Pasechnik, Anca Preda Abstract The common lore dictates that extra dimensional theories loose predictive power at energies just above the compatification scale, due to the power-law running of bulk coupling. We show that five-dimensional gauge-Yukawa theories can be valid up to arbitrarily high scales, provided: 1. A finite number of terms are required to absorb power-law divergences; 2. All power-law running couplings flow to UV fixed points. By explicitly computing bulk and localized divergences for a gauge-Yukawa theory on 𝒮 1 / ℤ 2 \mathcal{S}^{1}/\mathbb{Z}_{2} , we prove the one-loop renormalization properties of Lagrangians containing only interactions that would be renormalizable in four dimensions. The existence of UV fixed points imposes further constraints on the content of the model. Our results provide a consistency check for the high-energy behavior of any 5D theory, and provide a discrimination between UV consistent models and those that can describe only a handful of Kaluza-Klein modes. Hence, we offer the first concrete step towards an all-order proof of ‘renormalizability’ for gauge-Yukawa theories in five dimensions. 1 Introduction Quantum field theories in more than four spacetime dimensions provide a compelling playground for studying extensions of the Standard Model (SM). First employed as arenas for possible gauge-gravity unification Kaluza:1921tu ; Klein:1926tv and later required for the consistency of superstring theory, it was realized that extra dimensions could be relevant at scales as low as the TeV Antoniadis:1990ew . Higher-dimensional field theories, in fact, entail one of the straightforward extensions of space-time symmetries, besides supersymmetric theories. They can address various questions about symmetry breaking dynamics, coupling unification, emergence of mass hierarchies, and the origin of yet-to-be-discovered UV physics. In phenomenologically viable scenarios, the extra dimensions are typically compactified either via boundaries or warped geometry Randall:1999vf , so that at sufficiently low energies an effective four-dimensional (4D) theory emerges. This generates a specific new energy scale, where modifications to the 4D behavior emerge, and boundaries when the extra dimensional space geometry is based on orbifolds Hebecker_2002 . Therefore, the resulting spacetime is characterized by a bulk region, where extra-dimensional fields propagate, and boundaries, where lower-dimensional localized interactions and additional degrees of freedom may live as long as they respect the locally preserved symmetries. These features open the question of the validity of the extra dimensional theories and the sensitivity of the computable results to unknown UV corrections. The problem is twofold. On the one hand, couplings in the bulk (including gauge ones) are affected by power-law corrections Contino:2001si ; Hebecker:2002vm and may become non-perturbative shortly above the compactification scale, hence deeming the extra dimensional model a mere effective description of a more UV complete theory (such as string theory). On the other hand, higher dimensional operators may be required to regularize divergences, both in the bulk and on the boundaries Contino:2001si ; Hebecker_2004 ; Ghilencea:2006qm . In this paper, we critically analyze the conditions under which an extra dimensional theory can be considered ‘renormalizable’ Gies_2003 ; Morris_2005 . This consists in the absence of higher dimensional operators in the bulk required by loop divergences, and the taming of the power-law running of the couplings. The latter is achieved by requiring the presence of UV fixed points for such couplings. We focus on 5D theories, where both conditions are most likely to occur, while theories with more dimensions have been proven to be always non-renormalizable (see, e.g., Ghilencea:2006qm ). This issue is of particular interest in Grand unification theories (GUTs) in 5D, where the power-law running has been used to obtain accelerated quantitative unification Dienes_2003 and asymptotic unification via fixed points Cacciapaglia21 . Upon reduction to a 4D effective field theory, the higher-dimensional fields decompose into Kaluza–Klein (KK) towers Perez_Lorenzana_2005 with masses and interactions determined by both the geometry and the boundary conditions. As a result, the particle content relevant at any given energy scale changes in a highly constrained way. This can substantially modify the dependence of gauge, Yukawa, and scalar couplings on energy, compared to the familiar 4D case Dienes_2003 . It is well known that in 4D theories, the evolution of couplings, governed by the renormalization group equations (RGEs), has a logarithmic dependence on the renormalization scale. However, this behavior changes to a power-law dependence when theories are formulated in higher dimensions, precisely due to the presence of the KK modes that accelerate the running. This is particularly relevant in the context of Grand unification Cacciapaglia21 . Traditional 4D unification scenarios are built around the logarithmic running of couplings and threshold effects associated with heavy states. In extra dimensional models, by contrast, an increasing number of KK levels contribute, and the high-energy behaviour is no longer generically described by a single unification point Bajc_2016 . This motivates revisiting the idea of unification from the viewpoint of higher-dimensional gauge theories, and in particular exploring under which conditions it can be realized. In this work we focus on 5D gauge theories compactified on a \mathcal{S}^{1}/\mathbb{Z}_{2} orbifold, and we aim at determining the minimal Lagrangian and field content leading to a renormalizable theory, as defined above. We focus on boundary conditions consistent with an orbifold as it is the only case that preserves the 5D gauge symmetry at high scales, see e.g. Cacciapaglia:2023kyz . We limit our analysis at one loop, hence providing the first concrete step towards an all-order proof of renormalizability. Henceforth, we study the structure of the required bulk and localized counterterms, as well as the running of bulk gauge, Yukawa, and scalar quartic couplings. The presence of UV fixed points for the power-law running couplings imposes additional requirements on the field content and symmetries of the bulk theory and on the localized Yukawa couplings. We find that a theory containing 4D-renormalizable interactions in the bulk and boundaries may fulfill the renormalizability criteria in 5D. The effect of higher-loop orders is highly non-trivial, and it may require the inclusion of additional higher dimensional operators. However, a detailed analysis is required, which we leave for future investigation: the main point being that the presence of logarithmic running could be acceptable, as long as the 5D theory remains valid until scales much higher than the compactification one. The impact of higher-loop orders on the fixed points is less important as long as the fixed point values are perturbative. Also, fixed points in 5D have received some support from non-perturbative analyses Gies_2003 ; Codello:2016muj ; DeCesare:2021pfb ; Pastor-Gutierrez:2024huj . The manuscript is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we analyze the structure of one loop bulk divergences in 5D gauge-Yukawa theories. Using power-counting arguments, we show that at one-loop the divergent operator structure in 5D coincides with the one of 4D theories, with divergences enhanced by the power-law sensitivity to the UV cutoff. We also discuss how this conclusion could be extended to higher loops. Section 3 is devoted to the study of divergences localized on the orbifold fixed points. We begin with a detailed study of a pure Yang-Mills theory compactified on a \mathcal{S}_{1}/\mathbb{Z}_{2} orbifold, illustrating how the boundary terms arise from the breaking of translational invariance along the fifth dimension. We then extend the analysis to include fermions, scalars and Yukawa interactions, computing all