Searching for Periodicity in FRB 20240114A

J. I. Katz · 2025

Read Searching for Periodicity in FRB 20240114A by J. I. Katz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24936.txt.

Introduction

Katz searches for periodicity in the fast radio burst source FRB 20240114A, an extraordinarily active repeater. Magnetar models predict a spin period, so thousands of bursts offer a chance to find it. One day of observations held over three thousand bursts within a span short enough that slowing would not smear a period above a tenth of a second.

No significant peak appears in the periodogram of those bursts. Injecting artificial modulation shows an amplitude of about fifteen percent would have been detected robustly. Astronomy readers get a firm null result: if bursts are modulated by rotation, the modulation that day was weak or absent.

Catalog record

CREATORJ. I. Katz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE12 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24936

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Searching for Periodicity in FRB 20240114A J. I. Katz Abstract FRB 20240114A is extraordinarily active, and therefore presents an opportunity to search for the periodicity predicted by magnetar models of Fast Radio Bursts (FRB). Zhang et al. 2025 observed 11,553 bursts, including 3196 on MJD 60381 (March 12, 2024). We find no significant peak in the periodogram of those bursts, which occur within 15628 s, short enough that even with a characteristic slowing age of 1 year a signal with period ≥ 0.1 \geq 0.1\, s it would not significantly dephase within the observation. Introducing modulation artificially shows that an amplitude of 0.15 would have been detected robustly. Implications for magnetar models of FRB are briefly considered. I Introduction The most popular model of Fast Radio Bursts (FRB) ( Zhang 2023 ) attributes them to magnetars, hypermagnetized neutron stars. Magnetars were first proposed ( Katz 1982 ; Duncan & Thompson 1992 ) as models of Soft Gamma Repeaters (SGR; initially considered to be gamma-ray bursts), a model that was verified when rapid spindown between outbursts confirmed their extraordinary magnetic fields. This model makes one obvious prediction: that FRB, or the level of FRB activity are periodic with the neutron star’s rotational period. This prediction has never been verified for any FRB, despite evidence Niu, Li, Yang et al. 2025 ; Wang, Lan, Zhao et al. 2025 that at least one FRB is inside an expanding supernova remnant, as would be exptected in a magnetar model. The extreme activity and many detected bursts of FRB 20240114A, including 3196 within 15628 s on the single day March 12, 2024 ( Zhang et al. 2025 ) , present a favorable opportunity for a search. We report the failure of that search. II Types of periodicity We distinguish two types of periodicity: II.1 RRAT periodicity RRAT (Rotating RAdio Transients) emit pulses whose separations are integer multiples of a very slowly varying period. They are interpreted as pulsars most of whose pulses are nulled. It was easy to show ( Katz 2022 used five bursts of FRB 20121102 observed within 93 s by Gajjar et al. 2018 ) that RRAT-like periodicity was inconsistent with the bursts of at least one repeating FRB. The fact that most distributions of intervals between bursts are bimodal may cloud this picture. If the shorter intervals, typically tens of ms, represent substructure within bursts separated by (typically) a few minutes, then it is not possible to define the stable near-exact period required by RRAT-like periodicity. II.2 Periodic Modulation of Activity In a magnetar model of FRB the bursts themselves may be stochastic. However, they cannot emit isotropically because a neutron star magnetic field cannot be isotropic. An observation has a detection threshold, and the probability that a burst exceeds that threshold must depend on the orientation of the field with respect to the observer. That probability varies with the rotation period (unless the field is azimuthally symmetric about the rotation axis). This model predicts that the rate of detected bursts varies with the neutron star rotation period. In this note we search for, and set bounds on, such a periodic variation. III Parameters and Phase Drift Zhang et al. 2025 observed FRB 20240114A over eight months, which sets a lower bound on its age. No repeating FRB has ever been reported to turn off or even to show a secular decrease in its activity, although their activity varies greatly. This suggests that ages of observed repeating FRB are \gtrsim 1\, y, possibly \gg 1\, y. FRB 20121102 has been observed to be active for >10\, y. Here we assume FRB 20240114A had an age of 1 y when observed on March 12, 2024; numerical results are readily scaled. A magnetar with a dipole moment component perpendicular to its rotational axis \mu=\mu_{33}10^{33}\, Gauss-cm 3 (corresponding to an equatorial field of about 10^{15}\, Gauss), born spinning comparatively rapidly, has an angular rotation frequency \omega=\sqrt{{3\over 2}{Ic^{3}\over\mu^{2}A}}\approx 36\mu_{33}^{-1}A_{y}^{-1/2}\text{s}^{-1} (1) at age A, where we have taken its moment of inertia I=10^{45}\, g-cm 2 and A_{y} is its age in years. Eq. 1 corresponds to a rotational period 0.176 \mu_{33}^{-1}A_{y}^{1/2}\, s, and is consistent with observed SGR periods 2–12 s for their known ages of a few thousand years. IV Results In order to search for a periodic modulation of irregularly spaced events we perform a periodogram. There are few enough bursts and few enough possible frequencies (integer multiples of 2\pi/T ) up to 200\pi Hz, to allow for periods as short as 0.01 s. This assumes that \mu_{33} is not \ll 1 , as for known Galactic magnetars. It is plausible that a very active magnetar-FRB must be strongly magnetized; see also the energetic argument of Zhang et al. 2025 pointing to large magnetic fields, although this depends on uncertain assumptions about beaming and radiative efficiency. The peridogram of events occuring at times \{t_{i}\} is defined P(\omega)=\sqrt{\left(\sum_{i}\cos{(\omega t_{i})}\right)^{2}+\left(\sum_{i}\sin{(\omega t_{i})}\right)^{2}}. (2) It would be possible to weight the terms to account for the strength (flux or fluence) of each burst, but then the small number of very strong bursts would increase the stochastic noise. Results for frequencies (in cycles/s, not radians) up to 10 Hz are shown in Fig. 1 . Extending the search to frequencies up to 100 Hz found no P(\omega) larger than the largest found below 10 Hz (at a frequency of 2.19 Hz). The slight rise of the periodogram to the lowest frequencies indicates a modest variation of the rate of bursts through the 156280 s (4.34 hours) of observation. Figure 1: Periodogram of 3196 bursts of FRB 20240114A in a 15628 s observation March 12, 2024 (MJD 60381), data from Zhang et al. 2025 . Extension of the calculation to frequencies of 100 Hz (implying a neutron star with \mu_{33}\ll 1 ) produced no higher peaks than shown here. V Frequency Derivative For a rotor spinning down as a result of its dipole radiation {\dot{\omega}}=-{\omega\over 2A}\approx-5.7\times 10^{-7}\mu_{33}^{-1}\ A_{y}^{-3/2}\text{s}^{-2}. (3) A large |\dot{\omega}| blurs the signature of periodicity. For an observation of duration T the phase drift of an oscillation from the midpoint of the observation (to which it is fitted) to its ends is \Delta\phi={1\over 8}{\dot{\omega}}T^{2}\approx 17\mu_{33}^{-1}A_{y}^{-3/2}\ \text{radian}, (4) where for the observation on March 12, 2024 T=15628\, s. If A_{y}>10 , \Delta\phi<0.55\mu_{33}^{-1}\, radian and spindown during the observation may have little effect on the detectability of periodicity, while if A_{y}<5 , \Delta\phi>1.6\mu_{33}^{-1}\, radian and detectability is siginificantly reduced. Of course, both A and \mu_{33} are unknown a priori. The duration over which the source has been observed sets a lower bound to A , as to statistical arguments based on the improbability of discovering a repeating FRB shortly after its birth and arguments based on the radio opacity of very young SNR. A modified periodogram allows for steady frequency drift: \begin{split}C(\omega,{\dot{\omega}})&=\sum_{i}\cos{\left[(\omega t_{i})+{1\over 2}{\dot{\omega}}(t_{i}-t_{m})^{2}\right]}\\ S(\omega,{\dot{\omega}})&=\sum_{i}\sin{\left[(\omega t_{i})+{1\over 2}{\dot{\omega}}(t_{i}-t_{m})^{2}\right]}\\ P(\omega,{\dot{\omega}})&=\sqrt{C(\omega,{\dot{\omega}})^{2}+S(\omega,{\dot{\omega}})^{2}},\\ \end{split} (5) where t_{m} is the midpoint of the data range. We calculate this with {\dot{\omega}}\in[-1\times 10^{-6},+1\times 10^{-6}]\, s -2 in steps of 10^{-8} s -2 . Again, no significant peaks were found for any (\omega,{\dot{\omega}}) with 2\pi/T\leq\omega\leq 200\pi/ s and the preceding range of \dot{\omega} . Yet greater \omega would be inconsistent with the magnetic moment implied by the magnetar hypothesis

Read the complete text