The tournament ratchet’s clicktime process, and metastability in a Moran model

Jan Lukas Igelbrink, Charline Smadi, Anton Wakolbinger · 2025

Read The tournament ratchet’s clicktime process, and metastability in a Moran model by Jan Lukas Igelbrink, Charline Smadi, Anton Wakolbinger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24779.txt.

Introduction

Jan Lukas Igelbrink, Charline Smadi, and Anton Wakolbinger analyze Muller's ratchet under tournament selection, a model of how harmful mutations accumulate in asexual populations. Population size stays fixed, mutations arrive at a constant rate, and fitter individuals carry fewer mutations. In tournament selection only the sign of load differences matters, not their size, unlike the classical version.

In a slow-clicking regime, where the least-loaded class is lost rarely, they study the clicktime process and metastability in a Moran model. Probability readers get sharp tools for long quiet periods punctuated by sudden losses. The ratchet matters for understanding degeneration in small asexual populations.

Catalog record

CREATORJan Lukas Igelbrink, Charline Smadi, Anton Wakolbinger
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE87 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24779

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The tournament ratchet’s clicktime process, and metastability in a Moran model Jan Lukas Igelbrink, Charline Smadi, Anton Wakolbinger Abstract . Muller’s ratchet, in its prototype version, models a haploid, asexual population whose size N N is constant over the generations. Slightly deleterious mutations are acquired along the lineages at a constant rate, and individuals carrying less mutations have a selective advantage. In the classical variant, an individual’s selective advantage is proportional to the difference between the population average and the individual’s mutation load, whereas in the ratchet with tournament selection only the signs of the differences of the individual mutation loads matter. In a parameter regime which leads to slow clicking (i.e. to a loss of the currently fittest class at a rate ≪ 1 / N \ll 1/N ) we prove that the rescaled process of click times of the tournament ratchet converges as N → ∞ N\to\infty to a Poisson process. Central ingredients in the proof are a thorough analysis of the metastable behaviour of a two-type Moran model with selection and deleterious mutation (which describes the size of the fittest class up to its extinction time) and a lower estimate on the size of the new fittest class at a clicktime. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 92D15; secondary 60K35, 60J80, 60J27, 60F17 1. Introduction Muller’s ratchet is a prototype model in population genetics; among the pioneering papers are [ 18 , 26 , 16 ] . Originally, this model was conceived to explain the ubiquity of sexual reproduction among eukaryotes despite its many costs [ 23 , 13 ] . In its bare-bones version, Muller’s ratchet models a haploid asexual population whose size N is constant over generations. Slightly deleterious mutations are acquired along the lineages of descent at a constant rate, and an individual’s mutational load (i.e. the number of mutations that was accumulated along the individual’s ancestral lineage) compared to the mutational loads of its contemporaries is decisive for the individual’s success in the selective part of the reproduction dynamics. With the type of an individual being its current mutational load, the population dynamics leads to a type frequency profile that is “driven upwards” by the effect of mutation and “kept tight” by the effect of selection. Due to mutation and randomness in the individual reproduction, the currently fittest class, i.e. the subpopulation of individuals carrying the currently smallest mutational load, will eventually get extinct; this is a click of the ratchet . Tournament versus fitness proportionate selection For quantifying the effect of an individual mutational load within a population there are two prototypic ways: in the so-called fitness proportionate selection , the value of the individual mutational load is compared to the mean value of the mutational loads in the population, and the individual’s selective advantage is proportional to the resulting difference. In the so-called tournament selection , the selective advantage of an individual is determined by the rank of its mutational load within the contemporary population. We will work with the (continuous-time) Moran model for Muller’s ratchet with tournament selection, and refer to it as the tournament ratchet for short. Here we give a brief verbal description of the individual-based, Poisson-process driven dynamics of the tournament ratchet as specified by the graphical representation in [ 15 ] , which is in line with the definition of the type frequency process given at the beginning of Section 2 . - For each ordered pair of individuals, neutral reproduction events come at rate \tfrac{1}{2N} , resulting in a binary reproduction of the first and the death of the second individual. - For each pair of individuals carrying different mutational loads, selective reproduction events come at rate s_{N}/N , resulting in a binary reproduction of the fitter and the death of the less fit individual. - Each individual’s mutation load is increased by 1 at rate m_{N} . An appealing feature of the tournament ratchet is that for each k\in\mathbb{N} the dynamics of the k fittest classes is autonomous up to the time of extinction of the fittest class. In particular, the size of the currently fittest class is described by a two-type Moran model with selection and deleterious mutation. This “hierarchical autonomy” of the fitness classes does not hold true for Muller’s ratchet with fitness proportionate selection, and to the best of our knowledge the asymptotic analysis of the click rate of the latter so far has resisted a complete and rigorous solution despite several attacks, among them [ 11 , 24 , 21 ] . Links between the two ratchet models are established in [ 19 ] , showing that under an appropriate transformation of the mutation-selection ratio \rho_{N}\mathrel{\mathop{\mathchar 58\relax}}=m_{N}/s_{N} in the near-critical parameter regime \rho_{N}\uparrow 1 the dynamics of the size of the fittest class of the tournament ratchet becomes what is called in [ 11 ] the Poisson profile approximation of the size of the fittest class of Muller’s ratchet with fitness proportionate selection. Brief summary of results We focus on a parameter regime of moderate mutation and selection, with 1 1 1 As usual, for two positive sequences (a_{N}) , (b_{N}) , the notation a_{N}\gg b_{N} means that a_{N}/b_{N}\to\infty , and a_{N}\sim b_{N} means that the two sequences are asymptotically equivalent , i.e. a_{N}/b_{N}\to 1 . 1\gg s_{N}>m_{N}\gg 1/N , m_{N}/s_{N}=\rho_{N} being convergent as N\to\infty , and satisfying the condition \mathfrak{a}_{N}/\mathfrak{c}_{N}\to\infty , where \mathfrak{a}_{N}\mathrel{\mathop{\mathchar 58\relax}}=N(1-\rho_{N}) is the center of attraction of the size of the fittest class and \mathfrak{c}_{N}\mathrel{\mathop{\mathchar 58\relax}}=(s_{N}-m_{N})^{-1} is the critical size below which the fittest class (then similar to a slightly supercritical branching processs) experiences quick extinction. Specifically, it turns out that, after a click followed by a relaxation time of duration O(\mathfrak{c}_{N}\log\mathfrak{a}_{N}) , the size of the fittest class performs (asymptotically Ornstein-Uhlenbeck) fluctuations on the \mathfrak{c}_{N} -timescale, and goes extinct after an asymptotically exponentially distributed time on a much larger timescale, then with the next-fittest class taking over. In this sense, under the condition \mathfrak{c}_{N}\ll\mathfrak{a}_{N} , the model exhibits a metastable behaviour. (For more background on the concept of metastability, see e.g. the monograph [ 6 , Chapter 8] .) Thus our main result concerning the tournament ratchet (Theorem 2.3 ) is the convergence of the rescaled clicktime process to a standard Poisson process, with the expected time between clicks being given up to asymptotic equivalence as N\to\infty by an explicitly computed quantity e_{N} . This quantity appeared in [ 19 ] via a Green function analysis as the asymptotic equivalent of the expected extinction time of the fittest class when started from large sizes, see eq. ( 2.12 ) below. Theorem 2.3 constitutes also a substantial improvement compared to [ 15 , Theorem 2.2] , where convergence of the rescaled clicktime process to a standard Poisson process was proved in the special case of the mutation-selection ratio m_{N}/s_{N} not depending on N , and where the click rate was determined only up to logarithmic equivalence. The methods applied in the present paper are fundamentally different from those of [ 15 ] : while that paper pursued a backward-in-time strategy (relying on the duality of the tournament ratchet with a hierarchy of decorated ancestral selection graphs), the present paper takes a forward-in-time approach. As indicated above, a

Read the complete text