Runaway electron avalanche and macroscopic beam formation: simulations of the DTT full power scenario

Enrico Emanuelli, Francesco Vannini, Matthias Hoelzl, Eric Nardon, Vinodh Bandaru, Nina Schwarz, Daniele Bonfiglio, Giuseppe Ramogida, Fabio Subba, JOREK Team · 2025

Read Runaway electron avalanche and macroscopic beam formation: simulations of the DTT full power scenario by Enrico Emanuelli, Francesco Vannini, Matthias Hoelzl, Eric Nardon, Vinodh Bandaru, Nina Schwarz, Daniele Bonfiglio, Giuseppe Ramogida, Fabio Subba, JOREK Team (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24760.txt.

Introduction

Emanuelli, Vannini, Hoelzl, and colleagues simulate runaway electrons in the Divertor Tokamak Test facility at its full power scenario, with plasma current well above the commissioning level. Earlier low-current studies suggested a safe margin against runaway beam formation. Higher current changes that picture sharply, because avalanche gain grows exponentially with current.

Using the nonlinear magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK, they model the current quench phase across several disruption scenarios in two dimensions. The safe operating window narrows severely at full power. Fusion safety readers get a concrete reason to treat runaway beams as a central design concern for high-current tokamak operation.

Catalog record

CREATOREnrico Emanuelli, Francesco Vannini, Matthias Hoelzl, Eric Nardon, Vinodh Bandaru, Nina Schwarz, Daniele Bonfiglio, Giuseppe Ramogida, Fabio Subba, JOREK Team
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24760

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Runaway electron avalanche and macroscopic beam formation: simulations of the DTT full power scenario Enrico Emanuelli, Francesco Vannini, Matthias Hoelzl, Eric Nardon, Vinodh Bandaru, Nina Schwarz, Daniele Bonfiglio, Giuseppe Ramogida, Fabio Subba, JOREK Team Abstract The transition of the Divertor Tokamak Test (DTT) facility from its initial commissioning phase (Day-0, plasma current I p = 2 I_{p}=2 MA) to the full power scenario ( I p = 5.5 I_{p}=5.5 MA) introduces a critical shift in the dynamics of runaway electrons (REs) generation. While previous predictive studies of the low-current scenario indicated a robust safety margin against RE beam formation, this work reveals that the exponential scaling of the RE avalanche gain with plasma current severely narrows the safe operational window in the full power scenario. Using the non-linear magnetohydrodynamic code JOREK, we perform comprehensive 2D simulations of the current quench (CQ) phase of several disruption scenarios, systematically scanning initial RE seed currents and injected impurity levels. The results demonstrate that in the full power scenario, the avalanche multiplication factor is sufficiently high ( G a ​ v ≈ 1.3 ⋅ 10 5 G_{av}\approx 1.3\cdot 10^{5} ) to convert a mere 5.5 A seed current into macroscopic RE beams of ≈ 0.7 \approx 0.7 MA when large amounts of impurities are present. For even higher RE seeds, the RE current can peak at ≈ 3.2 \approx 3.2 MA, constituting up to ≈ \approx 80% of the total plasma current during the CQ. These findings suggest that, unlike the Day-0 phase, the disruption mitigation strategy for the full power scenario involves a careful balance between thermal load mitigation and RE avoidance, necessitating a well-chosen quantity of injected impurities. This work provides the baseline needed for future estimations of RE loads on the plasma-facing components of DTT, which will be essential for designing and positioning mitigation components like sacrificial limiters. I Introduction The successful operation of next-generation tokamaks requires robust strategies to prevent or mitigate plasma disruptions 26 ; 15 . Disruption mitigation typically relies on massive injection of impurities (e.g., neon or argon) to radiate the plasma thermal energy and distribute the heat load more uniformly 26 ; 15 . This rapid cooling of the plasma (thermal quench, TQ) drastically increases the plasma resistivity, ending the discharge by leading to a fast decay of the plasma current (current quench, CQ). However, the strong induced toroidal electric field can accelerate electrons to relativistic energies, generating a population of runaway electrons (REs) 8 ; 9 . The primary RE population (RE seed) can be exponentially amplified via the avalanche mechanism, where relativistic electrons knock thermal electrons into the runaway region through close Coulomb collisions 29 . The avalanche gain, defined as the amplification factor of the RE seed population in the limit of an extremely small initial seed, scales exponentially with the plasma current I_{p} ( G_{\text{av}}\approx e^{I_{p}/(I_{A}\ln\Lambda)} , where I_{A} is the Alfvén current and \ln\Lambda is the Coulomb logarithm), severely exacerbating the risk posed by REs in high-current regimes 29 . If not suppressed, the resulting RE beam can carry a substantial fraction of the pre-disruption plasma current, eventually impinging on localized regions of the first wall and potentially causing the deep melting of metallic plasma-facing components (PFCs) 15 ; 23 ; 27 . The Divertor Tokamak Test (DTT) facility 22 ; 28 , currently under construction, is designed to investigate power exhaust solutions in regimes relevant to ITER 12 and EU-DEMO 14 . With a nominal plasma current of I_{p}=5.5 MA and auxiliary heating power up to 45 MW, DTT will achieve divertor heat flux densities comparable to those expected in future reactors 28 . Although the ultimate goal is operation in the full power scenario, the operational plan of DTT includes an initial low-current commissioning phase (Day-0, characterized by I_{p}=2 MA and a toroidal magnetic field of B_{\phi}=3 T 10 ), where the potential for RE generation is substantially lower. Previous predictive studies 13 focused on this Day-0 scenario of DTT and indicated that, by controlling the amount of impurities injected via the disruption mitigation system (DMS), it is possible to avoid the conditions that generate a substantial RE beam, even with large RE seeds ( \approx 20 kA). For smaller RE seeds, the generation of RE beams remains minimal, even for high levels of impurities. However, the transition to the full power scenario ( I_{p}=5.5 MA, B_{\phi}=5.85 T) introduces a drastic shift in disruption dynamics: since the avalanche gain G_{\text{av}} scales exponentially with the plasma current, the 5.5 MA scenario is susceptible to the conversion of even minute seed populations into macroscopic RE beams, rendering the system more sensitive to the amount of impurities injected by the DMS. This work broadens the safety analysis of RE avalanches in DTT to the full power scenario, employing the non-linear magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) code JOREK 18 ; 17 and the resistive wall code STARWALL 24 ; 19 . Building upon the work carried out for the Day-0 scenario 13 , we extend the 2D analysis to the reactor-relevant regime, investigating the CQ dynamics and the formation of macroscopic RE beams at 5.5 MA. We systematically vary impurity levels and seed currents to assess the dependence of the RE beam current on these factors, clarifying the specific combinations of parameters that lead to significant RE beam formation and thereby defining the risk boundaries for the full power scenario. II Models and methods The computational framework employed in this study combines the non-linear MHD code JOREK 18 ; 17 with the resistive wall code STARWALL 24 ; 19 , closely following what was done in our previous work 13 . We employ the reduced MHD formulation of JOREK 18 ; 11 , where the magnetic and electric fields are expressed through the poloidal magnetic flux \psi and the velocity stream function u . To study RE dynamics, the MHD equations are coupled with the RE fluid model described in 2 ; 3 . This model treats REs as a distinct fluid species, self-consistently capturing the feedback between the RE population and the bulk plasma. We prescribe a pre-existing RE seed at the initialization to serve as a proxy for primary formation processes (e.g., hot-tail or Dreicer), which is then multiplied via the computation of the secondary volumetric source (RE avalanching). Previous applications of this framework include the study of RE formation and termination in JET 5 , ITER 4 ; 6 ; 33 and EU-DEMO 32 . Following the transport coefficients detailed in 13 , the electrical resistivity \eta_{e} and parallel thermal diffusivity \chi_{\parallel} follow the standard Spitzer ( \propto T_{e}^{-3/2} ) and Spitzer-Härm ( \propto T_{e}^{5/2} ) scalings, respectively, but are regularized by constant cut-off values for temperatures exceeding 500 eV and 350 eV. Additionally, the parallel thermal diffusivity is subject to a low-temperature cut-off at 20 eV. Regarding cross-field transport, we employ a constant particle diffusivity D=2 \text{m}^{2}/\text{s} and a perpendicular thermal diffusivity \chi_{\perp} profile with a core value of 2 \text{m}^{2}/\text{s} . The boundary condition for the electron temperature is fixed at 0.7 eV. For the RE fluid, a dominant parallel diffusivity of D_{\parallel,RE}=1\times 10^{9} \text{m}^{2}/\text{s} is imposed to mimic the rapid transit of RE along magnetic field lines. As established in

Read the complete text