Easier randomizing gates provide more accurate fidelity estimation

Debankan Sannamoth, Kristine Boone, Arnaud Carignan-Dugas, Akel Hashim, Irfan Siddiqi, Karl Mayer, Joseph Emerson · 2025

Read Easier randomizing gates provide more accurate fidelity estimation by Debankan Sannamoth, Kristine Boone, Arnaud Carignan-Dugas, Akel Hashim, Irfan Siddiqi, Karl Mayer, Joseph Emerson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24744.txt.

Introduction

Debankan Sannamoth, Kristine Boone, and Arnaud Carignan-Dugas show a flaw in a standard way of estimating quantum gate errors, and a fix using easier random gates. Interleaved random testing compares series with and without a target gate, random with the multi-qubit Clifford group. Under coherent errors, that method can give highly inaccurate or even invalid error estimates.

Numerical and lab results support the critique. Simpler random choices give more accurate fidelity estimates in their tests. Quantum hardware readers get a useful testing lesson: the randomizer itself can bias the answer, and lighter randomization can make gate error numbers more trustworthy.

Catalog record

CREATORDebankan Sannamoth, Kristine Boone, Arnaud Carignan-Dugas, Akel Hashim, Irfan Siddiqi, Karl Mayer, Joseph Emerson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24744

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Easier randomizing gates provide more accurate fidelity estimation Debankan Sannamoth, Kristine Boone, Arnaud Carignan-Dugas, Akel Hashim, Irfan Siddiqi, Karl Mayer, Joseph Emerson Abstract Accurate benchmarking of quantum gates is crucial for understanding and enhancing the performance of quantum hardware. A standard method for this is interleaved benchmarking, a technique which estimates the error on an interleaved target gate by comparing cumulative error rates of randomized sequences implemented with the interleaved gate and without it. In this work, we show both numerically and experimentally that the standard approach of interleaved randomized benchmarking (IRB), which uses the multi-qubit Clifford group for randomization, can produce highly inaccurate and even physically impossible estimates for the error on the interleaved gate in the presence of coherent errors. Fortunately we also show that interleaved benchmarking performed with cycle benchmarking, which randomizes with single qubit Pauli gates, provides dramatically reduced systematic uncertainty relative to standard IRB, and further provides as host of additional benefits including data reusability. We support our conclusions with a theoretical framework for bounding systematic errors, extensive numerical results comparing a range of interleaved protocols under fixed resource costs, and experimental demonstrations on three quantum computing platforms. I INTRODUCTION Randomized benchmarking Emerson et al. 2005 ; Dankert et al. 2009 ; Magesan et al. 2011 ; Magesan et al. 2012a ; Lévi et al. 2007 is a fundamental method in quantum computing that now comprises a broad class of methods to estimate the error rates of quantum gates Helsen et al. 2022 ; Hashim et al. 2025 . While these methods are often applied to estimate error rates averaged over some set or group of elementary gates, in this work we focus on interleaved benchmarking protocols which aim to estimate the error on some specific gate of interest, typically a two-qubit entangling gate such as the CNOT. The primary example of such a protocol is interleaved randomized benchmarking (IRB) Magesan et al. 2012b , which is currently a standard benchmarking approach with widespread adoption across all leading experimental platforms Córcoles et al. 2013 ; Barends et al. 2014 ; Kelly et al. 2014 ; McKay et al. 2019 ; Muhonen et al. 2015 ; Kawakami et al. 2016 ; Gaebler et al. 2012 ; Manetsch et al. 2025 ; Weinstein et al. 2023 ; Moses et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2023 ; Wu et al. ; Song et al. 2025 ; Champion et al. 2025 ; Norris et al. 2025 ; Scarato et al. 2025 ; Sung et al. 2021 . The standard IRB scheme proposes implementing a reference randomized benchmarking (RB) sequence, that is, a standard RB experiment with the full Clifford group, as well as an interleaved sequence with the gate of interest interleaved between the randomizing gates. The ratio of the latter over the former is intended to provide an accurate estimate of the error on the interleaved gate alone. In this work, we demonstrate with theoretical, numerical, and experimental evidence that the systematic uncertainty for IRB can lead to significant inaccuracy in practice, producing not just inaccurate but even physically impossible error-rate estimates for the interleaved gate in the presence of even moderate amounts of coherent error. Fortunately, we also show that this problem can be effectively mitigated by selecting an easier-to-implement randomization group based on single-qubit gates with lower average error, notably the Pauli randomization used in cycle benchmarking (CB) Erhard et al. 2019 and the local Clifford randomization Emerson et al. 2007 used in variety of other benchmarking protocols Emerson et al. 2007 ; McKay et al. . Benchmarking protocols with these simpler randomization groups have now been well-studied theoretically Emerson et al. 2007 ; McKay et al. ; Carignan-Dugas et al. 2023 ; Beale et al. 2020 ; Carignan-Dugas et al. 2024 ; Chen et al. 2023 ; Calzona et al. 2024 ; Zhang et al. 2025 ; Flammia and Wallman 2020 and experimentally across a wide-variety of platforms Emerson et al. 2007 ; McKay et al. ; Hashim et al. 2021 ; Fazio et al. 2025 ; Pulido-Mateo et al. 2024 ; Haghshenas et al. 2025 . In spite of the above works exploring single qubit randomization with low average error rates, there is still widespread adoption of IRB Córcoles et al. 2013 ; Barends et al. 2014 ; Kelly et al. 2014 ; McKay et al. 2019 ; Muhonen et al. 2015 ; Kawakami et al. 2016 ; Gaebler et al. 2012 ; Manetsch et al. 2025 ; Weinstein et al. 2023 ; Moses et al. 2023 ; Li et al. 2023 ; Wu et al. ; Song et al. 2025 ; Champion et al. 2025 ; Norris et al. 2025 ; Scarato et al. 2025 ; Sung et al. 2021 which requires multi-qubit randomization with associated high average error rates. We show below that the dramatic inaccuracy of IRB is entirely avoidable, where the single qubit randomization of cycle benchmarking provides a far more accurate alternative for interleaved benchmarking in addition to offering a host of additional benefits at scale, including robustness under cross-talk error and data-reusability, which local clifford randomization does not provide. Our analysis of the systematic error in interleaved benchmarking protocols builds on the systematic bounds developed in Carignan-Dugas et al. 2019a which characterize how component level errors in a composition of gates can interfere coherently to give rise to significant variation in the cumulative error across a product of gates. In particular, we evaluate the significance of this effect in different interleaved benchmarking protocols, where we demonstrate that extremely large systematic uncertainties can arise in realistic contexts. Our results counter the (incorrect) intuition that randomized sequences typically suppress coherent errors, and so destructive and constructive interference should not be a concern under randomized benchmarking. This intuition fails because for interleaved benchmarking protocol the suppression of coherence only occurs between the composed errors from the interleaved gate and the randomizing gates; coherence is not suppressed between each of these gates separately. Our work also counters the intuition that coherent (cancellation or amplification) effects for gate errors are actually rare and thus unlikely to be significant in practice. We show below that this is decidedly not the case: under typical experimental conditions, we provide both numerical and experimental evidence indicating that coherence effects can be significant enough to produce physically impossible estimates, in particular, negative error probabilities. The manuscript is structured as follows. First, in Section II , we provide conceptual and theoretical background and establish terminology for the set of interleaved benchmarking protocols that we evaluate. In Section III.1 , we discuss the details about systematic bounds. In Section III.2 , we discuss how performing extended randomized benchmarking (XRB) to extract knowledge of the unitarity of the error along with estimates from protocols like Haar-RB and IRB helps in providing a tighter bound as compared to the systematic bounds. In Section IV , we show numerical and experimental results across three different quantum computing platforms comparing different interleaved protocols in support of our conclusions. In Appendix A , we provide a framework for constructing the self-consistent gauge under which a theoretical value can be rigorously compared to the protocol estimator, to address the gauge ambiguity of RB protocols. Finally,

Read the complete text