Model-independent search of gravitational wave echoes in LVK data

Di Wu, Xi-Li Zhang, Qing-Guo Huang, Jing Ren · 2025

Read Model-independent search of gravitational wave echoes in LVK data by Di Wu, Xi-Li Zhang, Qing-Guo Huang, Jing Ren (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24730.txt.

Introduction

Di Wu, Xi-Li Zhang, and Qing-Guo Huang search LIGO, Virgo, and KAGRA data for gravitational wave echoes without assuming a specific echo waveform. Echoes could reveal structure near a black hole horizon, beyond standard spectroscopy, but theory gives uncertain predictions. Their target is long-lived quasinormal modes expected from strong reflection inside the remnant.

A generalized phase-marginalized likelihood combines each mode coherently across the detector network, raising sensitivity. An optimized notching step suppresses instrument spectral lines in real noise. Readers get a robust search design that stays useful even while echo models remain unsettled, plus a template for model-agnostic gravitational wave searches.

Catalog record

CREATORDi Wu, Xi-Li Zhang, Qing-Guo Huang, Jing Ren
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24730

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Model-independent search of gravitational wave echoes in LVK data Di Wu, Xi-Li Zhang, Qing-Guo Huang, Jing Ren Abstract Gravitational wave echoes offer a unique probe of the near-horizon structure of astrophysical black holes, beyond the standard “black hole spectroscopy”. Theoretical waveform predictions, however, remain uncertain, motivating robust searches that avoid specific echo modeling. We present a model-independent search framework targeting long-lived quasinormal modes (QNMs) expected from strong interior reflection. By employing a generalized phase-marginalized likelihood that coherently combines data for each QNM across a detector network, our method enhances sensitivity to the signals. To handle real detector noise, we implement an optimized notching procedure to suppress instrumental spectral lines and refine the Bayesian parameter settings. We validate the performance of this framework using injection studies on O1 background data, demonstrating reliable signal recovery in realistic noise conditions. We then apply this method to three binary black hole merger events with high ringdown signal-to-noise ratios (SNR) from observing runs O1 to O4: GW150914, GW231226, and the recently detected GW250114. No statistically significant evidence for postmerger echoes is found. Consequently, we derive 90% upper limits on the network SNR and the average amplitude of the long-lived QNMs, setting the first model-independent constraints on late-time echo signatures from LVK data. \usephysicsmodule ab I Introduction The discovery of gravitational waves from compact binary coalescence by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaborations has opened a new window for exploring the universe 5 . To date, more than 200 compact binary coalescence events have been detected 6 ; 7 ; 8 ; 3 . Among these, the recent detection of GW250114 during the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaborations O4 observing run stands as a notable milestone, as its high ringdown signal-to-noise ratio has enabled precise tests of black hole spectroscopy 2 ; 22 . While the quasi-normal modes excited during the early ringdown have successfully validated the light ring structure predicted by general relativity 51 ; 26 ; 35 ; 87 ; 43 ; 21 , they remain largely insensitive to near-horizon corrections in the high redshift regime. If the merger remnant is an ultracompact object with a reflective surface located just outside the would-be horizon, as suggested by various quantum-gravity inspired models, gravitational waves would be trapped between the light-ring potential barrier and this interior boundary. The repeated, gradual leakage of waves outside the barrier produces a series of quasi-periodic wavelets following the initial ringdown signal, known as gravitational wave echoes 29 ; 30 ; 46 ; 24 ; 99 ; 84 ; 59 ; 55 ; 28 ; 34 ; 88 ; 48 ; 42 ; 86 ; 98 ; 50 ; 52 ; 15 ; 96 ; 85 ; 44 ; 63 ; 66 ; 73 ; 97 ; 95 ; 100 ; 56 ; 25 ; 49 ; 79 . Notably, the time delay for the echo wavelets remains observationally accessible even for the extreme case in which the reflective surface lies only a Planck length outside the would-be horizon. However, searching for these echoes presents significant challenges due to theoretical uncertainties. Various model-dependent templates were developed to capture the echo waveform with some applied to real data searches 12 ; 13 ; 91 ; 60 ; 57 ; 65 ; 82 ; 90 ; 89 ; 14 ; 92 ; 16 ; 83 ; 53 ; 62 ; 45 , but they often rely on specific assumptions regarding the ultracompact object structure, which remain poorly understood. To overcome this limitation, model-independent search methods have been proposed 33 ; 81 ; 11 ; 80 ; 74 ; 47 ; 32 ; 69 ; 61 ; 93 . A time-domain modeling utilizes pipelines developed for generic burst signals such as coherent WaveBurst 74 ; 32 ; 61 or BayesWave 81 ; 80 to search for the first few wavelets following the main event, a strategy sensitive to short-lived quasi-normal modes of the ultracompact object with a weak interior reflection. Conversely, when the echo decays slowly due to strong interior reflection, the signal-to-noise ratio accumulates steadily over time, making it necessary to include many wavelets and thus rendering burst-based searches computationally inefficient. In such cases, a frequency-domain modeling is more appropriate, as it directly targets the long-lived quasi-normal modes of the ultracompact object that dominate late-time echo signals, which appear as narrow, quasi-periodic resonances within a wide frequency band. A uniform comb model with narrow line widths can capture the generic features of these long-lived quasi-normal modes 33 ; 47 . By marginalizing over the unknown phase information, an efficient likelihood function was derived by some of the present authors to search for these modes in a model-independent manner. This method was applied to O1 data, and it found no clear evidence of narrow line structures for the first two CBC events 69 . However, this earlier approach completely discarded phase information, limiting its sensitivity to weak signals. More recently, a new phase-marginalized likelihood retaining partial phase information was proposed to address this sensitivity limitation 93 . By accounting for the relative phase variation between different frequency bins belonging to the same quasi-normal mode, this new method was shown to yield significant performance improvements in single-detector Gaussian noise. In particular, it delivers robust search results when the analysis duration is varied, especially in the high-frequency resolution regime. In this work, we extend the new phase-marginalized likelihood to a network of multiple detectors, enabling the coherent combination of data across the network to enhance detection sensitivity. We also improve the real-data search pipeline in several key aspects relative to earlier studies 69 ; 93 . These improvements include an optimized notching procedure to suppress the dominant non-Gaussian artifacts—instrumental spectral lines—as well as more appropriate setting for intrinsic and extrinsic parameters. We validate the performance of this pipeline on O1 detector noise by comparing with Gaussian noise results, confirming the effectiveness of notching and the robustness of signal recovery. We then apply this robust pipeline to search for gravitational wave echoes in LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaborations events from observing runs O1 to O4. We specifically focus on three events with high signal-to-noise ratio in the ringdown stage, including the newly detected O4 events which benefit from reduced background noise. This paper is structured as follows. In Sec. II , we review the quasi-normal modes of ultracompact objects in the case of strong interior reflection and derive the phase-marginalized likelihood for a multi-detector network, incorporating the individual detector responses. The data analysis procedure and parameter settings for LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaborations events are detailed in Sec. III . Sec. IV presents injection tests that validate the performance of this pipeline on real detector noise. In Sec. V , we apply our search pipeline to the three selected LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaborations events and present the search results. We summarize in Sec. VI . Additional information on instrumental lines relevant to the search and supplementary results for pure Gaussian noise are provided in Appendices A and B . Throughout the paper, we adopt geometric units, G=c=\hbar=1 , unless stated otherwise. II Phase-marginalized likelihood for a multi-detector network Without loss of generality, we model a sufficiently compact, spinning ultracompact object as a truncated Kerr black hole with a reflective surface r_{0} located slightly outside the would-be horizon r_{+} 33 ; 64

Read the complete text