Non-isomorphic metacyclic p p -groups of split type with the same group zeta function
Yuto Nogata · 2025
Read Non-isomorphic metacyclic p p -groups of split type with the same group zeta function by Yuto Nogata (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24546.txt.
Introduction
Yuto Nogata compares finite groups that share the same subgroup count profile. A group's zeta function sums over subgroups by order. Two non-isomorphic groups can share that function. No general criterion says when this happens. Nogata studies one family closely: metacyclic p-groups of split type. Each group is set by parameters m, n, and an action parameter k.
With m and n fixed, the question becomes which k values collide. Nogata characterizes the parameter pairs whose zeta functions agree exactly. Presentations of the groups make the counting possible. Subgroups of each order are tallied inside the family. Equality of the resulting Dirichlet series is then decided. The result gives a complete criterion inside this family. Group theorists gain a case where the zeta function's blindness is fully understood.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuto Nogata |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24546
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Non-isomorphic metacyclic p p -groups of split type with the same group zeta function Yuto Nogata Abstract Abstract For a finite group G , let a_{n}(G) be the number of subgroups of order n and define \zeta_{G}(s)=\sum_{n\geq 1}a_{n}(G)n^{-s} . Examples are known of non-isomorphic finite groups with the same group zeta function. However, no general criterion is known for when two finite groups have the same group zeta function. Fix integers m,n\geq 1 and a prime p , and consider the metacyclic p -groups of split type G(p,m,n,k) defined by G(p,m,n,k)=\langle a,b\mid a^{p^{m}}=b^{p^{n}}=\id,b^{-1}ab=a^{k}\rangle . For fixed m and n , we characterize the pairs of parameters k_{1},k_{2} for which \zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{1})}(s)=\zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{2})}(s) . 1 Introduction There is a long tradition of studying subgroup growth and related subgroup counting problems. Classical congruence results for the number of subgroups of index p in finite p -groups go back to [ Miller, 1919 ] and were strengthened in [ Dyubyuk, 1950 ] . For free groups, a recursion for the number of subgroups of index n is given in [ Hall, 1949 ] . For the modular group \PSL(2,\Z) , explicit computations and asymptotics for the number of subgroups of index n are studied in [ Imrich, 1978 ] , [ Stothers, 1977 ] . Motivated by these developments, the Dirichlet series enumerating finite-index subgroups is defined by \zeta^{\mathrm{idx}}_{G}(s):=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}H\leq G\\ [G:H]<\infty\end{subarray}}[G:H]^{-s}=\sum_{n\geq 1}\frac{a^{\mathrm{idx}}_{n}(G)}{n^{s}},\qquad a^{\mathrm{idx}}_{n}(G):=\#\{\,H\leq G\mid[G:H]=n\,\}. It was introduced in [ Smith, 1983 ] , and it was studied systematically for nilpotent groups in [ Grunewald et al., 1988 ] . Analogous Dirichlet series enumerating normal finite-index subgroups are studied in [ Lee, 2022 ] . In this paper, we consider the group zeta function that enumerates all subgroups of a finite group by their orders. Following [ Hironaka, 2017 ] , we denote by S(G) the set of all subgroups of a finite group G . For each integer n\geq 1 , we define a_{n}(G):=\#\{\,H\in S(G)\mid|H|=n\,\} . We define the group zeta function of G by \zeta_{G}(s)=\sum_{H\in S(G)}|H|^{-s}=\sum_{n\geq 1}\frac{a_{n}(G)}{n^{s}}. For isomorphic finite groups G\simeq G^{\prime} , we trivially have \zeta_{G}(s)=\zeta_{G^{\prime}}(s) . In general, no criterion is known for when non-isomorphic groups can have the same group zeta function. In [ Hironaka, 2017 ] , the following pair is shown to provide an example of this phenomenon: \displaystyle G_{\lambda} \displaystyle=\langle a_{1},a_{2},\dots,a_{n}\mid|a_{i}|=p^{\lambda_{i}},\ a_{i}a_{j}=a_{j}a_{i}\rangle\simeq\prod_{i=1}^{n}\mathbb{Z}_{p^{\lambda_{i}}}, \displaystyle\widetilde{G}_{\lambda} \displaystyle=\langle a_{1},a_{2},\dots,a_{n}\mid|a_{i}|=p^{\lambda_{i}},\ a_{n}a_{1}a_{n}^{-1}=a_{1}^{\,1+p^{\lambda_{1}-1}},\ a_{i}a_{j}=a_{j}a_{i}\text{ unless }(i,j)=(1,n)\rangle \displaystyle\simeq\prod_{i=2}^{n-1}\mathbb{Z}_{p^{\lambda_{i}}}\times\bigl(\mathbb{Z}_{p^{\lambda_{1}}}\rtimes\mathbb{Z}_{p^{\lambda_{n}}}\bigr). Outside p -groups, further examples of non-isomorphic finite groups with the same group zeta function have been found, for instance in [ Parker and Kanchana, 2014 ] . More generally, no necessary and sufficient condition for this phenomenon is currently known. A finite group G is called metacyclic if G has a cyclic normal subgroup N\lhd G and the quotient G/N is also cyclic. Standard presentations of finite metacyclic groups were given in [ Hempel, 2000 ] . For arbitrary finite p -groups, [ Wall, 1961 ] studied general relations and inequalities between the numbers of subgroups of each order and each index, using Eulerian functions. For metacyclic p -groups, subgroup-counting formulas were obtained in [ Berkovich, 2011 ] , [ Mann, 2010 ] . In particular, these results imply that for an odd prime p and a fixed integer \ell\geq 1 , any two metacyclic p -groups of order p^{\ell} with the same exponent have the same group zeta function. Thus, for metacyclic p -groups with p\geq 3 , the problem posed in [ Hironaka, 2017 ] admits a partial answer. For p=2 , the subgroup-count formulas in [ Berkovich, 2011 ] are given by case distinctions. As summarized in Fact 2.10 , these distinctions depend on the structure of certain quotient groups. They determine the numbers a_{2^{t}}(G) for each individual metacyclic 2 -group. On the other hand, they do not explicitly describe which metacyclic 2 -groups are non-isomorphic but have the same group zeta function. In this paper, we focus primarily on the case p=2 . For a prime p and integers m,n\geq 1 , we denote by G(p,m,n,k) the group defined in ( 1.1 ) below. By [ Hempel, 2000 ] , every finite metacyclic p -group of split type is isomorphic to G(p,m,n,k) for some integers m,n\geq 1 and some ”valid” k . For p=2 , we give a necessary and sufficient condition for two non-isomorphic groups in this family to have the same group zeta function. The condition depends on the parameters m and n , and it is expressed in terms of the 2 -adic valuations v_{2}(k+1) , where v_{2}(\,\cdot\,) denotes the 2 -adic valuation. For p\geq 3 , our framework also shows that any two metacyclic p -groups of split type of order p^{m+n} with the same exponent have the same group zeta function. Theorem 1.1 Main Theorem Let p be a prime and let m,n\geq 1 be integers. Set H:=\mathbb{Z}_{p^{m}}=\langle a\rangle and K:=\mathbb{Z}_{p^{n}}=\langle b\rangle , and define G(p,m,n,k):=\langle a,b\mid a^{p^{m}}=b^{p^{n}}=\id,\ bab^{-1}=a^{k}\rangle. (1.1) We say that G(p,m,n,k) is ” valid ” if this presentation yields a finite metacyclic p -group of split type. In this case, G(p,m,n,k)=H\rtimes_{\phi}K , where \phi\colon K\to\Aut(H) is the homomorphism determined by \phi(b)(a)=bab^{-1}=a^{k} . Then the following hold. (I) the group G(p,m,n,k) is valid if and only if k^{p^{n}}\equiv 1\pmod{p^{m}}. (1.2) (II) Assume that k_{1} and k_{2} satisfy ( 1.2 ). Then the following equivalence holds: G(p,m,n,k_{1})\simeq G(p,m,n,k_{2})\iff\exists v\in(\mathbb{Z}/p^{n}\mathbb{Z})^{\times}\text{ such that }k_{2}\equiv k_{1}^{v}\pmod{p^{m}}. (III) Assume that k_{1} and k_{2} satisfy ( 1.2 ). A necessary and sufficient condition for \zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{1})}(s)=\zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{2})}(s) to hold is given as follows: (1) If p is an odd prime, then for any k_{1},k_{2} satisfying ( 1.2 ), we have \zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{1})}(s)=\zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{2})}(s) . (2) If p=2 and n<m , then for any k_{1},k_{2} satisfying ( 1.2 ), we have \zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{1})}(s)=\zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{2})}(s) if and only if one of the following conditions holds: \begin{cases}\text{{(A)}}\ \ v_{2}(k_{1}+1)=v_{2}(k_{2}+1)\leq m-n,\\ \text{{(B)}}\ \ \min\{v_{2}(k_{1}+1),v_{2}(k_{2}+1)\}>m-n.\end{cases} (3) If p=2 and n\geq m , then for any k_{1},k_{2} satisfying ( 1.2 ), we have \zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{1})}(s)=\zeta_{G(p,m,n,k_{2})}(s) . In particular, by choosing representatives k_{i} of the isomorphism classes as in (II) and applying the criterion in (III) , we can systematically obtain examples of non-isomorphic metacyclic p -groups of split type whose zeta functions coincide. 2 Notation and Preliminaries Definition 2.1 Throughout this paper, all groups are assumed to be finite. We use the following notation and terminology. • S(G) : the set of all subgroups of a group G , • a_{n}(G):=\#\{\,H\in S(G)\mid|H|=n\,\} , • p : a prime, • \zeta_{G}(s):=\sum_{n=1}^{\infty}\frac{a_{n}(G)}{n^{s}} , • H:=\langle a\rangle\simeq\mathbb{Z}_{p^{m}} , K:=\langle b\rangle\simeq\mathbb{Z}_{p^{n}} , • G(p,m,n,\lambda,k):=\langle a,b\mid a^{p^{m}}=\id,\ b^{p^{n}}=a^{p^{\lambda}},\ bab^{-1}=a^{k}\rangle , • G(p,m,n,k):=\langle a,b\mid a^{p^{m}}=b^{p^{n}}=\id,\ bab^{-1}=a^{k}\rangle , • A group L is called a section of a group G if there exist a subgroup A\subset G and a normal subgroup B\lhd A such that L\simeq A/B , • For a prime p and d\in\Z , we denote by v_{p}(d) the p -adic valuation of d , and we adopt the convention v_{p}(0):=\infty , • For a finite p -group P , we define \mho_{1}(P):=\langle\,x^{p}\mid x\in P\,\rangle , • For a finite group G , the exponent of G is \exp(G):=\mathrm{lcm}\{\,|g|\mid g\in G\,\} . By [ Hempel, 2000 ] , every finite metacyclic p -group is isomorphic to a group given by a presentation of the form G(p,m,n,\lambda,k) for suitable parameters.