Computing Flux-Surface Shapes in Tokamaks and Stellarators

M.J. Gerard, M.J. Pueschel, S. Stewart, H.O.M. Hillebrecht, B. Geiger · 2025

Read Computing Flux-Surface Shapes in Tokamaks and Stellarators by M.J. Gerard, M.J. Pueschel, S. Stewart, H.O.M. Hillebrecht, B. Geiger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24544.txt.

Introduction

M J Gerard and four colleagues characterize the shapes of plasma confinement surfaces. Tokamaks describe their flux surfaces with modes like elongation and triangularity. Stellarators add a twist, literally. In a non-axisymmetric device, each shaping mode rotates about the magnetic axis. Modern designs chase high magnetic quasi-symmetry through such shaping.

Fourier methods define the shaping modes for equilibrium cross-sections. The authors test several characterizations on quasi-symmetric configurations. The QUASR database supplies equilibria of varying symmetry quality. One method stands out. It picks cross-sections by shortest distance from the axis across symmetry contours. Shapes then need far fewer active modes to describe. Quasi-symmetry quality also tracks shape structure. Better symmetry means a tightly constrained, linear spread of modes. Shape complexity grows in step with rotation about the axis.

Catalog record

CREATORM.J. Gerard, M.J. Pueschel, S. Stewart, H.O.M. Hillebrecht, B. Geiger
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE78 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24544

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Computing Flux-Surface Shapes in Tokamaks and Stellarators Preprint: APS/123-QED M.J. Gerard, M.J. Pueschel, S. Stewart, H.O.M. Hillebrecht, B. Geiger Abstract There is currently no agreed-upon methodology for characterizing a stellarator magnetic field geometry, and yet modern stellarator designs routinely attain high levels of magnetic-field quasi-symmetry through careful flux-surface shaping. Here, we introduce a general method for computing the shape of an ideal-MHD equilibrium that can be used in both axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric configurations. This framework uses a Fourier mode analysis to define the shaping modes (e.g. elongation, triangularity, squareness, etc.) of cross-sections that can be non-planar. Relative to an axisymmetric equilibrium, the additional degree of freedom in a non-axisymmetric equilibrium manifests as a rotation of each shaping mode about the magnetic axis. Using this method, a shaping analysis is performed on non-axisymmetric configurations with precise quasi-symmetry and select cases from the QUASR database spanning a range of quasi-symmetry quality. Empirically, we find that quasi-symmetry results from a spatial resonance between shape complexity and shape rotation about the magnetic axis. The quantitative features of this resonance correlate closely with a configuration’s rotational transform and number of field periods. Based on these observations, it is conjectured that this shaping paradigm can facilitate systematic investigations into the relationship between general flux-surface geometries and other figures of merit. I Introduction In magnetic confinement fusion (MCF), the design and shape of the magnetic field plays a significant role in plasma confinement, influencing a wide range of phenomena that includes magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) stability Scarabosio et al. 2007 ; Brunetti et al. 2020 ; Rodríguez 2023 , fast-ion confinement Bindel et al. 2023 , neoclassical transport Beidler et al. 2021 ; Canik et al. 2007a ; Canik et al. 2007b , and turbulence Angelino et al. 2009 ; Mynick et al. 2010 ; Xanthopoulos et al. 2014 ; Proll et al. 2015 ; Hegna et al. 2018 ; Terry et al. 2018 ; Fontana et al. 2017 ; Huang et al. 2018 ; Laribi et al. 2021 ; Nakata and Matsuoka 2022 ; Mackenbach et al. 2022 ; Roberg-Clark et al. 2022 ; Merlo et al. 2023 ; Gerard et al. 2023 ; Gerard et al. 2024 ; Goodman et al. 2024 . In tokamaks, where the magnetic field is axisymmetric, the relationship between magnetic geometry and plasma dynamics can be investigated using, for instance, the so-called Miller parameters, which provide a geometric description of the axisymmetric poloidal cross-section with parameters like elongation, triangularity, and squareness Miller et al. 1998 . Importantly, this approach has allowed for the systematic investigation into the effect of shaping on the resulting plasma dynamics in both experiment and simulation Weisen et al. 1997 ; Waltz and Miller 1999 ; Reimerdes et al. 2000 ; Scarabosio et al. 2007 ; Ball and Parra 2017 ; Fontana et al. 2017 ; Marinoni et al. 2021 ; Beeke et al. 2021 . In the (non-axisymmetric) stellarator, however, there is currently no such shaping paradigm in which the complex three-dimensional shapes can be systematically investigated or compared across devices. Undoubtedly, important insights have been gained by investigating particular asymptotic limits of ideal MHD stellarator equilibria; most notably, these include the near-axis expansion Mercier 1964 ; Solov’ev and Shafranov 1970 ; Lortz and Nührenberg 1976 ; Garren and Boozer 1991 and flux-surface expansion Hegna 2000 ; Hegna 2015 models. However, neither of these models have provided a geometric description that can fully capture the complexity of stellarator shapes. Alternatively, some bespoke descriptions of plasma shaping have been shown to predict changes in specific microinstability dynamics in the Helically Symmetric eXperiment (HSX) stellarator Gerard et al. 2023 ; Gerard et al. 2024 , but again, these methods do not provide a generalizable method for characterizing stellarator shapes. When considering how one might define a generalized shape description, it is first helpful to consider that axisymmetry is defined as a spatial symmetry along the magnetic axis. This means that all poloidal cross-sections are identical. Therefore, in an axisymmetric equilibrium, if one simultaneously knows a single poloidal cross-section, the magnetic axis, and the position of a poloidal cross-section relative to the magnetic axis, then one has a minimal description of the entire equilibrium shape. As a corollary, consider that the notion of quasi-symmetry refers to a symmetry in the magnitude of the magnetic field on a flux surface Helander 2014 . The set of all quasi-symmetric equilibria includes subsets of equilibria that exhibit quasi-axisymmetry (QA) or quasi-helical symmetry (QH). Importantly, the spatial axisymmetry of a tokamak results in a QA magnetic field. Therefore, one is left to imagine whether or not an analogous spatial symmetry in a non-axisymmetric equilibrium will result in either a QA or QH magnetic field. Such a hypothetical symmetry is defined here to mean that an equilibrium shape can be uniquely defined by the magnetic axis, an appropriately selected cross-section, and the geometric relationship between the two. It is conjectured that this spatial symmetry would provide a minimal description of the corresponding QH or QA equilibrium shape. Like in the tokamak, this would facilitate more systematic investigations into the relationship between equilibrium shaping and other figures of merit in quasi-symmetric magnetic fields. Moreover, it may facilitate the direct construction of a quasi-symmetric equilibrium without the need of computationally intensive optimization. In this paper, a method for characterizing equilibrium shapes is introduced. This method invokes a geometric definition for an equilibrium cross-section that, when applied to a non-axisymmetric equilibrium, often results in a non-planar cross-section. This cross-section can be analyzed using a Fourier mode decomposition to producing shaping modes analogous to familiar shaping parameters in a tokamak (e.g. elongation, triangularity, squareness, etc.). While no claims are made that a generalized spatial symmetry is found, this method is shown to provide similar benefits. The method is introduced in Sec. II and demonstrated in a tokamak with a circular cross-section, a presice QA stellarator, and precise QH stellarator, with the latter two described in Ref. Landreman and Paul 2022 . Then, in Sec. III , the shape descriptions of the precise stellarator equilibria are compared to the shape descriptions of the initial configurations from which they were optimized. This shows that over the course of each configuration’s optimization, a proportionality between shaping mode complexity and mode rotation about the magnetic axis becomes apparent. It is argued that this proportionality implies a spatial resonance between shape complexity and shape rotation that results in quasi-symmetry. In Sec. IV , an additional set of equilibria are selected for analysis from the publicly available quasi-symmetric Stellarator Repository (QUASR), which hosts over 3\times 10^{5} QA and QH stellarator equilibria Giuliani et al. 2022a ; Giuliani et al. 2022b ; Giuliani et al. 2023 . From this analysis it is shown that the proportionality is most prominent in configurations with good quasi-symmetry. This provides support for the spatial-resonance hypothesis and demonstrates that quasi-symmetric equilibria require fewer shaping modes in their shape description relative to configurations with deteriorated quasi-symmetry. Moreover, it is shown that the details of this proportionality are correlated with a configuration’s rotational transform and number of field periods. In Sec. V , these results are summarized and a discussion on future work is presented. II Cross-sections in Non-axisymmetric Equilibria Though no generalized

Read the complete text