Detection of a Rényi Index Dependent Transition in Entanglement Entropy Scaling
Hatem Barghathi, Adrian Del Maestro · 2025
Read Detection of a Rényi Index Dependent Transition in Entanglement Entropy Scaling by Hatem Barghathi, Adrian Del Maestro (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24533.txt.
Introduction
Hatem Barghathi and Adrian Del Maestro find a change in how entanglement scales, driven by which entropy you measure. Entanglement growth with subsystem size reveals phases and critical points. The von Neumann entropy is the standard measure but costly to obtain. Experiments prefer the second Rényi entropy, assuming it tracks the same scaling. Earlier work on constrained spin models showed that assumption can fail.
The authors build a number-conserving many-body state for interacting fermions. Its leading entanglement scaling changes with the Rényi index. Power-law and logarithmic behaviors both appear, depending on the index chosen. That generalizes the spin-model warning. A practical diagnostic follows. A symmetry-aware lower bound on the von Neumann entropy is built from charge-resolved Rényi entropies. Experimentalists can test for anomalous scaling with accessible data alone.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Hatem Barghathi, Adrian Del Maestro |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24533
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Detection of a Rényi Index Dependent Transition in Entanglement Entropy Scaling Hatem Barghathi, Adrian Del Maestro Abstract The scaling of entanglement with subsystem size encodes key information about phases and criticality, but the von Neumann entropy is costly to access in experiments and simulations, often requiring full state tomography. The second Rényi entropy is readily measured using two-copy protocols and is often used as a proxy for the von Neumann entanglement entropy, where it is assumed to track its asymptotic scaling. However, Sugino and Korepiny (Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 32, 1850306 (2018)) revealed that in the ground state of some spin models, the scaling of the von Neumann and second Rényi entropies varies from power law to logarithmic scaling as a function of the Rényi index. By constructing a number-conserving many-body state with only two local degrees of freedom, we obtain a Rényi-index-dependent change in the leading entanglement scaling: the second Rényi entropy remains logarithmic while the von Neumann entropy is parametrically larger. We then introduce a symmetry-aware lower bound on the von Neumann entropy built from charge-resolved second Rényi entropies and the subsystem charge distribution. Comparing this bound to the total second Rényi entropy provides a practical diagnostic for anomalous entanglement scaling from experimentally accessible data. I Introduction In a pure quantum state |\Psi\rangle of a d -dimensional quantum system, the entanglement entropy between a spatial region of size \ell^{d} and the rest of the system, known as bipartite entanglement, is encoded in the reduced density matrix \hat{\rho}_{A} associated with partition A , which encompasses the degrees of freedom residing locally within it. The entanglement entropy can be quantified using the von Neumann entropy S_{\rm{vN}}(\hat{\rho}_{A}) , or, more generally, by applying the Rényi entropy measures S_{\alpha}(\hat{\rho}_{A}) , indexed by \alpha , on the spectrum of the normalized \hat{\rho}_{A} ( \Tr\hat{\rho}_{A}=1 ), where for integer values of \alpha>1 , the Rényi entropy can be connected to the expectation value of a swap operator that exchanges the configurations between \alpha replicas of the system within region A Calabrese and Cardy 2004 . This connection provides a practical method for estimating the Rényi entropy using experimental measurements and computational tools like quantum Monte Carlo (QMC) techniques Daley et al. 2012 ; Islam et al. 2015 ; Hastings et al. 2010 ; McMinis and Tubman 2013 ; Grover 2013 . On the other hand, the entanglement spectrum and thus all Rényi measures of entanglement, including the von Neumann entanglement entropy, can be accessed using density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) methods Pollmann and Moore 2010 ; Pižorn et al. 2013 ; Deng and Santos 2011 . Here, the efficient description of the ground state of the system as a matrix product state relies heavily on the scaling of entanglement entropy with system size, where area law scaling of entanglement is expected to take place Srednicki 1993 ; Eisert et al. 2010 ; Calabrese and Cardy 2004 ; Hastings 2007 ; Anshu et al. 2022 . The area-law conjecture posits that the dominant scaling of the entanglement entropy of the ground state of a gapped local Hamiltonian is directly proportional to the boundary area of the partition. For the purposes of analyzing the asymptotic scaling properties of the entanglement it is useful to remind the reader of the notion of asymptotic compatibility 1 1 1 The notation \asymp is standard in asymptotic analysis and analytic number theory, denoting equivalence up to a finite multiplicative constant. . Two functions f(x) and g(x) , that are positive for sufficiently large x , are said to be asymptotically compatible , denoted by f(x)\asymp g(x) , if there exists a constant c\in(0,\infty) such that \lim_{x\to\infty}{f(x)}/{g(x)}=c . If instead \lim_{x\to\infty}f(x)/g(x)=0 or \lim_{x\to\infty}f(x)/g(x)=\infty , we write f(x)\not\asymp g(x) . Thus, for the entanglement area law, S\asymp\ell^{d-1} . While only formally proven in d=1 Hastings 2007 , the more general conjecture holds significance in quantum Hamiltonian complexity theory, with important implications for the feasibility of simulating quantum many-body systems using classical methods Eisert et al. 2010 ; Srednicki 1993 ; Horodecki et al. 2009 ; Hastings 2007 . In particular, area-law-violating ground states cannot be efficiently represented by tensor networks with small bond dimension. They thus delineate the boundary between quantum systems that are classically tractable and those requiring full quantum resources. Understanding them can help to clarify the frontier of quantum advantage in simulation. In the absence of an energy gap, as in the case of critical one-dimensional quantum systems governed by conformal field theory, it is well established that the area law is violated, with entanglement entropy growing logarithmically with the size of the subsystem in the thermodynamic limit Vidal et al. 2003 ; Calabrese and Cardy 2004 ; Holzhey et al. 1994 ; Korepin 2004 . The logarithmic violation of the area law observed in this context may endure in higher dimensions, similar to its manifestation in the ground state of a free Fermi gas Wolf 2006 ; Gioev and Klich 2006 and the Bose-Einstein condensate of fixed total particle number Simon 2002 ; Herdman et al. 2014 . This scaling behavior is evident across all Rényi entropies with \alpha>0 , where it is found that S_{\alpha}\asymp(1+1/\alpha)\ell^{d-1}\ln\ell Leschke et al. 2014 . In addition strong violations of the area law often arise in systems with critical points Swingle 2012 ; Huijse and Swingle 2013 , fracton orders Ma et al. 2018 , or long-range interactions Nezhadhaghighi and Rajabpour 2013 ; Chakraborty and Angelinos 2024 ; Zhao et al. 2025 . These ground states can reveal new “entanglement phases” that go beyond the usual symmetry-breaking paradigm, and might underlie exotic materials or non-Fermi liquids. It has been noted that several 1d spin-models exhibit a violation of the area law in their ground states, yet achieving this outcome typically necessitates a certain level of fine-tuning, or the presence of a large local spin value Irani 2010 ; Vitagliano et al. 2010 . A very interesting case demonstrating a significant deviation from the area law has been documented in the ground state of the Motzkin and Fredkin spin models, where the von Neumann entropy scales as S_{\rm{vN}}\asymp\sqrt{\ell} , for local spins with s>1 Movassagh and Shor 2016 ; Dell’Anna et al. 2016 . Furthermore, Sugino and Korepin demonstrated that the scaling behavior of the ground state entanglement in the Motzkin and Fredkin models is significantly influenced by the Rényi index \alpha , where it has been shown that for \alpha<1 the entanglement entropy scales with the volume of the subsystem as S_{\alpha<1}\asymp\ell , while \alpha>1 exhibits logarithmic scaling S_{\alpha>1}\asymp\ln\ell Sugino and Korepin 2018 . Therefore, it is clear that different measures of entanglement entropy can show diverse scaling with the system size. The observation that certain entanglement measures exhibit a pronounced departure from the area law suggests that the corresponding reduced density matrix (RDM) possesses a large number of relevant eigenvalues. This characteristic presents a computational challenge for DMRG methods in accurately representing such highly entangled states efficiently, requiring a priori knowledge and the need to keep a large number of states for convergence that may be prohibitive based on computational resources. In contrast, QMC simulations and experimental determinations of entanglement entropy encounter distinct obstacles. Notably, the efficient estimation of entanglement