The Likelihood of Hosting Undetected Brown Dwarfs in the Solar Vicinity
© 2025 D. R. Bakirova, O. Yu. Malkov · 2025
Read The Likelihood of Hosting Undetected Brown Dwarfs in the Solar Vicinity by © 2025 D. R. Bakirova, O. Yu. Malkov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24319.txt.
Introduction
Diana Bakirova and Oleg Malkov ask whether a brown dwarf hides near the Sun. Brown dwarfs are faint objects between stars and planets in mass. The census of the solar neighborhood reaches twenty parsecs. That census is incomplete, though. Faint objects escape detection easily. The authors correct for that incompleteness statistically.
From the corrected spatial distribution, they derive a probability formula. It estimates the chance of an object at a given distance. The headline number is striking. With probability near one half, a brown dwarf sits within a short distance of the Sun. The paper discusses whether such an object could be multiple. A companion could hide the system longer. Reasons for the non-detection so far are weighed. The result is a careful odds statement, not a claimed discovery.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | © 2025 D. R. Bakirova, O. Yu. Malkov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 13 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24319
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Likelihood of Hosting Undetected Brown Dwarfs in the Solar Vicinity © 2025 D. R. Bakirova, O. Yu. Malkov Abstract Abstract Based on the spatial distribution of objects in the solar neighborhood with a radius of 20 parsecs, and after correcting for the incompleteness of observational data, an expression was obtained for estimating the probability of finding an object at a given distance from the Sun. According to these estimates, with a probability of about 0.5, there exists a brown dwarf in the immediate solar vicinity (< 1.2 pc). The possible multiplicity of this hypothetical object is discussed, as well as the reasons why it has not yet been detected. ASTRONOMY REPORTS, 2025, Vol. , No. I INTRODUCTION Objects in the solar neighborhood are of great interest to science, as their proximity allows us to obtain more complete and promising data about the Universe. According to the currently accepted initial mass function 5 , the overwhelming majority of stars in the Galaxy are red and brown dwarfs. In this context, it is noteworthy that at present the nearest known object to the Solar System is the triple system \alpha Cen, consisting of one red dwarf and two yellow dwarfs. Either this is related to peculiarities of star formation near the Sun, or observational selection effects are at play. This question is investigated in the present work. In Section II distances between nearest neighbors are calculated for objects in the solar neighborhood (up to 20 pc) and from the resulting distribution, a relationship is derived between distance and the probability of the existence of an object at that distance and closer. In Section III , the obtained results are used to estimate the probability of the existence of an object at a distance from the Sun smaller than the distance to the system \alpha Cen ( III.1 ), as well as to estimate the multiplicity of this object ( III.2 ). In Section III.3 , possible reasons are discussed why an object at such a close distance still remains undetected. Conclusions are presented in Section IV . II MEAN DISTANCE BETWEEN STARS IN THE SOLAR NEIGHBORHOOD II.1 SOURCE DATA At present, there exist in the literature several sources of information (catalogs) about nearby and/or cool stars, two of which are of particular interest due to their representativeness and variety of presented data. First and foremost is the catalog of Kirkpatrick et al. 1 1 1 https://vizier.cds.unistra.fr/viz-bin/VizieR?-source=J/ApJS/271/55 4 , which includes objects located at distances up to 20 pc from the Sun. In addition, there is the catalog of Best et al. 2 2 2 https://zenodo.org/records/10573247 2 . This catalog is called UltracoolSheet and contains data (positions, proper motions, parallaxes, photometry, multiplicity, spectroscopic classification, etc.) on more than 4000 ultracool dwarfs of spectral types M6 and later. Figure 1 presents the distribution of objects from these two catalogs by parallax, W2 magnitude, and W1-W2 color index. Obviously, for solving our problem, the first of these sources, Kirkpatrick et al. 4 , is more suitable, since it better ensures spatial completeness of objects. We use this catalog in what follows. Figure 1: W2 magnitudes (left) and W1-W2 color indices (right) as a function of parallax for objects from the catalog of Kirkpatrick et al. 4 (red) and the catalog of Best et al. 2 (blue). The catalog of Kirkpatrick et al. 4 contains information about 4407 objects. Excluded from consideration were 17 objects located farther than 20 pc from the Sun, as well as 72 objects for which parallaxes are unknown. The remaining 4318 objects were combined into 2672 systems, where a system is a grouping of one or more stars gravitationally bound to each other. Table 1 shows the percentage distribution of systems depending on their multiplicity. Table 1: Percentage distribution of systems in 4 depending on their multiplicity. Multiplicity Number Fraction 1 2001 75% 2 543 20% 3 110 4% 4 12 \sim 1% 5 5 6 1 The spatial distribution of systems is shown in Fig. 2 . Obviously, one can speak of a uniform distribution of systems in the studied neighborhood. Figure 2: Distribution of systems by their distance from the Sun (left), the red curve shows the theoretical dependence N\varpropto r^{2} . Spatial distribution of systems relative to the Sun (right). II.2 ESTIMATION OF THE MEAN DISTANCE TO THE NEAREST NEIGHBOR For each system, the distance to the nearest neighbor (dr_min) was found, the resulting distribution is shown in Fig. 3 . The peak of the distribution (corresponding to approximately 1.2 pc) can be taken as the mean distance to the nearest neighbor. Figure 3: Distribution of systems by their distances to the nearest neighbor. Left: the peak of the distribution is marked with a black dashed line. Right: corrected for incompleteness, red curve shows the Hertz dependence ( 1 ). It is advisable to account for the incompleteness of our data, for which it is necessary to exclude systems located at the boundary of the studied region, namely in a shell of width equal to the mean distance to the nearest neighbor, i.e., 1.2 pc (see Fig. 4 ). Figure 4: Correction for incompleteness: exclusion from consideration of systems located at the boundary of the studied region, in a shell of width 1.2 pc. They are marked in blue on the distribution of systems by their distances to the nearest neighbor (left) and on the spatial distribution of systems relative to the Sun (right). To verify our calculations and the completeness of the data, we compared the resulting distribution with the nearest neighbor problem, which was studied by Hertz 3 . According to his result, the dependence of the probability of finding the nearest neighbor at a given distance on the distance itself is described by the expression: \omega(r)=\text{exp}(-4\pi r^{3}n/3)\cdot 4\pi r^{2}n, (1) where n is the number of objects per unit volume. Having, after correcting for incompleteness, 2253 systems in a sphere of radius 18.8 pc, we can construct this dependence. After normalizing our histogram by area, it can be seen that our data agree well with the theoretical estimate of Hertz (see Fig. 3 ). His work also provided the mean distance to the nearest neighbor: \overline{dr\_min}=0.55396n^{-1/3} (2) Substituting our density n , we obtain \overline{dr\_min}\simeq 1.28 pc, which is similar to our estimate. Figure 5 presents the cumulative distribution of distances to the nearest neighbor, normalized to unity, i.e., the probability of the existence of an object located at the indicated distance from the Sun and closer. Using the least squares method, it can be approximated by a polynomial: \displaystyle P(x)=-1.6\cdot 10^{-6}-6.9\cdot 10^{-3}x+4.3\cdot 10^{-2}x^{2}-1.1\cdot 10^{-1}x^{3}+7\cdot 10^{-1}x^{4} \displaystyle-3.8\cdot 10^{-1}x^{5}-1.1\cdot 10^{-1}x^{6}+1.3\cdot 10^{-1}x^{7}-3.7\cdot 10^{-2}x^{8}+3.4\cdot 10^{-3}x^{9} (3) Figure 5: Left: cumulative distribution of systems by their distances to the nearest neighbor, normalized to unity. Red curve shows the approximating polynomial ( 3 ). Right: fragment of the distribution 5 in the range 1 – 1.5 pc. Blue line shows the linearized approximating polynomial ( 4 ) on this segment, black dashed line shows the position of the system \alpha Cen. II.3 ERROR ESTIMATION To estimate the error of the obtained dependence, one should first of all account for observational errors, which often have quite complex distributions. Thus, Fig.