Total Gluon Helicity Contribution to Proton Spin from Lattice QCD
Dian-Jun Zhao, Long Chen, Hongxin Dong, Xiangdong Ji, Liuming Liu, Zhuoyi Pang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Jian-Hui Zhang, Shiyi Zhong · 2025
Read Total Gluon Helicity Contribution to Proton Spin from Lattice QCD by Dian-Jun Zhao, Long Chen, Hongxin Dong, Xiangdong Ji, Liuming Liu, Zhuoyi Pang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Jian-Hui Zhang, Shiyi Zhong (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-24315.txt.
Introduction
Dian-Jun Zhao and five colleagues measure how much of the proton's spin comes from gluons. The proton spin puzzle has occupied physicists for decades. Quark spins explain only part of the total. Gluon helicity is a key missing piece. The team computes it with lattice QCD, the grid-based simulation of the strong force.
Three lattice spacings test the approach to the continuum. Distillation and momentum smearing sharpen the proton states. The topological current's matrix elements are extracted in a fixed gauge. A non-perturbative renormalization scheme sets the overall scale. An error-reduction technique refines those constants. Different current components agree within uncertainties, as Lorentz symmetry demands. After continuum extrapolation, gluon helicity accounts for roughly forty-six percent of the proton spin. The result is a state-of-the-art number for this quantity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dian-Jun Zhao, Long Chen, Hongxin Dong, Xiangdong Ji, Liuming Liu, Zhuoyi Pang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Jian-Hui Zhang, Shiyi Zhong |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-24315
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Total Gluon Helicity Contribution to Proton Spin from Lattice QCD Dian-Jun Zhao, Long Chen, Hongxin Dong, Xiangdong Ji, Liuming Liu, Zhuoyi Pang, Peng Sun, Yi-Bo Yang, Jian-Hui Zhang, Shiyi Zhong Abstract We report a state-of-the-art lattice QCD calculation of the total gluon helicity contribution to proton spin, Δ G \Delta G . The calculation is done on ensembles at three different lattice spacings a = { 0.08 , 0.09 , 0.11 } a=\{0.08,0.09,0.11\} fm. By employing distillation + momentum smearing for proton external states, we extract the bare matrix elements of the topological current K μ K^{\mu} under the 5-HYP smeared Coulomb gauge fixing configurations. Furthermore, we apply a non-perturbative RI / MOM \mathrm{RI/MOM} renormalization scheme augmented with the Cluster Decomposition Error Reduction (CDER) technique to determine the renormalization constants of K μ K^{\mu} . The results obtained from different components K t , i K^{t,i} (with i i being the direction of proton momentum or polarization) are consistent with Lorentz covariance within uncertainties. After extrapolating to the continuum limit, Δ G \Delta G is found to be Δ G = 0.231 ( 17 ) sta . ( 33 ) sym . \Delta G=0.231(17)^{\mathrm{sta.}}(33)^{\mathrm{sym.}} at the MS ¯ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} scale μ 2 = 10 GeV 2 {\mu}^{2}=10\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} , which constitutes approximately 46 ( 7 ) % 46(7)\% of the proton spin. Introduction: Since the European Muon Collaboration (EMC) measured the quark spin contribution to proton spin through deep inelastic scattering with polarized muon and proton 21 , the origin of proton spin has remained one of the most profound puzzles in modern particle and nuclear physics 29 . Our current understanding is that the quark spin contribution accounts for only \sim 30\% of the proton spin 18 ; 42 ; 1 ; 3 ; 37 ; 36 . The remaining contributions come from quark orbital angular momentum (OAM), as well as gluon spin and OAM. Two popular spin sum rules have been proposed in the literature to understand the proton spin structure. One is the Jaffe-Manohar sum rule 25 which offers a complete decomposition of the proton spin into quark and gluon spin and OAM. It has a clear partonic picture in the infinite momentum frame (IMF) of the proton and lightcone gauge. The other is the frame- and gauge-independent sum rule by Ji 26 , where the quark and gluon total angular momentum can be connected to the moments of generalized parton distributions 41 ; 26 . Among these contributions, the understanding of gluon spin has posed a significant challenge, mainly due to the absence of a local gauge-invariant gluon spin operator 28 . Nevertheless, it can be measured in polarized scattering experiments through the spin-dependent gluon helicity distribution \Delta g(x) as its lowest moment \Delta G=\int dx\Delta g(x) . Note that unlike in the case of the quark distribution, the lowest moment of the gluon helicity distribution is still nonlocal. Only in the lightcone gauge does it reduce to the matrix element of a local operator \vec{E}\times\vec{A} . Phenomenological global analyses of experimental data indicate that \Delta G is approximately 0.2 at the \overline{\mathrm{MS}} scale \mu^{2}=10\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} , provided that contributions from the small- x region ( x<0.05 ) with large uncertainties are excluded 18 ; 19 . On the other hand, recent theoretical developments 30 ; 22 ; 31 , particularly within the framework of Large-Momentum Effective Theory (LaMET) 32 ; 33 ; 27 , have enabled a direct computation of \Delta G using lattice QCD. In this approach, instead of computing in the IMF and lightcone gauge which are both inaccessible on the lattice, one computes the large-momentum nucleon matrix element of a static gluon spin operator, \vec{E}\times\vec{A} , in a physical gauge that leaves the transverse gauge field intact. Actually, there exists an infinite number of operators that can be used to extract \Delta G , all belonging to the same universality class 22 . The static gluon spin matrix element can then be matched to \Delta G through a perturbative factorization or matching relation 30 . Based on this, the \rm\chi QCD collaboration conducted an exploratory calculation of \Delta G by evaluating the nucleon matrix element of \vec{E}\times\vec{A} in the Coulomb gauge, yielding a result of 0.251(47)(16) 49 . However, the one-loop lattice perturbative renormalization employed in that study introduces a large correction, indicating the necessity of a proper nonperturbative renormalization – which was, at the time, very challenging to implement due to the Coulomb gauge fixing. Furthermore, recent studies 43 have revealed that the LaMET factorization for \Delta G is incompatible with that for \Delta g(x) . To circumvent the difficulties mentioned above, two new proposals have been made in Ref. 43 . One is based on using the topological current, and the other employs appropriate static nonlocal gluon operators generating the gluon helicity distribution. Both of them have a trivial matching only, and therefore resolve the inconsistency previously encountered in the matching for \Delta G and \Delta g(x) . Moreover, their nonperturbative renormalization can be easily implemented. This opens a new avenue for systematic studies of \Delta G from lattice QCD. In this work, we present a state-of-the-art lattice calculation of the total gluon helicity contribution to proton spin, \Delta G , using the topological current approach proposed in Ref. 43 . The calculation is done on ensembles at three different lattice spacings a=\{0.08,0.09,0.11\} fm, which allow us to perform a continuum extrapolation. Distillation 44 , momentum smearing 5 , and cluster decomposition 38 techniques have been used to improve the signal-to-noise ratio of proton matrix elements and parton Green’s functions, respectively. The nonperturbative renormalization has been performed in the \mathrm{RI/MOM} scheme, following the operator mixing pattern given in Ref. 43 . After converting to the \overline{\rm MS} scheme, the result is then evolved to the scale \mu^{2}=10\,{\rm GeV}^{2} using the renormalization group (RG) equation with three-loop anomalous dimensions. Theoretical Framework: Following Ref. 43 , the total gluon helicity \Delta G can be extracted by computing the matrix element of the local topological current K^{\mu}(x)=\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\text{Tr}[A_{\nu}F_{\rho\sigma}-\frac{2}{3}ig_{0}A_{\nu}A_{\rho}A_{\sigma}](x) (1) in a longitudinally polarized proton. More specifically, the proton matrix element of the Coulomb gauge fixed operator K^{\mu} ( \mu=t,i with i denoting the component along the direction of proton momentum or polarization) reduces to \Delta G in the IMF, namely, \frac{\langle\mathrm{PS}_{\mathrm{Proj.i}}|\int d^{3}xK^{t/i}_{\mathrm{C.G.}}(x)|\mathrm{PS}_{\mathrm{Proj.i}}\rangle}{2S^{t/i}}|_{\mathrm{IMF}}=\Delta G, (2) where |\mathrm{PS}_{\mathrm{Proj.i}}\rangle denotes the proton external state with specific momentum and polarization direction i , while S^{t/i} represents the corresponding polarization vector. The subscript \mathrm{C.G.} indicates the Coulomb gauge fixing for the topological current. As shown in Ref. 43 , the ultraviolet (UV) divergence of K^{\mu} is gauge independent. Therefore, we can perform a nonperturbative renormalization of K^{\mu} in the \mathrm{RI/MOM} scheme 40 where the renormalization factor is typically computed in the Landau gauge. K^{\mu} mixes only with the axial-vector current J^{\mu}_{5}=\bar{q}_{i}\gamma_{5}\gamma^{\mu}q_{i} even under RI/MOM renormalization 43 . The renormalization constants can be determined by the following conditions \displaystyle\begin{pmatrix}\langle ps|K^{\mu}|ps\rangle^{\mathrm{tree}}\\ \langle ps|J^{\mu}_{5}|ps\rangle^{\mathrm{tree}}\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}Z_{11}^{\mathrm{RI}}&Z_{12}^{\mathrm{RI}}\\ Z_{21}^{\mathrm{RI}}&Z_{22}^{\mathrm{RI}}\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}\langle ps|K^{\mu}|ps\rangle^{\mathrm{lat.}}\\ \langle ps|J^{\mu}_{5}|ps\rangle^{\mathrm{lat.}}\end{pmatrix}, (3) where |ps\rangle denotes either gluon ( g ) or quark ( q ) external states with specific momentum and polarization. In the discussion below, we introduce the abbreviations \mathcal{O}^{\mathrm{tree/lat.},{g/q}}\equiv\langle{g,q}|\mathcal{O}|{g,q}\rangle^{\mathrm{tree/lat.}} to simplify the notation. Note that K^{\mathrm{tree},q}=J_{5}^{\mathrm{tree},g}=0