Surface adsorption at the thermodynamic limit using periodic DLPNO-MP2 theory: A study of CO on MgO at dilute and dense coverages
Andrew Zhu, Poramas Komonvasee, Arman Nejad, David P. Tew · 2025
Read Surface adsorption at the thermodynamic limit using periodic DLPNO-MP2 theory: A study of CO on MgO at dilute and dense coverages by Andrew Zhu, Poramas Komonvasee, Arman Nejad, David P. Tew (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23879.txt.
Introduction
Andrew Zhu, Poramas Komonvasee, Arman Nejad, and David Tew compute how strongly carbon monoxide sticks to magnesium oxide, the textbook test case for surface sticking theory. For a single lonely CO molecule, accurate quantum methods now agree well with experiment. Denser layers are another matter: bigger cells cost much more to simulate, and the space of arrangements explodes, so coverage effects have rarely been probed at this accuracy.
Their method, periodic DLPNO-MP2, is a local-correlation version of second-order perturbation theory efficient enough for large supercells, which lets them approach the thermodynamic limit of an extended surface. In the dilute regime their sticking energies match existing benchmarks. As coverage rises toward a full monolayer, binding weakens, in agreement with experiment, and the authors blame the drop on growing sideways repulsion between neighboring CO molecules. The trend matches what labs actually see.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andrew Zhu, Poramas Komonvasee, Arman Nejad, David P. Tew |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23879
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Surface adsorption at the thermodynamic limit using periodic DLPNO-MP2 theory: A study of CO on MgO at dilute and dense coverages Andrew Zhu, Poramas Komonvasee, Arman Nejad, David P. Tew Abstract We apply periodic domain-based local pair natural orbital second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory (DLPNO-MP2) to probe the adsorption energy of CO on MgO(001), the consensus toy model system for surface adsorption. A number of robust correlated wavefunction methods now achieve excellent agreement with experiment for the adsorption of a single CO molecule onto the MgO surface. However, studies probing denser coverage ratios are scarce because of the increased computational expense and the larger configuration space to optimize. We leverage the computational efficiency of periodic DLPNO-MP2 to perform simulations beyond a single unit cell. By using large supercells, we highlight the importance of accurately representing the thermodynamic limit of the surface, and demonstrate in turn that different coverage ratios can be consistently probed. In the dilute regime, we show that adsorption energies obtained from periodic DLPNO-MP2 agree with existing benchmarks. We then obtain adsorption energies at increasing densities approaching full monolayer coverage. Our results show a reduction in binding strength at full coverage, agreeing with experimental observations, which is explained by the increasing lateral repulsions between the COs. This study demonstrates the efficacy of periodic DLPNO-MP2 for probing increasingly sophisticated adsorption systems at the thermodynamic limit. I Introduction The interaction of a molecule as it adsorbs onto a surface is a key chemical phenomenon, where accurate modeling provides benefits to a number of important applications. In particular, computational evaluation of the adsorption energy gives mechanistic insight to reactions for heterogeneous catalysis, gas storage and surface lubrication, among others. 12 ; 58 ; 11 ; 16 ; 50 ; 67 ; 37 ; 25 Electronic structure studies of adsorption systems have predominantly employed density functional theory (DFT), due to its computational efficiency. However, accurate modeling of the dispersion interactions involved is difficult unless semi-empirical corrections are incorporated into the density functional treatment. 19 ; 18 ; 20 ; 64 ; 13 ; 65 Notwithstanding these dispersion-corrected functionals (DFT-D), higher accuracy quantum chemistry methods, which inherently capture dispersive effects, are needed to provide reliable interaction energies. The adsorption of a single carbon monoxide (CO) molecule onto a pristine magnesium oxide (MgO(001)) surface has become the consensus toy model system to probe surface adsorption interactions. Computational schemes can be roughly divided into finite-cluster methods, or approaches employing periodic boundary conditions. Recently, a number of studies, employing high accuracy correlated wavefunction methods, including second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory (MP2) and coupled cluster theory with singles, doubles and perturbative triples excitations (CCSD(T)), have obtained excellent agreement for the adsorption energy of CO on MgO at the dilute coverage limit 6 ; 1 ; 56 ; 73 . Alessio et al. 1 and Boese and Sauer 6 both employ hybrid MP2: DFT-D embedded cluster calculations, incorporating single point CCSD(T) calculations to obtain the final adsorption energy estimate, with values of -21.2\pm 0.5\;\mathrm{kJ\;mol^{-1}} and -21.0\pm 1.0\;\mathrm{kJ\;mol^{-1}} , respectively. Alessio et al. also employ periodic local MP2 to demonstrate agreement with their embedded cluster MP2 estimates. Shi et al. 56 used CCSD(T) calculations within their embedded cluster SKZCAM approach, obtaining an adsorption energy of -19.2\pm 1.0\;\mathrm{kJ\;mol^{-1}} , which they show agreement with canonical periodic CCSD(T) and diffusion Monte Carlo. Finally, Ye and Berkelbach 73 calculate adsorption energies using periodic local natural orbital (LNO) schemes at MP2 and CCSD(T) levels, calculating a value of -20.0\pm 0.5\;\mathrm{kJ\;mol^{-1}} . Considering that the touted standard of ‘chemical accuracy’ is within 4.2\;\mathrm{kJ\;mol^{-1}} , the overall consensus of these methods is remarkable, considering the differences in the approaches taken and the need to converge out errors in all the method specific wavefunction and basis related parameters, as well as finite-size effects. Experimental enthalpies for CO on MgO(001) adsorption have been determined using temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) techniques, of which we highlight the work from Dohnálek et al., 14 and Wichtendahl et al. 70 Both studies produce TPD spectra at varying CO coverage ratios ( \Theta ), reporting desorption values at minimal densities of around \frac{1}{4} monolayer coverage, which provide the closest estimate to the adsorption energy at the dilute limit. Using these experimental references, previous computational works have conducted analyses to compute comparable adsorption energy values, by accounting for thermal and zero-point energy contributions, the PV term, and the pre-exponential factor used in the Redhead equation 48 . Boese and Sauer obtained a TPD-derived energy of (-20.6\pm 2.4) kJ mol -1 , whilst Shi et al. obtained an experimental estimate of (-19.2\pm 1.0) kJ mol -1 . With both experiment-derived and theoretical studies from a number of different works agreeing to well within chemical accuracy, the adsorption energy of CO on MgO at the dilute regime appears to have reached a robust consensus, providing a rigorous benchmark. There are, however, still unanswered questions for simulating adsorption processes. In real chemical conditions, adsorption reactions rarely feature a single adsorbate molecule, and consideration for the optimal ratio of surface site availability is a key concern for heterogeneous catalysis. For example, experimental literature for CO adsorption onto an MgO surface reports varying reactivities associated with dilute to dense coverage regimes. 57 ; 62 ; 14 ; 70 ; 51 Whilst an agreed benchmark for the adsorption energy of a single CO molecule on a pristine MgO surface has now been established, simulations incorporating multiple CO adsorption sites at denser monolayer coverages are still scarce. These systems are inherently more difficult to simulate, given the expanded configuration space to now optimize over, and the need to incorporate lateral interactions between the adsorbate monomers. For these larger adsorption unit cells or fragments, simulating the in-principle infinite extent of the surface, or the thermodynamic bulk limit, becomes increasingly important in order to remove finite size errors or edge effects. All in all, the increased computational demand required to simulate larger surface systems poses a steep challenge for current correlated wavefunction methods. Recently, we have outlined the theory and implementation of two complementary methods for periodic domain-based local pair natural orbital (DLPNO) second-order Møller–Plesset perturbation theory 41 ; 74 . These schemes enable a vast compression of the virtual space, enabling calculations of large supercells to accurately extrapolate to the thermodynamic limit. In this contribution, we use periodic DLPNO-MP2 to probe CO on MgO(001) adsorption with large supercells beyond a single unit cell. We focus upon ensuring our calculations are converged with respect to the thermodynamic limit of the surface, which then enables us to robustly probe the adsorption energy at different CO coverage densities. First, we outline our computational methodology employing periodic DLPNO-MP2 to model surface adsorption systems. Then, in Section III , we verify the validity of DLPNO-MP2 for surface interactions by evaluating the adsorption energy towards the infinitely dilute regime, which can be benchmarked rigorously against the aforementioned schemes. Having established agreement, we then use periodic DLPNO-MP2 to probe CO coverage ratios approaching the fully filled monolayer ( \Theta= 1) limit, in Section IV . This is achieved through leveraging the computational efficiency of periodic DLPNO-MP2, enabling simulation of multiple adsorption sites within a supercell, whilst ensuring the thermodynamic limit of the surface is probed. In doing so, we have conducted