Pair Space in Classical Mechanics III. Some Four-Body Central Configurations

Alon Drory · 2025

Read Pair Space in Classical Mechanics III. Some Four-Body Central Configurations by Alon Drory (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23730.txt.

Introduction

Alon Drory continues a series on the four-body problem, the gravitational choreography of four masses, using his pair-space formalism. He focuses on central configurations, arrangements in which the gravitational pull on every body points toward one common center, so the shape can rotate or collapse as a unit. Such configurations organize much of what is known about few-body dynamics.

The pair-space equations fully characterize these configurations, and Drory examines the subclass where at least two pairs of inter-body distances are equal. He shows the only non-collinear examples are the tetrahedron, the unique non-planar case, plus planar kites and the isosceles trapezium. For each shape, the internal angles are pinned down by the mass ratios of the bodies, and the paper gives explicit formulas for all of these relations.

Catalog record

CREATORAlon Drory
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23730

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Pair Space in Classical Mechanics III. Some Four-Body Central Configurations Alon Drory Abstract We study central configurations in the four body problem, i.e., configurations in which the forces on all the bodies point to a fixed, single point in space. The newly formulated pair-space formalism yields a set of vectorial equations that fully characterize such configurations. We investigate a sub-class of solutions in which at least two pairs of inter-body distances are equal. The only such non-collinear configurations are the tetrahedron (the unique non-planar configuration), kites and the isosceles trapezium. The specific shapes (internal angles) are determined by the ratio of the masses of the bodies. Mathematical expression are given for all these relations. 1 Introduction Assume a system containing N particles with masses \{m_{i}\} and vector positions \{\bm{r}_{i}\} . In many cases, from planetary systems to gas molecules, the particles are interacting via pairwise potentials v_{ij}(\bm{q}_{ij}) , where \bm{q}_{ij}=\bm{r}_{i}-\bm{r}_{j} . The difficulty in such systems lies in the coupling between the equations introduced by the relative positions \left\{\bm{q}_{ij}\right\} . In previous works [ 1 , 2 ] , I suggested representing such classical mechanical systems in a new space, henceforth called pair-space, which is spanned by the system’s center of mass \bm{R} and the pair positions \{\bm{q}_{12},...,\bm{q}_{(N-1)N}\} . Effectively, pair space considers pairs of particles as the fundamental objects, rather than the particles themselves. Therefore, the system’s potential energy is decoupled, being a sum of independent terms V=\sum\limits_{[ij]}v_{ij}(\bm{q}_{ij}), (1) where \sum_{[i,j]} means a sum over all pairs of distinct indices with i<j . In pair space, the system’s kinetic energy is T=\frac{1}{2}M\bm{\dot{R}}^{2}+\sum_{[i,j]}\frac{1}{2}\mu_{ij}\bm{\dot{q}_{ij}}^{2}-\sum_{[i,j,k]}\frac{1}{2}\mu_{ijk}\left(\bm{\dot{q}_{ij}}+\bm{\dot{q}_{jk}}+\bm{\dot{q}_{ki}}\right)^{2}, (2) where M=\sum_{i=1}^{N}m_{i} is the system’s total mass and \sum_{[i,j,k]} is a sum over all triplets of distinct indices such that i<j<k . \mu_{ij} and \mu_{ijk} are the pair and triplet reduced masses, respectively, defined as, \displaystyle\mu_{ij} \displaystyle=\dfrac{m_{i}m_{j}}{M}. (3a) \displaystyle\mu_{ijk} \displaystyle=\dfrac{m_{i}m_{j}m_{k}}{M^{2}}. (3b) Hamilton’s principle does not apply to the Lagrangian L=T-V because the pair positions are not all independent, as they verify the so-called “triangle conditions” \bm{q}_{ij}+\bm{q}_{jk}+\bm{q}_{ki}=0. (4) A configuration \{\bm{q}_{ij}\} that verifies these conditions will be termed “ realizable ”. Rather than use them to reduce the number of variables, we treat Eqs.( 4 ) as dynamical constraints. To this end, we introduce vector Lagrange multipliers, \bm{\phi}_{ijk} , defined for every triplet of monotonically ordered distinct indices. For convenience, we also define formal symbols where the ordering is different by \bm{\phi}_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)\sigma(k)}=sgn(\sigma)\bm{\phi}_{ijk}, (5) where \sigma is a permutation of the indices (ijk) . Hamilton’s principle and the Euler-Lagrange equations hold for the pair Lagrangian, L_{\pi} , defined as L_{\pi}=T-V+\sum_{[i,j,k]}\bm{\phi}_{ijk}\left(\bm{q}_{ij}+\bm{q}_{jk}+\bm{q}_{ki}\right). (6) After some manipulation of the Euler-Lagrange equations, we can write the equations of motion in the following form [ 1 ] : \mu_{ij}\bm{\ddot{q}}_{ij}+\frac{\partial v_{ij}(\bm{q}_{ij})}{\partial\bm{q}_{ij}}-\bm{J}_{ij}=0, (7) for any pair of indices i<j , where we defined \displaystyle\bm{J}_{ij}=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}n=1\\ n\neq i,j\end{subarray}}^{N}\bm{\phi}_{ijn}. (8) Note that \bm{J}_{ji}=-\bm{J}_{ij} . The explicit formula for these terms is (see [ 1 ] ), \displaystyle\frac{1}{\mu_{ij}}\bm{J}_{ij}=\sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}k=1\\ k\neq i,j\end{subarray}}^{N}\dfrac{m_{k}}{M}\bm{F}_{ijk}, (9a) where \displaystyle\bm{F}_{ijk}=\frac{1}{\mu_{ij}}\frac{\partial v_{ij}(\bm{q}_{ij})}{\partial\bm{q}_{ij}}+\frac{1}{\mu_{jk}}\frac{\partial v_{jk}(\bm{q}_{jk})}{\partial\bm{q}_{jk}}+\frac{1}{\mu_{ki}}\frac{\partial v_{ki}(\bm{q}_{ki})}{\partial\bm{q}_{ki}}. (9b) In particular, for the Newtonian potential, v_{ij}(q_{ij})=-\dfrac{GM\mu_{ij}}{q_{ij}} , we have that \bm{F}_{ijk}=GM\left(\frac{\bm{q}_{ij}}{q_{ij}^{3}}+\frac{\bm{q}_{jk}}{q_{jk}^{3}}+\frac{\bm{q}_{ki}}{q_{ki}^{3}}\right). (10) 2 Central Configurations Since pairs of particles are the fundamental entities in pair space, we can define angular momenta for each one. The pair angular momentum of [i,j] is defined as \bm{L}_{ij}=\bm{q}_{ij}\times\mu_{ij}\bm{\dot{q}}_{ij}. (11) The total pair angular-momentum, \sum_{[i,j]}\bm{L}_{ij} is always conserved (this is equivalent to the conservation of the system’s usual total angular momentum) [ 1 , 2 ] . Usually, however, individual pair angular momenta will not be conserved. Solutions that do conserve all individual pair momenta exist, and have important properties, because such solutions are central configurations [ 2 ] . A central configuration is defined as one in which the acceleration of each particle point towards the system’s center of mass, so that \ddot{\bm{r}}_{i}=-\lambda\left(\bm{r}_{i}-\bm{R}\right), where \lambda is identical for all indices i . In pair space, this is equivalent to \bm{\ddot{q}}_{ij}=-\lambda\bm{q}_{ij}. (12) Central configurations hold special importance in the study of the N -body problem [ 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 ] . The Lagrange and Euler solutions for three bodies, for example, are central configurations. More specifically, they are homographic, meaning that they are configurations that remain self-similar at all times. Pizzeti proved that homographic solutions are central at all times [ 8 ] . Another subtype of central configurations are those that display homothetic motion. This means that the bodies converge along fixed straight lines until they collide. Homothetic solutions are also homographic, and thus form central configurations at all times. Not all N -body collisions arise from homothetic motions, however. Configurations that lead to N -body collisions non-homothetically are not central; nevertheless, as the bodies approach each other, their orbits will asymptotically approach a central configuration [ 9 ] . Conversely, when a system expands and its bodies separate from each other, it also tends towards a central configuration [ 5 ] . Other properties of central configurations and the fundamental role they seem to play in the solution of the N -body problem can be found in [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . It follows from Eq.( 12 ) that in a central configuration, the associated pair-momentum is conserved for every pair, since: \dfrac{d\bm{L}_{ij}}{dt}=\bm{q}_{ij}\times\mu_{ij}\bm{\ddot{q}}_{ij}=0. (13) Hence, if a solution is a central configuration at all times, all its pair angular momenta are conserved individually. In [ 2 ] , I have shown that the reverse also holds. Thus central configurations can be characterized as precisely those that conserve all individual pair angular momenta. This yields an algebraic characterization of these configurations. As shown in [ 2 ] , a realizable configuration that does not remain on a single fixed line at all times is central if and only if, for every pair (i,j) : \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}k=1\\ k\neq i,j\end{subarray}}^{N}m_{k}\left(\bm{q}_{ij}\times\bm{q}_{jk}\right)\left(\frac{1}{q_{ik}^{3}}-\frac{1}{q_{jk}^{3}}\right)=0 (14) The condition “realizable” is necessary since it may be that some algebraic solutions of these equations have no geometrical meaning. For example, it is clear that if all the mutual distances q_{ij} are equal to each other, Eqs.( 14 ) hold trivially. But geometrically, such a configuration represents a regular simplex with N vertices, a structure that cannot exist in a space of dimension less than N-1 . In our three-dimensional space, therefore, such a solution can exist only for N\leq 4 , even though Eqs.( 14 ) are solved by any regular simplex configuration, independently of the value of N . Thus, the solutions of Eqs.( 14 ) must be checked to make sure that they are actually realizable solutions of the equations of motion. 3 Four-body central configurations Let us now consider the central configuration equations in the case of four bodies. In Eqs.( 14 ), we can manipulate the vector products so as to have only four different expressions. Arbitrarily, I have chosen to use \bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{31} , \bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{41} , \bm{q}_{41}\times\bm{q}_{31} , \bm{q}_{42}\times\bm{q}_{32} . Other products can be reduced to these by using the triangle condition, e.g. \bm{q}_{13}\times\bm{q}_{23}=-\bm{q}_{31}\times\left(-\bm{q}_{31}-\bm{q}_{12}\right)=\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{31} and so on. Eqs.( 14 ) become a set of six equations (one for each pair of bodies): \displaystyle m_{3}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{31}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{32}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) \displaystyle=m_{4}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{42}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{41}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{41}\right) (15a) \displaystyle m_{2}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{21}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{32}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) \displaystyle=m_{4}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{43}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{41}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{41}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) (15b) \displaystyle m_{1}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{21}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{31}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) \displaystyle=m_{4}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{42}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{43}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{42}\times\bm{q}_{32}\right) (15c) \displaystyle m_{2}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{42}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{21}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{41}\right) \displaystyle=m_{3}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{43}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{31}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{41}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) (15d) \displaystyle m_{1}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{41}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{21}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{21}\times\bm{q}_{41}\right) \displaystyle=m_{3}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{23}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{43}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{42}\times\bm{q}_{32}\right) (15e) \displaystyle m_{1}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{41}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{31}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{41}\times\bm{q}_{31}\right) \displaystyle=m_{2}\left[\dfrac{1}{q_{32}^{3}}-\dfrac{1}{q_{42}^{3}}\right]\left(\bm{q}_{42}\times\bm{q}_{32}\right) (15f) The remainder of this paper explores a certain class of solutions of these equations. Specifically, we shall examine

Read the complete text