The Effect of Hadronic Matter on Parton Energy Loss

Ritoban Datta, Abhijit Majumder · 2025

Read The Effect of Hadronic Matter on Parton Energy Loss by Ritoban Datta, Abhijit Majumder (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23692.txt.

Introduction

Ritoban Datta and Abhijit Majumder ask whether the hadronic stage of a heavy-ion collision still matters for jet quenching. The energy loss of fast partons plowing through the hot medium created in the collision. Partons scatter off the medium's own partonic structure, radiating energy and kicking medium particles. Most calculations focus on the hottest, purely partonic phase.

Working inside the JETSCAPE framework with two event generators, the authors modify the thermal distributions by a simple temperature-dependent factor in the quarks' and gluons' dispersion relations. Transport coefficients then fall off naturally as the system cools into the hot hadronic gas, instead of stopping abruptly. Combined with cold nuclear matter effects on the incoming nuclei, the extended calculation describes jet and hadron suppression and elliptic flow across many collision systems and energies at once.

Catalog record

CREATORRitoban Datta, Abhijit Majumder
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE80 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23692

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Effect of Hadronic Matter on Parton Energy Loss Preprint: APS/123-QED Ritoban Datta, Abhijit Majumder Abstract Modified thermal distributions (dispersion relations) are introduced within both the MATTER and LBT event generators used to describe jet modification in a heavy-ion collision, within the Jetscape framework. Hard partons, propagating through dense matter, scatter off the partonic substructure of the medium, leading to stimulated emission, accompanied by recoiling medium partons. We introduce a simple modification, a multiplicative ( 1 + a / T ) (1+a/T) correction to the dispersion relation of quarks and gluons (equivalent to an effective fugacity). This leads to calculated transport coefficients (e.g. q ^ / T 3 \hat{q}/T^{3} ) showing the expected behavior of depreciating at lower temperatures, including within the hot hadronic gas. This simple modification recovers the light-like dispersion relations at high temperatures, and introduces an excess depreciation factor for parton populations at lower temperatures, allowing partonic energy loss and recoil calculations to be extended into the hadronic phase. This modified distribution, in combination with initial state cold nuclear matter effects (shadowing), is used to simultaneously describe the nuclear modification factor and elliptic anisotropy of jets and leading hadrons, over multiple centralities and collision energies. I Introduction The quenching of hard jets as they propagate through the dense medium created in a relativistic heavy-ion collision is expected to yield information on the partonic substructure of the produced quark-gluon plasma (QGP) Majumder and Van Leeuwen 2011 ; Cao et al. 2024 . There is now somewhat wide agreement that, at temperatures at least an order of magnitude above the transition temperature T_{c} , the thermodynamics of the QGP can be described using Hard Thermal Loop (HTL) perturbation theory Braaten and Pisarski 1990a ; Braaten and Pisarski 1990b ; Frenkel and Taylor 1990 . This notion of agreement is based entirely on the comparison of the results of higher order HTL perturbation theory Andersen et al. 2011 with simulations from Lattice QCD Bazavov et al. 2009 ; Borsanyi et al. 2010 . As a result, simulations of jet modification which incorporate some part of HTL dynamics He et al. 2015 ; Zigic et al. 2022 ; Kumar et al. 2023 , should (and do) show considerable agreement with experimental data Tachibana et al. 2024 . To simultaneously describe jet and high transverse momentum (high- p_{T} ) leading hadron suppression, requires a multi-stage energy loss framework Cao et al. 2017 ; Caucal et al. 2018 ; Modarresi-Yazdi et al. 2025 . This involves an earlier (high virtuality) stage where scattering and stimulated emission are rare Wang and Guo 2001 ; Kumar et al. 2020a ; Majumder 2013a ; Cao and Majumder 2020 , compared to vacuum like emission, and a later (lower virtuality) stage dominated by scattering and stimulated emission Baier et al. 1995 ; Baier et al. 1997 ; Arnold et al. 2002 ; Jeon and Moore 2005 ; Majumder 2012 ; He et al. 2015 ; Cao et al. 2016 ; Schenke et al. 2009 (some hard partons may experience vacuum like emission on exit from the medium). The scattering of hard partons in the medium, leading to stimulated emission, is typically quantified using the transverse momentum diffusion transport coefficient: \displaystyle\hat{q}=\frac{1}{N_{events}}\sum_{events}\frac{1}{L}\sum_{i=1}^{N\in L}(k_{\perp}^{i})^{2}, (1) which represents the event averaged transverse momentum squared gained by a parton per unit length traversed in the plasma (where the parton may scatter an arbitrary N times, per event, within the length L ). In addition, allowing for scale evolution of the transverse momentum exchange transport coefficient \hat{q} Baier 2003 ; Majumder 2013b ; Kumar et al. 2022 , that modulates stimulated emission Kumar et al. 2020a ; Kumar et al. 2025 , yields simulations that can simultaneously address jet and leading hadron nuclear modification factors, over a range of centralities ( 0-50 %), from top RHIC to all LHC energies Kumar et al. 2023 , for light and heavy flavors Cao et al. 2019 ; Fan et al. 2023 . These same simulations, with parameters unchanged, also compare well with jet substructure observables Tachibana et al. 2024 , photon triggered jet distributions Sirimanna et al. 2024 , and even photon triggered jet substructure observables Tachibana et al. 2025 . All of the above simulations invoke the requirement of consistent recoil and scattering in jet modification, first introduced in Refs. Zapp et al. 2013 ; He et al. 2015 ; He et al. 2019 : Thermal partons, which stimulate radiation from jet partons via scattering, may get converted into new jet partons, if these thermal partons are struck with sufficient momentum transfer from the evolving jet. Thus, the thermal partons in the medium modify jet distributions in 3 ways: By 4-momentum exchange between jet and thermal partons, by inducing more radiation from the developing shower, and by adding partons from the medium to the shower. These “recoiling” partons may further undergo induced radiation, and excite more recoil partons out of the medium. In most calculations, the scattering in the medium that induces radiation is parameterized using the transport coefficient \hat{q} . In calculations with recoil, \hat{q} is derived from the scattering kernel. If an HTL distribution is used to compute \hat{q} Arnold and Xiao 2008 , this should also yield the distribution of recoil partons after the scattering with the jet. These recoil partons, may undergo further scattering and energy loss, leading to the generation of more recoils. These are hadronized along with the original shower partons, and then clustered within jets. The distribution of incoming thermal partons, prior to scattering off the jet, are then subtracted as energy-momentum holes within each jet cone (thereby conserving energy-momentum). Thus, the distribution of recoils and holes, in addition to stimulated radiation, affects jet modification, while high- p_{T} leading hadrons are only affected by scattering (which, on average, depends on the \hat{q} calculated using the distribution of holes and recoils). In this way, leading hadron and jet modification are described simultaneously, from the same simulation. In spite of the success of the multi-stage recoil based framework of jet modification, a close examination of these efforts highlights slight tensions in the comparison with data, particularly when jets and leading hadrons (over a range of collision energy and centrality) are compared simultaneously to results from the same simulations Ehlers et al. 2024 . The majority of the tension originates from leading hadrons with a p_{T}<30 GeV. The results of these simulations also tend to gradually fail in comparison to data at centralities above 50\% , when the hadronic phase in a heavy-ion collision is as large as, or larger than, the deconfined phase. In addition, these simulations have typically produced a lower elliptic anisotropy (v_{2}) for both leading hadrons at high p_{T} and jets Park 2019 ; Park et al. 2021 . In this paper, we will demonstrate that all three issues above may be resolved if one simply introduces initial state nuclear modification of parton distribution functions (shadowing) Eskola et al. 2009 ; Eskola et al. 2017 and a slight (realistic) modification to the distribution of quark and gluon quasi-particles, allowing for the extension of the recoil based jet modification formalism past the deconfined phase, into the hadronic phase. Remarkably, none of the prior efforts by the Jetscape

Read the complete text