Verifiable Off-Chain Governance
Jake Hartnell, Eugenio (Neno) Battaglia · 2025
Read Verifiable Off-Chain Governance by Jake Hartnell, Eugenio (Neno) Battaglia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23618.txt.
Introduction
Jake Hartnell and Eugenio Battaglia argue that decentralized autonomous organizations, or DAOs, govern themselves too crudely. Because blockchains are expensive places to compute, most DAOs reduce every decision to token-weighted voting, which flattens complex questions of legitimacy and preference into a single number.
Their proposal moves the heavy computation off-chain while keeping it verifiable, using verifiable services, trusted execution environments, and zero-knowledge proofs to guarantee the results. Three tools follow. One rates how much trust each group has earned. One adds up group choices in a way all can check. One turns the agreed rules into code that runs on its own. The paper gives architectural specifications, security models, and implementation notes, drawing on early real implementations to argue the approach is practical for DAOs wanting finer-grained governance.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jake Hartnell, Eugenio (Neno) Battaglia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23618
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Verifiable Off-Chain Governance Jake Hartnell, Eugenio (Neno) Battaglia Abstract Current DAO governance praxis limits organizational expressivity and reduces complex organizational decisions to token-weighted voting due to on-chain computational limits. This paper proposes verifiable off-chain computation (leveraging Verifiable Services, TEEs, and ZK proofs) as a framework to transcend these constraints while maintaining cryptoeconomic security. This paper explores three novel governance mechanisms: (1) attestation-based systems that compute multi-dimensional stakeholder legitimacy, (2) collective intelligence through verifiable preference processing, and (3) autonomous policy execution via Policy-as-Code. The framework provides architectural specifications, security models, and implementation considerations for DAOs seeking higher-resolution expressivity and increased operational efficiency, with validation from pioneering implementations demonstrating practical viability. 1 Introduction Decentralized Autonomous Organizations promised to rival traditional organizational dynamics through game-theoretic coordination mechanisms that align incentives at scale. These mechanisms leverage the cryptoeconomic and governance primitives enabled by blockchain’s inherent transparency and trustless execution. However, after a decade of experimentation, DAO governance remains primitive, often reducing complex organizational decisions to unidimensional token-weighted voting on predetermined proposals 1 . Smart contract execution environments constrain DAOs to their current primitive state. They cannot translate semantically rich off-chain contributions into on-chain governance decisions, nor implement liquid democracy with expertise-based delegation, nor execute adaptive policies that respond to changing conditions, nor can they coordinate effectively across blockchains. The same constraints that granted blockchain’s security and verifiability now bottleneck DAOs from developing the multi-dimensional governance mechanisms complex coordination requires. Verifiable Off-chain Services (hereafter “Verifiable Services”) and Zero Knowledge proofs enable a technical breakthrough that unlocks decentralized governance’s full speed and resolving power through cryptoeconomically secured off-chain computation. This paper presents a framework enabling three fundamental categories of governance innovation: 1. A formal model for attestation-based governance that captures multi-dimensional stakeholder legitimacy computing voting weights from verifiable social graphs. This enables sophisticated delegation, value-based incentives, and cross-DAO coordination. 2. Collective intelligence mechanisms that process semantically rich community preferences through fixed-stack, auditable DAO to Language Model pipelines embedded in the governance engine. These pipelines increase the throughput and resolution of governance by accelerating the pace and granularity of collective decision-making. 3. A Policy-as-Code execution framework that enables continuous organizational operations while maintaining democratic oversight. For instance, attestation graphs counterintuitively bolster Sybil resistance by converting “social noise” into verifiable legitimacy signals, while Policy-as-Code amplifies human oversight by making automated decisions auditable and contestable, transforming plutocratic weaknesses into meritocratic strengths. Unlike oracles that merely import external data, this model synthesizes attestations and preferences into verifiable policies without trusted intermediaries, addressing pain points like cross-chain fragmentation through seamless federation. By processing rich, verifiable inputs at scale, it mitigates risks such as attestation privacy breaches and new capture forms via clear trust boundaries, with off-chain computations verified economically or cryptographically on-chain. Ultimately, this framework equips DAOs to match or exceed legacy organizations’ efficiency in throughput and reliability, while preserving transparency, inclusivity, and capture resistance. Rather than constraining institutions to smart contract limits, DAOs can build governance systems tailored to 21st-century coordination demands. 2 The Governance Bottleneck: Smart Contracts Smart contracts deliver public verifiability and credible execution 7 . They also impose hard limits that shape what governance can do. For instance, a blockchain’s gas limit restricts the complexity of operations that can be performed in a single transaction. While these limitations are essential for blockchain security, they create significant barriers to implementing sophisticated governance mechanisms. Three constraints dominate in practice: computation is costly, data is siloed, and execution is synchronous. This section details each constraint and ties it to real governance needs. 2.1 Computational Constraints and Their Governance Implications On-chain computation is bounded by per-transaction gas budgets and conservative execution rules. Complex algorithms become impractical once a community grows. Liquid democracy shows the problem clearly. Effective voting power requires resolving multi-hop delegations, detecting cycles, and aggregating weights across the reachable subgraph for each voter or proposal. The work scales with the number of delegations and the depth of chains. At DAO scale, this traversal does not fit within a safe transaction. Splitting the computation across many transactions introduces race conditions. In Compound, more than 165,000 token holders and deep delegation chains make exact on-chain resolution unrealistic. The implementation falls back to simplified models that fit the budget. The outcomes match the constraint. Participation by delegated COMP hovered near 20 percent in 2024 and a small set of about 13 delegates could steer a majority. The mechanism did not begin that way. It was pushed there by cost. The same ceiling appears in other governance computations. Rich preference aggregation such as Condorcet or STV requires repeated pairwise comparisons and elimination rounds. Quadratic voting requires per identity squaring with identity control. Eligibility checks across multiple token positions and historical contribution windows require repeated cross-references. Any of these can be done for a few voters. They do not scale on chain without degradation. Storage and iteration costs matter too. Counting over large token holder sets forces repeated reads of account balances or snapshot structures. Even when data exists on chain, scanning it during a vote inflates cost and exposes proposals to gas price volatility. Designers respond by narrowing the computation or by pushing work off chain without guarantees. Both routes reduce expressivity. The implication is direct. Where the desired mechanism requires graph traversal, repeated comparison, or per voter personalization, gas replaces design as the binding constraint. DAOs then collapse toward unidimensional token voting and shallow quorum checks. Nuance is priced out. 2.2 Data Isolation and Cross-Chain Fragmentation Smart contracts execute in closed environments. They do not read from external systems or other chains without extra machinery. Governance quality suffers when relevant signals live elsewhere. Off-chain blind spots are common. Communities discuss and deliberate in forums, on GitHub, at events, and in working groups. Contracts cannot see that activity. MakerDAO is the clearest example. The forum shapes proposals through open discussion. Voting power is determined solely by MKR locked in the governance contract. A thoughtful contributor can influence opinions yet holds no formal weight unless they also hold tokens. This is a design choice driven by isolation. The contract cannot adjudicate forum reputation or review quality without a verifiable feed. Cross-chain fragmentation compounds the problem. Token holders and activity are spread across Ethereum, Polygon, Arbitrum, Optimism, and other networks. Unifying governance today often means asking voters to bridge assets, wait through finality windows, and accept extra risk. Many abstain. Even simple tasks like computing a voter’s aggregate stake across chains become awkward. Without a reliable way to view and combine positions, organizations either centralize voting on a single chain or accept fractured participation. The result is governance that rewards assets over participation, lacks nuance in source legitimacy, and forces communities into uncomfortable centralization. Technical limits, not organizational preference, dictate the shape of coordination. 2.3 Synchronous Execution and Timing Constraints Blockchain execution is strictly synchronous. Each state change follows the previous in a deterministic sequence. For payments and token transfers, this model provides essential ordering and safety. For governance workflows, it creates brittleness and inefficiency. Operational governance needs asynchronous processing. A DAO might evaluate grant applications in parallel, screen proposals for quality before voting, or update treasury allocations based on continuous monitoring. These workflows involve multiple agents working concurrently with different timing requirements. On chain,