Paradox-free classical non-causality and unambiguous non-locality without entanglement are equivalent

Hippolyte Dourdent, Kyrylo Simonov, Andreas Leitherer, Emanuel-Cristian Boghiu, Ravi Kunjwal, Saronath Halder, Remigiusz Augusiak, Antonio Acín · 2025

Read Paradox-free classical non-causality and unambiguous non-locality without entanglement are equivalent by Hippolyte Dourdent, Kyrylo Simonov, Andreas Leitherer, Emanuel-Cristian Boghiu, Ravi Kunjwal, Saronath Halder, Remigiusz Augusiak, Antonio Acín (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23599.txt.

Introduction

Hippolyte Dourdent and seven co-authors connect two puzzles about causality and quantum information. Closed timelike curves would let information loop into its own past, and any consistent theory of them must forbid paradoxes without changing local physics. That requirement leads to process functions: classical communication patterns that stay logically consistent under all local operations, yet produce correlations no definite causal order can explain.

The team proves these process functions correspond exactly to unambiguous complete product bases, sets of product states where every local state belongs to exactly one local basis. Through that mirror, classical non-causality matches quantum nonlocality without entanglement, the impossibility of telling certain separable states apart locally. Consequences include systematic constructions of examples, a proof that bipartite unambiguous bases of this kind do not exist, and a bridge between causal and Bell inequalities.

Catalog record

CREATORHippolyte Dourdent, Kyrylo Simonov, Andreas Leitherer, Emanuel-Cristian Boghiu, Ravi Kunjwal, Saronath Halder, Remigiusz Augusiak, Antonio Acín
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE142 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23599

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Paradox-free classical non-causality and unambiguous non-locality without entanglement are equivalent Preprint: APS/123-QED Hippolyte Dourdent, Kyrylo Simonov, Andreas Leitherer, Emanuel-Cristian Boghiu, Ravi Kunjwal, Saronath Halder, Remigiusz Augusiak, Antonio Acín Abstract Closed timelike curves (CTCs) challenge our conception of causality by allowing information to loop back into its own past. Any consistent description of such scenarios must avoid time-travel paradoxes while respecting the no-new-physics principle, which requires that the set of operations available within any local spacetime region remain unchanged, irrespective of whether CTCs exist elsewhere. Within an information-theoretic framework, this leads to process functions: deterministic classical communication structures that remain logically consistent under arbitrary local operations, yet can exhibit correlations incompatible with any definite causal order—a phenomenon known as non-causality. In this work, we provide the first complete recursive characterization of process functions and of (non-)causal process functions. We use it to establish a correspondence between process functions and unambiguous complete product bases, i.e., product bases in which every local state belongs to a unique local basis. This equivalence implies that non-causality of process functions is exactly mirrored by quantum nonlocality without entanglement (QNLWE)—the impossibility of perfectly distinguishing separable states using local operations and causal classical communication—for such bases. Our results generalize previous special cases to arbitrary local dimensions and any number of parties, enable systematic constructions of non-causal process functions and unambiguous QNLWE bases, and reveal an unexpected connection between certain non-signaling inequalities and causal inequalities. I Introduction Although it remains unknown whether closed timelike curves (CTCs), trajectories in spacetime that loop back into the past 52 ; 42 ; 54 , exist in Nature, their logical possibility challenges our understanding of physical dynamics and computer science 26 ; 22 ; 2 ; 70 . CTCs are notorious for giving rise to time-travel paradoxes 16 ; 64 ; 7 ; 19 ; 60 ; 3 such as the grandfather antinomy, in which an effect prevents its own cause, and the information or bootstrap antinomy, where an effect becomes its own cause. At their core lies a tension between events that have already occurred and the freedom of agents to influence them, a tension that has fueled a long-standing debate across physics and philosophy. Stephen Hawking famously argued that time-travel should be impossible, proposing the so-called chronology protection conjecture to “make the universe safe for historians” 48 . More nuanced accounts were offered by philosophers such as David Lewis, who, within his modal realist framework, argued that consistency can be restored through the Leibnizian notion of “compossible facts”, i.e. possible facts that can coexist with one another: what an agent can do relative to one set of facts may be impossible relative to another, more comprehensive, set that includes further facts 53 . Igor Novikov formulated a self-consistency principle 40 ; 57 , according to which “events on a closed timelike curve are already guaranteed to be self-consistent”. In this view, a time traveler retains the freedom to act, but her possible choices are constrained by a kind of “fine-tuning” or “time-policing” principle that prevents paradoxical outcomes. Analyses such as the billiard-ball-through-a-wormhole scenario 38 demonstrated that apparently inconsistent setups can nonetheless admit self-consistent solutions. This led to the formulation of the “no new physics” principle 40 , which asserts that the physical laws (in particular, the set of possible physical operations) within any local spacetime region remain unchanged, regardless of whether CTCs exist elsewhere 20 . Building on this idea, several consistent models have been proposed to investigate the interaction of quantum systems with operational, information-theoretic analogs of spacetime CTCs. Two prominent examples are the Deutsch-CTC (D-CTC) model 32 , motivated by the Everett interpretation, and the Post-selected-CTC (P-CTC) model 61 ; 21 ; 67 , inspired by quantum teleportation and based on post-selecting a Bell effect to implement a quantum channel to the past. While these frameworks successfully avoid causal paradoxes, this is achieved at the cost of abandoning either the “no new physics” principle or the assumption of freedom of choice, that is, the ability of agents to perform arbitrary operations in locally well-defined regions. Nevertheless, an alternative approach rooted in the study of quantum causality offers a framework free from these pathologies. The notion of indefinite causal orders originates from the causaloid formalism 46 ; 47 , which aims to bridge the dynamical causal structure of general relativity with the indeterminacy of quantum theory. This work questioned the fundamental nature of events taking place in a well-defined causal order and led to the development of the process matrix formalism 58 . This framework demonstrates that indefinite causal orders can emerge in scenarios involving spatially separated parties that control laboratories in which quantum theory holds locally - they are allowed to perform free local quantum operations - while no assumptions on a fixed global spacetime structure are made. In this information-theoretic context, local events are defined by classical outcomes of quantum operations in the laboratories. Causal relations between two events are then defined as one-way non-signaling constraints that encapsulate the order of operations. (For analysis and discussions on the relation between information-theoretic and space–time causal structures, cf. Ref 71 . For a brief overview of the debate surrounding the experimental realization of indefinite causal order, cf. Refs 62 and ( 65 , Appendix G.1) .). Process matrices preserve local physics while enabling globally acting processes that can violate causal inequalities 58 ; 25 , a phenomenon termed non-causality. These matrices can be seen as a linear subset of P-CTCs 10 or pre-post-selected quantum states 63 . The deterministic classical counterpart of process matrices, namely process functions (PF) 18 ; 17 ; 13 , was introduced to model classical communication scenarios beyond the standard causal ones. Various non-causal process functions for n\geq 3 parties have been identified 14 ; 18 ; 1 ; 15 ; 68 ; 55 . This is remarkable: despite lacking a well-defined causal order, these new classical communication structures preserve logical consistency, i.e., avoid time travel paradoxes, while maintaining freedom of choice 20 ; 16 . Local Operations with Process Function (LOPF) can be used as resources, providing advantages over traditional Local Operations with Classical Communication (LOCC) 29 , while still preserving freedom of choice—unlike the broader class of LOCC without causal order (LOCC*) 6 . In Ref. 50 , Kunjwal and Baumeler demonstrated that the SHIFT basis \displaystyle\{\mathinner{|{000}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{+01}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{01+}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{01-}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{1+0}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{-01}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{1-0}\rangle}\!,\mathinner{|{111}\rangle}\}, (1) which cannot be measured locally under LOCC—a phenomenon known as “quantum non-locality without entanglement” (QNLWE) 23 ; 43 ; 56 ; 45 ; 76 — is equivalent to a tripartite non-causal process function, the Lugano (AF/BW) process 1 ; 18 . In this process, each party’s input depends non-trivially on the outputs prepared by the other two parties, where all parties are both in each other’s past and future, with no restrictions on the local operations they perform: \displaystyle x_{1}:=a_{3}(a_{2}\oplus 1),\quad x_{2}:=a_{1}(a_{3}\oplus 1),\quad x_{3}:=a_{2}(a_{1}\oplus 1), (2) where x_{1},x_{2},x_{3} and a_{1},a_{2},a_{3} label the input and output bits for the first, second, and third party, respectively. By equivalence we refer to the fact that local operations communicating via the Lugano process can implement the SHIFT measurement (the projective measurement in the basis shown in Eq. ( 1 )) and, conversely, the SHIFT measurement enables the realization of the

Read the complete text