Poles from the conserved kinetic equation : The emerging gradient structure and causality riddle of relativistic hydrodynamics

Sukanya Mitra · 2025

Read Poles from the conserved kinetic equation : The emerging gradient structure and causality riddle of relativistic hydrodynamics by Sukanya Mitra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23456.txt.

Introduction

Sukanya Mitra studies relativistic hydrodynamics, the theory that describes hot, fast-moving fluids such as the matter formed in heavy-ion collisions. Working from the relativistic kinetic equation, she uses a proposed collision kernel built to conserve both energy-momentum and particle current exactly. The paper appeared in a version accepted by Physics Letters B.

Mitra analyzes the poles of the kinetic equation and the dispersion relations that follow from them. In the long-wavelength limit these relations show the gradient structure expected of hydrodynamics, with spatial and time gradients appearing together in a single relaxation operator. She argues that keeping this structure, including time derivatives, is what protects the theory from breaking causality at any truncation order. The paper runs to just seven pages.

Catalog record

CREATORSukanya Mitra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE35 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23456

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Poles from the conserved kinetic equation : The emerging gradient structure and causality riddle of relativistic hydrodynamics Sukanya Mitra Abstract In this work, the poles and the resulting dispersion spectra from the relativistic kinetic equation have been analyzed with the help of a proposed collision kernel that conserves both the energy-momentum tensor and particle current by construction. The dispersion relations, which originally come out in the form of logarithmic divergences, in the long wavelength limit exhibit the systematic gradient structure of the relativistic hydrodynamics. The key result is that, in the derivative expansion series, the spatial gradients appear in perfect unison with the temporal gradients in the non-local relaxation operator like forms. It is then shown that this dispersion structure, including non-local temporal derivatives, is essential for the preservation of causality of the theory truncated at any desired order. 1 Introduction In the study of the collective phenomena originating from microscopic dynamics of a system, the kinetic theory [ 1 ] has proved itself to be quite effective for the underlying coarse-graining method. In order to describe the transport properties of the system, such as momentum and charge diffusion, a description in terms of the weakly coupled quasiparticles and a governing kinetic equation of motion could be applicable at the late times of the emerging macroscopic formalism. The relativistic Boltzmann transport equation [ 2 , 3 ] has served the purpose quite well [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] to extract the characteristic signals of a system and decode its analytic behavior. Since it includes all types of non-analyticity describing both hydrodynamic and non-hydrodynamic sectors, it has found its application both in constructing hydrodynamic formalisms [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] and in the study of linear response theory through correlation functions [ 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 ] . However, the relativistic kinetic equation always had issues treating the highly non-linear microscopic collision term. A suitable approximation comes with a linearized collision kernel, which provides an exact solution in the Fourier space. But the linearization scheme comes with the cost of violating the conservation laws (of the macroscopic field variables) unless some external constraints are imposed in the name of the matching conditions or choice of hydrodynamic frames [ 16 ] . Starting from the Anderson-Witting relaxation time approximation (AWRTA) [ 17 ] to Bhatnagar-Gross-Krook (BGK) method [ 18 ] , the conservation in terms of both particle current and energy-momentum was never fully realized independent of these constraints. Only recently, [ 19 ] presented a fully conserved linearized kernel in terms of the orthogonal eigenvector basis. In the current work, a collision kernel has been proposed in Eq.( 9 ) which is expressed in terms of the out-of-equilibrium field corrections, much in the same line as the BGK kernel, but conserves both particle current and energy-momentum tensor without imposing any hydrodynamic frame choice. It is observed that in order to extract the poles from the conserved kinetic equation and consequently in constructing the dispersion relations, the form of the collision kernel presented here is quite effective. The dispersion relations are known to characterize the response of the system to perturbations around the equilibrium. In this work, these relations are directly obtained from the solution of the relativistic kinetic equation given in ( 9 ), without adopting any particular hydrodynamic theory. The field corrections used in the collision term to make the conservation possible act as the source term, much in the same line as the external force fields (electromagnetic or gravitational) in the correlator analysis. Expressing the solution of ( 9 ) in terms of these fields by taking suitable moments, it is possible to construct a system of simultaneous equations, the determinant of which provides the necessary pole structure that gives rise to the dispersion relations. The pole structure turns out to be in the form of the logarithmic singularity \Omega_{I} , which frequently appears in the expression of the retarded correlators [ 11 , 14 , 15 ] describing the collective behavior of a system. Next, these dispersion relations are analyzed at the hydrodynamic limit that corresponds to the low energy, long wavelength regime of the spectra. Expansion of the observed pole structures for small wave numbers results in an infinite power series of spatial derivatives resembling the hydrodynamic gradient expansion at near-equilibrium scenario. The crucial observation is that, for each increasing power of spatial gradients in the series, the temporal derivatives also appear in the denominator, maintaining perfect balance for mode conservation. The condition for mode conservation across a Lorentz boost has been discussed at length in [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , and it has been argued that the preservation of this condition is imperative for the causality of the theory. A proper truncation at some desired order of spatial gradient only makes sense if these non-local temporal derivatives are considered appropriately, like raised to a local set of equations. These non-local temporal terms appear in the form of the relaxation operator (1+i\omega\tau_{R}) which also sets the radius of convergence of the theory. These operators are actually the signature of the all order derivative corrections of a given causal theory as explained in [ 23 , 24 ] , and the abrupt truncation of the temporal gradients without treating the whole operator (1+i\omega\tau_{R}) directly leads to acausality. The current analysis depicts how the poles extracted from the relativistic kinetic equation with a fully conserved collision kernel emerge the hydrodynamic gradient expansion at long wave-length limit. Furthermore, the resulting dispersion series includes the in-built mechanism for causality preservation in terms of the non-local temporal operators, indicating the all-order derivative correction for a causal theory. This feature facilitates the claim made in [ 21 ] , that the underlying microscopic theories are always pathology free, and it is the limitation of the chosen truncation scheme that gives rise to the causality-related issues for a coarse-grained macroscopic theory. 2 Notations and convention Throughout the manuscript, natural unit ( \hbar=c=k_{B}=1 ) and flat space-time with mostly negative metric signature g^{\mu\nu}=\text{diag}\left(1,-1,-1,-1\right) have been used. n,\varepsilon,P,T and \mu respectively denote the particle number density, energy density, pressure, temperature, and chemical potential. The particle momenta is denoted by p^{\mu} with single particle energy E_{p}=p^{0}=p^{\mu}u_{\mu} , where the fluid velocity u^{\mu} in the global rest frame is given by (1,0,0,0) . x^{\mu} is the space-time coordinate and \partial_{\mu} defines the covariant derivative. d\Gamma_{p}=\frac{d^{3}p}{(2\pi)^{3}p^{0}} is the phase-space factor for moment integral. The Fourier transformation considered here is defined as \psi(x)\sim\int d^{4}k~e^{ik_{\mu}x^{\mu}}\tilde{\psi}(k) , with the wave 4-vector k^{\mu}=(\omega,0,0,k) , following \partial_{\mu}=ik_{\mu} . \eta and D_{F} are the coefficients of shear viscosity and charge diffusion respectively. \tau_{R} is the relaxation time for the single particle distribution function. 3 Moment definitions The fundamental fluid fields, namely the particle 4-current ( J^{\mu} ) and the energy-momentum tensor ( T^{\mu\nu} ) can be expressed as the moments folded over the single particle distribution function f(x,p) respectively as follows, \displaystyle J^{\mu}(x)=\int d\Gamma_{p}p^{\mu}f(x,p)~,~~~T^{\mu\nu}(x)=\int d\Gamma_{p}p^{\mu}p^{\nu}f(x,p)~. (1) Apart from that, two additional moments are defined here over the local equilibrium distribution function f_{eq}(x,p) as, \displaystyle a_{n}= \displaystyle\frac{1}{T^{n}}\int d\Gamma_{p}f_{eq}(x,p)E_{p}^{n}~, (2) \displaystyle\Delta^{\mu\nu}b_{n}= \displaystyle\frac{1}{T^{n+2}}\int d\Gamma_{p}f_{eq}(x,p)p^{\langle\mu\rangle}p^{\langle\nu\rangle}E_{p}^{n}~, (3) with p^{\langle\mu\rangle}=\Delta^{\mu\nu}p_{\nu} and \Delta^{\mu\nu}=g^{\mu\nu}-u^{\mu}u^{\nu} . Further, for the analysis

Read the complete text