The Quantum Rashomon Effect as a Failure of Gluing

Partha Ghose · 2025

Read The Quantum Rashomon Effect as a Failure of Gluing by Partha Ghose (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23325.txt.

Introduction

Partha Ghose writes a note on a quantum oddity, the Rashomon effect, explained as a failure of gluing. In extended Wigner's-friend scenarios, different observers can each hold coherent accounts of the same events. Those accounts refuse to merge into one shared story, like the conflicting testimonies in the film Rashomon. Szangolies had argued quantum theory permits such situations; Ghose recasts the phenomenon in math terms.

Local accounts exist over each context, but no single all-perspectives-at-once account exists, and that obstruction is the one sheaf theory uses to capture contextuality. Contextuality, where outcomes cannot be assigned independently of measurement context, is a signature of quantum behavior. The Rashomon effect thus joins a family of understood effects rather than standing as a new paradox. Ghose adds that the same math may serve quantum-like models of cognition, where context effects signal no joint probability space exists.

Catalog record

CREATORPartha Ghose
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE11 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23325

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Quantum Rashomon Effect as a Failure of Gluing Partha Ghose Abstract Recently Szangolies has argued (in the setting of extended Wigner’s-friend scenarios) that quantum theory permits “Rashomon” situations: multiple internally coherent accounts of events that cannot be combined into a single, consistent global narrative. This note explains why the Rashomon phenomenon can be understood as a failure of gluing : local descriptions over different contexts exist, but they do not admit a single global “all-perspectives-at-once” description. This is the same mathematical obstruction that underlies modern sheaf-theoretic treatments of contextuality. I then indicate why the same perspective is useful in parts of the social sciences (quantum-like modelling of cognition, judgment, and decision-making), where “context effects” can likewise be interpreted as the absence of a single joint probability space. 1 The quantum Rashomon effect: a brief summary Szangolies [ 1 ] has recently strengthened Frauchiger–Renner type arguments [ 2 ] by showing how different agents can arrive at different, internally coherent descriptions of “what happened,” while no single global narrative can simultaneously accommodate all of them. The key point is not that any one agent reasons incorrectly. Rather, the incompatibility arises because the agents’ descriptions are tied to different contexts 1 1 1 For physicists: “context” may be read as a set of mutually compatible (co-measurable) observables/records; here it is simply the information jointly accessible to an agent. (different sets of jointly meaningful propositions and records). For a recent overview of extended Wigner’s-friend arguments and how their tensions can be traced to structural assumptions, see Schmid, Yıng and Leifer [ 3 ] . The core feature can be stated without interpretational commitments: There are locally consistent descriptions relative to each context, but no globally consistent description that reduces to all of them at once. This is precisely the pattern captured by the presheaf/sheaf notion of “no global section” [ 4 ] . A related viewpoint—measurement as a form of “sheafification” of local, context-indexed truth assignments—is developed in my recent preprint [ 5 ] . 2 Rashomon as failure of gluing (minimal categorical formulation) This section uses only the most elementary “local-to-global” idea. Readers can keep in mind the familiar atlas metaphor from geometry: one may describe a sphere using many local maps (charts), but not every collection of local maps can be glued into a single global map. 2.1 Contexts and restrictions Let \mathsf{Ctx} denote a collection of contexts , partially ordered by refinement: D\leq C means that D is a sub-context of C (it speaks about fewer jointly meaningful questions/records, or contains less jointly accessible information). Whenever D\leq C , there is a natural restriction operation: from any description valid on C one can forget the extra claims and obtain a description valid on D . 2.2 A presheaf of local accounts A convenient way to formalize this is to assign to each context C the set of all admissible local accounts in that context. A convenient bookkeeping device is a presheaf of local accounts . For each context C , let \mathcal{F}(C) be the set of coherent accounts one may give using only the vocabulary/records available in C . Whenever D\leq C (“ D is a subcontext of C ”), there is a restriction map \rho_{CD}:\mathcal{F}(C)\to\mathcal{F}(D),\qquad s\mapsto s|_{D}, which simply forgets whatever is not expressible in D . (For readers who like categorical notation: this data is exactly a contravariant functor \mathcal{F}:\mathsf{Ctx}^{op}\to\mathbf{Set} .) 2.3 Gluing and global sections Suppose that a situation of interest is covered by a family of partial perspectives \{C_{i}\} . A collection of local accounts s_{i}\in\mathcal{F}(C_{i}) is called compatible on overlaps if, whenever two perspectives overlap (i.e., share a common subcontext—here C_{i}\cap C_{j} denotes this overlap), they agree on what both can express: s_{i}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}}\;=\;s_{j}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}}\qquad\text{for all }i,j. A global section is a single account s that simultaneously restricts to all the s_{i} : s|_{C_{i}}=s_{i}\qquad\text{for all }i. When such an s exists, one may legitimately speak of a single global narrative whose restrictions reproduce all local narratives. 2.4 The Rashomon pattern The Rashomon effect is exactly the failure of this gluing step: There exist locally coherent accounts s_{i}\in\mathcal{F}(C_{i}) , but there is no global section s whose restrictions reproduce all s_{i} . In the sheaf-theoretic approach to contextuality, the nonexistence of global sections is the precise sense in which there is no “view from nowhere” assigning outcomes/truth values across all contexts [ 4 ] . (Related local-to-global ideas also appear in topos-based approaches to quantum theory [ 6 ] .) There are two conceptually distinct ways “gluing” can fail. First, local accounts may already disagree on overlaps, s_{i}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}}\neq s_{j}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}} ; this corresponds to direct influence/disturbance (context-dependent marginals) and is not the Rashomon phenomenon emphasized here. The stronger, genuinely contextual obstruction is when the locals are compatible on all overlaps, s_{i}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}}=s_{j}|_{C_{i}\cap C_{j}} , yet there is still no global s\in\mathcal{F}(X) extending them. In the sheaf-theoretic framework this is an extension obstruction ; after passing to an abelian coefficient system built from the support of the local data, it can be represented by a nontrivial Čech cohomology class (typically in \check{H}^{1} ) [ 5 , 7 ] . Szangolies cites Lawvere [ 8 ] in connection with diagonal/self-reference reasoning. That is quite natural for Frauchiger–Renner type arguments, which involve agents reasoning about other agents who also apply quantum theory. However, Lawvere-style diagonal arguments and gluing obstructions address different structures: • Diagonal arguments organize fixed-point/self-reference phenomena. • Gluing-failure arguments block the passage from local descriptions to a single global description. Thus, the particular categorical tool used by Lawvere has a different target from the one intended here. The Rashomon phenomenon is especially transparent in the local-to-global language of presheaves. 3 A social-science bridge: quantum-like cognition and decision-making The term “Rashomon” already belongs to social science and qualitative methodology: multiple accounts of “what happened” can be individually compelling yet mutually incompatible. The quantum case adds a crisp mathematical template for when and why a single unified account may not exist. 3.1 Context effects as “no single joint distribution” In many behavioural and social datasets, responses depend on the measurement context: question order, framing, priming, and the set of available answers. A classical idealization assumes that there is a single underlying joint probability space from which all observed probabilities are marginals. When context effects are strong, no such single joint model may exist (or it may require additional hidden variables that defeat the intended “single story”). This is the probabilistic analogue of “no global section.” 3.2 Quantum-like modelling: what it claims (and what it does not) Quantum-like models in cognition do not require the brain to be quantum-mechanical. The claim is mathematical: Hilbert-space probability (noncommuting projections, state update, and interference-like terms) provides a compact way to encode context dependence and order effects in human judgments [ 9 , 10 ] . A canonical example is the empirically robust question order effect in surveys: the probability of answering “yes” to question A can change depending on whether A is asked before or after B . Quantum-like models represent A and B by noncommuting projectors, so that the two orderings are genuinely different sequential measurements [ 11 ] . In the presheaf language, each ordering corresponds to a different

Read the complete text