Essential Convergence Rates of Continuous-Time Models for Optimization Methods
Kansei Ushiyama, Shun Sato, Takayasu Matsuo · 2025
Read Essential Convergence Rates of Continuous-Time Models for Optimization Methods by Kansei Ushiyama, Shun Sato, Takayasu Matsuo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23317.txt.
Introduction
Kansei Ushiyama, Shun Sato, and Takayasu Matsuo ask what a convergence rate even means for an optimization method described by a differential equation. Analysts often model gradient methods as continuous-time flows because the equations feel simple. But rescaling time in the model speeds up or slows down its convergence at will, so chasing differential equations with fast rates is meaningless without a fix.
Their fix is the essential convergence rate, a notion designed to be immune to time rescaling. The backing is a theorem: under suitable rules for how the equation is discretized back into an algorithm, no discretization can converge faster than the model's essential rate. That makes the essential rate the honest ceiling a continuous model can promise. The paper reframes a popular design method, giving researchers a target that cannot be gamed by stretching the clock.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kansei Ushiyama, Shun Sato, Takayasu Matsuo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23317
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Essential Convergence Rates of Continuous-Time Models for Optimization Methods Thanks: A preliminary version of this paper appeared in JSIAM Lett., 14 (2022), pp. 119–122. https://doi.org/10.14495/jsiaml.14.119 Kansei Ushiyama, Shun Sato, Takayasu Matsuo Abstract Designing and analyzing optimization methods via continuous-time models expressed as ordinary differential equations (ODEs) is a promising approach for its intuitiveness and simplicity. A key concern, however, is that the convergence rates of such models can be arbitrarily modified by time rescaling, rendering the task of seeking ODEs with “fast” convergence meaningless. To eliminate this ambiguity of the rates, we introduce the notion of the essential convergence rate . We justify this notion by proving that, under appropriate assumptions on discretization, no method obtained by discretizing an ODE can achieve a faster rate than its essential convergence rate. 1 Introduction Some optimization methods can be modeled as ordinary differential equations (ODEs) by taking the limit as their step sizes vanish, as exemplified by the well-known relationship between the steepest descent method and gradient flow. This perspective has facilitated both the derivation and analysis of optimization methods, while also providing physical intuition into the optimization process, as demonstrated in Polyak’s seminal work [ 29 ] on the heavy-ball method. This approach gained significant attention following the introduction of the continuous time limit of Nesterov’s accelerated gradient method (AGM) [ 25 ] by Su et al. [ 33 ] , which offered a novel viewpoint on the underlying mechanisms of acceleration. Since then, numerous ODEs have been proposed to model various accelerated methods, such as the triple momentum method (TMM) [ 41 ] and the information-theoretic exact method (ITEM) [ 37 ] , as discussed in [ 19 ] , as well as ODEs derived via alternative continuous-limit techniques, such as high-resolution ODEs [ 31 ] . This line of work has now become a powerful framework for understanding and designing optimization methods, as surveyed in [ 13 ] , with notable advances including [ 5 , 6 , 16 , 22 , 2 , 9 , 36 , 32 ] . The efficiency of ODE models is characterized by their convergence rates, which have been analyzed for various ODEs under different settings. Consistency between the convergence rates of ODE models and those of the corresponding discrete optimization methods provides valuable insight into algorithm behavior. Moreover, identifying ODE models with fast convergence rates can guide the development of efficient optimization algorithms, as demonstrated in [ 20 ] . Numerous frameworks for analyzing the convergence rates of ODE models have been proposed, e.g., in [ 10 , 35 , 23 , 19 , 40 , 7 ] . Since convergence proofs for ODEs are often more straightforward than for their discrete counterparts, this approach offers clearer understanding of convergence proofs through analogies between continuous-time and discrete-time analyses [ 39 ] . However, an efficient continuous-time model cannot be identified solely by comparing convergence rates, since these rates can be arbitrarily modified through time-rescaling without changing the solution trajectory, i.e., the underlying convergence mechanism. Consequently, this arbitrariness of the rates renders the question “what is the fastest ODE?” meaningless. For example, if f\colon\mathbb{R}^{d}\to\mathbb{R} is convex, the gradient flow \dot{x}(t)=-\nabla f(x(t)),\quad x(0)=x_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{d}, (2) where \dot{x} denotes the time derivative of x , achieves the rate f(x(t))-f^{\star}=\mathrm{O}\left\lparen 1/t\right\rparen (cf. [ 34 ] ), where f^{\star} is the optimal value. However, a dynamics attaining a faster rate \mathrm{O}\left\lparen 1/t^{2}\right\rparen can be obtained only by considering the time-rescaled gradient flow \dot{x}(t)=-t\nabla f(x(t)) . The same rate is also achieved by the solution x(t) of the system \ddot{x}(t)+\frac{3}{t}\dot{x}(t)+\nabla f(x(t))=0,\quad x(0)=x_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} (3) which corresponds to the continuous-time limit of AGM [ 33 ] . Thus, one cannot determine which of these dynamics is superior solely on the basis of their convergence rates. This observation highlights the necessity of a tool for selecting a representative rate for each ODE. In [ 42 ] , the authors also emphasized the arbitrariness of convergence rates under time-rescaling, noting that “the underlying solution curve has a more fundamental structure that is worth exploring further.” In prior studies on convergence rates of ODEs, the ambiguity caused by time-rescaling has often been addressed by fixing the coefficients of the ODEs, thereby restricting the collection of ODEs under comparison. While this approach enables comparison within a given collection of ODEs, it does not allow meaningful comparison across different collections. Moreover, even within the same collection, comparing ODEs with fixed coefficients may not yield valid insights. For instance, consider the family of heavy-ball ODEs [ 29 ] : \ddot{x}(t)+a_{1}(t)\dot{x}(t)+a_{2}(t)\nabla f(x(t))=0,\quad x(0)=x_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} (4) where a_{1},a_{2}\colon[0,\infty)\to\mathbb{R} . An ODE in this family is specified by determining the coefficient functions (a_{1},a_{2}) . We define an equivalence relation on these coefficients: (a_{1},a_{2})\sim(b_{1},b_{2}) if the solution of the ODE with (a_{1},a_{2}) is a time-rescaled one of the solution with (b_{1},b_{2}) . This relation partitions the heavy-ball ODEs into equivalence classes. Our goal is then to compare these classes and identify the one that produces the most efficient solution trajectories, which in turn correspond to efficient discrete-time algorithms. Since for any (a_{1},a_{2}) , there exists a unique \hat{a} such that (a_{1},a_{2})\sim(\hat{a},1) , one can define a “normalized” representative in each class by fixing the coefficient a_{2}(t)=1 . Prior works have compared heavy-ball ODEs under this normalization [ 24 , 4 , 35 , 23 ] . However, there is no justification that comparisons restricted to these representatives reflect the relative efficiency of the underlying equivalence classes, i.e. the solution trajectories. This ambiguity becomes problematic when the heavy-ball ODE involves a gradient evaluated at a shifted point, which is equivalent to Hessian-driven damping [ 31 ] . Consider the following family of ODEs: \ddot{x}(t)+\frac{3}{t}\dot{x}(t)+\nabla f(x(t)+b\dot{x}(t))=0,\quad x(0)=x_{0}\in\mathbb{R}^{d} (5) where b>0 is a constant. For these ODEs, suppose that we eliminate the time-rescale ambiguity is eliminated by fixing the coefficient in front of the gradient term to 1. It has been shown [ 40 ] that, for convex f , \min_{0\leq s\leq t}\|\nabla f(x(s)+b\dot{x}(s))\|^{2}\leq\frac{18\|x(0)-x^{\star}\|^{2}}{7bt^{3}}. (6) If we compare these solution trajectories solely based on this convergence rate, we might conclude that larger values of b are better, suggesting an unlimited improvement in the constant factor of the rate. However, such a phenomenon cannot occur in the discrete-time setting, given the known lower bounds (cf. [ 26 ] ). Thus, it is unlikely that a fast algorithm can be developed by discretizing this model. We therefore need to adopt another approach to fixing the rate (or selecting the representative rate), so as to avoid continuous-time models that yield illusory convergence rates that do not correspond to any feasible algorithm. A similar issue arises in control theory. Increasing the gain enables faster convergence to the desired state, which corresponds to a time-rescaling effect in continuous-time models. In practical control situations, however, excessively large gain leads to higher control cost and greater sensitivity to noise, making arbitrarily large gain impractical. To balance this trade-off, optimal control strategies, such as the linear quadratic method (cf. [ 1 ] ), typically minimize a cost function that accounts for both performance and these side effects. In this study, we focus on a similar trade-off structure arising from time-rescaling, although our strategy differs from the control-theoretic approach above. We view optimization methods