Isotope Effects and the Negative Thermal Expansion Phenomena in Ice and Water
B. I. Min 1, J.-S. Kang 2 · 2025
Read Isotope Effects and the Negative Thermal Expansion Phenomena in Ice and Water by B. I. Min 1, J.-S. Kang 2 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-23247.txt.
Introduction
B. I. Min and J.-S. Kang explain two of water's strangest habits and trace both to quantum mechanics hiding inside an apparently classical substance. Ice shrinks as it warms at low temperature, and liquid water does the same near freezing, a negative thermal expansion almost unheard of elsewhere. Replacing hydrogen with heavier deuterium also expands the volume, an abnormal isotope effect. The authors model these phenomena with a Born-Oppenheimer-style approach and the Lindemann criterion for melting.
Their account pits three ingredients against each other: zero-point phonons that exist even at absolute zero, ordinary thermal phonons, and the hydrogen bonds that give water its open structure. The unusual isotope effects fall out of that competition. Every ingredient is a nuclear quantum process. The paper's moral follows: quantum physics is not a small correction to ice and water. It is the reason their thermal behavior looks so odd.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | B. I. Min 1, J.-S. Kang 2 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-23247
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Isotope Effects and the Negative Thermal Expansion Phenomena in Ice and Water B. I. Min 1, J.-S. Kang 2 Abstract H 2 O is a unique substance with exceptional thermal properties arising from the subtle interplay between its electronic, phononic, and structural degrees of freedom. Of particular interest in H 2 O are the negative thermal expansion (NTE) phenomena, observed in its solid phase (ice) at low temperature, and in its liquid phase (water) near the freezing temperature. Furthermore, ice and water exhibit the abnormal volume isotope effect (VIE), where volume expansions occur when replacing H with its heavier isotope, deuterium (D). In order to capture more conceptual and intuitive understanding of intriguing NTE and VIE phenomena in ice and water, we have explored isotope effects in their NTE and melting properties by employing a type of Born-Oppenheimer-approximation approach and the Lindemann criterion. Our findings demonstrate that unusual isotope effects in these phenomena stem from competition between zero-point-energy phonons, thermal phonons, and the hydrogen bonding in H 2 O. All these components originate from nuclear quantum mechanical (QM) processes, revealing that QM physics plays a crucial role in the seemingly classical ice/water systems. I Introduction Thermal expansion is a phenomenon of length, area, or volume change of a material with varying temperature ( T ). Most substances exhibit positive thermal expansions (PTEs), implying that they expand upon heating and contract upon cooling. However, H 2 O in its different solid, liquid, and gas phases manifests a fascinating exception to this rule (see the phase diagram in Fig. 1 (a)) PD-h2o . Namely, contrary to the general rule, upon cooling, liquid water expands below T=4~^{\circ} C exhibiting the volume minimum (density maximum) at T=4~^{\circ} C, and then its volume increases abruptly by about 9% when it freezes to ice at T=0~^{\circ} C ( T =273 K), as shown in Fig. 1 (b). Hence liquid water has the negative thermal expansion (NTE) coefficient between 0~^{\circ} C and 4~^{\circ} C (inset of Fig. 1 (b)), and ice is less dense than liquid water due to its larger volume Water-website . In fact, the negative slope ( \frac{dP}{dT}<0 ) of phase-equilibrium line between ice and water in Fig. 1 (a) is closely related to the observed NTE at the transition Liu11 ; Liu14 ; Jwkim23 ; Supp . The density maximum at T=4~^{\circ} C in H 2 O is well known to be essential for ecological systems and various environmental processes Water-website . Furthermore, H 2 O exhibits a colossal PTE (volume expands by \sim 1600 times), when boiling into its vapor gas phase. The most common form of ice at the ambient pressure is the ice-Ih phase Water-website . As shown in Fig. 1 (c), ice-Ih exhibits the normal PTE between \sim 70 K and 273 K ( 0~^{\circ} C), albeit at a much lower thermal-expansion rate than liquid water. A notable feature in ice-Ih is another NTE phenomenon below \sim 70 K. The NTE behavior in ice-Ih at low T is known to arise from low-energy vibrational modes of ice-Ih phase, which produce the negative Grüneisen parameters Liu14 ; Evans99 ; Strassle04 ; Pamuk12 ; Umemoto15 ; Gupta18 . Ice-Ih exhibits an additional abnormal feature in the volume isotope effect (VIE), where the volume of the ice changes distinctly depending on the isotope of hydrogen Roettger94 ; Fortes18 ; Buckingham18 . In most materials, replacing lighter isotopes with heavier ones leads to a normal VIE, indicating that the material contracts in volume. However, in ice-Ih, replacing H with its heavier isotope, deuterium (D), leads to the volume expansion, as shown in Fig. 1 (c). This abnormal VIE was reported to arise from the quantum-mechanical (QM) nature of the hydrogen atoms in the ice lattice Pamuk12 ; Umemoto15 ; Salim16 ; Cherubini21 ; Rasti22 . Interestingly, the abnormal VIE is also observed in water near the so-called T_{MD} ( T_{MD} : the temperature corresponding to the maximum density), as shown in Fig. 1 (d). The anomalous thermal expansion properties of ice and water highlight the complex physics and chemistry of the H 2 O system. Through decades of research, their mechanisms are understood to some extent based on numerical computations of the Grüneisen parameters of phonon modes at low T Pamuk12 ; Umemoto15 ; Salim16 ; Gupta18 and numerical simulations of molecular-dynamics at high T Morrone08 ; Ramirez10 ; McBride12 ; Xu20 ; Eltareb21 ; Romanelli24 . Despite extensive studies, however, conceptual understanding of the underlying physics and chemistry of intriguing NTE and VIE phenomena in ice and water is still lacking. So we revisit these issues to capture the comprehensive and intuitive picture from a more fundamental point of view. In this paper, to identify the physics behind the NTE phenomena in ice and water, we have examined the isotope effects in the NTE properties, such as the volume-minimum temperatures ( T_{vm} ’s) and the melting temperatures ( T_{m} ’s) as well as the VIEs. Specifically, we have addressed the issues on (i) the origin of different T_{vm} ’s for different isotopes as well as the abnormal VIE observed in ice-Ih at low T , and (ii) the origin of different T_{m} ’s and T_{MD} ’s for different isotopes as well as the abnormal VIE observed in ice-Ih and water near the freezing T . In the following, the approach we have adopted for the present analysis, including a type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation and the Lindemann criterion, is briefly described (Section II), and then results and discussions of our findings are presented (Section III), which is followed by concluding remarks (Section IV). Figure 1: (a) Phase diagram of H 2 O PD-h2o . A, B, C, and D correspond to the triple point, freezing point, boiling point, and critical point, respectively. (b) Thermal expansion data near the freezing point Vol-T . Note the NTE (abrupt volume jump) at the water to ice transition at T=0~^{\circ} C (273 K), and the NTE of water between 0~^{\circ} C (273 K) and 4~^{\circ} C (277 K) shown in the inset. (c) The thermal expansion data of ice-Ih phases of H 2 O and D 2 O. The NTEs are observed below \sim 70 K for both. D 2 O has the larger volume than H 2 O, manifesting the abnormal VIE. (d) Volume variations of supercooled-water isotopes as a function of T Water-website ; Tmd . (e) Open hexagonal crystal structure of ice-Ih (viewed along the c axis). (f) Hydrogen-bonding (H:O-bonding) in tetrahedral building block of ice-Ih. Each oxygen forms two-short H-O covalent bonds, and two-long hydrogen bonds (H:O-bonds) with neighboring H ions. II Methodology Based on the analysis of existing experimental data for ice and water, we have attempted to provide conceptual interpretation of anomalous NTE/VIE and melting properties observed in ice and water. For this purpose, we have newly employed a type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation Marechal68 ; Marechal07 to explain the former and the Lindemann criterion Lindemann1910 to explain the latter. A type of Born-Oppenheimer approximation we have employed is described in the supplement section (ii) Supp . For a system like H 2 O having the fast-moving high-energy ( \omega ) and the slow-moving low-energy ( \Omega ) phonon modes, which are