Generalised Entanglement Entropies from Unit-Invariant Singular Value Decomposition

Paweł Caputa, Abhigyan Saha, Piotr Sułkowski · 2025

Read Generalised Entanglement Entropies from Unit-Invariant Singular Value Decomposition by Paweł Caputa, Abhigyan Saha, Piotr Sułkowski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22997.txt.

Introduction

Pawel Caputa, Abhigyan Saha, and Piotr Sułkowski generalize entanglement entropy so the measure survives rescaling of the state. Standard singular value decomposition underlies the usual von Neumann entropy. Its values shift when a non-Hermitian or rectangular operator is rescaled. That is a nuisance in settings like biorthogonal quantum mechanics, where scale changes are meaningless. The authors build on unit-invariant versions of the decomposition, in left, right, and two-sided forms.

Each variant yields an entropy that stays fixed under its matching class of diagonal transformations. The definitions work when input and output spaces differ in dimension or carry different metric weights. The paper applies these entropies within biorthogonal quantum mechanics, where their scale stability is the point. It also tests them on bipartite states, random matrices tied to quantum chaos and holography, and Chern-Simons theory. Across these cases the spectra stay stable and interpretable.

Catalog record

CREATORPaweł Caputa, Abhigyan Saha, Piotr Sułkowski
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE135 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22997

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Generalised Entanglement Entropies from Unit-Invariant Singular Value Decomposition Preprint: YITP-25-193 Paweł Caputa, Abhigyan Saha, Piotr Sułkowski Abstract We introduce generalisations of von Neumann entanglement entropy that are invariant with respect to certain scale transformations. These constructions are based on Unit-Invariant Singular Value Decomposition (UISVD) with its right-, left-, and bi-invariant incarnations, which itself are variations of the standard Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) that remain invariant under (appropriate set of) diagonal transformations. These measures are naturally defined for non-Hermitian or rectangular operators and remain useful when the input and output spaces possess different dimensions or metric weights. We apply the UISVD entropy and discuss its advantages in the physically interesting framework of Biorthogonal Quantum Mechanics, whose important aspect is indeed the behavior under scale transformations. Further, we illustrate features of UISVD-based entropies in other representative settings, from simple quantum mechanical bipartite states to random matrices relevant to quantum chaos and holography, and in the context of Chern-Simons theory. In all cases, the UISVD yields stable, physically meaningful entropic spectra that are invariant under rescalings and normalisations. 1 Introduction Quantum entanglement has become one of the most powerful and unifying concepts in modern theoretical physics. It underlies our understanding of correlations and information in quantum many-body systems 1 ; 8 , quantum field theories 55 ; 30 ; 9 , and even quantum gravity 52 ; 57 ; 62 through holography 41 . Entanglement entropy and its generalisations have emerged as indispensable probes of quantum structure, diagnosing topological order, characterising quantum phases, and encoding the emergence of spacetime geometry 58 . Still, despite its success, quantifying entanglement in general situations, particularly for mixed states, or for open as well as non-Hermitian systems, remains conceptually and technically challenging. Traditional measures of entanglement rely on the Schmidt or Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) of a pure state or operator in a bipartite Hilbert space \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} (see 31 ; 19 ; 46 for more on operator entanglement). For pure states, the Schmidt coefficients fully determine the entanglement spectrum and yield Rényi or von Neumann entropies with clear operational meaning. However, when the system evolves non-unitarily, interacts with an environment, or the setup is described by transition rather than density matrices, the conventional SVD-based framework becomes ambiguous. In such cases, even defining an “entropy” that reflects physical, quantum correlations rather than normalisation or scaling artefacts can be subtle. Related to these challenges, several generalisations of entanglement have recently been proposed, including pseudo-entropy 45 ; 44 , SVD entropy 49 , and entropies in time 17 ; 18 ; 43 among them. These approaches use the singular values of transition matrices or non-Hermitian operators to construct Rényi-type quantities that extend entanglement to post-selected, time-dependent or general open quantum systems. Such ideas and tools already found applications across diverse areas, from dS/CFT correspondence 17 ; 28 ; 29 , renormalisation 23 , topological theories 47 ; 12 to spectral form factors used to diagnose quantum chaos 11 . However, a fundamental issue persists across all these constructions: the singular values themselves depend on the choice of units and scaling conventions in the subspaces involved. To see the problem concretely, consider even the simplest quantum mechanical example: a two-level system where one rescales the basis states in one subsystem by an arbitrary factor (a trivial change of normalisation or physical units). Although this transformation leaves the physical content unchanged, it modifies the singular values. As a result, the entropy constructed from those singular values varies under a mere redefinition of scale i.e. conventional SVD, while invariant under unitaries, is not invariant under such diagonal rescalings. Consequently, SVD-based entropic measures may conflate genuine quantum correlations with artefacts of normalisation, a subtle but crucial distinction, especially in field-theoretic or non-Hermitian settings where operator norms (choices of inner-products) or couplings carry non-trivial scaling behaviour (see e.g. 21 ). A mathematically rigorous resolution to this problem with SVD was recently provided by Uhlmann 61 . Following earlier works on construction of singular values invariant under more specific rescalings, he introduced the Unit-Invariant Singular Value Decomposition (UISVD) as a variation of the standard SVD that remains invariant under diagonal (unit) transformations acting on a given operator from both sides. The UISVD produces unit-invariant singular values that eliminate spurious dependencies on scaling conventions. In effect, UISVD isolates the physically meaningful, scale-independent structure of a linear map. This property makes the UISVD particularly appealing for the above-mentioned physical setups, where operators often connect Hilbert spaces with different metric or normalisation structures present. Indeed, in these contexts, one may start from entanglement and information measures that are invariant under simple changes of physical units, and hope that classifying them will be easier and more robust, similarly to von Neumann entropies for pure states. In this work, we introduce the UISVD framework into quantum information and field-theoretic contexts, proposing it as a new foundation for unit-invariant measures of entanglement. We construct UISVD-based analogues of von Neumann entropy and demonstrate the variation from familiar SVD-based quantities while removing their dependence on arbitrary scale choices. These measures are naturally defined for non-Hermitian or rectangular operators and remain robust when the input and output spaces possess different dimensions or metric weights. As a proof of concept, we apply UISVD-based entropies to several representative settings, from simple quantum mechanical bipartite mixed states to random matrices relevant to quantum chaos and holography. In all cases, the UISVD yields stable, physically meaningful entropic spectra that are invariant under rescalings and normalisations. Beyond their practical advantages, our results suggest a deeper conceptual point: UISVD restores a natural physical covariance to operator-based entropies, ensuring that what we quantify as “entanglement” or “correlation” is independent of arbitrary normalisation or choice of units. In this sense, we hope that UISVD may contribute to providing a unifying, invariant language for quantifying quantum correlations in systems where conventional assumptions of unitarity or normalisation fail. Let us briefly summarise how we construct scale invariant entropy measures. First, following 61 , for a matrix A we introduce its left unit-invariant, right unit-invariant, and (full, left and right) bi-unit-invariant singular values, denoted respectively \sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{L}}(A),\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{R}}(A) and \sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{B}}(A) . Scale (or unit) invariance means that they satisfy the relations \sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{L}}(A)=\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{L}}(DAU),\qquad\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{R}}(A)=\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{R}}(UAD^{\prime}),\qquad\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{B}}(A)=\sigma_{i}^{\mathrm{B}}(DAD^{\prime}), (1) where D and D^{\prime} are complex non-singular diagonal matrices that represent scaling transformations acting on A from left or right, while U is a unitary matrix (so that left- and right-singular values are in addition invariant under unitary transformation on the opposite side). We then consider quantum systems with bipartite Hilbert spaces \mathcal{H}=\mathcal{H}_{\mathbb{A}}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{\mathbb{B}} characterised by reduced density matrix or reduced transition matrix \rho_{\mathbb{A}}=\textrm{Tr}_{\mathbb{B}}(\rho) , obtained by taking partial trace of a density or transition matrix \rho . The systems of our interest involve some natural scaling operations, which amount to rescaling of \rho_{\mathbb{A}} by diagonal matrices D and D^{\prime} from left or right, or both sides. We then identify corresponding unit-invariant singular values, which are scale invariant analogously to Eq. 1 , and introduce associated unit invariant entropy measures. Depending on the system under consideration, such entropies generalise other familiar versions of entanglement entropy, such as ordinary von Neumann entropy, or pseudo entropy and SVD entropy (when \rho is a transition matrix with respect to some pre- or post-selected state). In the rest of the

Read the complete text