Panhandle polynomials of torus links and geometric applications

Andrei Mironov, Hisham Sati, Vivek Kumar Singh, Alexander Stoimenov · 2025

Read Panhandle polynomials of torus links and geometric applications by Andrei Mironov, Hisham Sati, Vivek Kumar Singh, Alexander Stoimenov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22967.txt.

Introduction

Andrei Mironov, Hisham Sati, Vivek Kumar Singh, and Alexander Stoimenov study a famous knot invariant, the HOMFLY-PT polynomial, for a special family: reverses and parallels of torus knots and links. Using a decomposition of the fundamental representation of a quantum group, with the Rosso-Jones formula, they show these polynomials take a curious shape. The authors call it a panhandle shape, and the polynomials themselves earn the nickname panhandle polynomials.

That rigid shape has geometric payoffs. Combined with an invariant denoted l, it extends a result of Etnyre and Honda about arc index and the maximal Thurston-Bennequin invariant from torus knots to torus links. Consequences follow for braid index, for Bennequin surfaces of banded and Whitehead doubled links, for the Bennequin sharpness problem, and for when quasipositivity and strong quasipositivity coincide. The authors close by discussing how the l-invariant might be defined for general links.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrei Mironov, Hisham Sati, Vivek Kumar Singh, Alexander Stoimenov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE122 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22967

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Panhandle polynomials of torus links and geometric applications Andrei Mironov, Hisham Sati, Vivek Kumar Singh, Alexander Stoimenov Abstract We use a decomposition of the tensor of the fundamental representation of the quantum group U q ​ ( 𝔰 ​ 𝔩 N ) U_{q}(\mathfrak{sl}_{N}) and the Rosso-Jones formula to establish a peculiar “panhandle” shape of the HOMFLY-PT polynomial of the reverse parallel of torus knots and links. Due to their panhandle-like intrinsic properties, the HOMFLY-PT polynomial is referred to as a “panhandle polynomial”. With the help of the ℓ \ell -invariant, this extends to links the Etnyre-Honda result about the arc index and maximal Thurston-Bennequin invariant of torus knots. It has further geometric consequences, related to the braid index, the existence of minimal string Bennequin surfaces for banded and Whitehead doubled links, the Bennequin sharpness problem, and the equivalence of their quasipositivity and strong quasipositivity. We extend these properties to torus links, which relate to the classification of their component-wise Thurston-Bennequin invariants. Finally, we discuss the definition of the ℓ \ell -invariant for general links. Contents 1 Introduction Polynomial invariants have provided deep insights into knot theory and topology. Some of the most widely studied knot polynomial invariants include the Alexander polynomial [ Al ] , the Jones polynomial [ Jo ] , and the HOMFLY-PT polynomial [ H+ ] . In this paper, we exhibit a peculiar shape of the latter polynomial of the reverse parallel of a torus knot and a torus link. We fix for K=T_{m,n}=T(m,n) , with (m,n)=1\,,\quad m<n\,, the vertical framing t=t_{\nu} , given in ( 3 ), and the convention ( 5 ) below. Our main result is the following: Theorem 1.1 (Panhandle Theorem) . Let X=[\underline{M};M]_{v} denote a polynomial such that \min\deg_{v}X=\underline{M}\quad\text{and}\quad\max\deg_{v}X=M. (1) Then the HOMFLY-PT polynomial for the reverse 2 - cable torus knot C_{2}(T_{m,n},t) has the form P(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t))=[1-2m;2m-1]_{v}\;+\;\underbrace{(m-1)zv\frac{v^{2n}-v^{2m}}{v^{2}-1}}_{\rm{panhandle}}\,. The condition m<n is essential: restoring the symmetry of the torus knot T(m,n) in m and n (topological framing) requires the vanishing of certain leading coefficients in the Laurent polynomial [1-2m;2m-1]_{v} when m>n . Establishing Theorem 1.1 directly from the skein relation ( 5 ) is cumbersome. Hence, we adopt a representation theory approach. The construction of HOMFLY-PT invariants, denoted by \mathcal{H}(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t)) , naturally relies on the decomposition of the tensor product of representations (see [ RT ] [ MMM2 ] ) into irreducible components R\otimes\bar{R}\;=\;\bigoplus_{i}Q_{i},\qquad Q_{i}\in\mathrm{Rep}(U_{q}(\mathfrak{sl}_{N}))\,. Here R denotes the fundamental representation associated with a Young tableau of the quantum group U_{q}(\mathfrak{sl}_{N}) and \bar{R} is its conjugate. In this context, the HOMFLY-PT polynomial of a knot C_{2}(T_{m,n},t) can be written as the sum of contributions from the relevant representations, namely the scalar representation ( Q_{1}=\Phi ) and the adjoint representation ( Q_{2}=\mathrm{Adj} ): {}P\big(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t_{\nu})\big):=\mathcal{H}\big(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t_{\nu})\big)=\frac{1}{\mathcal{H}_{R}({U})}\Big(\mathcal{H}_{\Phi}\big({T_{m,n}}\big)+\mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{Adj}}\big({T_{m,n}}\big)\!\Big). (2) Here t_{\nu}=(1-m)n (3) is the vertical framing (see Defs. 2.3 and 2.10 ) and U is the unknot. Whereas the HOMFLY-PT polynomial of the scalar representation \mathcal{H}_{\Phi}(K)=1 , that of the adjoint representation \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{Adj}}(K) is generally nontrivial. This formulation provides a natural framework for analyzing the structure of P\big(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t)\big) . Theorem 1.1 emerges from expression ( 2 ) using the Rosso-Jones formula ( [ LZ , Theorem 5.1] [ RJ , Theorem 8] ), which provides a systematic approach to understanding the adjoint polynomials of torus knots \mathcal{H}_{\mathrm{Adj}}({T_{m,n}}) . We describe this in section 2 , with a general proof of Theorem 1.1 established in section 2.3 . The particular case of m=2 of Theorem 1.1 was proved in [ JLS2 ] by the fourth author using skein algebra programming. The leading ( v -degree) term of the panhandle for m=2 was also identified by Diao and Morton [ DM , Theorem 2.7] . The main motivation behind Theorem 1.1 is not the peculiar shape of the polynomial. It emerged through explicit computations related to very different subjects. Specifically, it is related to a new method of estimating the arc index and maximal Thurston-Bennequin invariant of knots [ JLS2 ] . This method, which relies on a quantity named \ell -invariant, allows for an algebraic proof of some of Etnyre-Honda’s work [ EH ] on torus knots. The work in [ JLS2 ] allows us to further relate to the braid index of the reverse parallel (see [ DM ] ), the existence of its minimal string Bennequin surfaces (see [ BMe ] [ HS ] ), the Bennequin sharpness problem (Problem 3.8 ), and the equivalence of quasipositivity and strong quasipositivity for certain links. We outline these applications in § 3 . Theorem 1.1 also admits an extension to the setting of torus links, which we discuss in section 2.4 . This extension follows directly from the underlying Def. 2.32 and the arguments developed in § 2.4 . We state the result in the following theorem (see Theorem 2.34 ). Theorem 1.2 (Panhandle for links) . The HOMFLY-PT polynomial for the reverse 2 -cable l -component torus link C_{2}(T_{m,n},t_{\nu}) has the form P\big(C_{2}(T_{m,n},t_{\nu})\big)=\bigg[1-2m;\,2n\ {l-1\over l}\ +\frac{2m}{l}-1\!\bigg]\bigg]_{{}_{v}}\;+\;\underbrace{\zeta_{m,l}\ zv\ \frac{v^{2n}-v^{2m}}{v^{2}-1}}_{\rm{panhandle}}\,, where \zeta_{m,l}:=\sum_{k=0}^{l}(-1)^{l+k}{l!\over(l-k)!}\left({m\over l}\right)^{k}. Hence, the length of the link panhandle is equal to 2(n-m)/l . In § 4 we extend the above applications to torus links. Apart from determining their arc index, we give a full description of their component-wise Thurston-Bennequin invariants in § 4.1.2 . Then, the further geometric applications outlined for torus knots are largely generalized to torus links in § 4.2 , with the addition of the Baker-Motegi problem (§ 4.2.4 ). The conclusion of § 4 (and the paper) discusses the extension of the \ell -invariant for general links, based on the properties studied for the torus links. 2 Panhandle polynomials for torus knots and links 2.1 Background and Definitions Definition 2.1 (Torus Knots) . Let m,n\in\mathbb{Z}_{>0} such that \gcd(m,n)=1 . The torus knot T_{m,n}=T(m,n) is defined as the closure of the braid word T_{m,n}:=\widehat{(\sigma_{1}\sigma_{2}\cdots\sigma_{m-1})^{n}}\in B_{m}, where B_{m} is the braid group on m strands with standard Artin generators \sigma_{1},\dots,\sigma_{m-1} . The closure operation, \widehat{\cdot} , connects the corresponding top and bottom endpoints of the braid to form a knot. Example 2.2 . The torus knot T_{4,3} is the closure of the braid (\sigma_{1}\sigma_{2}\sigma_{3})^{3}\in B_{4} . See Fig. 1 for an illustration. Figure 1: Braid representation of torus knots T(4,3) . Definition 2.3 (The reverse 2 -cable knots) . Let {K}=\widehat{\beta} be the closure of a braid \beta\in B_{m} . Define the reverse 2 -cable of \beta to be the braid \phi(\beta)\in B_{2m} obtained by “doubling and reversing orientation” of each strand of \beta with framing t . The framing t\in\mathbb{Z} is defined by the factor of q^{t\kappa_{\lambda}} (see ( 10 )) that differs the framed HOMFLY-PT polynomial from the invariant polynomial (topological framing). The sign of framing changes if the orientation is reversed. We will use the vertical framing [ AM ] , which for the torus knot T(m,n) is given in ( 3 ). Concretely, on the Artin generators \phi:B_{m}\;\longrightarrow\;B_{2m},\qquad\phi\bigl(\sigma_{i}\bigr)\;=\;\sigma_{2i}\sigma_{2i+1}\sigma_{2i-1}\,\sigma_{2i}\quad(1\leq i\leq m-1). (4) Then the 2-cable knot C_{2}({K},t) is C_{2}({K},t)\;:=\;\widehat{\phi(\beta)}\;\in\;S^{3}. See Fig. 2 for a schematic of the reverse 2 -cable torus knot T_{4,5} with framing t=-15 . Figure 2: Braid representation of reverse 2 -cable torus knots T_{4,5} . Definition 2.4 (HOMFLY-PT Polynomial [ H+ ] ) . For a knot K , the (uncolored) HOMFLY–PT polynomial P(K) is defined via the

Read the complete text