Reply to “Comment on ‘Absence of a consistent classical equation of motion for a mass-renormalized point charge’ ” (arXiv:2511.02865v1, 3 Nov 2025)

Arthur D. Yaghjian · 2025

Read Reply to “Comment on ‘Absence of a consistent classical equation of motion for a mass-renormalized point charge’ ” (arXiv:2511.02865v1, 3 Nov 2025) by Arthur D. Yaghjian (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22936.txt.

Introduction

Arthur Yaghjian replies to a comment disputing his claim about the classical motion of a point electric charge. The background dispute concerns radiation reaction, the force a charge feels from its own emitted radiation, and whether a consistent causal equation exists after the charge's mass is renormalized. Critics Zin and Pylak objected to how the derivation handles abrupt changes in the applied force.

His answer retraces the derivation, which starts from the motion of an extended charged sphere and takes the sphere's radius to zero. Along the way, the modified equation produces a causal version of the Lorentz-Abraham-Dirac equation. He then addresses the objection directly. Velocity jumps across short intervals near points where the force is nonanalytic do not create delta-function spikes in the radiated fields, contrary to the critics' claim. The reply is short and defensive, aiming to leave the original conclusion standing.

Catalog record

CREATORArthur D. Yaghjian
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE12 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22936

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reply to “Comment on ‘Absence of a consistent classical equation of motion for a mass-renormalized point charge’ ” (arXiv:2511.02865v1, 3 Nov 2025) Arthur D. Yaghjian Abstract By means of a brief review of the derivation of the causal modified Lorentz-Abraham-Dirac classical equation of motion from the renormalization of the mass in the modified equation of motion of an extended charged sphere as its radius approaches zero, it is shown that Zin and Pylak’s objection that the jumps in velocity allowed across transition intervals near nonanalytic points in time of the externally applied force produce delta functions in the radiated fields is incorrect. I Introduction In the paper [ 1 ] and book [ 2 ] , the equation of motion of the classical model of a relativistically rigid surface-charged spherical insulator of radius a and total charge e is derived from Maxwell’s equations, the relativistic generalization of Newton’s second law of motion, and Einstein’s mass-energy relation. The derivation takes into account that the Lorentz power-series for the electromagnetic self-force is not valid for the time durations \varDelta t_{a}=O(a/c) just after nonanalytic points in time of the external force on the charged sphere, such as when it is first applied and terminated. These transition time intervals are approximately equal to the time 2a/c that it takes light to traverse the diameter of the rest-frame sphere (with c the free-space speed of light). Although the fields and self-force cannot be evaluated in detail during these transition time intervals because the precise equation of motion is unknown during the transition intervals, there are transition forces during (and only during) the transition intervals that maintain causality of the resulting equation of motion, even as the radius a of the charged sphere approaches zero and the mass m is renormalized to a finite value. In their recent comment on this work [ 3 ] , Zyn and Pylak claim that the jumps in velocity across the transition intervals allowed by the mass-renormalized equation of motion of the point charge ( a\to 0 ) [ 1 ] , [ 2 ] modified by the transition forces imply from Maxwell’s equations an unphysical infinite radiated energy. Although this modified mass-renormalized Lorentz-Abraham-Dirac (LAD) equation of motion predicts a finite radiated energy, and the objection of Zyn and Pylak was addressed in [ 2 , footnote 8, ch. 8 ] (footnote 7 of the 2nd edition), it will be explained here in more detail that the textbook formula for the radiated energy of a point charge is not applicable to an extended charge as a\to 0 and the mass is renormalized. First, some other mistaken statements in the comments of Zin and Pylak will be addressed. They say that “These [transition] intervals occur when the external force is nonzero only on some part of the charged sphere.” This is not quite correct. As explained in [ 2 , see, for example, p. 2] , the charged sphere is assumed to be held fixed in an external electromagnetic field when it is released instantaneously at a time t=t_{1} . The external force is assumed to be an analytic function of time tor t>t_{1} until it is terminated instantaneously across the entire sphere at t=t_{2} . The two transition intervals have durations \varDelta t_{a}\approx 2a/c just after t_{1} and t_{2} (in the instantaneous rest frames at t_{1} and t_{2} ). Also, equation (1) of Zyn and Pylak, taken from equation (8.83) of the second edition of my book, applies only to evaluating the total energy radiated during both transition intervals, not the energy radiated during each transition interval. Because of its limited application, this equation was omitted in the third edition of the book [ 2 ] . II Response to Primary Objection Zyn and Pylak claim that the energy radiated W_{\mathrm{TI},n} during the n th transition interval obtained from the modified LAD rectilinear equation of motion for the mass-renormalized charge as a\to 0 , namely [ 2 , eq.(8.84)] \frac{W_{\mathrm{TI},n}}{mc^{2}}=\frac{1}{mc^{2}}\int\limits_{t_{n}}^{t_{n}^{+}=t_{n}+\varDelta t_{a\to 0}}\left(\frac{e^{2}}{6\pi\epsilon_{0}c^{3}}\gamma^{6}\dot{u}^{2}-f_{an}u\right){\rm d}t=\tau_{e}[\gamma(t_{n}^{+})\dot{\gamma}(t_{n}^{+})-\gamma(t_{n})\dot{\gamma}(t_{n})]-[\gamma(t_{n}^{+})-\gamma(t_{n})] (1) where u(t) is the center velocity of the sphere witn \gamma=(1-u^{2}/c^{2})^{-\frac{1}{2}} , \tau_{e}=e^{2}/(6\pi\epsilon_{0}mc^{3}) , and \epsilon_{0} is the free-space permittivity, is not valid because the integral of just the \dot{u}^{2} term (without the transition-force term f_{an}u ) is the textbook point-charge Maxwellian radiated energy. Moreover, this textbook point-charge radiated energy is infinite for transition intervals with abrupt jumps in velocity (giving delta functions in acceleration). As will be explained in detail, the ad hoc (not derived from fundamental equations) renormalization, which allows these jumps in velocity, also violates Maxwell’s equations during the transition intervals but not outside the transition intervals, so that the modified LAD equation of motion gives the correct finite radiated energy in the last equality of ( 1 ) from the integral in ( 1 ). Without renormalization, the mass of the charged sphere approaches an infinite value as a\to 0 and both the jump in velocity and radiated energy across a transition interval approach zero. It is not surprising that the energy radiated during a transition interval in ( 1 ) involves f_{an}u because [ 2 , eq. (8.41)] shows that f_{an} depends on both the external force F_{\rm ext} and the acceleration \dot{u} in the transition interval. Moreover, in order to keep the same \dot{u}^{2} term on the right-hand side of the modified LAD rectilinear power equation of motion [ 2 , eq. (8.80b)] \frac{[F_{\mathrm{ext}}(t)+f_{a}(t)]u}{mc^{2}}=\frac{{\rm d}\gamma}{{\rm d}t}-\tau_{e}\left[\frac{{\rm d}}{{\rm d}t}\left(\gamma\frac{{\rm d}\gamma}{{\rm d}t}\right)-\frac{\gamma^{6}}{c^{2}}\dot{u}^{2}\right],\;\;\;f_{a}(t)=\sum_{n=1}^{N}f_{an}(t) (2) during a transition interval where the power series used to derive the right-hand side of ( 2 ) is not valid, there has to be an effective transition force f_{a}(t) that does work on the charged sphere during the transition intervals and adds a contribution to the \dot{u}^{2} power term radiated during the transition intervals. If the mass is not renormalized as a\to 0 so that m=e^{2}/(8\pi\epsilon_{0}ac^{2})\to\infty as 1/a and \tau_{e}=4a/(3c)\to 0 as a , the velocity jump \varDelta u_{n} and thus the \dot{u}^{2} -term energy radiated across a transition interval as determined by the Liénard-Wiechert fields from the surface charge on the extended charged sphere can be shown to approach zero as a\to 0 . Similarly, the energy radiated by the f_{an}u term approaches zero as a\to 0 . However, if the mass is renormalized to a finite value m , the modified LAD equation of motion allows a nonzero jump in velocity \varDelta u_{n} across a limitingly short transition interval. Such a jump in velocity means that the acceleration will contain a delta function \varDelta u_{n}\delta(t) . A naive application of the textbook point-charge Liénard-Wiechert potentials [ 2 , sec. 2.1.8] then predicts a delta function in the radiated fields proportional to \dot{u}(t)=\varDelta u_{n}\delta(t) and infinite radiated energy [since e^{2}\varDelta u_{n}^{2}\int\delta^{2}(t)dt=\infty ]. However, if the far fields [ 2 , eqs. (5.34)-(5.35)] are evaluated for an extended charge of nonzero radius a with \dot{u}(t)=\varDelta u_{n}\delta(t) of infinitesimal duration in time, the far fields extend over a time duration equal to 2a/c with a finite magnitude proportional to 1/(2a/c) so that the total energy radiated during the transition interval is proportional to 1/(2a/c) and not \int\delta^{2}(t)dt=\infty ; this result was first obtained by Paul Hertz (Abraham’s student) [ 4 ] and Abraham [ 5 , sec. 25] as

Read the complete text