Gauge Symmetry in Quantum Simulation

Masanori Hanada a, Shunji Matsuura b, Andreas Schäfer c, Jinzhao Sun d · 2025

Read Gauge Symmetry in Quantum Simulation by Masanori Hanada a, Shunji Matsuura b, Andreas Schäfer c, Jinzhao Sun d (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22932.txt.

Introduction

Masanori Hanada, Shunji Matsuura, Andreas Schafer, and Jinzhao Sun lay out universal rules for handling gauge symmetry when simulating gauge theories on quantum computers. Gauge theories, the framework behind the strong nuclear force, contain redundant descriptions of the same physics. A simulation must decide how to treat that redundancy. A common belief says physical states must be gauge singlets; the authors show non-singlet representations are equally valid, with different trade-offs.

The principles are shown inside a simulation framework based on the orbifold lattice, producing explicit circuits aimed at quantum chromodynamics. For singlet approaches they give a projection built from Haar averaging with cost and error analysis, plus a Hamiltonian trick that pushes non-singlet states out of the low-energy spectrum. Non-singlet approaches extract gauge-invariant observables from wave packets and excitations. Small classical simulations check errors and yield resource estimates for SU(N) theories.

Catalog record

CREATORMasanori Hanada a, Shunji Matsuura b, Andreas Schäfer c, Jinzhao Sun d
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE110 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22932

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Gauge Symmetry in Quantum Simulation Masanori Hanada a, Shunji Matsuura b, Andreas Schäfer c, Jinzhao Sun d Abstract Quantum simulation of non-Abelian gauge theories requires careful handling of gauge redundancy. We address this challenge by presenting universal principles for treating gauge symmetry that apply to any quantum simulation approach, clarifying that physical states need not be represented solely by gauge singlets. Both singlet and non-singlet representations are valid, with distinct practical trade-offs, which we elucidate using analogies to BRST quantization. We demonstrate these principles within a complete quantum simulation framework based on the orbifold lattice, which enables explicit and efficient circuit constructions relevant to real-world QCD. For singlet-based approaches, we introduce a Haar-averaging projection implemented via linear combinations of unitaries, and analyze its cost and truncation errors. Beyond the singlet-approach, we show how non-singlet approaches can yield gauge-invariant observables through wave packets and string excitations. This non-singlet approach is proven to be both universal and efficient. Working in temporal gauge, we provide explicit mappings of lattice Yang–Mills dynamics to Pauli-string Hamiltonians suitable for Trotterization. Classical simulations of small systems validate convergence criteria and quantify truncation and Trotter errors, showing concrete resource estimates and scalable circuit recipes for SU ( N ) (N) gauge theories. Our framework provides both conceptual clarity and practical tools toward quantum advantage in simulating non-Abelian gauge theories. I Introduction Gauge symmetry is a fundamental feature of many physical theories, including electromagnetism, Yang–Mills theory Yang and Mills 1954 ; Peskin and Schroeder 1995 ; Weinberg 2013 , and Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) Han and Nambu 1965 ; Fritzsch et al. 1973 ; Gross and Wilczek 1973 ; Politzer 1973 , and more broadly, the standard model of particle physics Glashow 1961 ; Weinberg 1967 ; Salam 1968 ; ’t Hooft 1971 ; ’t Hooft and Veltman 1972 . They also lie at the core of the most concrete approaches to quantum gravity through dualities between supersymmetric Yang-Mills theories and string/M-theory Maldacena 1998 . Less widely appreciated is that permutation symmetry in systems of identical bosons Bose 1924 ; Einstein 1924 functions as a gauge symmetry with physical consequences — the Bose-Einstein condensation Einstein 1925 ; Feynman 1953 . Any faithful quantum simulation of such systems must confront the role of gauge symmetry at a fundamental level. While it is often stated that physical states must be gauge-invariant 1 1 1 The origin of this widespread misconception is not clear. The claim that physical states must be gauge-invariant is often attributed to Kogut and Susskind Kogut and Susskind 1975 , but their actual statement was “The physical states are drawn from the space of gauge-invariant states” , which describes a particular choice of basis convenient for their Hamiltonian lattice formulation. The physical content resides in gauge-equivalence classes; gauge-invariant representatives are one valid choice among many. In the past, non-singlet descriptions played crucial roles in the understanding of confinement in the large- N gauge theories Hanada et al. 2021 and emergent geometry in string theory Hanada 2021 ; Gautam et al. 2025 . See also refs. Gautam et al. 2023 ; Fliss et al. 2025 that emphasized the difference between physical and gauge-invariant . , this statement obscures an important distinction between physical equivalence and representation: gauge symmetry — or rather, gauge redundancy — identifies physically equivalent configurations, but does not uniquely prescribe how those configurations should be represented in a quantum simulation. As a result, different representations of physical states — gauge singlet and non-singlet alike — can be equally valid, provided they encode the same equivalence class and reproduce gauge-invariant observables. Recent work established quantum circuit constructions for Yang-Mills theory using extended Hilbert space and non-compact variables Buser et al. 2021 ; Bergner et al. 2024 ; Halimeh, Jad C. and Hanada, Masanori and Matsuura, Shunji and Nori, Franco and Rinaldi, Enrico and Schäfer, Andreas 2024 ; Bergner and Hanada 2025 , in such a way that the generalization to QCD is straightforward Halimeh et al. 2025 . However, crucial questions regarding the treatment of gauge redundancy remained: how to implement gauge-singlet constraints (when necessary), and when to use singlet or non-singlet formulations. Furthermore, it was not very clear how to validate convergence criteria concerning the truncation of the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space associated with bosons. We address these by: (1) introducing the first singlet projection protocol for SU( N ) gauge theory via Haar averaging realized through Linear Combination of Unitaries, (2) establishing universal principles for gauge symmetry treatment applicable to any quantum simulation approach, and (3) providing systematic numerical validation and complete resource estimates. Our framework completes the quantum simulation toolkit for non-Abelian gauge theories, providing both conceptual clarity and practical implementation protocols with validated scalings. Yang-Mills theory is a natural generalization of electromagnetism, which is a gauge theory with the U(1) gauge group, to the SU( N ) gauge group. As in electromagnetism, gauge symmetry plays a crucial role in the quantization of the relativistic theory without negative-norm modes in the Hilbert space. To see this, imagine creation operators \hat{a}^{\dagger}_{\mu} corresponding to the U(1) gauge field A_{\mu} , where \mu=0,1,2,3,4=t,x,y,z , act on the Lorentz-invariant vacuum \ket{\rm VAC} . Then, the natural inner product that is consistent with the Lorentz symmetry is \bra{\rm VAC}\hat{a}_{\mu}\hat{a}^{\dagger}_{\nu}\ket{\rm VAC}=\eta_{\mu\nu} , where \eta_{\mu\nu}=(-1)^{\delta_{\mu,0}}\delta_{\mu\nu} . This seems to be a problem because \hat{a}^{\dagger}_{\mu}\ket{\rm VAC} has a negative norm (specifically, the norm is -1 for \mu=0 ), which could conflict with the probability interpretation of quantum mechanics. Gauge symmetry cures this problem because only the transverse modes are physical, and negative-norm modes decouple from physical processes. The temporal gauge ( A_{t}=0 gauge; see Supplementary Material ) is convenient for quantum simulations, because the negative-norm modes are absent; if the Hilbert space contains negative-norm states, it is unclear how to map it to qubits. Some caution is required because this gauge condition does not remove gauge redundancy completely. A common option is to restrict the Hilbert space to be invariant under the residual gauge symmetry; we call such a Hilbert space the gauge-invariant Hilbert space, or the singlet Hilbert space, and denote it by \mathcal{H}_{\rm inv} . This is a subspace of the extended Hilbert space \mathcal{H}_{\rm ext} that contains both gauge singlets and non-singlets. This singlet-prescription is, however, not straightforward. If one tries to construct only \mathcal{H}_{\rm inv} on quantum devices, it is difficult to build orthonormal basis, and the operators including the Hamiltonian become complicated. This leads to exponential growth in classical pre-processing cost, and possibly also in the circuit depth, with respect to the number of logical qubits, which destroys any potential quantum advantage Hanada et al. 2025 . Therefore, we will use \mathcal{H}_{\rm ext} for quantum simulations. Still, \mathcal{H}_{\rm inv} is realized as a subspace of \mathcal{H}_{\rm ext} , and one has the option to use only states in \mathcal{H}_{\rm inv} . As established in refs. Bergner et al. 2024 ; Halimeh, Jad C. and Hanada, Masanori and Matsuura, Shunji and Nori, Franco and Rinaldi, Enrico and Schäfer, Andreas 2024 ; Bergner and Hanada 2025 ; Halimeh et al. 2025 , the orbifold lattice framework provides explicit quantum circuit construction for SU( N ) gauge theories with polynomial resource scaling, both on quantum devices (the number of gates and circuit

Read the complete text