An asymmetric and fast Rydberg gate protocol for long range entanglement

Daniel C. Cole, Vikas Buchemmavari, Mark Saffman · 2025

Read An asymmetric and fast Rydberg gate protocol for long range entanglement by Daniel C. Cole, Vikas Buchemmavari, Mark Saffman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22767.txt.

Introduction

Daniel Cole, Vikas Buchemmavari, and Mark Saffman redesign a classic Rydberg atom gate so it works well outside the strong blockade regime. Rydberg gates use highly excited atoms to entangle qubits, and the original pi-2pi-pi pulse sequence needed a strong interaction between atoms to reach high fidelity. The new design keeps that pulse structure but adds a detuning to the middle pulse on the target qubit.

With that change, the gate comes close to the best fidelity allowed by the finite lifetime of Rydberg states, for both equal and unequal driving strengths on the two qubits. The authors extend the scheme to arbitrary controlled phases and shape the target pulse for a range of interaction strengths. They also show the simple constant-phase version is fastest at fixed laser power, and add control tricks that keep the gate steady when experimental settings drift.

Catalog record

CREATORDaniel C. Cole, Vikas Buchemmavari, Mark Saffman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22767

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An asymmetric and fast Rydberg gate protocol for long range entanglement Daniel C. Cole, Vikas Buchemmavari, Mark Saffman Abstract We analyze a new Rydberg gate design based on the original π − 2 ​ π − π \pi-2\pi-\pi protocol [Jaksch, et. al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 , 2208 (2000)] that is modified to enable high fidelity operation without requiring a strong Rydberg interaction. The gate retains the π − 2 ​ π − π \pi-2\pi-\pi structure with an additional detuning added to the 2 ​ π 2\pi pulse on the target qubit. The protocol reaches within a factor of 2.39 (1.68) of the fundamental fidelity limit set by Rydberg lifetime for equal (asymmetric) Rabi frequencies on the control and target qubits. We generalize the gate protocol to arbitrary controlled phases. We design optimal target-qubit phase waveforms to generalize the gate across a range of interaction strengths and we find that, within this family of gates, the constant-phase protocol is time-optimal for a fixed laser Rabi frequency and tunable interaction strength. Robust control methods are used to design gates that are robust against variations in Rydberg Rabi frequency or interaction strength. I Introduction The strong interaction of Rydberg atoms provides a mechanism for entangling neutral atom qubits as was originally proposed in Ref. Jaksch et al. 2000 using a \pi-2\pi-\pi sequence of ground-Rydberg pulses. The original protocol was first demonstrated in Refs. Isenhower et al. 2010 ; Zhang et al. 2010 , but has since been supplanted by improved protocols that apply the same optical pulses symmetrically to both atoms Sun et al. 2020 ; Saffman et al. 2020 ; Levine et al. 2019 ; Robicheaux et al. 2021 ; Jandura and Pupillo 2022 ; Pagano et al. 2022 ; Mohan et al. 2023 . The symmetric protocols simplify optical control requirements and use of a time-optimal protocol has led to \sf CZ fidelities surpassing {\mathcal{F}}=0.993 with four different atomic species: Rb Evered et al. 2023 , Cs Radnaev et al. 2025 , Sr Tsai et al. 2025 , and Yb Peper et al. 2025 ; Muniz et al. 2025 ; Senoo et al. 2025 . While high fidelity is critical for quantum error correction, leveraging the long range nature of the Rydberg interaction is also of interest for implementing non-local error correcting codes Poole et al. 2025 ; Pecorari et al. 2025 . We present here a modified version of the \pi-2\pi-\pi gate that has the remarkable feature of having no coherent rotation error (that is, it achieves unity fidelity in the absence of dissipation and experimental imperfections), even in the partial blockade limit of interaction strength V comparable to Rydberg excitation rate \Omega . The ability to provide high fidelity for moderate V implies that the gate can be operated at large inter-atomic spacings. We proceed in Sec. II by briefly reviewing the original \pi-2\pi-\pi protocol shown in Fig. 1 and the associated gate fidelity analysis. In Sec. III we describe the new protocol, provide a simplified error analysis, and generalize the gate for arbitrary controlled phases. We generalize the protocol to different interaction strengths using optimal control in Sec. IV . An enhanced asymmetric protocol that uses phase-modulated pulses on the target qubit to achieve robustness against variations in Rabi frequency and interaction energy is analyzed in Sec. V . We conclude with a comparison of the new protocol relative to fundamental limits in Sec. VI . Figure 1: Protocol for a Rydberg \sf CZ gate. a) Atomic levels with qubits encoded in \ket{0},\ket{1} that are separated by \omega_{q} . State \ket{0} is coupled to \ket{r} with Rabi frequency \Omega . The Rydberg levels decay at rate 1/\tau and the two-atom interaction strength is V . b) A three pulse gate protocol is: 1) \pi pulse on control qubit, 2) 2\pi pulse on target, 3) \pi pulse on control. c) A modified gate protocol is the same as in a) and b) except that the 2\pi pulse on the target is detuned by \Delta . II \pi-2\pi-\pi Rydberg gate The original Rydberg \sf CZ gate protocol Jaksch et al. 2000 is based on a three pulse sequence. A \pi pulse is applied to the control qubit, a 2\pi pulse is applied to the target qubit, and a final \pi pulse is applied to the control qubit. Each pulse is resonant with the \ket{0}\leftrightarrow\ket{r} transition a a a We adopt this convention to simplify phase calculations. where the qubit basis is \ket{0},\ket{1} and \ket{r} is the Rydberg state. In the idealized limit of V,\omega_{q}\gg\Omega\gg 1/\tau where V is the two-atom interaction strength, \omega_{q} is the energy separation of \ket{0} and \ket{1} , \Omega is the ground-Rydberg Rabi frequency, and \tau is the Rydberg lifetime we obtain the mapping for control, target basis states \ket{ct} : \displaystyle\ket{00}\rightarrow-e^{-\imath\phi_{00}}\ket{00}, (1a) \displaystyle\ket{01}\rightarrow-e^{-\imath\phi_{01}}\ket{01}, (1b) \displaystyle\ket{10}\rightarrow-e^{-\imath\phi_{10}}\ket{10}, (1c) \displaystyle\ket{11}\rightarrow e^{-\imath\phi_{11}}\ket{11}. (1d) Here \phi_{00},\phi_{01},\phi_{10},\phi_{11} are dynamical phases from differential Stark shifts on the qubit states due to the Rydberg pulses and the minus signs on the first three states are geometrical phases from the trajectory with area 2\pi in the \{\ket{0},\ket{r}\} Hilbert space. When all three pulses use the same Rabi rate the dynamical phases can be expressed as \phi_{00}=2\phi_{0} , \phi_{01}=\phi_{10}=\phi_{0}+\phi_{1} , \phi_{11}=2\phi_{1} , with \phi_{0} , \phi_{1} the single atom Stark shifts on states \ket{0},\ket{1} during the gate. Applying a global phase rotation {\sf R}_{z}(\phi_{1}-\phi_{0})\otimes{\sf R}_{z}(\phi_{1}-\phi_{0}) and suppressing an irrelevant global phase we obtain the canonical \sf CZ gate: \displaystyle\ket{00}\rightarrow\ket{00}, (2a) \displaystyle\ket{01}\rightarrow\ket{01}, (2b) \displaystyle\ket{10}\rightarrow\ket{10}, (2c) \displaystyle\ket{11}\rightarrow-\ket{11}. (2d) In practice the ratios V/\Omega and \Omega/(1/\tau) are chosen to be large but finite, while \omega_{q}\gg V . This leads to the dominant error terms being those due to decay from the Rydberg state and incomplete blocking of the target atom rotation when the control atom is Rydberg excited. The errors are minimized by choosing the Rabi frequency to be \Omega_{\rm opt}=(7\pi)^{1/3}\left(V^{2}/\tau\right)^{1/3} which leads to a minimum gate error of Saffman et al. 2010 : \epsilon_{\pi-2\pi-\pi}=\frac{3(7\pi)^{2/3}}{8}\frac{1}{(V\tau)^{2/3}}. (3) Note that the minimum error scales as \epsilon_{\pi-2\pi-\pi}\sim(V\tau)^{-2/3} whereas the best possible scaling for an arbitrary gate protocol is \epsilon_{\rm DDP}=(1+\pi/2)/(V\tau)\simeq 2.57/(V\tau) Wesenberg et al. 2007 ; Doultsinos et al. 2025 . The highest fidelity that has been demonstrated with the \pi-2\pi-\pi gate is {\mathcal{F}}=1-\epsilon=0.89 Graham et al. 2019 . Detailed numerical analysis taking into account the finite spacing of Rydberg levels in Rb and Cs atoms Zhang et al. 2012 leads to an error floor in the absence of technical imperfections that is at best \epsilon\simeq 0.002. This can be improved on by using shaped pulses to suppress excitation of neighboring Rydberg states in which case errors as low as \epsilon<10^{-4} are theoretically achievable, albeit with the requirement of very fast Rydberg pulses and very strong interactions Theis et al. 2016 . III Asymmetric \pi-2\pi-\pi Rydberg gate The error scaling of the gate can be improved by detuning the pulse on the target atom by an amount \Delta=\omega-\omega_{r0} where \omega is the laser frequency and \omega_{r0} is the atomic ground-Rydberg frequency. With this detuning the \ket{10} state will return to the ground state provided t\sqrt{|\Omega|^{2}+\Delta^{2}}=2\pi (4) and the \ket{00} state will return to the ground state provided t\sqrt{|\Omega|^{2}+(\Delta-V)^{2}}=2\pi. (5) Here we assume \Delta and V are the same sign. In

Read the complete text