Probing higher curvature gravity via ringdown with overtones
Keisuke Nakashi, Masashi Kimura, Hayato Motohashi, Kazufumi Takahashi · 2025
Read Probing higher curvature gravity via ringdown with overtones by Keisuke Nakashi, Masashi Kimura, Hayato Motohashi, Kazufumi Takahashi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22728.txt.
Introduction
Keisuke Nakashi, Masashi Kimura, Hayato Motohashi, and Kazufumi Takahashi study how black holes vibrate after a disturbance when gravity includes higher curvature corrections beyond Einstein's theory. Their subject is the ringdown, the fading set of tones a black hole emits, described by quasinormal mode frequencies. Earlier work suggested such corrections might hide in the fundamental tone, so the authors focus on the higher overtones instead.
Calculations for a round, non-spinning black hole show that the corrections reshape the effective potential near the horizon, and the overtone frequencies shift far more than the fundamental one. As the order of the correction grows, the shifts grow too. Fitted ringdown waveforms confirm the shifted tones can still be picked out of the signal, giving observers a sharper test of gravity.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Keisuke Nakashi, Masashi Kimura, Hayato Motohashi, Kazufumi Takahashi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 54 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22728
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Probing higher curvature gravity via ringdown with overtones Preprint: RUP-25-27 Keisuke Nakashi, Masashi Kimura, Hayato Motohashi, Kazufumi Takahashi Abstract We investigate metric perturbations of a spherically symmetric black hole in higher curvature gravity. We show that higher curvature corrections deform the near-horizon region of the effective potential, and that the deviations of the quasinormal mode (QNM) frequencies from their general relativity (GR) values become more pronounced for overtone modes. We find that, as the order of the higher curvature term increases, the deformations approach the horizon and the deviations of the overtone QNM frequencies grow progressively larger. We also analyze the ringdown waveforms in the higher curvature gravity model. We consider setups in which the deviations from the vacuum-GR QNMs remain mild for the fundamental mode and the first few overtones, and show that these shifted QNMs can be identified in the ringdown signal through waveform fitting. I Introduction Since the detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from binary black hole coalescences LIGOScientific:2016aoc ; LIGOScientific:2018mvr ; LIGOScientific:2020ibl ; LIGOScientific:2021usb ; KAGRA:2021vkt ; LIGOScientific:2025slb , we have been able to test general relativity (GR) in the regime where spacetime is extremely curved and dynamical Barack:2018yly ; LIGOScientific:2021sio ; Berti:2025hly . Such a development provides us with an opportunity to explore possible signatures of new physics. There are several motivations for considering gravitational theories that extend GR. One such motivation is the incompleteness of GR in the ultraviolet regime, and hence the development of theories that modify GR in the high-energy regime has been pursued so far (see Ref. Berti:2015itd and references therein for example). One natural possibility for such modifications in the high-energy regime is to incorporate higher derivative corrections into the Einstein-Hilbert action. For instance, string theory predicts that an infinite series of higher curvature correction terms are added to the Einstein-Hilbert action Gross:1986mw ; Gross:1986iv . Such correction terms are also motivated from the perspective of effective field theory (EFT), which is itself suggested by more fundamental physics. Furthermore, exploring which type of EFTs can be tested through GW observations is of significant importance, as it provides valuable feedback to fundamental physics. Given the wide range of possible extensions of GR, it is common to impose physically motivated assumptions such as the following: the contributions from modifications to GR are characterized by an energy scale higher than the curvature scale around the compact object emitting GWs, and the contributions from higher curvature terms are assumed to be sufficiently small to be treated perturbatively. Furthermore, we assume that such EFTs should be testable through GW observations, be consistent with other experiments and observations, including short distance tests of GR, and not involve new light degrees of freedom. *1 *1 *1 For EFTs that include additional light degree(s) of freedom, see extensive studies in the context of scalar-tensor gravity Arkani-Hamed:2003pdi ; Arkani-Hamed:2003juy ; Cheung:2007st ; Gubitosi:2012hu ; Franciolini:2018uyq ; Mukohyama:2022enj ; Mukohyama:2025jzk and vector-tensor gravity Cheng:2006us ; Mukohyama:2006mm ; Aoki:2021wew ; Aoki:2023bmz . The Lagrangian of the EFT obeying these assumptions has been constructed in Ref. Endlich:2017tqa , and its effects on black hole spacetimes have also been investigated Cardoso:2018ptl ; Cano:2019ore . The GWs emitted immediately after the binary black hole merger, the so-called ringdown, are well suited for testing GR in the strong and dynamical regime of gravitational fields Berti:2025hly . In GR, it is well known that the ringdown can be well described by the quasinormal modes (QNMs) of the black hole Buonanno:2006ui , which can be predicted using black hole perturbation theory Leaver:1985ax ; Leaver:1986gd . According to the black hole uniqueness theorem in GR, the Kerr black hole is the unique stationary and asymptotically flat vacuum solution, and its mass and angular momentum completely determine the QNM frequencies. It is expected that testing gravity theories using the ringdown phase of GWs allows us to detect beyond GR effects. The actual observational data of GWs are consistent with the fundamental mode of QNMs predicted in GR LIGOScientific:2021sio . Meanwhile, it has been pointed out that including overtones in the fitting model is important for improving the agreement with the numerical waveform and extracting the information of the remnant black hole parameters Baibhav:2017jhs ; Bhagwat:2019dtm ; Giesler:2019uxc ; Cook:2020otn ; Forteza:2021wfq ; Baibhav:2023clw ; Nee:2023osy ; Takahashi:2023tkb . There has been active debate on whether overtone information can be reliably extracted from GW observations. Some analyses claim that the observational data contain evidence of the overtone contributions Isi:2019aib ; Isi:2022mhy ; Finch:2022ynt ; LIGOScientific:2025obp ; LIGOScientific:2025rid , whereas others argue that such signals remain buried in the noise and cannot be robustly identified Cotesta:2022pci ; Carullo:2023gtf . The verification of gravity theories using overtones is anticipated to become increasingly important as the sensitivity of future GW detectors improves. In EFTs with higher curvature corrections, modifications to GR introduce corrections to the QNM frequencies. By comparing the QNM frequencies with the ringdown waveform, it becomes possible to explore the validity of GR and which EFTs are justified. Driven by this motivation, numerous studies have been conducted to calculate the corrections to the QNM frequencies of black holes in EFTs, focusing on both static spherically symmetric black holes Cardoso:2018ptl ; deRham:2020ejn ; Hirano:2024fgp ; Cardoso:2019mqo ; Silva:2024ffz and rotating black holes Cano:2020cao ; Cano:2021myl ; Cano:2023tmv ; Cano:2023jbk ; Cano:2024ezp ; Maenaut:2024oci . Furthermore, there are some attempts to obtain constraints on EFTs from the observational GW data Silva:2022srr ; Liu:2024atc . Complementary to such a theory-specific approach, one can directly parametrize the deformation of the effective potential in the GR master equation for GWs and examine how it affects the QNMs. This approach, known as the parametrized QNM formalism Cardoso:2018ptl ; Hirano:2024fgp , allows for model-independent predictions of QNM frequencies Volkel:2022aca ; Volkel:2022khh ; Franchini:2022axs . In the present paper, we investigate how higher curvature corrections affect the QNMs and their imprint on the ringdown waveform. We focus on a class of higher curvature gravity theories that admit the Schwarzschild spacetime as a background solution while modifying the dynamics of perturbations. The higher curvature terms deform the effective potential in the near-horizon region, and the deformation approaches the horizon as the order of the higher curvature terms becomes larger. Using the parametrized QNM formalism, we first compute the frequency shifts of QNMs induced by the higher curvature corrections. In particular, we demonstrate that the overtone frequencies tend to deviate more strongly from their GR values as the deformation approaches the horizon, while the fundamental mode is less affected as reported in Ref. Konoplya:2022pbc . Although the results are valid only to linear order in the deviation from GR, this behavior suggests a close connection between the higher curvature corrections and the overtone outbursts, a phenomenon known in the context of spectral instability Barausse:2014tra ; Jaramillo:2020tuu ; Jaramillo:2021tmt ; Cheung:2021bol . To assess whether these QNM deviations manifest in observable signals, we compute time-domain waveforms by solving the master equation. The authors of Refs. Thomopoulos:2025nuf ; deMedeiros:2025ayq computed time-domain waveforms assuming a small deviation from the Regge-Wheeler equation in GR, using parametrized potentials that contain a single power-law correction of the form (r_{\rm H}/r)^{j} , with r_{\rm H} the horizon radius of the background black hole, and focused on relatively small