Tiling Triangles With 2 ​ π / 3 2\pi/3 Angles

Yan X Zhang · 2025

Read Tiling Triangles With 2 ​ π / 3 2\pi/3 Angles by Yan X Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22696.txt.

Introduction

Yan X Zhang asks which triangles can be perfectly tiled by congruent copies of another triangle. The question descends from Erdős, with later inquiries by Beeson and Laczkovich. When the big triangle is similar to the small one, or when all angles are rational multiples of pi, the possible counts are understood. Zhang attacks the most interesting leftover case: the small triangle contains a two-thirds-pi angle, and the big one is one of six sporadic specific triangles.

Only two of those six sporadic triangles earlier had any tiling constructions. For each of them, Zhang creates a whole family of constructions producing various copy counts. He conjectures that these families exhaust every count that can occur for these triangles.

Catalog record

CREATORYan X Zhang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE6 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22696

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tiling Triangles With 2 ​ π / 3 2\pi/3 Angles
Yan X Zhang

Abstract
Motivated by a question of Erdös and inquiries by Beeson and Laczkovich, we explore the possible N N for which a triangle T T can tile into N N congruent copies of a triangle R R . The reptile cases (where T T is similar to R R ) and the commensurable-angles cases (where all angles of R R are rational multiples of π \pi ) are well-understood. We tackle the most interesting remaining case, which is when R R contains an angle of 2 ​ π / 3 2\pi/3 and when T T is one of 6 6 “sporadic” specific triangles, of which only 2 2 were known to have constructions. For each of these, we create a family of constructions and conjecture that they are the only possible N N that occur for these triangles.



1
Introduction

We say that a polygon
T

tiles into
(
N
copies of) polygon
R
if
T
is a disjoint union of congruent copies of
R
, in which case we call
R
the
tile
. Our motivating problem is

For which triples
(N,T,R)
does a triangle
T
tile into
N
copies of a triangle
R
?

This problem has been extensively studied by Beeson (
[
beeson-seven
]
,
[
beeson-equilateral
]
,
[
beeson-isosceles
]
,
[
beeson-triangletiling3
]
); there is also a significant overlap with Laczkovich’s program of understanding tilings of triangles
T
into triangles
similar
to some
R
. Furthermore, this problem is a higher-resolution version of an open ($25) Erdös problem
[
soifer2009
]
:

For which
N
does there exist a tiling of some triangle
T
into some triangle
R
?

Two well-studied special cases of our problems are:

1.

The problem is completely understood for the case of
reptiling

[
golomb1964replicating
]
(when
T
and
R
are similar). In this case the families
N=k^{2}
(for all triangles) and
h^{2}+k^{2}
(for right triangles) appear.

2.

The problem is well-understood if the tile
R
has
commensurable angles
1
1

1

This notion is due to Laczkovich
[
laczkovich1995tilings
]
, who gives a finite classification for the generalization where the tiles only need to be similar instead of congruent.
, meaning when all the angles of the tile are rational multiples of
\pi
. See e.g.
[
beeson-seven
]
for what tilings arise; a few extra families of potential values of
N
(specifically,
N=3k^{2}
and
6k^{2}
) appear involving specific triangles.

For the rest of our paper, we assume that we have
incommensurable angles
(that is, we do not have commensurable angles). The remaining cases take a finite number of forms (see
[
beeson-seven
]
), each obeying some linear equation involving
\pi
. For each of these, the angles of the tiled triangle are also constrained. See Figure
1
for a list.

Figure 1:
A List of the possible incommensurable-angles cases, where
ABC
is the triangle being tiled. This table is taken (with permission) from Beeson
[
beeson-seven
]
, though it contains the same content as Theorem 4.1 of
[
laczkovich1995tilings
]
.

Very little is known in general about the incommensurable angles cases:

1.

Herdt (communicated through works of Beeson) has some specific constructions for the equilateral and isosceles triangles; they contain the least known
N
for those cases with
R
having an angle of
2\pi/3
.

2.

Beeson proved that no prime
N
is possible in many of the cases (see
[
beeson-seven
]
,
[
beeson-equilateral
]
,
[
beeson-isosceles
]
,
[
beeson-triangletiling3
]
), sometimes ruling out bigger families of
N
such as squarefree numbers. For the case when one of the angles of
R
is
2\pi/3
and
T
is isosceles, Beeson
[
beeson-isosceles
]
gives a lower bound of
2736
for potential
N
.

3.

Laczkovich
[
laczkovich2020rational
]
related possible
N
for equilateral triangles to rationality of points on an elliptic curve.

In our work, we focus on the
\gamma=2\pi/3
case, which appears the most frequently (
6
times) as subcases of Figure
1
, and the closely related
\pi/3
case. Our main contribution is proving the existence of
N
for a large family of tilings for the incommensurable angles cases involving
2\pi/3
. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first known construction for
4
of those
6
cases. We also conjecture that this construction solves the question of what
(N,T,R)
are possible (when
R
satisfies our conditions) for sufficiently big
N
; we prove our conjecture under certain assumptions for
T
being an equilateral triangle.

In Section
2
we give preliminary knowledge and assumptions, including our main tool
ideal trapezoids
. In Section
we give our main construction and result in Theorem
. In Section
we show how our construction can be used to produce families of tilings for all the incommensurable-angles cases is Figure
1
. We end with some remarks in Section
.

2
Preliminaries

For this paper, unless specified, we assume the tile
R
is a triangle with side lengths
(a,b,c)
and corresponding angles
(\alpha,\beta,\gamma)
. Except for one subsection (where we extend our techniques to the
\gamma=\pi/3
case), we will assume
\gamma=2\pi/3.

2.1
Integrality Assumptions

If the pairwise ratios of
(a,b,c)
are all rational, we say that the tile has
commensurable sides
(this is sometimes just called
commensurable
in the literature, but we emphasize ”side” to avoid confusion with angles). A tile with commensurable sides can be scaled to be integers (in fact, pairwise prime), turning the
c^{2}=a^{2}+b^{2}+ab
(by the law of cosines) relationship into a diophantine equation.
For the rest of this paper, we assume that
(a,b,c)
are all integers.

This seems to be a very strong restriction, but it seems closer to necessary than sufficient. For example, for
T
an equilateral triangle, techniques in
[
laczkovich2012tilings
]
show that the tile must either have commensurable angles or have
\{\sin(\alpha),\sin(\beta),\sin(\gamma)\}
be rational multiples of each other, which is equivalent to our assumption (by noting that
a:b:c
take rational values by the Law of sines). For
T
an isosceles triangle,
[
beeson-isosceles
]
proves that a tile such as ours (with
\gamma=2\pi/3
) must either have commensurable angles or commensurable sides.

2.2
Ideal Trapezoids

We say that trapezoid
ABCD
is
ideal
if
AB
is parallel to
CD
and
DAB=ABC=\pi/3
. In such a trapezoid, we use
x(ABCD)
to denote the length of the shorter parallel side
|CD|
and
y(ABCD)
to denote the longer
|AB|
, and we abbreviate them as simply
x
and
y
when the context is clear. We first explore which trapezoids are tileable by
(a,b,c)
.

Lemma 1
.

Let
ABCD
be an ideal trapezoid. Then if
x=a^{2}+b^{2}
and
y=ab
,
ABCD
can be tiled by
(a,b,c)
.

A
B
C
D
E
a^{2}
b^{2}

Read the complete text