The species scale and the refined TCC bound in time-dependent backgrounds of string theory

Ahmad. Moradpouri · 2025

Read The species scale and the refined TCC bound in time-dependent backgrounds of string theory by Ahmad. Moradpouri (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22694.txt.

Introduction

Ahmad Moradpouri explores a sharpened version of a conjecture about how long an expanding universe like ours can last. The starting point is the species scale, the energy where quantum corrections to Einstein's gravity become significant, often the string scale, far below the Planck scale at weak coupling. Moradpouri studies a refined Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture tied to that scale, asking whether stringy modes can stay stringy and never cross the Hubble horizon.

The refined conjecture predicts a shorter lifetime for de Sitter spacetime and bounds the cosmological constant. Evidence is assembled from cosmological solutions across different compactifications of various string theories. Moradpouri also argues both versions of the conjecture clash with a big-bang singularity, so if they hold, the singularity must go, as in string gas cosmology.

Catalog record

CREATORAhmad. Moradpouri
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE49 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22694

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The species scale and the refined TCC bound in time-dependent backgrounds of string theory Ahmad. Moradpouri Abstract The species scale is the energy scale at which quantum corrections to Einstein’s theory of gravity become significant. In many cases, this scale corresponds to the string mass scale, which can be much lower than the Planck scale in the weak coupling limit. In this note, we explore a variant of the TCC conjecture, which we refer to as the refined TCC. This version is related to the species scale as a new cutoff in quantum gravity, and we study whether stringy modes remain stringy and never exceed the Hubble horizon. The refined TCC predicts a shorter lifetime for de-Sitter spacetime and imposes a bound on the cosmological constant. We present supporting evidence for the refined TCC from cosmological solutions of different compactifications of various string theories. Furthermore, it is argued that both the TCC and the refined TCC are incompatible with the big-bang singularity. Therefore, if the TCC and the refined TCC hold, the big bang singularity must be ruled out. In scenarios such as string gas cosmology, where the TCC is realized, the spacetime background remains completely regular. 1 Introduction String theory is currently the leading candidate for explaining the principles of quantum gravity. However, from a phenomenological standpoint, its biggest challenge lies in providing concrete, testable predictions. The Swampland program aims to address this by proposing conjectures that are believed to be satisfied by all consistent effective field theories when coupled with gravity 29 ; 38 ; 1 . These conjectures impose nontrivial constraints on cosmological and particle physics models which have many consequences from early universe, dark energy and dark matter to phenomenological particle physics 28 ; 25 ; 6 ; 16 ; 37 ; 26 ; 22 ; 18 ; 24 ; 4 ; 17 . The conventional energy scale at which quantum corrections to Einstein’s theory of gravity are expected to become significant is the Planck mass scale. However, as is argued in 12 ; 14 ; 13 ; 11 , the species scale, \Lambda_{s} , introduces a lower cutoff in presence of large number of light particles. Based on the recent investigations 39 ; 41 ; 40 , it is suggested that the species scales must be identified by a scale where the higher derivative corrections to the Einstein gravity should be accounted. On the other hand, the emergent string conjecture 23 , characterizes the nature of the tower of the light particles which are connected to the species scale. Therefore, in the infinite distance of the moduli space of the theory, either we have a decompactify phase or a weakly coupled string theory. Then the species scale corresponds to the higher dimensional Planck mass or the string mass scale. It is interesting to explore how the species scale affects other conjectures in the swampland program. The trans-Planckian conjecture 6 is one of the key cosmological conjectures, placing bounds on the rate of the universe’s expansion scale factor. More precisely, it states the following: \displaystyle\frac{a_{f}}{a_{i}}l_{P}<\frac{1}{H_{f}}, (1) It states that sub-Planckian modes should remain quantum and never exceed the size of the Hubble horizon. Under time reversal, the Trans-Planckian Censorship Conjecture (TCC) applies to contracting universes, taking the following form: \displaystyle\frac{a_{f}}{a_{i}}(-\frac{1}{H_{i}})>l_{P} (2) The contracting case can be interpreted through the lens of the "no big bang singularity" conjecture. For a given initial Hubble horizon -\frac{1}{H_{i}} , if the theory predicts a singularity, the final scale factor approaches zero, a_{f}\to 0 , violating the TCC inequality. Thus, the TCC suggests that the contracting phase of the universe cannot lead to a singularity. Even at the classical level, the singularity theorems (such as 30 ; 20 ; 19 ; 7 and for more examples see 34 ; 36 and 35 for a review) indicate that general relativity is incomplete, necessitating a more fundamental theory to resolve this issue. As the species scale is the true scale that the quantum corrections to the classical theory has to be considered and in principle can be much smaller than the Planck scale, it is interesting to see how TCC behave under the new cutoff of the theory. The relation between the species scale and the TCC conjecture is explored in 5 , however the analysis in not exactly based on the exact solutions of the string theroy backgrounds. In this paper, we analyze different string theory compactifications and focus on the cosmological solutions of the theory. The main result of this paper is validity of the TCC under considering the new cutoff of the theory. As a result, the refined TCC is as follows: Stringy or higher dimensional quantum modes should remain stringy or quantum Organization of the paper is as follows: in Section 2 , we focus on the immediate consequences of the refined TCC, which imposes distinct bound on the Hubble scale H and investigates how this bound constrain the cosmological constant \Lambda . We argue that if we live in a universe with weakly coupled strings, the cosmological constant cannot be too large. Furthermore, we discuss how the TCC and its variants, in some sense, imply the no-singularity conjecture, suggesting that the effective spacetime metric must remain regular for all times. Sections 3 explore various compactifications of string theories, where the dilaton is the only modulus. We demonstrate that cosmological solutions in these settings satisfy the refined TCC. In Section 4 , we extend these results to compactifications with two modulus: the dilaton field and the overall volume of the compactifying manifold. In these cases, the refined TCC is also satisfied. Finally, in Section 5 , we further analyze the problem from the perspective of string thermodynamics, where the string length plays the role of the species scale. This analysis suggests that the ultimate temperature is set by the string mass scale, indicating that the string scale is the fundamental scale that must be taken into account. 2 The refined TCC The essence of the TCC is that quantum fluctuations must remain quantum in order to maintain consistency with the classical picture of spacetime as a Riemannian geometry at larger scales. Following this line of reasoning, string theory introduces additional scales where Riemannian geometry ceases to be the appropriate framework, suggesting that the Planck length is not the first scale that we should be careful. The string length l_{s} is a natural scale to consider, particularly in scenarios such as toroidal backgrounds where T -duality suggests that l_{s} represents the characteristic length at which the conventional Riemannian geometry should be abandoned. Many noncommutative geometries emerging in string theory is due to Kalb-Ramond field B_{\mu\nu} where coupled to fundamental open string with intrinsic length l_{s} 33 indicate that Riemannian geometry is not an appropriate tool in these scales. Even in the absence of Kalb-Ramond field, closed strings in T^{n} -backgrounds show some intrinsic noncommutativity proportional to l_{s}^{2} 15 . As all swampland conjectures are expressed in the Einstein frame, to states the refined TCC, we need to measure the string length in the Einstein frame. Using the appropriate Weyl transformation in such away \displaystyle g_{\mu\nu}^{E}\equiv e^{-\frac{4\phi}{D-2}}g_{\mu\nu}^{S} (3) where \phi is the dilaton field, we can relate the lengths in two

Read the complete text