Constituency Structure over Eojeol in Korean Treebanks
Jungyeul Park, Chulwoo Park · 2025
Read Constituency Structure over Eojeol in Korean Treebanks by Jungyeul Park, Chulwoo Park (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22487.txt.
Introduction
Jungyeul Park and Chulwoo Park settle a design question for Korean syntax databases: what should count as the basic terminal unit in a constituency treebank? Korean words are morphologically rich. Using morphemes as terminals blurs the line between word-internal structure and phrase structure. It also clashes with resources built on the eojeol, the space-delimited word unit of Korean writing.
The authors argue for eojeol-based constituency representation, with morphological segmentation and fine-grained part-of-speech detail kept in a separate, non-constituent layer. Under explicit normalization assumptions, the Sejong, Penn Korean, and KAIST treebanks can all be compared over one shared eojeol backbone. Their outlined annotation scheme preserves interpretable trees, supports alignment between constituency and dependency resources, and gives future Korean parsers a surface-form terminal layer.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jungyeul Park, Chulwoo Park |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 66 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22487
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Constituency Structure over Eojeol in Korean Treebanks Jungyeul Park, Chulwoo Park Abstract The design of Korean constituency treebanks raises a fundamental representational question concerning the choice of terminal units. Although Korean words are morphologically complex, treating morphemes as constituency terminals conflates word internal morphology with phrase level syntactic structure and creates mismatches with eojeol based dependency resources. This paper argues for an eojeol based constituency representation, with morphological segmentation and fine grained part of speech information encoded in a separate, non constituent layer. A comparative analysis shows that, under explicit normalization assumptions, the Sejong and Penn Korean treebanks can be treated as representationally equivalent at the eojeol based constituency level. Building on this result, we outline an eojeol based annotation scheme that preserves interpretable constituency and supports cross treebank comparison and constituency dependency conversion. 1 Introduction A recurring issue in the design of Korean constituency treebanks concerns the choice of terminal units. This choice is not merely a matter of annotation practice, but one that shapes how syntactic structure is interpreted, how constituency representations relate to one another, and how they interface with other syntactic resources. In Korean, the question is particularly salient because surface words are internally complex, combining lexical material with multiple functional morphemes ( Park and Kim 2023 ) . As a result, constituency annotation inevitably involves a decision about whether phrase structure should be built over morphemes or over larger grammatical units. This paper examines the consequences of this decision and argues that defining constituency structure over eojeol 1 1 1 An eojeol is the orthographic spacing unit in Korean, typically consisting of a lexical stem combined with one or more functional morphemes (such as case markers or verbal endings), which together form the basic unit of written word segmentation. provides a more stable and interpretable basis for Korean syntactic annotation. This stance is consistent with the synthetic view of Korean wordhood, according to which functional morphemes such as case particles and verbal endings do not constitute independent syntactic words but are grammatically integrated within a single syntactic unit ( Park 2018 ) . Eojeol function as the minimal units that participate systematically in syntactic relations such as argument structure, modification, and clausal embedding ( Park and Kim 2024 ) . Morphemes, while grammatically essential, contribute to syntax through their integration within eojeol rather than by entering syntactic configurations independently. When morphemes are treated as constituency terminals, word-internal morphological composition becomes intertwined with phrase-level organization, complicating the interpretation of hierarchical structure. The goal of this paper is therefore to provide a theoretical and methodological foundation for constructing Korean constituency treebanks, clarifying which grammatical units should serve as syntactic terminals and how morphological information should be integrated without redefining constituency structure. The motivation for an eojeol-based representation is reinforced by existing work on Korean dependency annotation ( Noh et al. 2018 ; Seo et al. 2019 ; Han et al. 2020b ; Park et al. 2021 ; Kim et al. 2024 ) . Prior studies have shown that dependency analysis relies on eojeol-based representations to maintain coherent syntactic relations and a stable interface with morphological information. When constituency annotation adopts a different terminal granularity, mismatches arise between hierarchical and relational representations, making conversion, comparison, and evaluation across resources more complex than necessary. Against this background, we propose an eojeol-based constituency representation that aligns naturally with eojeol-based dependency treebanks while retaining access to rich morphological information. Under this approach, phrase structure is defined over eojeol terminals, and morphological segmentation together with fine-grained part-of-speech (POS) information is recorded in a separate, explicitly non-constituent annotation layer. This separation clarifies the linguistic interpretation of constituency, improves interoperability across Korean syntactic resources, and offers a principled basis for future corpus development without constraining morphological analysis. 2 Background and conceptual distinctions This section lays out the conceptual background necessary for evaluating representational choices in Korean constituency annotation. It clarifies how constituency and dependency representations differ in their treatment of terminal units and motivates why the choice of terminals is not a merely technical decision but a linguistically consequential one. The section then situates eojeol and morphemes within Korean grammar, establishing the grammatical facts that underlie the representational stance adopted in this paper. 2.1 Constituency, dependency, and the choice of terminal units Constituency and dependency representations differ fundamentally in how syntactic structure is anchored to surface material. In a constituency representation, terminal units define the atoms over which hierarchical phrase structure is built. The choice of terminals therefore determines what counts as a syntactic unit and constrains how syntactic relations can be expressed. In contrast, dependency representations define structure directly over tokens by encoding binary relations between heads and dependents, with less emphasis on hierarchical grouping. Because of this difference, the choice of terminal units is especially consequential for constituency treebanks. Terminals are not merely surface tokens but the basic objects that phrase structure dominates. Changing the terminal unit alters the shape of the tree, the interpretation of nonterminal projections, and the granularity at which syntactic relations are encoded. As a result, constituency treebanks that adopt different terminal units are not directly comparable, even when they annotate the same sentences. This issue is particularly salient in Korean, where eojeol-based tokenization is standard in dependency treebanks and many downstream resources. When constituency treebanks adopt morphemes as terminals ( Chung et al. 2010 ; Park et al. 2016 ; Kim and Park 2022 ) , while dependency treebanks operate over eojeol, conversion and evaluation require reconstructing or collapsing terminals, often through heuristic procedures ( Xia and Palmer 2001 ) . Such mismatches complicate cross-resource comparison and obscure whether observed differences reflect genuine syntactic variation or representational artifacts. Distinguishing terminals as syntactic atoms from tokens as surface units is therefore essential. A tokenization scheme may be suitable for corpus indexing or morphological analysis without being an appropriate choice for constituency terminals. The present work adopts this distinction explicitly and treats the choice of constituency terminals as a representational decision grounded in syntactic considerations rather than in surface segmentation alone. 2.2 Eojeol and morphemes in Korean grammar Eojeol occupies a central but complex position in Korean grammar ( Chen et al. 2022 ; Chen et al. 2024b ; Chen et al. 2024a ) . Orthographically, eojeol corresponds to a spacing unit in written Korean. Grammatically, it serves as the unit that participates in syntactic relations such as argument structure, modification, and case marking. At the same time, eojeol is internally complex, typically consisting of a lexical stem combined with one or more functional morphemes. Because eojeol exhibits internally heterogeneous composition, it cannot be reduced to a uniform syntactic category and may function as a nominal, a verbal predicate, a modifier, or a clausal unit. Its syntactic role is determined by the combination of lexical material and functional morphology, rather than by any single morpheme in isolation. This makes eojeol the minimal unit that systematically participates in syntax, even though it is not morphologically atomic. Morpheme segmentation is nevertheless indispensable for Korean linguistic analysis. Morphemes encode case, tense, mood, derivation, and other grammatical information that is central to the interpretation of sentences. They are essential for morphological analysis, generation, and many downstream tasks. However, morphemes do not independently enter