Learning_to_Program != “One-Size-Fits-All”: Exploring Variations of Parsons Problems as Scaffolding CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI)

Carl Haynes-Magyar · 2025

Read Learning_to_Program != “One-Size-Fits-All”: Exploring Variations of Parsons Problems as Scaffolding CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) by Carl Haynes-Magyar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22407.txt.

Introduction

Carl Christopher Haynes-Magyar studies gentler on-ramps for learning to program. Parsons problems, where learners drag code blocks into the right order and indentation, are known scaffolding for writing code from scratch. His Codespec environment adds two variants as optional scaffolding: Faded Parsons, with parts of lines blanked, and Pseudocode Parsons, written in plain language. Nine programmers tried them in retrospective think-aloud interviews.

Learners reached for Faded Parsons when wrestling with syntax and structure, and for Pseudocode Parsons when planning at a high level. The optional scaffolds supported checking their own understanding, forming strategies, and refining prior knowledge. Costs included slow drag-and-drop and confusion when a provided solution clashed with the learner's own mental model. Faded Parsons was also enjoyed as a desirable challenge.

Catalog record

CREATORCarl Haynes-Magyar
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE106 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22407

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Learning_to_Program != “One-Size-Fits-All”: Exploring Variations of Parsons Problems as Scaffolding CCS: Human-centered computing Human computer interaction (HCI) Carl Haynes-Magyar Abstract . Lowering the barriers to computer programming requires understanding how to scaffold learning. Parsons problems, which require learners to drag-and-drop blocks of code into the correct order and indentation, are proving to be beneficial for scaffolding learning how to write code from scratch. But little is known about the ability of other problem types to do so. This study explores learners’ perceptions of a new programming environment called Codespec, which was developed to make computer programming more accessible and equitable by offering multiple means of engagement. Retrospective think-aloud interviews were conducted with nine programmers who were given the choice between Faded Parsons and Pseudocode Parsons problems as optional scaffolding toward solving write-code problems. The results showed that offering Faded and Pseudocode Parsons problems as optional scaffolds supported comprehension monitoring, strategy formation, and refinement of prior knowledge. Learners selectively used Faded Parsons problems for syntax/structure and Pseudocode Parsons problems for high-level reasoning. The costs noted included the time it takes to drag-and-drop the blocks and the confusion experienced when a solution diverges from a learners’ mental model. Faded Parsons problems were also perceived as a desirable challenge. This study contributes to the field of computing education and human-computer interaction by extending the functionality of problem spaces that support Parsons problems and by providing empirical evidence of the effectiveness of using other problem types as scaffolding techniques. 1. Introduction Learning to program can be difficult, but we can make it more achievable if we set realistic expectations and decenter cognitive norms for learners as a way of authoring positive trajectories of participation in computing education ( 15 ; 48 ) . In introductory computer programming courses, learners may experience high cognitive load because they lack the necessary schemata and plans to exploit while solving computer programming problems ( 64 ) , or they may be negatively affected by poorly designed learning environments and difficult programming tasks that are introduced without the appropriate support ( 41 ) . For novice programmers taking computer science (CS) or CS-X courses (i.e., a non-CS major blended with the core computer science curriculum), the initial plunge into coding can be a significant rite of passage, one marred by cognitive overload and steep learning curves, but the rewards of learning how to compute for discovery, expression, or justice underscore the importance of innovative teaching practices and the acquisition of computing knowledge and skills ( 4 ) . The problem is that current introductory computer programming instruction and assessment may fail to scaffold the acquisition of these skills ( 85 ) and there is still more to learn about the relationship between skills (i.e., skill hierarchies) ( 61 ) . Computing education theorists posit these skills include: code reading and tracing, code writing, pattern comprehension, pattern application ( 46 ; 85 ) , reverse tracing, sequencing, and explaining code ( 61 ) . Figure 1. Codespec’s problem space area featuring a Faded Parsons problem with a fix-code block denoted by the dashed orange/amber border and bug icon in the upper right-hand corner. Type.. It is within this challenging milieu that the pedagogical potential of Parsons problems emerges, offering a scaffolded learning environment that reduces cognitive load while underscoring conceptual understanding and the details of syntax ( 18 ; 49 ) . Traditionally, novice programmers have been instructed to practice programming by writing code from scratch—i.e., solving many small programs ( 2 ) . In contrast, Parsons problems require learners to construct a solution by rearranging and sometimes indenting blocks of code correctly, as shown in Figure 1 . Not all programmers are alike in their affinity for computer programming practice problems; some novice programmers reject code-tracing problems while others prefer it, and novice programmers with prior experience can have strong adverse reactions to Parsons problems ( 31 ) , but they may find Faded Parsons ( 23 ; 79 ) or Pseudocode Parsons problems (further described in Section 2 ) more suitable for scaffolding. Hence, there is a need to create tools and environments that reduce the barrier to programming by offering a wider range of problem types to challenge learners with and without prior programming experience ( 41 ) . In response to this pedagogical exigency, this study explores learners’ perceptions about choosing between different scaffolding techniques, such as Faded Parsons and Pseudocode Parsons problems. In this context, scaffolding means that when learners are asked to solve a write-code problem, they can choose to view and solve a Faded Parsons and or a Pseudocode Parsons problem to aid them in completing the write-code problem. The research questions addressed in this study are: (1) What do learners perceive are the advantages and challenges of using Faded Parsons and Pseudocode Parsons problems as optional scaffolding for write-code problems? (2) What preliminary insights emerge from piloting the Scaffolding Learning Questionnaire with programmers using Codespec? This study extends the functionality of problem spaces that support Parsons problems through the development of Codespec—a new computer programming practice environment that offers multiple means of engagement (see in Section 3.2 ). By examining how learners choose to engage with these scaffolds (i.e., different optional problem types), this study contributes to our understanding of their impact. 2. Related Work 2.1. Parsons Problems Parsons problems, originally called Parsons Programming Puzzles, were designed to: maximize engagement, constrain logic, permit common errors, model well written code, and provide immediate feedback ( 18 ; 58 ) . They can introduce learners to syntactic and semantic language constructs while exposing them to common programming patterns. Researchers have developed a variety of them since their inception. Parsons problems can vary by dimension, feedback, adaptation, use of distractor blocks, use of subgoal labels, use of fading, the number of lines, and use of optional blocks ( 16 ; 21 ; 18 ; 53 ; 55 ; 79 ) . One-dimensional Parsons problems require learners to drag-and-drop blocks of code into the correct order only ( 14 ) . Two-dimensional Parsons problems require learners to place blocks of code into the correct order and indent them correctly ( 40 ) . Research has shown that it is harder to solve two-dimensional as opposed to one-dimensional Parsons problems ( 14 ) but the former has become the de facto template for introducing desirable difficulties ( 20 ; 16 ) . Parsons problems can also be accompanied by different types of feedback, such as execution-based feedback or line- or block-based feedback . Execution-based feedback systems execute code and indicate correctness by returning expected and actual values and any error messages ( 35 ) . Line-based feedback systems highlight code blocks to indicate when they are in the wrong order or indentation, or when a code block needs to be rearranged somehow in order to create a working program. In a study by Helminen et al., the researchers found that “it is not an either-or situation” ( 35 , p. 59) . The responses to questions about whether or not learners thought line-based or execution-based feedback supported their learning were correlated. However, execution-based feedback caused learners to focus more on whether or not their code was executable,

Read the complete text