Mass-to-Horizon Entropic Cosmology: A Unified Thermodynamic Pathway to Cosmic Acceleration
Tomasz Denkiewicz, Hussain Gohar · 2025
Read Mass-to-Horizon Entropic Cosmology: A Unified Thermodynamic Pathway to Cosmic Acceleration by Tomasz Denkiewicz, Hussain Gohar (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-22103.txt.
Introduction
Tomasz Denkiewicz and Hussain Gohar test a cosmology in which the universe's speeding expansion comes from entropy rather than a fixed cosmic constant. Their system starts from a general relation between mass and horizon size, which produces a matching general entropy. An entropic force on the cosmic horizon then drives the acceleration as an emergent effect.
Earlier work showed these models can mimic the standard model's expansion history. Here the authors add data on how structure grows, alongside supernova distances, baryon acoustic oscillations, and microwave background distance measures. A Bayesian comparison finds the entropic models preferred on the numbers over the standard scenario. The result supports entropy, not a basic constant, as the driver of late-time acceleration.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tomasz Denkiewicz, Hussain Gohar |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 61 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-22103
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Mass-to-Horizon Entropic Cosmology: A Unified Thermodynamic Pathway to Cosmic Acceleration Tomasz Denkiewicz, Hussain Gohar Abstract We investigate the observational tests of generalized mass-to-horizon entropic cosmology by incorporating large-scale structure growth data in addition to purely geometric probes. The theoretical framework is constructed from a generalized mass-to-horizon scaling relation, M ∝ L n M\propto L^{n} , which implies a corresponding generalized entropic functional S n ∝ L n + 1 S_{n}\propto L^{n+1} . Within this setting, cosmic acceleration arises as an emergent phenomenon driven by an entropic force acting on the cosmological horizon. While earlier studies demonstrated that these entropic cosmologies can reproduce the background expansion history of the standard Λ \Lambda CDM model, here we present a comprehensive observational analysis that jointly employs Pantheon+ Type Ia supernova data with SH0ES calibration, DESI DR2 baryon acoustic oscillation measurements, cosmic microwave background (CMB) distance priors, and a suite of cosmological structure growth observations. A Bayesian model comparison indicates that the entropic models are statistically preferred over the conventional Λ \Lambda CDM scenario, thereby providing strong support for an entropic origin of the observed late-time cosmic acceleration in place of a fundamental cosmological constant. I Introduction Recent evidence indicates that the universe is experiencing an unprecedented rate of expansion Perlmutter et al. 1999 ; Riess et al. 1998 ; Riess et al. 2004 ; Riess et al. 2007 ; Scolnic et al. 2018 ; Hinshaw et al. 2013 ; Aghanim et al. 2020 ; Alam et al. 2020 . A multitude of studies have been conducted to explore this phenomenon Li et al. 2011 ; Bamba et al. 2012 . Dark energy, characterized by its unique attributes that influence the Einstein field equations, has been suggested as a possible explanation for this acceleration. Nonetheless, models of dark energy encounter certain discrepancies when confronted with observational data and present theoretical challenges Bull et al. 2016 . Consequently, numerous alternative approaches have been explored to comprehend the underlying physical mechanisms driving the accelerated expansion. Among the promising frameworks under consideration is entropic acceleration, or entropic cosmology 1 1 1 Entropic cosmology differs from entropic gravity Verlinde 2011 . In entropic cosmology, general relativity is assumed valid and extra entropic force terms are added to the field equations, whereas entropic gravity treats gravity itself as an emergent force. , as proposed in Easson et al. 2011 ; Easson et al. 2012 . In this approach, terms associated with entropic forces—motivated by boundary contributions to the Einstein–Hilbert action (see, for instance, the detailed derivations in Garcia-Bellido and Espinosa-Portales 2021 ; Arjona et al. 2022 ; Garcia-Bellido 2024 ; García-Bellido 2025 ; Calderon et al. 2025 in the context of general relativistic entropic acceleration) and further supported by the holographic principle Susskind 1995 ; ’t Hooft 1993 —are incorporated into the Einstein field equations. These entropic force contributions are postulated to drive the present cosmic acceleration and to provide a unified entropic explanation for both early- and late-time accelerated expansion. From a holographic standpoint, it is conjectured that the information encoded on the boundary of the universe induces an entropic force and an associated effective negative pressure, which may account for the observed rapid expansion of the universe. Assuming the validity of the holographic principle, the earliest models of entropic cosmology employ the Hawking temperature Hawking 1974 and Bekenstein entropy Bekenstein 1973 defined on the boundary in order to derive the entropic force terms. However, these original formulations face serious difficulties in reproducing the transition between accelerated and decelerated expansion phases and fail to provide an adequate fit to observational growth-of-structure data Basilakos et al. 2012 ; Basilakos and Sola 2014 . These shortcomings have been mitigated by phenomenologically introducing additional terms beyond those originally proposed in Komatsu and Kimura 2013a ; Komatsu and Kimura 2013b ; Komatsu and Kimura 2014a ; Komatsu and Kimura 2014b ; Komatsu and Kimura 2015 ; Komatsu and Kimura 2016 ; Gohar and Salzano 2021 . Recently, new generalized entropic-force cosmological models were developed in Gohar and Salzano 2024a ; Gohar and Salzano 2024b by one of the authors of the present work, which successfully resolve the main limitations of the original scenarios. It has been demonstrated that these generalized models are statistically indistinguishable from the standard Lambda Cold Dark Matter ( \Lambda CDM) cosmological model in terms of Bayesian evidence, and they yield parameter estimates that are effectively identical to those of the standard scenario. This provides the first concrete realization of a fully entropic framework underlying dark energy. However, in Gohar and Salzano 2024a , the growth of cosmic structures was not analyzed, as the primary objective was to establish an entropic origin for dark energy. In this work, we examine the growth of cosmic structures within the framework of generalized entropic cosmologies, with the goal of addressing the evolution of structure formation and incorporating the latest observational datasets to constrain the model parameters One of the foundational components of entropic cosmology is the specification of the entropic force contributions, which are intrinsically determined by the particular entropy functional associated with the chosen cosmological horizon. A broad spectrum of entropy proposals have been proposed, inspired by developments in nonextensive statistical mechanics Tsallis 1988 ; Tsallis 2009 , thermodynamics Tsallis and Cirto 2013 ; Zamora and Tsallis 2022a ; Zamora and Tsallis 2022b , quantum gravity Rovelli 1996 ; Meissner 2004 , and various phenomenological frameworks Barrow 2020 . Recent investigations have demonstrated that many of these generalized entropy definitions, which extend beyond the standard Bekenstein entropy, become thermodynamically inconsistent when combined with the Hawking temperature Gohar and Salzano 2024a ; Çimdiker et al. 2023 ; Nojiri et al. 2021 ; Gohar and Salzano 2024b , thereby generating tensions within holographic scenarios. These inconsistencies have been systematically examined in the context of entropic cosmology in Gohar and Salzano 2024b ; Gohar and Salzano 2024a , and in the context of black hole thermodynamics in Çimdiker et al. 2023 ; Nojiri et al. 2021 . In the holographic scenarios, thermodynamic consistency requires that any entropy S and temperature T attributed to a holographic horizon, when inserted into the Clausius relation dE=T\,dS , must preserve the identification of the energy E with the mass M . In most generalizations that go beyond the Bekenstein entropy, the strategy is to deform or extend the Bekenstein entropy while keeping the standard Hawking temperature unmodified. The central question is whether these generalized entropy functionals, when used in conjunction with Hawking temperature, still satisfy the conditions of thermodynamic consistency. A closely related issue is whether the adoption of the Hawking temperature remains theoretically justified once such non-Bekenstein entropy forms are introduced. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that generalized entropy functionals fail to satisfy the consistency condition when combined with the Hawking temperature Nojiri et al. 2021 ; Çimdiker et al. 2023 . Although one may attempt to modify the Hawking temperature, as it is done in Cimidiker et al. 2023 , to restore consistency, such modifications lack a clear justification from quantum field theory. A key but often overlooked element in holographic cosmology is the linear mass–horizon relation (MHR), M=\gamma c^{2}L/G , where \gamma>0 is a dimensionless parameter. Although commonly used—typically implicitly—when invoking the Clausius relation and