Memory of topologically constrained disorder in Shakti artificial spin ice
Priyanka Priyanka, Cristiano Nisoli, Yair Shokef · 2025
Read Memory of topologically constrained disorder in Shakti artificial spin ice by Priyanka Priyanka, Cristiano Nisoli, Yair Shokef (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-21767.txt.
Introduction
Priyanka Priyanka, Cristiano Nisoli, and Yair Shokef ask whether disordered magnetic materials can remember how they were driven. Artificial spin ices are arrays of tiny magnets arranged to frustrate each other, creating rich states. Memory usually means holding an ordered pattern, but constrained disorder might remember a sequence of manipulations instead.
The authors compare two contrasting systems, in theory and in simulation. Square spin ice settles into an ordered state and shows no sequence dependence. Shakti spin ice, whose disorder is topologically constrained, responds in a sequence-dependent way: the same set of drives in a different order leads elsewhere. Even its smallest repeating unit shows deterministic and stochastic forms of sequence memory, depending on interaction strength. Retracing the same drive path strengthens retention.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Priyanka Priyanka, Cristiano Nisoli, Yair Shokef |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 60 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-21767
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Memory of topologically constrained disorder in Shakti artificial spin ice Priyanka Priyanka, Cristiano Nisoli, Yair Shokef Abstract Complex behaviors often sit at a critical threshold between order and disorder. But not all disorder is created equal. Disorder can be trivial or constrained, and correlated disorder can even be topological. Crucially, constrained disorder can harbor memory, leading to non-trivial, sequence-dependent responses to external manipulations. And yet the fascinating subject of “memory of disorder” remains poorly explored, as memory is often associated to the retention of metastable order. In recent years artificial frustrated materials—in particular arrays of frustrated nanomagnets known as artificial spin ices—have been employed to study complex disorders and its wealth of exotic behaviors, yet their memory properties have received much less attention. Here, we investigate both analytically and numerically the sequence-dependent responses of two somehow opposite yet related artificial spin ices: the Landau-ordered square spin ice and the disordered but topologically-ordered Shakti spin ice. We find that Shakti exhibits a pronounced sequence-dependent response, whereas in the square lattice, such path dependence is absent. Within Shakti, even the minimal periodic supercell demonstrates both deterministic and stochastic forms of sequence memory, depending on the interaction strength. Extending our study to cyclic driving, we find that retracing the same input path leads to enhanced memory retention. These results open new perspectives on how topological constraints and correlated disorder generate robust memory effects in frustrated artificial materials, hitherto examined mainly in terms of their ground-state kinetics and thermodynamics. 1 Introduction Complex systems such as granular matter [ 27 ] , foam [ 36 ] , crumpled sheets [ 55 ] , amorphous solids [ 8 , 50 , 39 , 18 , 17 , 38 ] , origami [ 15 ] and mechanical metamaterials [ 7 , 56 , 28 , 32 ] typically accommodate multiple quasidegenerate or degenerate metastabilities often connected by constrained pathways [ 51 ] , leading to memory in their response [ 19 ] , which can explain biological function [ 37 ] or could be exploited for technological applications [ 63 , 46 ] . Perhaps the simplest and most notorious cases of memory-endowed response are provided by magnetism, where the simplest ferromagnet proves hysteretic. But more complex, disordered magnets, such as frustrated antiferromagnets, can reveal even more complex memory, including rate dependent memory [ 20 ] . Of particular interest are magnets that are topologically constrained [ 13 , 14 ] , whose phase space can be partitioned into sectors weakly connected by available pathways [ 25 , 44 , 66 ] . Recently, magnets with exotic behaviors have been designed with intention and realized at the nanoscale as arrays of ferromagnetic anisotropic nanoislands called artificial spin ices [ 61 , 40 ] . The magnetic state of the nanoisland can be described as a binary, classical Ising spin which can be characterized individually through various techniques, sometimes even in real-time. Moreover, their flexible design allows for the deliberate generation of novel Hamiltonians to produce magnets of collective behaviors that are often absent in natural systems [ 42 , 57 ] . Among these intriguing properties, memory effects have received perhaps insufficient attention following some promising initial studies of direct visualization of avalanches of magnetic charges during moment inversion [ 21 , 30 , 62 ] , and of return point memory [ 24 , 10 ] related to the propagation of magnetic monopoles. Here we investigate memory as sequence-dependent response in two widely studied artificial spin ices, which represent opposite extremes in their structural design and resulting low-energy manifolds: one is square ice, the first to be introduced nearly two decades ago [ 61 , 41 ] , and the other is Shakti spin ice [ 3 , 35 , 11 , 22 , 59 , 52 ] , a more recent realization that belongs to a new generation of spin ices based on a distinct concept of vertex frustration [ 35 , 58 , 12 , 9 , 42 , 60 ] . Square spin ice [ 61 , 41 , 43 ] obeys the ice rule, but its degeneracy is notoriously lifted, resulting in a conventional antiferromagnetic Landau order [ 34 , 64 , 49 ] below a thermal phase transition of the Ising class [ 54 ] . In contrast, Shakti—derived by removing islands from square ice—exhibits a thermal crossover to a disordered phase characterized by algebraically correlated classical topological order [ 14 ] . We intend that in the sense that its ground state can be mapped onto a dimer model [ 22 ] or, equivalently, the F-model [ 25 ] at the free fermion point [ 3 ] , both of which are inherently topological states. Moreover, in addition to topological order, for certain ratios among its couplings, Shakti also supports the trivial Landau order it inherits from square ice. Therefore, a comparative study of these two systems offers the potential to elucidate memory in ordered phases and in disordered, but topologically ordered, ones. Interestingly, we have previously demonstrated that both geometries can be adapted into mechanical metamaterials [ 6 , 29 , 29 , 48 ] , also resulting in intriguing forms of mechanical memory [ 31 , 56 ] . For both lattices, we consider athermal dynamics in which we quasistatically increase the in-plane magnetic field in different sequences. Initially, we focus on the ground-state configurations that exhibit the smallest repeating structures within the square and Shakti lattices, and we measure the magnetization at the conclusion of the process. In contrast with the simpler and predictable behavior that we find in square ice, for the more complex Shakti lattice, our study reveals a sequence-dependent response, which depends on the structural phase of the material. Moreover, we find that the response to applying an external field is not always deterministic; the dynamics can exhibit bifurcations, leading to multiple possible final states. Whether the system can return to the ground state configuration when the magnetic field is switched off depends on factors such as spin orientation, the locations of defects (or excitations) where the vertices are not in their minimum energy configurations, and the selected protocols for the evolution of the external magnetic field. However, in large systems, regardless of the protocols employed, the system does not revert to its initial state once it is driven beyond a certain level. This phenomenon occurs because large systems are composed of overlapping supercells, which results in a reduction of the external field threshold to the minimum threshold observed in periodic arrangements of the individual supercells. We chose and followed protocols that can be replicated in an experimental setting with magnetic force microscopy (MFM) under field. Our results might prove relevant in the context of magneto-transport in these systems [ 1 , 5 , 23 , 2 ] . More broadly, we envision a series of experiments in which a small sized, static Shakti (that is an artificial spin ice with nanoislands of circa 20 nm of thickness), can be repetitively subjected to applied field and visualized via e.g. MFM after each application. In Sec. 2 we present the two lattices and the various protocols that we employed for studying their responses to changing