VLBI Diagnostics of Off-axis Jets in Radio Flares of Tidal Disruption Events
Tatsuya Matsumoto · 2025
Read VLBI Diagnostics of Off-axis Jets in Radio Flares of Tidal Disruption Events by Tatsuya Matsumoto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-21669.txt.
Introduction
Tatsuya Matsumoto asks how radio astronomers can tell what powers the late radio flares of tidal disruption events, outbursts seen when a star is torn apart by a black hole. The flare of AT2018hyz has two rival explanations: a delayed outflow launched about a thousand days later, or a relativistic jet pointing far from our line of sight.
Matsumoto computes synthetic radio images for both scenarios and compares what very long baseline interferometry would see. The sharpest test is the motion of the emission centroid, the brightness center of the image. A delayed outflow keeps the centroid within a non-relativistic distance. An off-axis jet makes the centroid appear to move faster than light. Detecting such superluminal motion would be a smoking gun for the jet. Jet images also show a distinctive, non-monotonic change in aspect ratio. The same diagnostics should apply to other jetted explosions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Tatsuya Matsumoto |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-21669
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
VLBI Diagnostics of Off-axis Jets in Radio Flares of Tidal Disruption Events Tatsuya Matsumoto Abstract The origin of late-time radio flares in tidal disruption events remains unclear. In particular, the peculiar radio flare observed in AT2018hyz has motivated two leading scenarios: a delayed outflow launched ∼ 1000 days \sim 1000\,\rm days after discovery, or an off-axis relativistic jet directed far from our line of sight. Very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) imaging provides the most direct way to distinguish between these scenarios. In this paper, we calculate synthetic radio images for both models and examine their observational signatures. The motion of the emission centroid is the most powerful diagnostic for breaking the degeneracy. In the delayed-outflow scenario, the centroid motion is confined within a non-relativistic distance, whereas in the off-axis jet scenario it exhibits apparent superluminal motion. Detecting such superluminal motion would therefore provide a smoking-gun signature of the off-axis jet interpretation. We also find that the jet image exhibits characteristic features, including a non-monotonic evolution of the image aspect ratio. These results are expected to be generic and applicable to other jetted explosions, such as microquasars and gamma-ray bursts. show][email protected] I Introduction Recent observations have revealed that a significant fraction of optical tidal disruption events ( M. J. Rees 1988 , TDEs;) are accompanied by radio flares appearing as late as \sim 1000\,\rm days after discovery ( Y. Cendes et al. 2024 ; see also A. Horesh et al. 2021a ; A. Horesh et al. 2021b ; Y. Cendes et al. 2022 ; A. J. Goodwin et al. 2023 ; C. T. Christy et al. 2024 ; F. Zhang et al. 2024 ; W. W. Golay et al. 2025 ; A. Hajela et al. 2025 ; A. J. Goodwin et al. 2025 ). Several ideas have been proposed for the origin of these late-time radio flares, including delayed outflows produced by delayed disk formation or state transitions in the disk ( Y. Cendes et al. 2022 ; K. D. Alexander et al. 2025 ; S. C. Wu et al. 2025 ) , prompt outflows interacting with a circumnuclear medium (CNM) with a non-monotonic density profile ( T. Matsumoto & T. Piran 2024 ; J. Zhuang et al. 2025 ) , and off-axis relativistic jets ( T. Matsumoto & T. Piran 2023 ; I. Sfaradi et al. 2024 ) . Despite these efforts, their physical origin remains uncertain. Among the late-time radio flares, AT2018hyz stands out as a particularly remarkable event ( Y. Cendes et al. 2022 ; I. Sfaradi et al. 2024 ; Y. Cendes et al. 2025 ) . After \sim 1000\,\rm days of non-detection, a radio flare suddenly emerged with a sharply rising light curve and an unusually high luminosity, comparable to that of jetted TDEs ( T. Eftekhari et al. 2018 ; Y. Cendes et al. 2021 ) . As one of the earliest identified examples of late-time flares, this event was initially interpreted as being powered by a delayed outflow ( Y. Cendes et al. 2022 ) . T. Matsumoto & T. Piran 2023 further demonstrated that an off-axis relativistic jet ( D. Giannios & B. D. Metzger 2011 , e.g.,) can also reproduce the observed properties. At present, both scenarios remain viable and cannot be distinguished using the radio light curve and spectrum alone ( Y. Cendes et al. 2025 ) . T. Matsumoto & T. Piran 2023 proposed that radio imaging with very long baseline interferometry (VLBI) could provide a direct diagnostic of the origin of the radio emission in AT2018hyz. VLBI observations have played a crucial role in revealing the nature of relativistic transients, including Galactic microquasars ( I. F. Mirabel & L. F. Rodríguez 1994 ; S. J. Tingay et al. 1995 ; see also R. Fender 2006 ) and binary neutron star (BNS) mergers ( K. P. Mooley et al. 2018 ; G. Ghirlanda et al. 2019 ) . In particular, the BNS merger GW170817 has heightened interest in radio imaging and motivated numerous theoretical studies, using both (semi-)analytical ( R. Gill & J. Granot 2018 ; J. J. Fernández et al. 2022 ; T. Govreen-Segal & E. Nakar 2023 ; G. Sadeh et al. 2024 ) and numerical approaches ( J. Zrake et al. 2018 ; J. Granot et al. 2018 ; J. J. Fernández et al. 2022 ; V. Nedora et al. 2023 ) . The same techniques are applicable to TDEs. In this paper, we compute radio images of late-time radio flares in TDEs using a semi-analytical framework. In the context of TDEs, several previous studies have calculated synthetic images based on simulations ( P. Mimica et al. 2015 ; F. F. Hu et al. 2025 ; G. Mou & X. Shu 2025 , e.g.,) , but did not carry out a detailed analysis of their properties. Moreover, recent VLBI observations of TDE radio flares ( W. W. Golay et al. 2025 ; A. Hajela et al. 2025 ) further motivate a detailed theoretical investigation of their expected imaging signatures. Our approach allows us to isolate key physical effects and clarify the observational diagnostics that can distinguish between different scenarios. The structure of the paper is as follows. In Section II , we describe the method used to calculate the radio images as well as light curve and spectrum. In Section III , we present radio images of AT2018hyz based on two different models. We discuss the very late-time evolution of the radio images and their implications in Section IV , and summarize our findings in Section V . II Method Light curves and images of synchrotron-emitting outflows have been calculated by many authors at various levels of approximation. In this study, we assume that the outflow is piecewise spherical; that is, each fluid element evolves as though it were part of a spherically symmetric outflow. We further assume that the emitting region is a thin shell, and do not consider any angular structure ( A. Tchekhovskoy et al. 2014 ; O. Teboul & B. D. Metzger 2023 ; W. Lu et al. 2024 , but see e.g.,) . Figure 1: A schematic picture of the adopted coordinate system in our calculation. For a jet geometry, the jet is assumed to have a bipolar structure and each jet propagates along z axis. An observer is located within the xz plane, whose viewing angle \theta_{\rm obs} is measured from the z axis. The incoming (traveling into the positive z direction) and outgoing jets are called an approaching and counter jets, respectively. The coordinate system of the sky ( XY ) plane is defined so that the approaching jet always propagates into the positive X direction. II.1 Dynamics The dynamics of the outflow is calculated under the piecewise spherical approximation. This is justified when the outflow is highly relativistic. However, for a jetted outflow, when its Lorentz factor becomes smaller than the inverse of the half opening angle, the jet starts to expand laterally ( J. E. Rhoads 1999 ; J. Granot & T. Piran 2012 , e.g.,) . We neglect this sideway expansion in this paper, and assume that the jet propagates keeping its original shape. For TDE jets, this might be allowed because some jetted TDEs do