Insufficiency of Pure-State Ensembles in Characterizing Transformations of Entangled States under LOCC

C. L. Liu, Baoqing Sun, D. L. Zhou · 2025

Read Insufficiency of Pure-State Ensembles in Characterizing Transformations of Entangled States under LOCC by C. L. Liu, Baoqing Sun, D. L. Zhou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-21665.txt.

Introduction

C. L. Liu, Baoqing Sun, and D. L. Zhou answer a question about entanglement transformations. Two parties holding an entangled quantum state can manipulate it using local operations and classical communication, called LOCC. For pure states, the rules for which transformations are possible are well understood. Mixed states, though, can be prepared as many different ensembles of pure states.

The natural hope was that transformation rules for mixed states could be read off from their pure-state ensembles. Liu and his co-authors rule this out. They show that satisfying the inequalities for every convex-roof entanglement measure is not enough to guarantee an LOCC transformation between two mixed states. Likewise, comparing average entanglement across ensembles, for all entanglement monotones, does not ensure an ensemble-to-ensemble transformation exists. The result closes off a tempting shortcut and settles open questions. Mixed-state entanglement must be treated on its terms.

Catalog record

CREATORC. L. Liu, Baoqing Sun, D. L. Zhou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE37 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-21665

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Insufficiency of Pure-State Ensembles in Characterizing Transformations of Entangled States under LOCC C. L. Liu, Baoqing Sun, D. L. Zhou Abstract The conditions for transforming pure entangled states under local operations and classical communication (LOCC) are well understood. A natural question then arises: Can we determine the transformation conditions for mixed entangled states under LOCC based on the properties of their pure-state ensembles? While much effort has been devoted to this issue, in this paper, we rule out this possibility. Our findings address several open questions, including: (i) The conditions E f c ​ r ​ ( ρ ) ≥ E f c ​ r ​ ( σ ) E_{f}^{cr}(\rho)\geq E_{f}^{cr}(\sigma) for all convex roof entanglement measures E f c ​ r E_{f}^{cr} is insufficient to guarantee the existence of an LOCC transformation Λ L ​ ( ⋅ ) \Lambda^{L}(\cdot) from ρ \rho to σ \sigma ; and (ii) The inequalities ∑ j p j ​ E ​ ( φ j ) ≥ ∑ l q l ​ E ​ ( ψ l ) \sum_{j}p_{j}E(\varphi_{j})\geq\sum_{l}q_{l}E(\psi_{l}) for all entanglement monotones E E are not sufficient to ensure the existence of an LOCC transformation from { p j , | φ j ⟩ } \{p_{j},|\varphi_{j}\rangle\} to { q l , | ψ l ⟩ } \{q_{l},|\psi_{l}\rangle\} . I Introduction Quantum entanglement, first recognized by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen Einstein , as well as Schrödinger Schrodinger , was viewed by Einstein and his collaborators as evidence of the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. However, with Bell’s work in 1964 Bell and subsequent experiments Clauser ; Zeilinger ; Aspect ; Clasuer1 , quantum entanglement has been recognized as one of the fundamental features of quantum mechanics. Then, the understanding of quantum entanglement began to shift from a qualitative to a quantitative perspective. It is now recognized as a crucial resource for accomplishing various tasks in quantum information processing Horodecki ; Plenio ; Guhne ; Dur ; Aolita ; Chitambar1 ; Nielsen1 , such as dense coding, teleportation, and reduction of communication complexity. In these applications, a situation of particular interest in quantum information processing consists of two parties that are spatially separated from each other and share a composite system in an entangled state. This setting requires the parties to act only local operations and classical communication (LOCC) on their subsystems Bennett1 . A central topic in the theory of quantum entanglement is the transformation of entangled states under LOCC. This investigation was initiated by Lo and Popescu Lo and a seminal result in this area was established by Nielsen Nielsen , who provided the necessary and sufficient conditions for transforming between two entangled pure states. Specifically, let |\psi_{1}\rangle=\sum_{i=0}^{n-1}\sqrt{\mu_{i}}|i_{A}i_{B}\rangle and |\psi_{2}\rangle=\sum_{j=0}^{n-1}\sqrt{\eta_{j}}|j_{A}j_{B}\rangle be the Schmidt decompositions of |\psi_{1}\rangle and |\psi_{2}\rangle , respectively. Without loss of generality, we assume 0\leq\mu_{i}\leq\mu_{i+1} and 0\leq\eta_{j}\leq\eta_{j+1} for all i and j . Then, |\psi_{1}\rangle can be transformed into |\psi_{2}\rangle using LOCC if and only if \displaystyle E_{l}(\psi_{1}):=\sum_{i=0}^{l}\mu_{i}\geq E_{l}(\psi_{2}):=\sum_{j=0}^{l}\eta_{j} (1) holds for all 0\leq l\leq n-1 . For simplicity, we denote E_{l}(\psi_{1})\geq E_{l}(\psi_{2}) for all l by writing \uplambda_{\psi_{1}}\prec\uplambda_{\psi_{2}} Bhatia ; Horn . Here, \uplambda_{\psi} is the vector of squared Schmidt coefficients of the state |\psi\rangle . Subsequently, Jonathan and Plenio Jonathan demonstrated that the transformation from |\psi\rangle to \rho can be accomplished via LOCC if and only if \rho has a pure-state ensemble \{p_{\alpha},|\varphi_{\alpha}\rangle\}_{\alpha=1}^{N} such that \displaystyle\sum_{\alpha=1}^{N}p_{\alpha}E_{l}(|\varphi_{\alpha}\rangle)\leq E_{l}(|\psi\rangle) (2) hold for all l . The above results provide a clear understanding of the conditions under which transformations between pure entangled states can be achieved using LOCC. Building on these foundational findings, many researchers have sought to extend the analysis to more general scenarios, including transformations between mixed entangled states as well as between pure-state ensembles Gour ; Jonathan ; Li ; Ghiu ; Li1 ; Girard ; Barnum ; Hayden . On the one hand, Ref. Jonathan and related works might lead one to expect that, if a certain inequality is satisfied for all convex-roof entanglement measures, this would be sufficient to guarantee the possibility of an LOCC transformation between two mixed states. Motivated by this suggestion, several studies have explored this direction in depth Gour ; Li ; Ghiu ; Li1 ; Barnum ; Hayden , though no definitive conclusion has yet been reached. On the other hand, when considering transformations between pure-state ensembles under LOCC, it has been conjectured Gour that a transformation T:D_{1}\to D_{2} between two probability distributions of bipartite pure states can be implemented via LOCC if and only if E(D_{1})\geq E(D_{2}) for all entanglement monotones E , where D:=\{p_{j},|\varphi_{j}\rangle\} and E(D):=\sum_{j}p_{j}E(|\varphi_{j}\rangle) . In this paper, we will address these open questions. To tackle these issues, we will first demonstrate that the pure-state ensembles of entangled states are insufficient for characterizing their transformations under LOCC. More precisely, we will demonstrate that there exist two entangled states, \rho_{AB} and \sigma_{AB} , with \{p_{j},|\varphi_{j}\rangle_{AB}\} and \{q_{i},|\psi_{i}\rangle_{AB}\} as arbitrary ensembles of \rho_{AB} and \sigma_{AB} , respectively, such that it is possible to use an LOCC transformation to convert \{p_{j},|\varphi_{j}\rangle_{AB}\} into \{q_{i},|\psi_{i}\rangle_{AB}\} , but it is not possible to transform \rho_{AB} into \sigma_{AB} using only LOCC (noting that in the conversion from one pure-state ensemble to the other pure-state ensemble, it is assumed that one always knows which pure state one is starting with). Then, we will use this result to study the above two questions. Our results indicate that to provide the necessary and sufficient conditions for the transformation of mixed entangled states under LOCC, we need to introduce additional mathematical tools. II Some Concepts in Entanglement Theory To address the above issues clearly, it is helpful to review several related concepts, including separable states, entangled states, separable operations, and LOCC (local operations and classical communication). Separable States: A bipartite quantum state \rho_{AB} is called separable if it can be expressed as a convex combination of product states \displaystyle\rho_{AB}=\sum_{\alpha}p_{\alpha}\rho_{\alpha}^{A}\otimes\rho_{\alpha}^{B}, (3) where \{p_{\alpha}\} is a probability distribution and \rho_{\alpha}^{A} and \rho_{\alpha}^{B} are density operators acting on the Hilbert spaces \mathcal{H}_{A} and \mathcal{H}_{B} , respectively Werner . A state is considered entangled if it cannot be represented as a separable state. Separable Operations: A separable operation \Lambda^{S}(\cdot) on a bipartite quantum system is a transformation of the form Rains ; Horodecki \displaystyle\Lambda^{S}(\rho_{AB})=\sum_{n=1}^{N}K_{n}^{A}\otimes K_{n}^{B}\,\rho_{AB}\,{K_{n}^{A}}^{\dagger}\otimes{K_{n}^{B}}^{\dagger}, (4) where \rho_{AB} is the initial density operator on the Hilbert space \mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} . The Kraus operators K_{n}^{A}\otimes K_{n}^{B} are arbitrary product operators that satisfy the trace-preserving condition \displaystyle\sum_{n}{K_{n}^{A}}^{\dagger}K_{n}^{A}\otimes{K_{n}^{B}}^{\dagger}K_{n}^{B}=\mathbb{I}_{A}\otimes\mathbb{I}_{B}, (5) where \mathbb{I}_{A} and \mathbb{I}_{B} are the identity operators on parties A and B, respectively. The extension to multipartite systems is straightforward; however, we will focus on the bipartite case here. Therefore, for simplicity, we will omit the indices AB in the following discussion. LOCC describes all the transformations that two separated parties (party A and party B) can perform when they apply local operations and have access to classical communication. In general, local operations encompass measurements and operations involving additional local systems Bennett1 . Classical communication allows the two parties to exchange information over a classical channel. Specifically, consider two subsystems, one located in party A’s laboratory and the other in party B’s. Suppose party A starts by performing a generalized measurement with outcomes corresponding to Kraus operators K_{i_{1}} . If the initial state of the system was |\psi\rangle

Read the complete text