Discrete-time asset price bubbles with short sales prohibitions under model uncertainty

Wenqing Zhang · 2025

Read Discrete-time asset price bubbles with short sales prohibitions under model uncertainty by Wenqing Zhang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-21115.txt.

Introduction

Wenqing Zhang and Lin Zhang give asset bubbles a rigorous definition in a market unsure of its own model, one that forbids short selling. Working in discrete time and discrete states, they measure a bubble as the gap between an asset's market price and its fundamental value. That value is set by a super-hedging benchmark: the cheapest cost of a strategy that surely covers the asset's payoff. How long an asset may be held before liquidation turns out to govern the mathematics.

For bounded maturity without dividends, a supermartingale-style property of prices is equivalent to bubbles existing. With unbounded maturity, one variant stays necessary and another sufficient. A no-dominance condition excludes bubbles when liquidation is bounded. Finite-horizon claims add a split personality. Fundamental prices obey put-call bounds, and market prices obey put-call parity. American and European call values coincide in the dividend-free case.

Catalog record

CREATORWenqing Zhang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE80 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-21115

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Discrete-time asset price bubbles with short sales prohibitions under model uncertainty Wenqing Zhang Abstract In this study, we investigate asset price bubbles in a discrete-time, discrete-state market under model uncertainty and short sales prohibitions. Building on a new fundamental theorem of asset pricing and a superhedging duality in this setting, we introduce a notion of bubble based on a novel definition of the fundamental price, and analyze their types and characterization. We show that two distinct types of bubbles arise, depending on the maturity structure of the asset. For assets with bounded maturity and no dividend payments, the G G -supermartingale property of prices provides a necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of bubbles. In contrast, when maturity is unbounded, the infi-supermartingale property yields a necessary condition, while the G G -supermartingale property remains sufficient. Moreover, there is no bubble under a strengthened no dominance condition. As applications, we examine price bubbles for several standard contingent claims. We show that put-call parity generally fails for fundamental prices, whereas it holds for market prices under no dominance assumption. Furthermore, we establish bounds for the fundamental and market prices of American call options in terms of the corresponding European call prices, adjusted by the associated bubble components. KEYWORDS: Asset price bubbles; Discrete time and states; Sublinear expectation; Short sales prohibitions; Contingent claims 1 Introduction Asset price bubbles have long attracted the attention of economists. Classical episodes, such as the Dutch Tulipmania, the Mississippi Bubble, and the South Sea Bubble, have been extensively documented and analyzed ( Garber 1990 ) . More recently, the bursting of the housing price bubble and its connection to the subprime mortgage crisis has renewed interest in bubble phenomena within both the financial industry and academic research ( Jarrow and Protter 2009 ; Jarrow et al. 2011a ) . In general terms, a bubble is a deviation between the trading price of an asset and its underlying value. The economic literature has examined this deviation from various perspectives in an attempt to explain why and under what conditions bubble arise. For example, Harrison and Kreps 1978 showed that speculative trading may cause prices to persistently exceed fundamental values. Other mechanisms contributing to bubble formation include traders’ myopic behavior ( Tirole 1982 ) , overconfidence ( Scheinkman and Xiong 2003 ) , trend-chasing behavior ( Föllmer et al. 2005 ) , and the presence of noise traders ( De Long et al. 1990 ) . In recent decades, a growing literature has leveraged tools from mathematical finance, particularly the theory of (local) martingale, to analyze asset price bubbles. The martingale approach originated from the seminal work of Loewenstein and Willard 2000 , who introduced a probabilistic framework for studying bubbles, and was further advanced by Cox and Hobson 2005 . Subsequently contributed include Jarrow et al. 2010 , who considered markets with time-varying local martingale measures, leading to results that differ markedly from classical theory, and Biagini et al. 2014 , who analyzed a flow of equivalent martingale measures under which an asset price initially behaves as a submartingale, later becomes a supermartingale, and eventually returns to zero. Parallel to these developmeants, numerous studies investigate bubbles across various asset classes, including forwards and futures ( Jarrow and Protter 2009 ) , equities ( Jarrow et al. 2011b ) , foreign exchange ( Jarrow and Protter 2011 ) , bonds ( Bilina-Falafala et al. 2016 ) , options ( Jarrow and Kwok 2021 ) , and so on ( Jarrow 2016 ) . Discrete-time frameworks also play a prominent role in the study of financial markets, owing to their structural simplicity and their closer correspondence to empirically observed price dynamics. Their tractability makes them especially suitable for modeling periodic collapses and drawdowns characteristic of bubble behavior ( Schatz and Sornette 2020 ) . From the perspective of financial mathematics, discrete-time models require special attention because strict local martingales and singular processes, central to many continuous-time bubble models, cannot arise; in discrete time, any nonnegative local martingale is necessarily a true martingale ( Jarrow and Protter 2012 ; Herdegen and Kreher 2022 ) . This necessitates a separate investigation of bubble phenomena in discrete time. Indeed, Santos and Woodford 1997 provided a systematic analysis of the conditions under which rational bubbles emerge in competitive equilibria; Fukuta 1998 studied incomplete bursting bubbles and their interrelationships; and Herdegen and Kreher 2022 proposed a new definition of bubbles in discrete-time models based on loss of mass in discounted asset prices. In addition to model structure, short sales restrictions paly a significant role in financial markets, as they help stabilize prices during financial crises and widely implemented in most emerging economies ( Pulido 2014 ) . However, short sales constraints may also facilitate the formation and persistence of asset price bubbles by impeding arbitrage and contributing to overvaluation ( Miller 1977 ; Jarrow 2019 ) , and the persistence of such bubbles has been explored in Lim 2011 . In addition, Hong et al. 2006 examined the relationship between asset float and bubbles under short sales constraints; and Kocherlakota 2008 constructed equilibrium allocations exhibiting bubbles induced by short sales limitations. Moreover, in many continuous-time models, admissibility conditions requiring wealth processes to remain bounded from below effectively impose implicit short sale constraints, permitting bubble phenomena in otherwise arbitrage-free settings ( Jarrow et al. 2010 ) . Despite the extensive literature on bubbles, relatively little attention has been paid to Knightian uncertainty, an intrinsic feature of modern financial markets. Knightian uncertainty can invalidate the classical risk-neutral pricing framework, potentially causing abtupt asset price movements without corresponding changes in fundamentals ( Epstein and Wang 1995 ) . To model such uncertainty, Peng 1997 ; Peng 2004 ; Peng 2006 ; Peng 2008 ; Peng 2019 introduced sublinear expectation theory, replacing the traditional single probability measure with a family of probability measures, thereby capturing both mean and volatility uncertainty. This framework has since been widely applied in financial modeling ( Epstein and Ji 2013 ; Epstein and Ji 2014 ; Peng and Yang 2022 ; Peng et al. 2023 ) . Within the context of asset price bubbles, Biagini and Mancin 2017 offered the first robust definition of asset price bubbles under model uncertainty, establishing fundamental properties of the bubble and analyzing how bubble existence depends on the investor’s set of priors. In contrast, our framework incorporates not only model uncertainty but also explicit short-sales constraints, leading to several novel and distinct conclusions. In this paper, we investigate discrete-time asset price bubbles under short selling constraints in the presence of model uncertainty. We consider a discrete state space \Omega=\{\omega_{k}\}_{k\in\mathbb{Z}^{+}} , and represent model uncertainty by a family of probability measures \mathcal{P} . Time is indexed discretely. For the traded asset, we introduce the discounted wealth process W associated with the market price S_{t} , the discounted dividend process \hat{D}_{t} and the discounted terminal payoff \hat{X}_{\tau} . Specifically, W_{t}=S_{t}I_{\{t<\tau\}}+\sum_{u=0}^{t\wedge\tau}\hat{D}_{u}+\hat{X}_{\tau}I_{\{\tau\leq t\}}. Let \pi denote the trading strategy in the asset, which is restricted to be nonnegative due to the short selling prohibition. The corresponding discounted value process is then V_{t}=\pi_{t}W_{t} . Within this framework, we establish a fundamental theorem of asset pricing under model uncertainty. We show that the absence

Read the complete text