Intrinsic limits of timekeeping precision in gene regulatory cascades
Juan Sebastián Hernández, César Nieto, Juan Manuel Pedraza, Abhyudai Singh · 2025
Read Intrinsic limits of timekeeping precision in gene regulatory cascades by Juan Sebastián Hernández, César Nieto, Juan Manuel Pedraza, Abhyudai Singh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-20933.txt.
Introduction
Juan Sebastian Hernandez, Cesar Nieto, Juan Manuel Pedraza, and Abhyudai Singh work out how precisely a cell can tell time. Many cellular events fire when a regulatory protein crosses a threshold, and real timers usually chain genes that switch each other on in sequence. Using a hybrid stochastic model of bursty production and dilution, the team derives when adding another gene to the chain sharpens timing and when it blurs it.
For two-gene cascades they find three regimes set by the noise levels and dilution rate. For cascades of identical genes, timing noise falls as the chain lengthens, provided the mean firing time grows too. The conditions define the intrinsic limits of biological timekeeping and give synthetic biologists a rule for how long a timer cascade should be.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Juan Sebastián Hernández, César Nieto, Juan Manuel Pedraza, Abhyudai Singh |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 50 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-20933
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Intrinsic limits of timekeeping precision in gene regulatory cascades Preprint: APS/123-QED Juan Sebastián Hernández, César Nieto, Juan Manuel Pedraza, Abhyudai Singh Abstract Multiple cellular processes are triggered when the concentration of a regulatory protein reaches a critical threshold. Previous analyses have characterized timing statistics for single-gene systems. However, many biological timers are based on cascades of genes that activate each other sequentially. Here, we develop an analytical framework to describe the timing precision of such cascades using a burst–dilution hybrid stochastic model. We first revisit the single-gene case and recover the known result of an optimal activation threshold that minimizes first-passage-time (FPT) variability. Extending this concept to two-gene cascades, we identify three distinct optimization regimes determined by the ratio of intrinsic noise levels and the protein dilution rate, defining when coupling improves or worsens timing precision compared to a single-gene strategy. Generalizing to cascades of arbitrary gene length, we obtain a simple mathematical condition that determines when a new gene in the cascade can decrease the timing noise based on its intrinsic noise and protein dilution rate. In the specific case of a cascade of identical genes, our analytical results predict suppression of FPT noise with increasing cascade length and the existence of a mean time that decreases relative timing fluctuations. Together, these results define the intrinsic limits of timekeeping precision in gene regulatory cascades and provide a minimal analytical framework to explore timing control in biological systems. I Introduction Cells regulate physiological processes by activating and deactivating molecular mechanisms. In many instances, activated molecules can activate other molecules through a regulatory cascade in which its final stage triggers a specific event. Relevant examples include gene expression systems such as the synthesis of molecules involved in the development of the flagellar motor in E. coli 31 , the lytic cycle of bacteriophages, viruses that infect bacteria, in which the components of new phages are synthesized sequentially 47 ; 32 , and the sequential synthesis of cyclins to define transitions between different stages of the cell cycle 30 . Similar mechanisms are also key in synthetic circuit design 15 . Furthermore, other types of cascades with a similar structure include the sequential activation of molecules in signaling processes, such as mitogen-activated protein (MAP) kinases, in which MAPKKK molecules when reaching a threshold concentration activate MAPKK molecules that, in turn, activate MAPK molecules 4 . This signaling process is a common trigger in cellular events such as proliferation, differentiation, and apoptosis 34 . In this article, we examine the timing process of gene expression cascades. The process begins with the induction of the first gene, which produces a protein that activates a second gene once a certain threshold concentration (activation threshold) is reached. This sequential cascade of multiple genes continues, with each gene activating the next, until the timekeeping process concludes when the last gene reaches its respective threshold, as depicted by Fig. 1 . Since each step depends on the accumulation of molecules to a threshold, cascades inherently introduce a delay between signal initiation and the final response. Therefore, with proper parameter settings, regulatory cascades can be used to manage the timing of molecular events 39 ; 1 . However, the stochastic nature of these molecular processes, such as the intrinsic random noise in the levels of proteins involved in cascades 13 and in their respective activation thresholds 11 ; 6 , can disrupt the precision of these timers. In fact, the malfunction of these mechanisms can dramatically affect cellular function 33 . This motivates the study of how different architectures and variables within the cascade system can influence the accuracy of these molecular timers and which parameters can generate the most accurate timing statistics 51 . The performance of biomolecular timing systems is usually described in terms of the statistics of the first-passage time (FPT) 19 , defined as the time interval between the initiation of a process and the achievement of the goal, typically reaching a threshold concentration. To study the threshold crossing dynamics, multiple mathematical frameworks have been developed to study the stochasticity of the gene product levels 14 ; 50 ; 37 ; 40 . Theoretical approaches include discrete frameworks such as the birth-death process and chemical master equation (CME) formulations 41 , continuous-valued approaches based on stochastic differential equations 44 , and stochastic hybrid systems, with the burst–dilution representation being one of the simplest and easiest to manipulate analytically 48 . These models have been successfully applied to a wide range of regulatory systems, including self-regulation 19 ; 9 ; 11 ; 42 , regulation by product degradation 43 , sRNA-mediated control 2 , sequestration 7 and phage lysis timing 26 ; 27 , showing that these simplified representations produce useful, testable predictions despite biological approximations. A fundamental result of these theories is that a shorter molecular half-life, related to gene product dilution or spontaneous degradation, reduces clock accuracy 19 ; 42 . As a result, in a context with non-zero degradation/dilution, there is an optimal threshold that minimizes FPT variability 11 ; 36 . This prediction has been experimentally verified in a single-gene cascade 27 and currently the existence of these optimal activation thresholds is not clear in cascades of an arbitrary number of genes. To date, most FPT studies have derived exact analytical results to single-gene cascades 44 . Other approximations estimated optimal parameters for self-regulation motifs and timers based on protein degradation 19 ; 35 ; 43 ; 12 . Finally, there are numerical solutions to the two-gene system with self regulation 24 ; 23 Experimentally, multiple-gene cascade studies (notably the lytic pathway of \lambda -phage in E. coli ) reveal that for a cascade of a given number of genes, as the cascade progresses, the FPT variance increases, while the coefficient of variation decreases 3 . This suggests that a higher temporal precision can be achieved with a large number of fast steps in the cascade. However, it is still unclear what specific properties each cascade species (genes) must commit to enhance timing precision or how to estimate optimal activation threshold to minimize the FPT noise. These open questions motivate the need for a general analytical description of timing in gene expression networks beyond one or two genes. In this manuscript, by modeling the gene expression process as a burst-dilution hybrid stochastic system, we derive an analytical approximation for the noise in the cascade’s FPT. These formulas depend on the intrinsic noise and the activation threshold of each cascade gene. Solving the optimization problem with a fixed mean FPT we obtain simple expressions for the optimal activation threshold levels, along with the conditions that a new gene must meet in order to improve the cascade timekeeping performance. The article is structured as follows: In Section II we introduce the theoretical framework. In Section III , we revisit the optimization problem in a single-gene cascade. In Section IV , we solve as an example the two-species cascade. We explain how, depending on the intrinsic noise of gene expression and the protein dilution rate, a two-gene cascade could perform better than a single-gene cascade. In Section V we generalize our results to a cascade with an arbitrary number of species finding the ranges of