Scaling Symmetry and Carrollian Gravity

Hamid Afshar , Mehdi Ahmadi-Jahmani · 2025

Read Scaling Symmetry and Carrollian Gravity by Hamid Afshar , Mehdi Ahmadi-Jahmani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-20736.txt.

Introduction

Hamid Afshar and Mehdi Ahmadi-Jahmani work on Carrollian gravity, a version of gravity suited to settings where light cones collapse and motion behaves very differently from everyday physics. They add matter and a scaling symmetry, then recast the whole setup as a gauge theory, a framework that builds theories from symmetry rules.

Their construction loosens one conformal symmetry and enlarges the set of gravity fields. After fixing the scaling freedom, a few fields govern the theory, including a vector field tied to size changes. Suitable gauge choices then recover several known descriptions, among them Carrollian and Aristotelian pictures. The result unifies views that looked separate before.

Catalog record

CREATORHamid Afshar , Mehdi Ahmadi-Jahmani
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE85 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-20736

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Scaling Symmetry and Carrollian Gravity Hamid Afshar , Mehdi Ahmadi-Jahmani Abstract We formulate matter-coupled scaling–Carroll gravity as a gauge theory and analyze its associated gravity multiplet. After fixing the scaling symmetry, the theory is governed by the trace of the extrinsic curvature, the Carroll boost symmetry, and a vector field descending from dilatations. We show that appropriate gauge choices and geometric constraints lead to distinct regimes, including dynamical Carroll gravity, Aristotelian gravity, and a fracton gauge theory coupled to Aristotelian geometry. In the fracton phase, the Carroll boost parameter plays the role of a vector-charge gauge symmetry. 1 Introduction Carrollian geometry is the geometric structure induced on null hypersurfaces of Lorentzian spacetimes Henneaux:1979vn ; Hartong:2015xda ; Ciambelli:2025unn . Any null slice carries a degenerate temporal metric and a spatial metric whose combination defines a Carroll manifold Duval:2014uoa ; Duval:2014lpa ; Herfray:2021qmp ; Ciambelli:2025unn . This makes Carrollian geometry an essential ingredient in several areas of gravitational physics. Most notably, boundary field theories appearing in flat space holography naturally couple to a Carrollian background, positioning Carroll geometry as the appropriate framework for understanding holography in asymptotically flat spacetimes Duval:2014uva ; Nguyen:2023vfz ; Bagchi:2023cen ; Donnay:2023mrd . The interest in this setting is further strengthened by the fact that the Carroll algebra admits infinite-dimensional conformal extensions Duval:2014uoa ; Afshar:2024llh ; Despontin:2025dog , which arise as the asymptotic symmetry algebras of asymptotically flat spacetimes Duval:2014uva . A closely related setting arises at black hole event horizons, which themselves are null hypersurfaces Donnay:2019jiz ; Ecker:2023uwm ; Bagchi:2023cfp . Beyond gravitational applications, Carrollian structures have also emerged in field theoretic and condensed matter contexts. In particular, Carrollian kinematics appear in descriptions of fractonic matter Bidussi:2021nmp ; Baig:2023yaz ; Kasikci:2023tvs ; Figueroa-OFarrill:2023vbj ; Figueroa-OFarrill:2023qty ; Ahmadi-Jahmani:2025iqc . Our work focuses on the systematic construction of Carrollian local invariants, providing a natural framework for gravitational dynamics in Carrollian geometry. A useful technique for constructing such invariants is the conformal method, which is based on gauging a conformal extension of a kinematical Lie algebra (Carroll algebra in this case) and introducing compensating multiplets that transform under conformal transformations. By gauge fixing some components of the compensator, one eliminates redundant conformal symmetries and obtains the desired invariant. A similar method has also been applied successfully in non-relativistic contexts, such as Newton-Cartan Afshar:2015aku ; Abedini:2019voz and Hořava-Lifshitz gravity Afshar:2015aku ; Devecioglu:2018apj , and more recently in the Carrollian and Aristotelian contexts Bergshoeff:2024ilz ; Bergshoeff:2025qtt . Carroll gravity theories can be derived from the ultra-relativistic limit of General Relativity (GR), where the speed of light is taken to zero Dautcourt:1997hb ; Hartong:2015xda ; Bergshoeff:2017btm . When this limit is applied to the Einstein–Hilbert action, it gives rise to two distinct sectors: the electric Carrollian limit and the magnetic Carrollian limit Henneaux:2021yzg ; Guerrieri:2021cdz . These two sectors have been recovered as the leading and the next-to-leading order of the Einstein-Hilbert action in powers of c , respectively Dautcourt:1997hb ; Hansen:2021fxi . Carrollian theories of gravity can also appear from gauging the Carroll algebra Hartong:2015xda ; Bergshoeff:2017btm ; Guerrieri:2021cdz ; Figueroa-OFarrill:2022mcy , which similarly yields electric and magnetic sectors Campoleoni:2022ebj . The distinction between these two sectors is geometrically encoded in the intrinsic torsion of the Carroll structure (\tau^{\mu},h_{\mu\nu}) Figueroa-OFarrill:2020gpr . The intrinsic torsion of the Carroll structure, in the magnetic Carroll gravity has to be zero and thus the space is absolute Campoleoni:2022ebj , whereas electric Carroll gravity corresponds to a torsional phase where the space can be dynamical Hartong:2015xda ; Musaeus:2023oyp . Our Carrollian conformal construction is based on gauging the anisotropic scaling Carroll symmetry and allows for both electric and magnetic gravity sectors as solutions. Our conformal construction couples a real compensating scalar \phi to scaling-Carroll gravity, preserving local Carroll and z -scaling symmetries while excluding Carrollian special conformal transformations (SCTs). This relaxation of symmetry constraints is crucial, it allows for the introduction of an additional spatial vector b_{a} originating from the dilatation gauge field. After gauge fixing \phi=1 , (which gauge fixes dilatation symmetry and yields dynamical Carroll gravity), this vector acquires a shift transformation under Carroll boosts proportional to the trace of the extrinsic curvature K . As a result, when K\neq 0 , one can construct boost-invariant combinations and access more general torsional geometries than in standard conformal Carroll frameworks. Depending on how the boost symmetry and the residual vector field b_{a} are treated after fixing the scale symmetry, our construction naturally interpolates between distinct geometric regimes. In particular, when K\neq 0 , fixing the boost symmetry via gauge fixing condition b_{a}=0 leads to Aristotelian gravity, while keeping it unfixed and imposing a Frobenius condition on the clock one-form \tau gives rise to a fractonic sector coupled to Aristotelian spacetime, with the Carroll boost parameter playing the role of a vector-charge gauge symmetry. This provides a unified framework for Carrollian gravity, Aristotelian geometry, and fractonic dynamics within a single geometric setup. The relations between these regimes are summarized in Fig. 1 . Scaling–Carroll Gauge Theory Dynamical Carroll Gravity Aristotelian Gravity Fracton Gravity \phi=1 b_{a}=0 \tau\wedge\mathrm{d}\tau=0 Figure 1: Schematic relation between different regimes arising from scaling–Carroll gauge theory. Fixing \phi=1 gauge fixes the dilatation and yields dynamical Carroll gravity. For K\neq 0 , imposing b_{a}=0 in the dynamical Carroll gravity, gauge fixes the boost and leads to Aristotelian gravity, while for b_{a}\neq 0 imposing hypersurface orthogonality results in a fracton gauge theory coupled to Aristotelian geometry. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 , we review the geometric structure of Carrollian manifolds, including the role of the extrinsic curvature and torsional extensions that naturally arise in the ultra-relativistic limit. Section 3 presents the scaling-Carroll algebra and its gauging, establishing the framework for implementing local Carroll and scale symmetries. In Section 4 , we introduce the conformal construction with a compensating scalar field, which allows the systematic generation of Carrollian local invariants. Then we analyze the different emergent geometric and physical regimes — Carrollian, Aristotelian, and fractonic — that arise. Section 5 develops the corresponding Carrollian gravity theory, including scaling-Carroll field theories and curvature invariants Finally, Section 6 summarizes our results and outlines possible directions for future research. Notation and convention. We work in D=d+1 space-time dimensions, where d refers to the number of spatial dimensions. The small Latin alphabet letters (a,b,c,\cdots) refer to the spatial local Carroll frame The Greek indices (\mu,\nu,\rho,\cdots) refer to the coordinate frame and labels all spacetime coordinates (x^{\mu}\equiv t,x^{i}) where i=1,\cdots,d . We sometimes use A\cdot B to represent the contraction of the spatial indices in A and B . 2 Carrollian extrinsic curvature The Carrollian structure in a (d+1) -dimensional spacetime is described by a degenerate metric h_{\mu\nu} of rank d and the nowhere-vanishing unit vector field \tau^{\mu} . The kernel of this tensor field is generated by the nowhere-vanishing vector field \tau^{\mu} \displaystyle h_{\mu\nu}\tau^{\mu}=0\,. (2.1) The inverse tensors \tau_{\mu} and h^{\mu\nu} can be defined through the following orthonormality and completeness relations \displaystyle\tau_{\mu}\tau^{\mu}=1\,,\qquad\tau_{\mu}h^{\mu\nu}=\tau^{\mu}h_{\mu\nu}=0\,,\qquad\delta_{\mu}^{\nu}=\tau_{\mu}\tau^{\nu}+h^{\nu\rho}h_{\rho\mu}\,, (2.2) where \tau_{\mu} is a nowhere-vanishing covector that defines the temporal direction. Thus, h_{\mu\nu} acts as a projector onto the spatial directions orthogonal to it. The vector \tau^{\mu} and the metric h_{\mu\nu} are by definition invariant under local homogeneous Carroll transformation. In fact,

Read the complete text