Kinetic Theory of Multicomponent Ostwald Ripening in Porous Media
Nicolas Bueno, Luis F. Ayala, Yashar Mehmani · 2025
Read Kinetic Theory of Multicomponent Ostwald Ripening in Porous Media by Nicolas Bueno, Luis F. Ayala, Yashar Mehmani (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-20665.txt.
Introduction
Nicolas Bueno, Luis F Ayala, and Yashar Mehmani write the first kinetic theory of bubbles trading mass underground. In porous rock, trapped gas bubbles differ in size and composition; through Ostwald ripening, big bubbles grow at the expense of small ones. Underground hydrogen storage, with its cycles of fragmented gas, is the motivating application.
Single-component theories existed for porous media, but mixtures had none. The new formulation tracks a number-density function over a three-dimensional state space of pore size, bubble saturation, and composition. A population balance equation, closed by mean-field approximations respecting pore-size correlations and mass conservation, governs the evolution. Validation against pore-network simulations across four network types agrees well with no adjustable parameters. Predictions can now exceed the pore scale.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Nicolas Bueno, Luis F. Ayala, Yashar Mehmani |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 108 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-20665
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Kinetic Theory of Multicomponent Ostwald Ripening in Porous Media Nicolas Bueno, Luis F. Ayala, Yashar Mehmani Abstract Partially miscible bubble populations trapped in porous media are ubiquitous in subsurface applications such as underground hydrogen storage (UHS), where cyclic injections fragment gas into numerous bubbles with distributions of sizes and compositions. These bubbles exchange mass through Ostwald ripening, driven by differences in composition and interfacial curvature. While kinetic theories have been developed for single-component ripening in porous media, accounting for bubble deformation and spatial correlations in pore size, no such theory exists for multicomponent systems. We present the first kinetic theory for multicomponent Ostwald ripening of bubbles in porous media. The formulation describes the bubble population with a number-density function g ( s , t ) g(s;t) in a 3D statistical space of bubble states s = ( R p , S b , y ) s\!=\!(R_{p},S^{b},y) , consisting of pore size, bubble saturation, and composition. Evolution is governed by a population balance equation with closure through mean-field approximations that account for spatial correlations in pore size and ensure mass conservation. The theory generalizes previous single-component formulations, removing key limitations such as the inability to capture interactions between distant bubbles. Systematic validation against pore-network simulations across homogeneous, heterogeneous, correlated, and uncorrelated networks demonstrates good agreement without adjustable parameters. Pending challenges and limitations are discussed. Since the theory imposes no constraints on bubble count or correlation length, it enables predictions beyond the pore scale. 1 Introduction Partially miscible bubble populations trapped inside porous media are ubiquitous, with applications in underground hydrogen storage (UHS) 11 , geologic CO 2 sequestration 1 , removal of nonaqueous phase liquids from groundwater (NAPL) 13 , bubble/water management in fuel cells and electrolyzers 23 , 19 , and air-water mass transfer in soils 12 . This work is motivated specifically by UHS, where H 2 is seasonally injected into and withdrawn from an aquifer to buffer the intermittency of renewable energy sources (e.g., solar, wind). Cyclic injections during periods of peak and low demand (i.e., summer and winter) subject the porous medium to repeated drainage and imbibition that fragment the H 2 into numerous bubbles. Since the first cycle is often preceded by injecting a cushion gas (e.g., CO 2 , N 2 , CH 4 ), trapped bubbles end up with a distribution of sizes and compositions 10 . Due to chemical potential differences, these bubbles are in disequilibrium and exchange mass to equilibrate. Two factors contribute to a bubble’s chemical potential: composition and interfacial curvature (assuming surface tension is constant, as we do here). These induce different dissolved concentrations of each species at the interface of each bubble, driving mass transfer by molecular diffusion. Such mass exchange between bubbles is called Ostwald ripening 28 , which we aim to describe theoretically. Ostwald ripening has been studied extensively in bulk fluids, where bubbles are always spherical with curvature \kappa inversely proportional to radius R 22 , 36 , 35 , 34 , 4 . When comprised of only one component, mass transfer between bubbles is purely curvature-driven. A hallmark of such ripening is that all bubbles coarsen into a single large bubble, because any configuration with more than one bubble has further room to minimize surface energy by reducing bubble count. Extensions to multicomponent bubbles in bulk fluids have also been made, where inter-bubble mass transfer is more complex 27 , 18 , 29 , 16 . By contrast, studies of ripening in porous media are a recent development and have focused almost exclusively on single-component bubbles. Early microfluidic experiments 37 and pore-network modeling 8 , 25 of single-component ripening revealed that equilibration is far more complex within the confinement of a porous medium. A bubble population in disequilibrium no longer evolves toward a single bubble, but toward another population with different bubble volumes V^{b} and uniform curvature \kappa . This is because confinement exerts first-order control on \kappa , rendering it a non-monotonic function of V^{b} —not so for spherical bubbles. Subsequent advances in pore-scale modeling 24 , 14 , 32 , 31 , microfluidic experiments 15 , 30 , and in-situ X-ray \mu CT observations 40 , 33 , 3 have provided further evidence of ripening in complex microstructures, shed insight into controlling factors (e.g., pore-size distribution, wettability, initial condition), and enabled higher-fidelity simulations. Theories developed for single-component ripening fall into two categories: pore-scale and continuum . Continuum theories 20 , 26 , 30 describe how trapped-bubble saturation evolves due to gradients in \kappa or capillary pressure P_{c} at large scales. They have been used to assess the timescale and trajectory of bubble redistribution due to gravity and geothermal gradients 38 , 9 , 2 , 21 . Crucially, continuum theories assume local equilibrium within each representative elementary volume (REV). Pore-scale theories, by contrast, can capture the kinetics prior to local equilibrium and predict population statistics of bubbles, providing far more detail than a single aggregate quantity like saturation. The present work focuses on developing a pore-scale theory. Pore-scale theories build upon the seminal works by Lifshitz & Slyozov 22 and Wagner 36 (LSW) for single-component bubbles in bulk fluids. The idea is to introduce a bubble number-density function g(R) that describes the statistical distribution of bubble radii R and evolve it with a population balance equation: \frac{\partial g}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial}{\partial R}(g\frac{dR}{dt})=0 (1) Here, dR/dt is the rate of change of radius for bubbles with radius R , which we refer to as the phase velocity (i.e., velocity in the 1D statistical space of R ). It is computed by assuming each bubble interacts with a mean field that represents the rest of the population. For bubbles with radius R , the phase velocity reads: \frac{dR}{dt}\propto\frac{1}{R}({x^{mf}-x})\propto\frac{1}{R}({\frac{1}{R_{c}}-\frac{1}{R}}) (2) where x is the dissolved concentration next to the R -bubble and x^{mf} is the mean-field concentration. Since x is proportional to \kappa (or P_{c} ) by Henry’s law, and \kappa\!\propto\!1/R by Young-Laplace for spherical bubbles, the second proportionality in Eq. 2 follows. Note x^{mf}\!\propto\!1/R_{c} , where R_{c} is the critical radius below which bubbles shrink and above which they grow. R_{c} is a property of the mean field and equals the average radius of all bubbles in the population, obtained by imposing mass conservation on the total mass of bubbles. The factor 1/R can be viewed as the “distance” of the mean field from an R -bubble. LSW further showed that g(R) approaches a self-similar regime described by g(R)\!=\!R_{c}^{-4}f(R/R_{c}) , where f(\cdot) is a complicated function. The first extension of LSW theory to porous media was proposed by Yu et al. 39 , under the assumption that trapped bubbles remain spherical throughout ripening. Therefore, the only difference from bulk fluids is that the pore network topology imposes a fixed distance across which bubbles interact. When this distance, l , is set to some multiple of the throat length l_{t} , Eq. 2 becomes: \frac{dR}{dt}\propto\frac{1}{l_{t}}({x^{mf}-x})\propto\frac{1}{l_{t}}({\frac{1}{R_{c}}-\frac{1}{R}}) (3) although l continuously grows with time as bubbles dissolve and disappear. Yu and co-workers derived similar self-similar solutions for g(R) and showed that R_{c} is now the harmonic average of all R in the population (again obtained by imposing mass conservation). Note that since bubble deformation by porous confinement is neglected,