How Feasible are Passive Network Attacks on 5G Networks and Beyond? A Survey

Atmane Ayoub Mansour Bahar, , Andrés Alayón Glazunov, , Romaric Duvignau · 2025

Read How Feasible are Passive Network Attacks on 5G Networks and Beyond? A Survey by Atmane Ayoub Mansour Bahar, , Andrés Alayón Glazunov, , Romaric Duvignau (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-20622.txt.

Introduction

Atmane Ayoub Mansour Bahar, Andrés Alayón Glazunov, and Romaric Duvignau survey the quietest kind of network attack. Passive attackers never touch the target network; they only listen, which makes them nearly impossible to detect. From the traffic they can fingerprint websites and applications, identify systems and users, and track positions.

Such attacks are well documented on Wi-Fi and, to a lesser extent, LTE. For 5G, theory says they remain possible, but directional beamforming, high-frequency propagation, and encryption constrain them severely in practice. For beyond-5G and early 6G, no public tools exist and hardware costs are prohibitive, so the attacks are currently infeasible. The survey flags a threat-model gap: future networks are being designed before their passive-attack surface is understood.

Catalog record

CREATORAtmane Ayoub Mansour Bahar, , Andrés Alayón Glazunov, , Romaric Duvignau
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE97 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-20622

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

How Feasible are Passive Network Attacks on 5G Networks and Beyond? A Survey Atmane Ayoub Mansour Bahar, , Andrés Alayón Glazunov, , Romaric Duvignau Abstract Privacy concerns around 5G, the latest generation of mobile networks, are growing, with fears that its deployment may increase exposure to privacy risks. This perception is largely driven by the use of denser deployments of small antenna systems, which enable highly accurate data collection at higher speeds and closer proximity to mobile users. At the same time, 5G’s unique radio communication features can make the reproduction of known network attacks more challenging. In particular, passive network attacks, which do not involve direct interaction with the target network and are therefore nearly impossible to detect, remain a pressing concern. Such attacks can reveal sensitive information about users, their devices, and active applications, which may then be exploited through known vulnerabilities or spear-phishing schemes. This survey examines the feasibility of passive network attacks in 5G and beyond (B5G/6G) networks, with emphasis on two major categories: information extraction (system identification, website and application fingerprinting) and geolocation (user identification and position tracking). These attacks are well documented and reproducible in existing wireless and mobile systems, including short-range networks (IEEE 802.11) and, to a lesser extent, LTE. Current evidence suggests that while such attacks remain theoretically possible in 5G, their practical execution is significantly constrained by directional beamforming, high-frequency propagation characteristics, and encryption mechanisms. For B5G and early 6G networks, the lack of public tools and high hardware cost currently renders these attacks infeasible in practice, which highlights a critical gap in our understanding of future network threat models. I Introduction Privacy protection [ 77 ] has become an increasingly important concern in the past decade, reinforced by the advent of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and similar legislation. In particular, there is growing concern that 5G [ 39 , 6 ] , the latest generation of mobile networks, is more vulnerable to privacy risks and eavesdropping (see Fig. 1 for an illustration). This belief is largely driven by the denser deployment of small antenna systems positioned closer to mobile users, which enable faster, more accurate data transmission with lower latency [ 45 , 63 , 88 , 89 ] . At the same time, through beamforming and massive MIMO (Multiple Input Multiple Output), 5G’s New Radio communications are much more directional than in previous generations, which makes the reproduction of known attacks significantly more challenging in this environment [ 53 ] . Consequently, it remains unclear whether 5G and beyond 5G (B5G/6G) networks pose greater or lesser privacy risks compared with other forms of wireless communication and earlier cellular standards. Fig. 1: Eavesdropping on cellular communications at the edge. In parallel, the volume of data generated by internet-connected devices has sharply increased. Combined with greater data availability and advances in machine learning (ML) technologies, this growth enables the identification of individual mobile users and their behaviors with high accuracy [ 66 , 67 , 20 , 2 , 52 ] . Such information mining increasingly relies on subtle user data, particularly encrypted network traces. These traces, which act as a side-channel of wireless communication, are continuously produced, difficult to control, and therefore an attractive target. Analyzing them, a process referred to as network trace analysis , enables the design of entirely passive attack schemes , which do not require any interaction with the attacked network. Because these attacks only extract information from network logs, they are practically impossible for victims to detect. Nevertheless, they can create serious security risks, as the extracted information may be exploited to target known or even zero-day vulnerabilities in software or network protocols. Even more concerning is that such passive attacks are relatively easy to set up, potentially enabling individuals without advanced networking expertise to acquire private information about victims. This opens the door to spear-phishing schemes, such as sending fake job offers after detecting traffic from a job-seeking application, proposing fraudulent medical treatments, or even attempting direct blackmail based on visited websites [ 54 ] . Challenges for attackers The main objectives of packet trace analysis include traffic classification (see Fig. 2 for an illustration), user identification and localization, website fingerprinting, application recognition, and data-content inference. In general, only acquiring information from side-channel data is inherently difficult. When communication is encrypted at the link layer, information extraction becomes even more challenging. Eavesdropping on cellular communications is particularly demanding not only because of such encryption, but also due to the limited availability of commercially sold capture interfaces, the scarcity of open-source tools, the noisier characteristics of wireless channels, and the higher variability of network traces. Fig. 2: Illustration of encrypted traffic classification from captured traces. Motivations for this survey Packet trace analysis over encrypted communication channels poses serious societal challenges. This work surveys the current landscape of existing and potential Passive Network Attacks (PNAs), with the aim of informing the design of countermeasures before such attacks are widely deployed. A careful study of these possible attacks can also encourage the early adoption of necessary updates in wireless protocols and standards. The primary motivation of this survey is to provide a clearer understanding of privacy concerns in 5G and B5G networks [ 41 , 59 ] , thereby addressing public apprehension surrounding their deployment. By offering a qualitative analysis of privacy risks, this work seeks to reduce popular concerns about new wireless technologies, which in turn can help increase public acceptance and accelerate the development and deployment of both current and future network generations. Contributions By surveying 41 works from literature, this work investigates the feasibility of PNAs on 5G and B5G networks. Particular emphasis is placed on information extraction related to users’ devices (e.g., system identification, website fingerprinting, and application fingerprinting) and on users’ geographical position [ 100 ] (e.g., device tracking). The survey primarily considers attacks that have already been demonstrated in wireless networks, either in short-range technologies or LTE cellular systems. However, it remains unclear whether these attacks can be easily adapted to 5G, since the new radio characteristics of 5G enable highly directional communication compared with earlier generation, requiring attackers to be in close proximity to their targets for effective eavesdropping [ 49 ] . It is also uncertain whether they will transfer to B5G, which builds upon the capabilities of today’s 5G environments [ 35 ] . To the best of our knowledge, this survey is the first to provide a comprehensive evaluation of the feasibility of passive network attacks in 5G and B5G communications, and it contributes to clarifying public concerns about potential weaknesses in privacy protection in these networks. Plan Section II introduces key concepts and surveys related work as well as previous studies on PNAs in mobile networks. Section III provides an overview of PNAs, while Section IV discusses the main characteristics and distinguishing features of 5G communications. Section V presents a taxonomy of PNAs, categorizing attacks by their targets and required capabilities. Section VI is our core contribution: a detailed review of prior attack schemes and an assessment of their feasibility in 5G and B5G environments. Finally, Section VII concludes the paper and outlines directions for future work. II Background and Related Work We present

Read the complete text