An Explicit dg–Lie Model Governing Jordan Algebra Deformations

Vincent E. Coll, Jr · 2025

Read An Explicit dg–Lie Model Governing Jordan Algebra Deformations by Vincent E. Coll, Jr (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19975.txt.

Introduction

Vincent Coll builds concrete algebra for bending Jordan algebras. These nonassociative algebras were born from quantum mechanics. A quartic identity, the Jordan identity, governs them. He works over a field of characteristic zero. There, the identity matches its standard four-variable polarization. He codes that polarization as a cubic map in the product itself. He calls it the Jordan defect. It vanishes just when the product is truly Jordan.

Linearizing the defect yields a deformation complex in low degrees. Three spaces are joined by two maps. The second cohomology sorts small deformations up to sameness. A named obstruction space holds the main block to extending them. Coll is plain about scope. The build takes only the low-degree part of the full theory. The revised text adds clear examples.

Catalog record

CREATORVincent E. Coll, Jr
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE16 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19975

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

An Explicit dg–Lie Model Governing Jordan Algebra Deformations Vincent E. Coll, Jr Abstract Over a field of characteristic 0 0 we place the deformation theory of Jordan algebras on a concrete, computation–friendly differential graded Lie algebra. On the symmetric cochains C n ​ ( J ) = Sym n ​ ( J ∨ ) ⊗ J C^{n}(J)=\mathrm{Sym}^{n}(J^{\vee})\otimes J we define an unshuffle–averaged insertion whose commutator is a graded Lie bracket. For the Jordan product μ ∈ C 2 ​ ( J ) \mu\in C^{2}(J) the differential d μ = [ μ , ⋅ ] d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] governs deformations. We prove that [ μ , μ ] = 0 [\mu,\mu]=0 is equivalent to the Jordan identity (via polarization), hence d μ 2 = 0 d_{\mu}^{2}=0 , and record the standard Maurer–Cartan/gauge recursion together with low–degree coboundary formulas. A small two–dimensional unital example is worked out explicitly. The note is deliberately lean and self–contained. MSC 2020. 17C10, 13D10, 16W99. Keywords. Jordan algebras; deformation theory; differential graded Lie algebra; Maurer–Cartan equation. 1 Introduction Let (J,\circ) be a Jordan algebra over a field k of characteristic 0 . A Jordan algebra over k is a k –vector space J equipped with a bilinear product \circ:J\times J\to J that is commutative, x\circ y=y\circ x , and satisfies the Jordan identity (x\circ x)\circ(y\circ x)=x\circ(x\circ(y\circ x))\quad\text{for all }x,y\in J. If there exists an element e\in J such that e\circ x=x for all x\in J , we call J unital and refer to e as the unit. The deformation theory of Jordan algebras was developed classically by McCrimmon through linearization of the Jordan identity and explicit construction of cochain complexes and coboundary operators; see, for example, [ 4 , §I.3] and related papers. In this approach, cocycles and obstructions are described by polynomial identities written degree by degree, and deformation theory is formulated without reference to an underlying bracket or Maurer–Cartan formalism. A central principle of modern deformation theory is that formal deformations of an algebraic structure are governed by a differential graded Lie algebra (dg–Lie algebra): Maurer–Cartan elements encode deformations, cohomology controls infinitesimal deformations and obstructions, and gauge equivalence corresponds to equivalence of deformations. For associative algebras this role is played by the Gerstenhaber complex, and for Lie algebras by the Nijenhuis–Richardson bracket. Aim. The purpose of this note is to place Jordan algebra deformations into this dg–Lie framework. Working on the symmetric cochains C^{n}(J)=\mathrm{Sym}^{n}(J^{\vee})\otimes J, we define an explicit unshuffle–averaged insertion whose graded commutator is a Lie bracket. For a Jordan product \mu\in C^{2}(J) , the operator d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] defines a differential. We show that the Maurer–Cartan condition [\mu,\mu]=0 is equivalent to the Jordan identity, via polarization in characteristic 0 . Consequently, the resulting dg–Lie algebra governs formal deformations of (J,\circ) in the standard sense. From this perspective, the classical Jordan coboundary operator of McCrimmon arises naturally as the inner derivation d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] , while higher–order deformation equations and gauge equivalence are encoded uniformly by the Maurer–Cartan formalism. The presentation here is deliberately concrete and self–contained, with all formulas written explicitly for direct computation. 2 Introduction Let (J,\circ) be a Jordan algebra over a field k . A Jordan algebra over k is a k –vector space J equipped with a bilinear product \circ:J\times J\to J that is commutative, x\circ y=y\circ x , and satisfies the Jordan identity (x\circ x)\circ(y\circ x)=x\circ(x\circ(y\circ x))\quad\text{for all }x,y\in J. If there exists an element e\in J such that e\circ x=x for all x\in J , we call J unital and refer to e as the unit. Throughout we assume \operatorname{char}k=0 so that averaging over symmetric groups and polarization identities are valid (small characteristics 2,3 require adjusted normalizations). A central principle in deformation theory is that formal deformations of a law \mu are governed by a differential graded Lie algebra (dgLA): Maurer–Cartan elements encode deformations; cohomology controls obstructions. For associative algebras this is Gerstenhaber’s complex, and for Lie algebras the Nijenhuis–Richardson bracket. Relation to classical Jordan cohomology. Jordan algebra cohomology and deformation theory were developed classically by McCrimmon via linearized polynomial identities and explicit coboundary operators written degree by degree. The present note does not rederive that theory from first principles; rather, it places Jordan deformations in a differential graded Lie algebra on symmetric cochains whose Maurer–Cartan elements correspond exactly to Jordan products. In particular, the classical Jordan differential appears here as an inner derivation d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] , giving a conceptual Maurer–Cartan and gauge framework not present in the original formulations. Aim. We give an explicit dgLA for Jordan algebras on the symmetric cochains C^{\bullet}(J)=\mathrm{Sym}^{\bullet}(J^{\vee})\otimes J . The insertion is an unshuffle–average adapted to symmetric inputs; its commutator is a graded Lie bracket. Setting d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] for \mu(x,y)=x\circ y yields the controlling differential. We prove [\mu,\mu]=0 \Longleftrightarrow the Jordan identity (Theorem 3.4 ), so d_{\mu}^{2}=0 ; in fact (d_{\mu})^{2}=\frac{1}{2}\mathrm{ad}_{[\mu,\mu]} (Proposition 3.5 ), a standard graded–Lie identity whose proof is included in Appendix B . Everything needed for computation is contained in § 3 –§ 5 . Conventions. For F(x,y,z) we write \displaystyle\sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}F(x,y,z):=F(x,y,z)+F(y,z,x)+F(z,x,y) . The graded commutator uses the convention [f,g]=-(-1)^{|f||g|}[g,f] . 3 The governing dg–Lie complex Fix \operatorname{char}k=0 . Write \mu(x,y)=x\circ y for the symmetric product on J . Cochains and degrees C^{n}(J):=\mathrm{Sym}^{n}(J^{\vee})\otimes J\qquad(n\geq 0),\qquad|f|:=n-1\ \text{ for }f\in C^{n}(J). Insertion and bracket For f\in C^{m}(J) , g\in C^{n}(J) define the unshuffle–averaged insertion (f\!\circ g)(x_{1},\dots,x_{m+n-1}):=\frac{1}{(m-1)!\,n!}\!\!\sum_{\sigma\in\mathrm{Sh}(m-1,n)}f\big(x_{\sigma(1)},\dots,x_{\sigma(m-1)},\,g(x_{\sigma(m)},\dots,x_{\sigma(m+n-1)})\big), (3.1) where \mathrm{Sh}(p,q)\subset S_{p+q} denotes (p,q) –unshuffles. Set the graded commutator [f,g]:=f\!\circ g-(-1)^{|f||g|}\,g\!\circ f. Lemma 3.1 (Insertion preserves symmetry) . If f\in C^{m}(J) and g\in C^{n}(J) are totally symmetric, then (f\circ g)\in C^{m+n-1}(J) is totally symmetric. In particular, C^{\bullet}(J) is closed under \circ and under [\ ,\ ] . Proof. For any \pi\in S_{m+n-1} , relabel the inputs by \pi . The set \mathrm{Sh}(m-1,n) is stable under the induced relabeling, and symmetry of f and g allows reordering their arguments without changing values; the averaging factor is unchanged. Thus (f\circ g)\circ\pi=(f\circ g) . ∎ Lemma 3.2 . With ( 3.1 ), C^{\bullet}(J) is a graded right pre–Lie algebra, hence [\ ,\ ] satisfies the graded Jacobi identity and C^{\bullet}(J)[1] is a graded Lie algebra. Proof sketch. This is the standard pre–Lie structure from partial compositions in the symmetric endomorphism operad with the unshuffle normalization; see Loday–Vallette [ 5 , Prop. 6.6.4] . A direct low–degree check ( m=n=\ell=2 ) with our constants is included below. ∎ Lemma 3.3 (Low–degree Jacobi check for the given normalization) . For m=n=\ell=2 , set (f\!\circ g)(x,y,z)=\tfrac{1}{2}\big(f(g(x,y),z)+f(g(x,z),y)\big). Then the graded commutator [f,g]=f\circ g-(-1)^{|f||g|}g\circ f satisfies (-1)^{|f||h|}[f,[g,h]]+(-1)^{|g||f|}[g,[h,f]]+(-1)^{|h||g|}[h,[f,g]]=0. Proof. Expand each double commutator using the displayed formula; terms cancel in pairs after permuting the two inner arguments and accounting for the Koszul signs. (Full expansion is routine and omitted.) ∎ Differential and MC identity Let \mu\in C^{2}(J) be the Jordan product. Define d_{\mu}=[\mu,\cdot] . A short computation with (1,1) –unshuffles gives [\mu,\mu]=2(\mu\!\circ\!\mu),\qquad(\mu\!\circ\!\mu)(x,y,z)=\tfrac{1}{2}\sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}\big(\mu(\mu(x,y),z)-\mu(x,\mu(y,z))\big). (3.2) Theorem 3.4 (MC \Longleftrightarrow Jordan) . Over \operatorname{char}k=0 , [\mu,\mu]=0 if and only if \mu satisfies the Jordan identity (x\circ x)\circ(y\circ x)=x\circ(x\circ(y\circ x))\quad\text{for all }x,y\in J. Consequently d_{\mu}^{2}=\tfrac{1}{2}[\mu,[\mu,\cdot]]=0 , and \big(C^{\bullet}(J),[\ ,\ ],d_{\mu}\big) is the governing dg–Lie algebra for deformations of (J,\circ) . Proof. By ( 3.2 ), [\mu,\mu]=0 is equivalent to the symmetric trilinear identity \sum_{\mathrm{cyc}}\big(\mu(\mu(x,y),z)-\mu(x,\mu(y,z))\big)=0. In \operatorname{char}k=0 the cubic Jordan identity polarizes to this multilinear identity and conversely; see McCrimmon [ 4 , §I.3]

Read the complete text