Analytical blueprint for 99.999% fidelity X-gates on present superconducting hardware under strong driving

José Diogo Da Costa Jesus, Boxi Li, Yuan Gao, Rami Barends, Francisco Andrés Cárdenas-López, Felix Motzoi · 2025

Read Analytical blueprint for 99.999% fidelity X-gates on present superconducting hardware under strong driving by José Diogo Da Costa Jesus, Boxi Li, Yuan Gao, Rami Barends, Francisco Andrés Cárdenas-López, Felix Motzoi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19919.txt.

Introduction

José Diogo Da Costa Jesus leads a six-author team drafting a plan for near-perfect quantum gates. The target is gates with fidelity of 99.999 percent. The gates must also be fast, near seven nanoseconds per turn. That means driving qubits hard. In that regime the usual three-level model breaks down. New error paths open as photons leak out of the computing space.

The team works out those leak paths on paper, not in the lab. From the math come formulas to suppress each error channel. Two schemes, R1D and R2D, cancel set unwanted transitions. Old open questions on DRAG settings are settled too. Computer checks with real decoherence rates then predict very low error. The rate falls below one part in one hundred thousand for a fast pi turn.

Catalog record

CREATORJosé Diogo Da Costa Jesus, Boxi Li, Yuan Gao, Rami Barends, Francisco Andrés Cárdenas-López, Felix Motzoi
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19919

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Analytical blueprint for 99.999% fidelity X-gates on present superconducting hardware under strong driving José Diogo Da Costa Jesus, Boxi Li, Yuan Gao, Rami Barends, Francisco Andrés Cárdenas-López, Felix Motzoi Abstract Achieving very fast gates that undercut the natural limits set by decoherence requires going into the strong driving limit. Realizing single-qubit control predicted beyond semi-classical, time-dependent modeling has yet to be experimentally realized on superconducting and most other computing platforms. In this regime, the common model of dynamics within a three-level manifold breaks down, and instead, we see new quantum error channels growing abruptly with decreasing time. To identify these error processes we systematically calculate the effect of multi-photon transitions that occur out of the computational space. We then derive analytical formulas to suppress these effects, as well as amplitude and phase errors on the qubit space; we term these R1D for suppressing the | 0 ⟩ ⇄ | 2 ⟩ |0\rangle\rightleftarrows|2\rangle transition and R2D when also suppressing | 1 ⟩ ⇄ | 3 ⟩ |1\rangle\rightleftarrows|3\rangle leakage. We also answer long-standing questions about the optimal values of the DRAG prefactor as well as constant detuning, when accounting for time-ordering, and also show how to calibrate other prefactors for further performance improvement. Upon correcting these varied sources of error, we numerically demonstrate gate infidelities below 10 − 5 10^{-5} for a 7ns π \pi -rotation when incorporating existing decoherence rates. I Introduction Superconducting quantum circuits Krantz et al. 2019 ; Blais et al. 2021 position themselves as a promising quantum computing platform due to the capacity of tailoring internal circuit parameters, enabling a high degree of controlability over individual qubits. Current quantum processing units based on transmon circuits Koch et al. 2007 are described as anharmonic oscillators suffering from low anharmonicity, which induces transitions with the outlying energy levels through the drive, leading to accumulated population in non-computational states – leakage – and phase errors, upper-bounding the performance of the single-qubit operations Chen et al. 2016 . The standard approach to correct these errors relies on using pulse shaping and is known as Derivative Removal by Adiabatic Gate (DRAG) Motzoi et al. 2009 ; Motzoi and Wilhelm 2013 ; Theis et al. 2018 , where an off-phase quadrature drive is added to the pulses to counteract leakage Motzoi et al. 2009 and/or phase errors perturbatively Gambetta et al. 2011 . However, this method has not been successfully employed when the driving amplitude becomes comensurate with the detuning, the so-called strong driving regime. Here, a crossover occurs where the three-level model of the transmon (or other anharmonic oscillator) breaks down, invalidating existing approaches in the literature. That is, as one tries to further speed up gates and improve system function, the driving amplitude approaches the anharmonicity of the ladder structure, and the dynamics becomes overconstrained with multiple leakage channels being activated Li et al. 2024 ; Li et al. 2025 . While several semi-classical mitigation strategies have emerged to add Fourier spectrum notches to unwanted transitions Hyyppä et al. 2024 ; Chiaro and Zhang 2025 , the semi-classical analysis is valid only in the perturbative regime. In this work, we show that the above-mentioned semi-classical analysis and a three-level manifold are both insufficient to model the onset of the strong driving regime. We identify two-photon transitions that become dominant when only the linear drive term is corrected. By designing DRAG-type corrections that simultaneously target single- and two-photon leakage channels, through a recursive construction, we derive fully analytical pulse shapes that eliminate all leading error terms. In particular, we observe that a mimimum four-level description is essential for capturing the necessary dynamics. Using these analytical pulses without any calibration, we achieve an error rate of 10^{-5} with an 11.8 ns gate. In practice, free parameters are often introduced into the control terms and are calibrated to compensate for model uncertainties and further enhance the performance. These are often chosen in an ad-hoc manner, but exhibit correlated behaviour Chen et al. 2016 . We explain the typically seen functional forms using toggling-frame transformations and a Magnus-expansion analysis, which together clarify where parameter calibration yields substantial improvements. In particular, we explain the linear relationship between detuning and the DRAG prefactor, and explain why, counterintuitively, constant detuning can outperform time-dependent detuning in several important cases. Incorporating additional prefactors to the recursive DRAG terms for calibration reduces the minimum achievable gate time further to 6.7 ns with error 10^{-5} . The remainder of the paper is organized as follows: Sec. II.1 introduces the DRAG formalism and the first-order errors on single-qubit gates. Section II.3 describes the recursive DRAG approach, termed as R1D, for correcting two-photon errors |0\rangle\rightleftarrows|2\rangle . Sec. II.4 generalizes to a second recursive set of frame transformations, termed as R2D, that further remove errors from the higher excited states of the ladder. Sec. III provides analytical predictions and analysis for the drive amplitude and constant detuning to remove additional computational-space errors. In Sec. IV , we analyse the effect of decoherence on the gate performance. Finally, in Sec. V we provide our conclusions. II Error budget and corresponding corrections II.1 Linear leakage error and standard DRAG correction Figure 1: Analytical pulse performance for a transmon qubit. a) Low-lying energy structure of a transmon system represented as a particle in a cosine potential, where different opacity refers to the importance of higher energy levels in the performance of the gate. b) Structure of the energy levels of the transmon system in the rotating frame with respect to the transition \omega_{10} . The dashed arrows connecting different states represent single-photon transitions, while dotted dashed connects states through two-photon processes. c) Gate infidelity for implementing an X gate under different pulses: black lines corresponds to Hann pulse, blue line is for DRAG and green and violet stand for recursive pulses R1D and R2D, respectively. These pulses are simulated analytically without calibration. R2D outperforms every method and achieves a gate fidelity of 99.99 % at 9 ns and a fidelity of 99.999% at 11.8 ns. d) Histogram with the final population of the relevant leakage states for different pulses when implementing an X gate at 6ns. The main source of error in DRAG can be addressed by using R1D, which will suppress 2 photon transitions to |2\rangle . However ,for R1D the leakage to |3\rangle is a major source of error. This can suppressed by an order of magnitude by R2D. The simulations were performed by modeling the transmon as an anharmonic oscillator with anharmonicity \Delta_{2}=-2\pi\times 0.225 GHz. We start by revisiting the DRAG method introduced in Ref. Motzoi et al. 2009 , considering a weakly anharmonic oscillator with four levels, |0\rangle , |1\rangle , |2\rangle and |3\rangle , as depicted in Fig. 1 (a). The first two levels are used for information processing – they form the computational subspace – with the rest representing leakage states. DRAG aims to implement operations between the lowest two levels while suppressing leakage and phase errors by engineering the drive envelope. Let us start with our system Hamiltonian in the rotating frame with respect to the drive frequency, taking \hbar=1 (see Appendix A for a full derivation): \displaystyle\hat{\mathcal{H}}(t) \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{j=1}^{M}[\Delta_{j}+j\delta(t)]|j\rangle\langle j| (1) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\sum_{j=1}^{M}\lambda_{j}\bigg[\frac{\Omega_{x}(t)}{2}\hat{\sigma}^{x}_{j-1,j}+\frac{\Omega_{y}(t)\textsection}{2}\hat{\sigma}^{y}_{j-1,j}\bigg] where \Delta_{j} is the anharmonicity of the j

Read the complete text