Detecting Coordinated Activities Through Temporal, Multiplex, and Collaborative Analysis

Letizia Iannucci, Elisa Muratore, Antonis Matakos, Mikko Kivelä · 2025

Read Detecting Coordinated Activities Through Temporal, Multiplex, and Collaborative Analysis by Letizia Iannucci, Elisa Muratore, Antonis Matakos, Mikko Kivelä (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19677.txt.

Introduction

Letizia Iannucci and three co-authors hunt for online accounts that move as a pack. In influence drives, no single account looks odd on its own. The tell is that many accounts act in sync. Their framework models online activity as a multiplex network. Each type of action gets its own layer in the network.

On top sits a time-aware model of joint work. It credits acts done together again and again over time. A decay curve makes old joint acts count for less. The team tested the method on several sets of coordinated activity. The full model found the groups better than past methods. The aim is to catch campaigns early, as groups, not one account at a time.

Catalog record

CREATORLetizia Iannucci, Elisa Muratore, Antonis Matakos, Mikko Kivelä
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE84 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19677

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Detecting Coordinated Activities Through Temporal, Multiplex, and Collaborative Analysis Letizia Iannucci, Elisa Muratore, Antonis Matakos, Mikko Kivelä Abstract In the era of widespread online content consumption, effective detection of coordinated efforts is crucial for mitigating potential threats arising from information manipulation. Despite advances in isolating inauthentic and automated actors, the actions of individual accounts involved in influence campaigns may not stand out as anomalous if analyzed independently of the coordinated group. Given the collaborative nature of information operations, coordinated campaigns are better characterized by evidence of similar temporal behavioral patterns that extend beyond coincidental synchronicity across a group of accounts. We propose a framework to model complex coordination patterns across multiple online modalities. This framework utilizes multiplex networks to first decompose online activities into different interaction layers, and subsequently aggregate evidence of online coordination across the layers. In addition, we propose a time-aware collaboration model to capture patterns of online coordination for each modality. The proposed time-aware model builds upon the node-normalized collaboration model and accounts for repetitions of coordinated actions over different time intervals by employing an exponential decay temporal kernel. We validate our approach on multiple datasets featuring different coordinated activities. Our results demonstrate that a multiplex time-aware model excels in the identification of coordinating groups, outperforming previously proposed methods in coordinated activity detection. 1 Introduction The widespread use of social media as a primary information source makes it vital to detect unreliable or malicious actors who exploit the features of those platforms to intentionally manipulate public opinion, intensify societal divisions, and influence policy decisions [ 11 ] . Specifically, the ability to rapidly distribute content and facilitate real-time interactions creates opportunities for the inauthentic amplification of misleading or inflammatory information. For these reasons, early detection of influence operations and information campaigns becomes imperative to prevent the spread of propaganda and the deepening of societal divisions, and to maintain the integrity of the information environment [ 1 ] . In response to the alarming observation of coordinated activities tampering with crucial events, such as political elections [ 8 , 18 , 32 ] , researchers have devoted significant efforts to address this challenge by categorizing individual accounts as information polluters, bots, or other types of inauthentic social actors [ 6 , 14 , 5 ] . Detecting individual malicious users can be challenging, especially within bot networks where the activity of each bot is strategically calibrated to evade detection. However, it is the coordinated nature of their activities, rather than the isolated actions, that ultimately generates a significant impact on the social media platform. Recent research underscores how information operations exhibit strong characteristics of collaborative work [ 42 ] , making coordinated group behavior a better descriptor than focusing solely on individual actions or isolated elements [ 12 ] . This shift in perspective makes it possible to expose coordinated efforts by identifying an anomalous degree of consistency within a group of accounts [ 12 ] . When analyzing group dynamics, it becomes evident that malicious actors exploit numerous opportunities for coordination on online platforms. These opportunities manifest in various coordination strategies, such as utilizing the same set of hashtags, engaging in the same discussions, amplifying identical narratives, or repeatedly sharing content from a specific account or external source [ 32 , 37 ] . The complexity of online coordination is further heightened by the ability of groups of accounts to coordinate across multiple dimensions simultaneously [ 32 , 22 ] . Coordination may occur in the temporal dimension, involving activities at similar times or with similar frequency [ 12 ] , and it may extend to the social dimension when coordinating actors interact with the same set of users [ 22 ] . Coordination can operate on the semantic level through the use of identical words, hashtags, or similar text [ 5 ] , while the referral dimension can be employed to redirect users to the same external content or sources [ 8 ] . Finally, the manipulation of metadata can be leveraged to create fabricated personas designed to resemble regular users, making them well-suited for deployment in information campaigns [ 6 ] . The potential for simultaneous coordination across multiple dimensions effectively turns the detection of online coordinated behavior into a multi-dimensional problem [ 32 ] . Therefore, reliable detection of coordinated behavior necessitates a comprehensive approach that considers the time patterns of collaborative effort across different potential strategies of coordination. These assumptions lead to the following research question: RQ. Does integrating the temporal aspect and multiple modalities of coordination improve the detection and characterization of collaborative efforts? We address the multi-dimensional nature of coordination by combining different potential strategies of coordination in a multiplex representation of online latent collaboration. The multiplex representation is able to accumulate evidence of coordination from diverse coordination modalities, such as hashtag usage, user interactions, narrative amplification, and content sharing, and to describe latent collaboration on each of them. A multiplex model provides a rich description of coordinated activities, from which we can extract clusters of coordinating accounts that exhibit collaboration across different modalities. As our second contribution, we propose an application of the node-normalized collaboration model introduced by 28 and we design it to model the significance of temporal patterns of online coordination. Coordinating accounts intentionally manipulate online spaces through common and repeated behavior [ 22 ] . Thus, both the number of repetitions of common actions and their temporal differences represent fundamental indicators to distinguish coordination from random or independent user activity. In particular, similar actions occurring within a short time frame may signify malicious tactics, including spamming, participation in disinformation campaigns, or involvement in coordinated attacks [ 12 ] . Furthermore, repeated instances of the same activities, even if distributed over an extended period of time, suggest concerted efforts [ 48 ] . In both cases, larger weights assigned by the model capture the deliberate effort to synchronize or repeat activities beyond mere coincidence and highlight the collaborative nature of these actions. To assess the efficacy of our proposed model, we begin by investigating its performance on a series of simple synthetic case studies. These controlled experiments allow us to validate the model’s behavior against diverse patterns of coordination and to anticipate its strengths and limitations. We then benchmark the performance of our model against several state-of-the-art methods previously established for the analysis of coordinated campaigns, leveraging available labeled datasets [ 40 ] . Our analysis demonstrates how our model contributes to advancing the identification of coordinated operations. The remainder of the paper provides a review of related literature (Section 2 ), introduces the model (Section 3 ), and concludes with the presentation of experiments (Section 4 ) and discussion of our findings (Section 5 ). 2 Related work 2.1 Coordination detection Coordinated inauthentic behavior refers to the collaborative actions of a group of social media accounts with the deliberate intent of deceiving other users [ 49 , 37 ] . This definition emphasizes the collective effort to purposely increase the visibility of specific content, regardless of the authenticity of the content being shared. Therefore, common methods for uncovering coordinated groups primarily rely on the study of synchronized or highly similar online actions that defy random occurrence [

Read the complete text