Quantum critical theories in a periodic potential: strange metallic thermoelectric and magneto-transport

E. Nilsson, K. Schalm · 2025

Read Quantum critical theories in a periodic potential: strange metallic thermoelectric and magneto-transport by E. Nilsson, K. Schalm (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19480.txt.

Introduction

Eric Nilsson and Koenraad Schalm study how quantum critical matter conducts heat and charge when a lattice potential scrambles its momentum. Their two-dimensional theories break translation strongly, with a chemical potential that varies in space yet averages to zero. That missing average scale gives the systems odd, distinctive signatures.

Holographic models built on near-extremal black holes supply the answers. Currents sneak around obstacles, making the systems better conductors, not worse. Electrical transport looks like a bad metal while thermal transport mimics a Drude form it does not truly follow. At strong magnetic fields, resistance grows near-linearly, echoing effective medium theory.

Catalog record

CREATORE. Nilsson, K. Schalm
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE77 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19480

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Quantum critical theories in a periodic potential: strange metallic thermoelectric and magneto-transport E. Nilsson, K. Schalm Abstract We study DC and AC thermoelectric and magneto-transport in 2D quantum critical theories with strong translational symmetry breaking due to a varying chemical potential lattice with zero average μ ¯ = 0 \bar{\mu}=0 . The combination of quantum criticality and the absence of the average natural scale implies that such systems have idiosyncratic signatures that may apply more generally when the variance in the lattice potential far exceeds the average or for strong translational symmetry breaking in general. We model such theories holographically through near-extremal AdS black holes. We find that these systems (a) become better conductors. In a 2D lattice, this can be explained by currents flowing around obstacles; (b) exhibit bad-metal electrical transport with Drude-like thermal transport, though it is not Drude, and, notably, (c) display an approximately B B -linear longitudinal magnetoresistance at large fields, similar to Effective Medium Theory. We comment on how these results may apply when μ ¯ ≠ 0 \bar{\mu}\neq 0 . 1 Introduction Essentially all critical points studied in real materials require fine tuning to a very special point among all of its possible configurations. Nevertheless, this special point is of fundamental physical interest, due to universality: the physics at a critical point is independent of its microscopic origins. The particularities of the material in question no longer matter as long as one is able to tune to the special point. If the material is a (crystalline) solid, the crystal lattice is generically such a particularity. In the formal sense, the lattice is irrelevant under the renormalization group flow to the critical point. Precisely because of this fact, a lattice is often used in numerical analyses as a regulator. Quantum critical theories, where the critical point exists at T=0 , have the added factor that the critical behavior extends fan-wise into the phase diagram at finite temperature T 48 . The temperature T acts as an IR regulator, and probes of the system at a scale less than T are controlled by collective hydrodynamic rather than pure scale- and collisionless behavior. Importantly, the entrance to the hydrodynamic regime halts the RG flow, and whatever remains of the lattice is imprinted in the response. A striking example is a weak chemical potential lattice, \mu(x)=\bar{\mu}+\delta\mu\cos(Gx) , with lattice momentum G<\bar{\mu} 6 : in this case the IR is described by Umklapp hydrodynamics based on Bloch waves, rather than conventional hydrodynamics based on Fourier modes. When instead G>\bar{\mu} , the conventional notion that the lattice is irrelevant holds. A chemical potential lattice also has a third scale \delta\mu , encoding the size of the lattice variations. Intuited by real metals with a finite density of valence electrons, one normally studies the weak lattice regime, where the average chemical potential is parametrically larger than the size of these variations; \bar{\mu}\gg\delta\mu . For quantum critical theories placed in such a lattice, all changes w.r.t. the translational invariant theory are then encoded as functions of two dimensionless parameters \bar{\mu}/G and \delta\mu/G . Chesler, Lucas, and Sachdev realized that the study of the strong lattice regime \mu\ll\delta\mu in such critical theories becomes tractably simpler by taking the extremal value \bar{\mu}=0 17 . This eliminates a background scale, simplifying the structure of the solutions and opening the possibility of universal transport regimes exhibiting scaling collapse. This may therefore serve as a testing ground for strongly correlated physics near or at quantum criticality where translational symmetry breaking is strong. In this article we extend their findings of electronic transport in this special regime in 1D lattices to 2D lattices including DC and AC thermal-, thermoelectric- and magneto-transport. As Chesler, Lucas and Sachdev, we use holographic models of quantum criticality to compute these responses. For an experimental realization of such physics, graphene at charge neutrality naturally comes to mind. Indeed, many studies have considered the scenario of a spatially periodic chemical potential imposed on \bar{\mu}=0 charge neutral graphene either in terms of large scale ripples (a 1D periodic potential) or an egg-carton landscape (a 2D periodic potential), see e.g. 43 ; 37 ; 44 ; 53 ; 13 ; 54 ; 10 ; 26 . Most of these take a non- or weakly-interacting point of view, even though charged excitations in graphene are arguably not weakly coupled. For 1D potentials, these weak coupling results agree qualitatively with the strong coupling approach in 17 . We shall show that this is not so for a 2D periodic potential, where the weak coupling approach surprisingly predicts no change to electrical transport 13 . Our approach at strong coupling does however show distinct physics that also differs from the 1D case; thus, both interactions and dimensionality matter. Due to its quantum critical-like physics at charge neutrality, graphene is in fact an “almost strange metal” 47 ; 41 . Our findings are particularly relevant in light of the notion that the phenomenology of the strange metal phase in high- T_{c} cuprate superconductors is also described by such quantum critical physics in the presence of a 2D lattice 55 ; 34 . This was recently exemplified by computations in a 2D Yukawa-SYK model, which has a holographic dual. This model reproduces the the observed linear-in- T -DC conductivity, an AC conductivity with apparent \omega^{-2/3} -mid-IR scaling, T\ln T specific heat, Homes’ law relating the T=0 superfluid density to T_{c}\sigma_{DC}(T_{c}) , and broad ARPES width from marginal-Fermi-liquid self-energies \Sigma(\omega)\sim\omega\ln\omega 40 . The presence of translational symmetry breaking — in 40 mainly through disorder in addition to the lattice — is paramount in order to obtain finite and properly scaling transport properties. However, one important phenomenological observation is hitherto unexplained: the magneto-transport. No models as of yet are able to convincingly explain the observed Hall angle scaling \frac{\sigma_{xx}}{\sigma_{xy}}\sim T^{2} . In systems dominated by a single momentum relaxation rate, this rate determines both the Hall angle and DC resistivity and these must scale the same way with temperature. Anderson already pointed out that to explain this observed difference in the cuprate strange metal one needs a second relaxation rate, which is not trivial 1 . As one of us has recently shown 14 , by extending Anderson’s earlier arguments to a full hydrodynamic analysis, this requires a system where momentum relaxation through lattice Umklapp or disorder is not the single parametrically small relaxation rate, independently of whether the microscopics is strongly or weakly coupled. Experiments on certain cuprates (and pnictides) also reveal a longitudinal magnetoresistance on the form 35 ; 3 ; 27 \rho(B,T)-\rho(0,0)\propto\sqrt{(\alpha k_{B}T)^{2}+(\gamma\mu_{B}B)^{2}} (1) where \alpha and \gamma are two dimensionless parameters. This leads to an unsaturating B -linear magnetoresistance at large magnetic fields, which stands similarly in stark contrast to the B^{2} -scaling of conventional Fermi liquids that saturates to a constant at large fields 38 . B -linear magnetoresistance has been shown to be a general feature of systems with large fluctuations in the conductivity, extending down to moderate magnetic fields in the case of strong inhomogeneities 42 . In that case, such systems can be modeled as random resistor networks, which has been shown to be equivalent to “Effective Medium Theory” (EMT) 45 . Within EMT, one

Read the complete text