Strong model-agnostic constraints for twin-star solutions

Sofia Blomqvist, Christian Ecker, Tyler Gorda, Aleksi Vuorinen · 2025

Read Strong model-agnostic constraints for twin-star solutions by Sofia Blomqvist, Christian Ecker, Tyler Gorda, Aleksi Vuorinen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2512-19477.txt.

Introduction

Sofia Blomqvist, Christian Ecker, Tyler Gorda, and Aleksi Vuorinen ask whether neutron stars can come in twins: same mass, different size. Twins arise when matter inside the star jumps through a first-order phase transition. Their Bayesian analysis stays model-agnostic, mixing first-principles constraints with telescope observations of the matter equation of state.

Allowing sharp transitions and then searching, they find current data exclude nearly every twin family. Two classes survive: one with a very early transition, and one where a fast crossover at higher density precedes the jump, with the sound speed peaking twice. The classic story tying twins to quark deconfinement is firmly ruled out.

Catalog record

CREATORSofia Blomqvist, Christian Ecker, Tyler Gorda, Aleksi Vuorinen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE31 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2512-19477

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Strong model-agnostic constraints for twin-star solutions Preprint: HIP-2025-26/TH Sofia Blomqvist, Christian Ecker, Tyler Gorda, Aleksi Vuorinen Abstract We perform a model-agnostic Bayesian analysis of the neutron-star-matter equation of state (EoS), using known ab-initio constraints and astrophysical observations to limit its behavior at intermediate densities. Permitting explicit first-order phase transitions allows us to systematically search for twin-star solutions, i.e. the existence of stars degenerate in mass but differing in radius. We find that current observational constraints exclude all but two classes of twin stars. The first is characterized by a first-order transition occurring at a very low density, where the material properties of the system either stay largely intact or move away from the conformal limit. In the second, more interesting class, the discontinuity in the mass-radius curve emerges after a rapid crossover transition at a significantly higher density, with the speed of sound exhibiting two sharp peaks at distinct densities. Since neither class shows clear conformalization upon entering the second branch, the standard twin-star scenario linking the mass–radius discontinuity to deconfinement can be firmly ruled out, while even the remaining solutions —– disfavored by per-mille Bayes factors and in tension with theoretical bounds –— are likely to be excluded in the future. Introduction. —Advances in theoretical ab-initio studies of nuclear Tews et al. 2013 ; Lynn et al. 2016 ; Drischler et al. 2019 ; Drischler et al. 2020a ; Drischler et al. 2020b ; Keller et al. 2023 ; Alp et al. 2025 and quark matter Kurkela et al. 2010 ; Gorda et al. 2021a ; Gorda et al. 2021b ; Gorda et al. 2023a ; Kärkkäinen et al. 2025 as well as neutron-star (NS) observations Demorest et al. 2010 ; Antoniadis et al. 2013 ; Fonseca et al. 2016 ; Cromartie et al. 2019 ; Fonseca et al. 2021 ; Abbott et al. 2017 ; Abbott et al. 2018 ; Shaw et al. 2018 ; Steiner et al. 2018 ; Nättilä et al. 2017 ; Miller et al. 2019 ; Riley et al. 2019 ; Miller et al. 2021 ; Riley et al. 2021 have recently enabled a model-agnostic approach to inferring the thermodynamic properties of NS matter, including its equation of state (EoS). This has led to crucial insights of both quantitative and qualitative nature, including a robust demonstration of the rapid stiffening of the EoS at low and moderate densities, corresponding to a high maximum speed of sound Hebeler et al. 2013 ; Kurkela et al. 2014 ; Annala et al. 2018 ; Most et al. 2018 ; Tews et al. 2018 ; Landry and Essick 2019 ; Capano et al. 2020 ; Miller et al. 2020 ; Essick et al. 2020 ; Raaijmakers et al. 2020 ; Dietrich et al. 2020 ; Landry et al. 2020 ; Al-Mamun et al. 2021 ; Essick et al. 2021 ; Raaijmakers et al. 2021 ; Annala et al. 2022 ; Huth et al. 2022 ; Altiparmak et al. 2022 ; Lim and Holt 2022 ; Gorda et al. 2023b . At even higher densities, both hard-cutoff and Bayesian studies have identified a marked softening of the EoS, leading to near-conformal behavior below the central densities of maximal-mass NSs. This has been interpreted as signaling a transition to deconfined degrees of freedom within Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) Annala et al. 2020 ; Annala et al. 2023 ; Komoltsev et al. 2024 ; Ayriyan et al. 2025 . Despite the progress described above, some important caveats remain. A prominent example has to do with the possibility of a discontinuous first-order phase transition (FOPT) between two phases of high-density QCD matter — be that two separate phases of confined matter or, more interestingly, hadronic and quark matter (QM). Strong FOPTs, featuring a sizable jump in energy density, are known to have potentially interesting phenomenological consequences both for binary NS mergers Bauswein et al. 2019 ; Most et al. 2019 ; Ecker et al. 2020 ; Weih et al. 2020 ; Most et al. 2020 ; Tootle et al. 2022 ; Fujimoto et al. 2023 ; Ecker et al. 2025a and quiescent NSs Chamel et al. 2013 ; Alford et al. 2013 ; Demircik et al. 2021 ; Brandes et al. 2023 ; Brandes and Weise 2024 ; Ecker et al. 2025b . Only a handful of works have, however, attempted to constrain FOPTs in a model-agnostic fashion Gorda et al. 2023c ; Kumar et al. 2024 ; Essick et al. 2023 ; Brandes et al. 2023 ; Mroczek et al. 2024 ; Komoltsev 2024 ; Verma et al. 2025 ; Tang et al. 2025 ; Li et al. 2025a , and even fewer such studies have systematically studied a specific phenomenon often linked to FOPTs, i.e., the existence of two disjoint branches of compact stars (see, however, Montana et al. 2019 for an early attempt in this direction). Intriguingly, this phenomenon gives rise to stellar solutions sharing a common mass but differing in radii, commonly referred to as twin stars Gerlach 1968 , which offer a clear observational prediction for current and future mass-radius measurements. In more phenomenological studies, twin stars have received extensive attention both in the astrophysics and nuclear-physics communities (see e.g. Schaffner-Bielich et al. 2002 ; Alford et al. 2005 ; Benic et al. 2015 ; Alvarez-Castillo et al. 2016 ; Alvarez-Castillo and Blaschke 2017 ; Li et al. 2025b and references therein), leading to the identification of multiple classes of potential solutions Montana et al. 2019 . Given recent advances in both the observational study of NSs and ab-initio limits from nuclear and particle theory, it is, however, unclear whether these results are still valid and if all proposed classes of twin stars continue to be viable. This situation motivates us to address the viability of twin stars in a maximally robust and conservative manner, only relying on commonly accepted observational data and first-principles EoS limits. To this end, we introduce an EoS ansatz versatile enough to describe all twin classes previously identified and perform a Bayesian analysis involving a gradual introduction of astrophysical constraints. As detailed in our letter, this leads us to a crisp conclusion: current observations rule out all but two of the twin categories suggested in Montana et al. 2019 , with the viable EoSs featuring either an early-onset FOPT beginning around 1.5 nuclear saturation densities n_{\rm s}\approx 0.16~\mathrm{fm}^{-3} or a crossover-type transition at 4-5 n_{\rm s} . Given that the Bayes factors for both solutions are at the per-mille level, and that neither family shows signs of conformalization upon entering the second branch, we conclude that deconfinement-induced twin solutions can be firmly ruled out. Finally, we analyze how various observational constraints affect our conclusion, finding X-ray data to play a particularly prominent role in the process. Setup. —We parameterize our EoSs in three parts. For baryon-number densities n<0.5~n_{\rm s} , we apply the Baym-Pethick–Sutherland (BPS) prescription for the NS crust ( Baym et al. 1971 ) , while in the range 0.5\,n_{\rm s}\leq n<n_{\rm CEFT} , we sample polytropic EoSs with pressure values p_{\rm CEFT}\in[1.5,7]\,\mathrm{MeV}/\mathrm{fm}^{3} , uniformly distributed at n_{\rm CEFT}=1.1\,n_{\rm s} . This covers the conservative next-to-next-to-leading order (N2LO) Chiral Effective Field Theory (CEFT) uncertainty band from Drischler et al. 2021 .

Read the complete text